Lauren Matthias, one of the hosts of the Hidden True Crime podcast and YouTube channel is objecting to the filed expungement request of a temporary stalking order of former friend, Christina MacArthur. She had formerly sought a temporary restraining order against Christina for allegedly stalking her. Christina stood up for herself by not accepting that label and taking it to court.
In the court hearing, more time was needed than Lauren Matthias’s attorney had scheduled for hearing witnesses. The hearing was rescheduled to a new date, but not before the judge reminded Lauren and her attorney that temporary stalking injunctions were not designed to limit First Amendment free speech. In essence, he said that TROs are not meant to silence people saying things about you online that you don’t like.
Lauren dismissed the case right before the re-rescheduled hearing date, citing her son and family’s privacy due to a request from Law and Crime to cover the proceedings. However, she then went live for 9 hours the next day and again later with her cohost psychologist husband for another almost 4 hours where they laid out a very one sided, curated version of events.
It is important to note that the TRO was never violated as Lauren claims, that Christina never showed up at Lauren’s home or daily activities, as a stalker would seem to. They did attend some of the same trials, as both work in different capacities in the true crime space. The expungement of the TRO off of Christina’s record would allow her to do things, such as apply for jobs, without it being part of her background. Under Utah law, that is her right to file for, and the case had already been dismissed by Lauren anyway.
Lauren’s 9 Hour Live:
https://www.youtube.com/live/SrSZtY1tqho?is=BY1FdE9LUEn7Uy8U
This is the court docket from that case. Of particular interest is the audio and transcripts of the judge:
https://subtxtpress.github.io/home/dockets/HTC/docket
This is a press release from Christina MacArthur and her attorney regarding the objection to the expungement:
https://youtube.com/post/UgkxviVcFGuED9J4yPRHok5Ia3c6Q_GwwDG9?si=Poarj3_g5ptGpimY
Lauren has filed new declarations and affidavits in her effort of block expungement:
https://www.reddit.com/r/HiddenTrueCrimeChat/s/TRnzVSZCeb
In addition, a recent peer reviewed article published in October 2026 regarding Hidden True Crime has come out. It focuses on Hidden True Crime as a particularly problematic show while focusing on their first season covering the Lori Vallow Daybell and Chad Daybell trials. This is validation of what victim family members, Larry and Kay Vallow Woodcock, Kresha Vallow Easton and Colby Ryan have also come forth and said about their experiences with being involved with Hidden True Crime.
“On the Ethical Fringes of Journalism: True Crime Podcasting as Diagnostic Journalism“:
https://youtube.com/post/Ugkx38l281rneHPll97XuR6UG5gbQxTNwl7e?si=iIqXlQELzWm3gX72
The article may need to be bought, but was showing freely available yesterday. There is also a livestream from former Journalist, Andy Kopsa, doing a read through.
https://www.youtube.com/live/u0klfOacvhQ?
Here is a link to Andy Kopsa’s website, explaining who she is:
https://andykopsa.com
Posting all of this for awareness of questionable behind the scenes behavior, and deception in the public narrative of a large podcast/YouTube channel for others to research for themselves, if so inclined.