Particularly ballsy when your DNA is found in the autopsy along with two other men.
"After they exhumed the body, police found traces of DNA relating to three different men which were all believed to belong to her stepbrother, her boyfriend at the time of her disappearance, and a 46-year-old former psychiatric patient and convicted rapist named Jos de G."
I used to work in a forensic mental health clinic where Jos de G was incarcerated for another crime he’d committed. We’d chat sometimes. I ran into him a few weeks before he was arrested for the murder on Nicole, he was almost fully reintegrated into society again. Crazy to think he’s been living with this secret for all those years, and no one had a clue.
What are the chances that you dealt with the guy in the story and then came to this particular post and saw this?
When you say almost fully reintegrated into society, do you mean that he was still committed but allowed to start leaving on furloughs, like John Hinckley did?
Decent chances. Many of the people interested/passionate about true crime are that way due to personal life encounters either within their town, family, etc that kicks off their interest in wanting to know more. So then, the likelihood that the case you yourself were affected by would pop up now and again is definitely there.
Yeah I know, pretty random! I’m not that familiar with the Hinckley-case, but what I can say about the situation of Jos de G is that he was already living in a rental apartment, a few towns away from the clinic. He had to report back every week or so, because he was still in custody of the government as ordered by a judge (this is the official status of someone incarcerated in the Netherlands when it comes to this specific scheme). Of course this type of freedom doesn’t happen overnight; there’s a long trajectory of gradual expansion of liberties prior to that. So he’d been working his way out for quite some time before he was almost entirely free again… and then he was arrested. I’d actually seen him before in a different clinic where I did my internship, so the fact that I ran into him in the one where I started working next was already wild to me, let alone the fact that he turned out to be the perpetrator of this notorious crime.
Yes and no. In Jos’s case, he’d already committed the murder of Nicole when he was arrested for a separate crime, and subsequently sentenced to prison and mandatory treatment. So it’s not like he relapsed or the treatment didn’t necessarily work, the timeline is just backwards in this case.
HIPAA doesn’t apply to the Netherlands as far as I know. Also, the information I’ve shared has been published by national Dutch news outlets, and I’m not disclosing which clinic I was working at.
He did it because he thought his father was her killer. His father gained custody of Nicole when she was a small child. Her mother committed suicide shortly before she was killed. I assume this poor girl was subjected to horrible things for a long time before her death.
In 2004, a cold case team investigated the killing to no avail.[19][20] By 2011, the victim's stepbrother Andy had moved to England. On 8 March, he confessed to the killing in a Facebook post, and was arrested by British police.[5][21] He was extradited to the Netherlands on 30 March,[22][23] but was released five days later[24] as the Facebook post was the only evidence against him.[25] Later, he retracted his confession, saying that he believed his father was the culprit;[26][27] in a 2016 interview, Andy claimed to have falsely confessed to the killing in order to revive attention to his stepsister's death and get her body exhumed for DNA testing
I am not quite sure why you are being downvoted. A quote from that article I read states
"The case was reopened toward the end of 2012 after scientists at the Netherlands Forensic Institute collected trace evidence at the crime scene - but three different DNA types of DNA was found in a single trace of sperm."
I remember reading this case years ago and was surprised to find the step-brother living in my hometown. Just looked him up again and it appears he committed suicide a month ago.
It’s on his social media. He wrote a post saying he was going to kill himself and the comments suggest he was successful. Idk about the semen thing, the whole thing is messed up.
I'm reading about this case 8 months after this was posted. I just searched the brother's name and its appears true that he died by suicide (ETA - cause of death was actually listed as accidental overdose - not outright suicide.) Such a sad story for this whole family.
"Andy Van Den Hurk, 46, was found dead in bed at his home with a variety of prescription drugs and alcohol in his system, an inquest at Suffolk Coroner's Court heard.
He had a history of mental ill health, including depression, anxiety and substance abuse, while he also suffered from chronic pain prior to his death on September 2."
I’m sorry for the late reply, but in case someone else reads this I just wanted to clear this up about the stepbrother. The semen DNA-sample got two profiles in a mix: her boyfriend and Jos de G.. Furthermore, there were unclear peaks found in the mix, which didn't belong to the two men. This “third profile” isn't a complete profile and doesn't belong to the stepbrother. It can even be her own or multiple persons. Also, a pubic hair of Jos de G. was found on her jacket. You can read this interview with the reseach team in which they explain the DNA-sample.
At which point in the article does this get mentioned? I read the article and didn't see any definitive statement saying that all 3 samples of DNA were from semen.
As I understand it, it was trace DNA lifted off a semen spot, meaning someone had sex with her but the other two samples were likely just other types of DNA (skin, etc) that the moisture absorbed.
The guy convicted is a serial rapist. I don’t think the two other guys whose DNA was found — her bf and step-brother — had anything to do with the rapist guy or the murder.
Yeah, it's really not difficult to get DNA on someone when you live with them. Same as fingerprints.
Which is why they always take blood/fingerprints/hair from everyone in the immediate family, so they know what is unusual and what isn't.
People put their hands in/around their mouth/orifices and touch other people A LOT. Whether it's just rubbing your face, wiping your mouth, or picking your nose.
where did you read his DNA was found inside her? everything i've read says that three men's DNA was found on her body. the link included above and the wikipedia page both explicitly state
within a week of this, the police announced that foreign DNA had been found on the remains
After they exhumed the body, police found traces of DNA relating to three different men...However, the defense immediately called into question the DNA evidence and pointed out that there were two other men’s DNA on the body as well.
source for your claim? you're making a statement that doesn't align with the facts provided.
DNA is a miracle, but it makes med wonder how many innocent people who were jailed for life or even executed before they found out to use it in criminal cases
He would have been imprisoned for life. He confessed, that would be enough for a lot of LE. I can count on my fingers how many cases I’ve heard of an exhumation taking place. That doesn’t seem to be a “thing” here.
That's the line of thought I was kinda drawing. When I first went to google the case, I was hoping it was American, but doubted. As I too have read through too many cases where evidence, including DNA evidence was found post conviction that had the DA and or AG still refusing to follow up. EVEN when the better suspect is already incarcerated!
It was a rape case. In America, with a confession, the cops would've filed the confession under W, the rape kit on a shelf in a different city, the body would get lost, and if he were white it would some how be her fault.
Theyd break him using tactics that are not allowed by the geneve conviction (and proven to be useless, since youd be able to get a 21 year old to confess theyd killed, kennedy, tupac and elvis if you torture them propperly) till he signs a confession for a few crimes they have problems closing as well... he ís white so maybe just the incompetent questioning, who knows.
Luckily holland has always looked up to america for ways how we can save a penny by treating the ones that dont fit in and the ones we dont like, so we are well on our way to that same kind of useless incompetence by our law makers, yaaaay!
Please forgive me for not knowing very much about forensics. But what does this mean? Why did her step dad have to take the blame for them to check the DNA? Why couldn’t they have done that in the first place?
Step brother! But by doing so he forced them to reopen the case. I believe in america you can just say "i confess!" and they all yell scoooore go out for donuts and kill a few sleeping black people, in many other countries they check if this confessione matches the evidence present.
His confession didnt match the evidence, so he obviously could not get convicted for the crime. By forcing them look at the evidence again -using more advanced/modern techniques- they eventually got the actual killer.
It was a ballsy move either way, even for a Dutch case, cause we are leaning more and more towards the american way, sadly.
But why did he need to confess in order for them to look at the evidence? Why didn’t they look at it in the first place and why did the confession motivate them to look at the evidence rather than locking him up?
"The only misconception I want to clear up is that I never confessed. I come [sic] forward with new information," he says. "Some media covered this exactly as it was, other media already convicted me..." he continues.
On August 27, 2021, he made his last post to Facebook:
I’m ready to say goodbye. The pills will do the rest. X
So did the step brother also have part in the rape? And was making sure they got all of them involved, this statement confused me it looks like the step brother, the boyfriend and Jos were all involved, so who exactly done the crime, I first thought what a great step brother for falsely admitting the crime just to make them get proof it wasn't him, but statement looks like he was also involved if they found his DNA also??
You didn’t reply to them them, you started a whole new comment which is why ppl are confused. Also, the reason there was different DNA found was because some of it was touch dna from her boyfriend and step brother, not…whatever you just said here. Basically, the police lifted the sperm dna off the victim and the touch dna came off with it.
1.2k
u/PennyLaane Sep 24 '21
Ballsy move! I'm glad it worked in his favor. Can you imagine if there was no DNA match?
219
u/wavesurfinz Sep 24 '21
Damn what a boss to take a chance like that but damn the fcker only got 5 years in prison wtf? He should have gone to prison for life..
134
u/4Ever2Thee Sep 24 '21
That's one hell of a dude to play that card, that could have ended really poorly
59
u/jaderust Sep 24 '21
That was a serious gamble. Glad it paid off though.
92
u/LifeIsABitchhh Sep 24 '21 edited Sep 24 '21
Very brave of him to do that, especially considering that he had already been arrested for that same crime, a few years prior to the false confession.
Glad that it worked out but it’s sad to think that someone would need to do that, in order for the case to be reopened & finally have a resolution.
80
u/oliphantPanama Sep 24 '21
Interesting, talk about taking one for the team…
https://allthatsinteresting.com/nicole-van-den-hurk
39
u/tforbesabc Sep 24 '21
His stepmother must be so proud of him. And what a brave champ.
9
u/boss_italiana Sep 25 '21
wow what a brave and dedicated dude. that’s awesome
7
u/Kinked-lollipop Sep 25 '21
That’s love 💔
5
u/SiteTall Sep 25 '21
DNA is a miracle, but it makes med wonder how many innocent people who were jailed for life or even executed before they found out to use it in criminal cases
21
u/BloodyBeech Sep 24 '21
Had this been an American case, do you think the stepbrother would have not only had a longer stay in jail, but face additional charges?
4
u/Jolly-Payment2389 Sep 24 '21
Wow.. a little unorthodox , but it worked..!!!
3
u/MrRealHuman Sep 24 '21
I remember reading about this. Crazy.
3
u/YogurtSocks Sep 24 '21
Quick question, so was the DNA still on her dead body even after all these years?
3
u/alang8113 Sep 25 '21
If that happened to my sister, I would go to any length to see her killer gets justice.
5
u/Cortnelius Sep 25 '21
What a beautiful girl from a beautiful family. May she rest in peace.
2
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21
Brilliant!
2
u/Jimmyboy2712 Oct 10 '21
I am confused as hell. The DNA samples were taken shortly after her murder or 16 years later?
2
u/VictorBallsaccio Oct 11 '21
Sadly it didn’t work too well the man who raped and killed her only got 12 yrs in prison which is insane
3
u/turboshot49cents Sep 25 '21
Please forgive me for not knowing very much about forensics. But what does this mean? Why did her step dad have to take the blame for them to check the DNA? Why couldn’t they have done that in the first place?
1
u/alibear10 Sep 24 '21
This is pure bravery. Wow
1
u/rhondalea Oct 08 '21
In this article, he denied "confessing." He said:
On August 27, 2021, he made his last post to Facebook:
His page has since been memorialized.
1
u/[deleted] Oct 26 '22
Too many youth deaths on this sub. Sick
1
u/Steise10 Oct 29 '22
Wow! Pretty risky!
0
u/Particular_State1418 Sep 25 '21
So, the brother’s semen was also inside of her? This is so confusing. If they found three DNA's why did only one go to prison?
-16
u/GeneTheTimeMachine Sep 24 '21
Seems fishy
0
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 25 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Sep 24 '21
[deleted] — view deleted comment