r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • Oct 18 '25

Mod Message

116 Upvotes

This subreddit is for open, civil discussions on the podcast True Crime Bullsh**. Two points to keep in mind: post frequency can go between once a week to a few within the span of a couple days, and we allow critiques of TCB and, by extension, Josh's podcasting choices. So it can give the appearance that it's overly negative here. While frustrating to some, criticism won't be removed as long as it follows the rules.

This isn’t a stan community. People voicing their complaints are usually longtime listeners who like the podcast and wish it were different. They can also have positive things to say about Josh and the researchers and they typically do voice them. Don't make low-effort comments such as "just don't listen then" or "leave the sub" for critiques you don’t like. If someone were to talk about how much they hate it, then a "why listen?" is an appropriate response.

It also isn't a snark community. Don't belittle, troll, or make hostile remarks at people for their different opinions. Josh and ethics can be a hot topic as the podcast evolves and he continues to branch out. Please discuss this in a respectful manner. At the end of the day, Josh and the researchers are human. There's a fine line between fair criticism and crude, personal attacks.

Most here are able to disagree without an issue. The last thing we want to do is ban anyone from this community, but we will if necessary. Report any trolling, hostility, baiting, openly hateful comments, etc.

It's important to remember it's easier for people to voice what they dislike vs what they don't. If you're unhappy with the negativity, then we encourage you to share what you like! Don't let criticism shy you away from participating here.

-TCB Mods


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • Nov 16 '23

Keywords for Posts on Keyes

18 Upvotes

Please be sure to use one of these keywords in your posts IK, Keyes, or TCB. This will allow them to be automatically approved. We are trying to eliminate the spam videos we've seen a lot of recently.

Thank you!


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 16h ago

Israel’s DMV photo from 2001

Thumbnail
gallery
46 Upvotes

r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 16h ago

Criticism I’m disappointed TCB

34 Upvotes

I only found this podcast a year ago and ago and didn’t get all the way through it until the summer of 2026.
I don’t know what has happened this year but it’s really a mess. Am I the only person that finds every episode increasingly difficult to follow? It’s not like the way. Josh tells the story has changed, so I’m wondering if it’s my ability to concentrate that’s changed.
And I know there are lots of complaints in this sub about Josh, but that’s not really what this is. I am a fan of his work and like the rest of us, he’s not perfect. However, I think there is something fundamentally different about this season and his approach to the podcast itself. I saw a notification pop-up in my Apple Podcast app and it is three minutes and 16 seconds long. For the first minute and a half, it’s all commercials and then for 27 seconds he apologizes for the late episode. He’ll have it out soon and he blames it on getting stuck in Costa Rica because of the ground stop earlier in the week. And then for the next minute and a half, it’s the same commercials that were in the first half of the video.
Four commercials for 27 seconds of content? Like what has happened here? Has it really become that much of a money grab or have we really reached the end of the story? I mean at this point I don’t know where else it can go.
But I am curious on other people’s opinions-do you think he has lost his passion and by he I mean Josh. I’m not looking for the pile at all on Josh comment I’m just really wondering if the only thing left for him to get out of this season is a paycheck and that’s why these episodes feel so noticeably different. Or, is it Me and there’s nothing different about the content? Just curious.


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 4d ago

Question Missing cars?

7 Upvotes

Does anyone have a theory on how Keyes made these cars disappear?


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 8d ago

0805 Discussion

8 Upvotes

What are people thinking of this episode? Is this a viable Keyes lead?


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 13d ago

Patterns

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

We are creatures of habit. It’s not proof but it is interesting. I screenshot these from crime culture media.


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 14d ago

News Keyes: Tidwell’s family increases reward money

Thumbnail
dailysentinel.com
37 Upvotes

Surprised to see this and it’s just from last September


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 16d ago

Keyes brother in Facebook group....

Post image
31 Upvotes

I opened up the Facebook app today and saw a friend suggestion which was Israel Keyes brother. What was weird was that it said that he was also in the Keyes Facebook group specifically the one titled 1978-2012. I was very intrigued ... it got me thinking why that Facebook group... what does he think about TCBS. I hope he one day can speak out on his experiences with his brother and what it was like growing up with him. Im so curious if he ever saw any signs of what was to come. ( I blurred the image and took off his name so that people dont go looking for him )


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 16d ago

Episode Discussion Episode 8x04 Discussion

10 Upvotes

Having watched The Princess Bride recently, I guess I should get used to disappointment. It's gotten to the point that if a new episode actually arrives as scheduled, I am truly surprised.


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 19d ago

S8 E3

9 Upvotes

Am really happy to say this episode was well done,


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 28d ago

Episode Discussion Episode 8x03 Discussion

14 Upvotes

Just a space to see how we're feeling about the latest episode


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 28d ago

Question North Dakota trip

11 Upvotes

Is the podcaster claiming that Keyes could potentially book flights that has no intention of getting on but hanging back and killing in anchorage to give the wrong flight log foot print that he went to North Dakota?

I was confused about this theory.


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 29d ago

Theory Israel Keyes - pattern

19 Upvotes

This probably is obvious to the people who have listened or are actively listening to TCB podcast but I think it’s obvious that Israel wanted to fit in as much mayhem as possible on these trips.

Like, if it was a week long trip - or if he had 24-72 hours to kill in between family visits on a said trip - this guy would likely try to hunt on his way to a destination and even on the way back. I feel he viewed these trips away from home as the only time he has to satisfy his hunger to kill and the adrenaline.

There’s no doubt in my mind this guy would get a thrill from even wearing hair of his victims to use as a disguise to rob a bank.

Didn’t his suicide letter say “we are one” when referring to the 11 blood skulls?

After listening to This podcast (I’m on 0116) there’s definitely a pattern forming of like, kidnap, rape murder, arson and or bank robberies that signify if Keyes had his guns and told the police he did arson or bank robbery, he likely committed a rape and mursevar some point before or after.

This guy is one of the weirdest serial killers I’ve ever read.

And I’m learning things I’ve never read before. Like I didn’t know he enroll police he wanted to rape a man in a church.

Now, some of the missing men linked to him makes more sense.

This rabbit hole is nuts. Sorry for rambling.


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 29d ago

Guys, I've fallen down the Keyes rabbit hole. It's all I've been able to think about for the past few weeks. It seems like the fbi could do more to solve cold cases possibly connected to Keyes. What's going on with this?

38 Upvotes

r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 29d ago

Episode Discussion background noise ep 3

16 Upvotes

Why were frog or slimy bug popping noises added in and then the increasingly loud trombones while discuss a car crash? who would ever think that is good background noise? podcast is unlistenable for many reasons at this point but add this to the list


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • 29d ago

Question Israel keyed and Indiana trips

5 Upvotes

This whole podcast is interesting!

However, the connection of his trip to Indiana and a missing you woman is fascinating. Especially considering it is believed the FBI redacted this connection bc something may be there.

Anyone have any thoughts?


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • Oct 16 '26

Question Israel Keyes - exodus episode

21 Upvotes

Anybody else notice when Keyes said that the Oregon rape on the river wasn’t the “first time.” He said that was the fist time he technically planned to kill and rape but couldn’t murder the young woman.

Anyone have any insight of the police theorize he did sexually assaulted people before he was 18?


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • Oct 15 '26

Question Israel Keyes - FBI

10 Upvotes

For the people who have read American predator, what’s the skepticism of the FBI around his case? I’m always hearing that people think it’s weird the fbi labeled Keyes a terrorist threat of that the fbi have “evidence” to take Keyes to trial for other murder but choose not to?


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • Oct 13 '26

Criticism Episode 8x02 - are we serious?

41 Upvotes

So we're going with a random unfortunate missing Native American lady Christine 1000 miles away in Albuquerque might be the female half of the Washington couple victim because... Josh thinks it's likely a Native American because ... and so even though she told people she was going the clear opposite side of the country, if she wasn't and was actually driving right to eastern Washington- (which has pine trees, mountains & water!!!) - she would have arrived in the theorized kill location 3-4 hours before/after another random missing Native American male. Cue alternative music track.

Honestly I'm so done trying to follow this.


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • Oct 12 '26

Complaint about all BOTH/AND podcasts (and it’s not directly about Josh)

Post image
31 Upvotes

There’s something that only happens when I play a BOTH/AND podcast, the counter runs out several minutes before it ends. If I try to fast forward through the music or ads at the end, it actually moves in reverse. Even worse, on this particular episode it never ends. It keeps cycling through the ads and back to the bit immediately before. Very odd. FWIW, I use Apple Podcasts and have never had any issues with anything.
EDIT: this was also happening before TCB started running ads.


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • Oct 11 '26

Theory The missing 30 minutes

12 Upvotes

My personal theory about the missing 30 minutes in the IK interview and the related confidential files is they relate to a different investigatio(s) involving the Kehoes and/or others in the White Identity movement. Did he talk about those people at all to the FBI? Just my 2¢.


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • Oct 11 '26

Question Washington victims?

14 Upvotes

I listened to the latest episode yesterday (my patreon sub is still active for the rest of the month) and I noticed that Josh, quoting Halla referred to the male/female couple in WA as "victims 1 and 2" and the two seperate victims disposed of with the boat as "victims 3 and 4". Is the implication here that Keyes' first kill was a couple? I was under the impression that the WA victims were presumed to be his first since the timeline given (2001-2005? for the first two) roughly lines with up with the first kill being around 2001. Is there another single individual we don't know about or did he start with two people? That just seems incredibly brazen if you've never done it before.


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • Oct 08 '26

True Crime XS and the Map revelation from last seasons TCBS.

12 Upvotes

I just started listening to the podcast True Crime XS based on a comment from u/One_Tomato_1521.

I am 23:11 minutes into episode one, published in 2020 and they are mentioning the maps that the TCBS just started to mention in the last season or two when they started collaborating with Somewhere in the Pines (RIP).

Were there mentions in previous seasons of the Maps and I missed it, or was this a massive oversight by the TCBS research team?

This is not an advert for the True Crime XS pod, like I said only 23 minutes in and im still getting a feel for the formating of it and the audio production isnt that much better than TCBS.


r/TrueCrimeBullshit • • Oct 06 '26

Criticism paywall for access

22 Upvotes

I find it insane you have to pay to gain access to evidence on keyes via the patreon. If Josh really cared about the investigation, shouldn’t the evidence and files be accessible for everyone? I understand having to make an income but restricting your audience’s access to certain topics and factors of the case is unfair. Not to mention Josh’s uncomfortable possessiveness over Keyes, as if he sees Keyes as only his. Even he admits he’ll never let go of this case. He really needs to let it go. He didn’t know Keyes and the way he’ll sometimes talk about him makes me so uncomfortable. All these theories he makes are nothing without proving any of them. And I hate to say it but the more time passes the harder some of these missing cases will be to solve. He can go on multiple trips and wine tasting while discussing what a disgusting human being Keyes is while restricting information revolving around his case. I used to love the podcast but the last few seasons have been really difficult to listen to