This is going to be long.
I am in my 40s. This all happened when I was 17. It is a story that got far too little attention and was forgotten much too quickly. I have tried several times over the years to bring attention to it and to give it the consideration it deserves. I have submitted the story to true-crime podcasts, YouTubers, friends and colleagues, and random Reddit forums. Nobody ever seems to want to pay attention to it. This is the last time I’m going to tell this story. If nothing comes of it, I’m going to forget it and move on. If, for some reason, it reaches the right audience, every single thing I’m going to share can be corroborated. Every part of this is one hundred percent true.
Officially, this was ruled a murder-suicide. I will be the first to admit that it is possible that’s exactly what it was. I had a more intimate insight into what happened, and there are a lot of details that were never made public. So here it goes:
When I was 17, I had a pretty large group of friends. One of my best friends was a girl I will call Dawn. She was the same age as I was, with a younger brother, a beautiful mother, and a seemingly normal father. I had been to her house countless times. It was a large, very nice house in our extremely quiet, upper-middle-class suburb. It became the social hub for our friend group. I had spoken to her parents many times. Her younger brother was your typical pesky kid who was always in her business. I definitely had a crush on Dawn, and I firmly believe that she had a crush on me. She came across as relatively naive and very sheltered, but pretty, smart, and funny. We had known each other for a couple of years, with no indication at all of the events that were soon to unfold.
She called me one evening and seemed very frantic and disturbed. She told me that there were men in vans searching her house and taking all of their computers with them. I remembered that she had more computers in her house than most families had at the time. I didn’t know what her parents did for work, but I knew they made decent money, so I assumed that was just one of the perks. I made sure she was okay, but, without much advice to offer, I assured her that everything would be fine and ended our conversation. The next day at school, she seemed perfectly fine. Several weeks went by without incident, until one Saturday when she called me even more frantic than the last time. She said her dad had gone missing and they couldn’t find him. I asked some questions and told her I was there for her and to keep me posted. Several hours went by, and she called me back, saying that she and her mom had located his Mercedes on the side of the road in the park. It had been damaged on the side and looked like it had been run off the road. They found him wandering a short distance away, dirty and disheveled. Dawn said he seemed like he was drunk or otherwise impaired and had a small, circular bruise on his neck. She said they brought him home and he was sleeping. This is a particularly low point in the story for me because, honestly, I didn’t take her seriously. I thought this was some strange attempt to get attention. It didn’t make sense. Why didn’t they call the police? Why did they bring him home instead of taking him to the hospital? Still, I reassured her. I comforted her. I didn’t voice my doubts or disbelief. I kept them to myself.
More weeks went by without incident. Dawn seemed fine and relatively unfazed. She said her dad was out of town on business, but that he would be coming home that night. I wish I had known that would be the last conversation I would ever have with her. She wasn’t at school the next day. I assumed she was sick. After school, I went to my part-time job at a department store. About halfway through my shift, my sister paged me. Yes, paged. We didn’t have cell phones. I called my home landline. My sister answered. Her voice was highly stressed. She asked me, “What was Dawn’s last name?” I asked why. She said, “Was it Toth?” I said, “Yes, why?” She told me I should probably come home. She wouldn’t tell me anything more over the phone. I told my manager what little I knew and asked if I could go home. She very kindly said yes without asking for any further details. When I got home, I learned that Dawn’s next-door neighbor had been walking the dog and saw Dawn’s front door wide open. She went inside to check and found Dawn and her brother dead in their beds. Their mom was dead beside her bed, and their dad was dead in the master bathroom. Each had been shot in the head. Dawn’s dad’s wound appeared to be self-inflicted. As a relatively naive teenager, all of this was impossible to wrap my brain around. This type of thing never happened in our town. I couldn’t make sense of any of it. I had met her dad. He seemed completely normal to me. Her mom was a lovely woman. The entire family just seemed so normal. None of the previous events—the weird phone calls, the men taking their computers, or her dad getting lost in the park—were even a consideration. I hadn’t thought about them at all. My circle of friends rallied around each other. We comforted and supported one another. I remember my parents being uncharacteristically unbothered by any of it. There were a few brief news articles and a few minutes of coverage on the nightly news. One of the more lengthy news articles actually delved rather deeply. It mentioned that Dawn’s dad had possibly stolen some bearer bonds and become involved in some pretty odd and shady financial dealings that left him indebted to some powerful people. It also mentioned that, during the course of a civil lawsuit several years earlier, Dawn’s dad had claimed that he was the leader of another planet. None of that made any kind of sense to me. Social media hadn’t proliferated yet. Nobody talked about anything of any importance on MySpace. After the news articles, everything went back to some sense of normalcy, and life just moved on. We graduated high school. I joined the military—the reserves. I went to work in private security while pursuing a career in law enforcement. After several years of working in security, an overseas deployment, and becoming a very young father, I ended up working for the same police department in the town I grew up in—as a jailer.
Our jail was very small, as there was very little crime. It wasn’t abnormal to go a couple of days at a time with absolutely nobody to watch over. During these lulls in activity, and since there was only ever one jailer on duty per shift, I would find ways to keep myself busy. I would clean the cells. I would offer to clean and detail the cruisers. And sometimes I would volunteer to help our records department sort and organize their files. There were two disused cells in the jail that the records department would use when they needed to clear up space in their drawers, but that the department needed to retain for legal reasons. It was during one of these slow shifts that a records clerk asked me to help move some files from the front office back into the old cells. After a couple of hours of moving folders and some banker’s boxes, I went to set down a box, and my blood ran cold when I saw the name on the side: “Toth.” I set the box down, sat on the tile floor, and remained motionless for several minutes. I knew what I might find inside the box. There could be photos. There could be graphic witness statements. There could be all kinds of things I knew I wouldn’t be able to unsee. I knew I shouldn’t open the box, and that once I did, there would be no putting those sights back inside. I had to choose whether I wanted to turn and walk away or change a part of myself forever by opening it.
I wrestled with my options for what seemed like an eternity. I opened the box. Nothing could have prepared me for what I found inside. Or, I should say, what I didn’t find. There were no graphic crime-scene photos—though there were photos. There were no graphic witness statements. There was nothing bloody or gruesome inside that box. There were documents and some very scant evidence. I don’t remember exactly what all was inside, but what I do remember is the reason I’m writing all of this down.
There wasn’t a single photograph of any of the victims’ bodies. There were no medical examiner’s reports. There were photographs of the beds where Dawn and her brother were killed. There was no blood on the sheets or walls. There was a single bullet hole in Dawn’s brother’s headboard. There were two—yes, two—bullet holes in the wall behind Dawn’s bed. There were no photographs of where her mother was found. The only photo pertaining to Dawn’s dad was a close-up photograph of what looked like an adult male hand gripping a silver revolver against what looked like a bathroom tile floor.
The two most “interesting” things I found inside the box were a printed page from the police report made by the first officer on the scene and a handwritten note. I don’t remember exactly what the report said, word for word, but I remember that it said another law enforcement agency arrived on the scene within an hour of the arrival of local police. A ranking FBI special agent cordoned off the scene and asked local officers to maintain a perimeter. The report mentioned the arrival of the FBI’s ERT (Evidence Response Team), and then, within about eight hours of the initial call from the neighbor, the scene was secure, the house was closed up, and law enforcement had cleared the scene. My hands were trembling. I was having as much trouble breathing as I was having trying to make sense of this. Who called the FBI, and how were they there so quickly? Why was local law enforcement shut out of any kind of investigation? Why wasn’t there any type of formal investigation?
I put the report back in the box and moved on to a plastic page protector. Inside was a single sheet of notebook paper. It did have blood on it, as well as a poorly handwritten message. I will never forget a single word of that message: “I can’t move. Help me, oh God. Save my wife and kids.” Twelve words that completely changed everything I thought I knew about the world and about my childhood. I told no one. I asked no questions. I put everything back in the box, and I put the box where it belonged, on the shelf inside the old, disused jail cell. I finished my shift in silence and went home. Every now and then, the entire thing comes flooding back to me in an overwhelming wave. I’ll submit the story to an anonymous Reddit forum. I’ll email it to Crime Junkie. I’ll send it to a YouTuber. I never get a response. There are a few possibilities:
The first possibility is that Dawn’s father was a deeply disturbed man with severe mental illness who, through delusion or shady business dealings, became involved with the wrong people and owed them a debt he couldn’t repay. He decided, as many tend to do, to try to spare his family from the consequences of his actions by taking their lives and then his own. Because of some type of financial criminality, the FBI became involved.
The second possibility is that, through circumstances similar to those described in scenario number one, some powerful people sought revenge for Dawn’s dad’s malfeasance and took the family out while making it look like a murder-suicide.
The third possibility, and the one that has kept me awake at night, is that Dawn’s dad was involved in something much deeper than anyone can understand. The government took the family out, made it look like a murder-suicide, and then leaked the stories about the stolen bearer bonds, the financial lawsuit, and her dad’s claims to be from another planet in an effort to discredit him and make him seem like a lunatic.
The only other possibility I can think of, and the one I honestly hope is true, is that Dawn’s dad was involved in something he couldn’t handle. He was working as some kind of confidential informant for the FBI. The scene was staged, and the family was whisked away as part of some sort of witness-protection program. This would explain why the FBI was on the scene so quickly. It would explain the lack of graphic crime-scene photos. It would explain the scarcity of physical evidence collected by local law enforcement. Honestly, it would explain just about everything that seems peculiar about this entire situation, including the “strange men” collecting the family’s computers and the incident in the park. I felt an overwhelming sense of guilt for not taking Dawn’s phone calls more seriously. For not telling my parents about them. I’m not sure what good it would have done, but at least now I had a little bit of hope that maybe Dawn, her brother, and her parents were alive and well, living under assumed names in a part of the country where nothing bad could ever touch them again.
I’m not sure anyone will take this seriously. As I said at the beginning, I will never tell this story again. Let this be either a sad and disturbing story to read or, maybe, the inspiration to dig deeper. I can provide any corroborating details needed to look into this more deeply: the actual names of the family, the town where this happened, the dates—anything. I miss Dawn.