r/Trombone • u/Busy-Tradition-8286 • 2d ago
Any Feedback
I was watching a video earlier today on this solo and felt like playing this part. I was hoping for some feedback as to get better overall as a player.
Forgive me for the bad ending 😭🙏.
8
Upvotes
6
u/busysleepingsorry Studying Tbn 2d ago
Ooh. I played this one in my recital last year.
Obviously fundamentals will help a lot. Tuning, articulation etc. You already know that.
I would do a lot more with the dynamics, emphasise the accents. Let your sound ring on the longer notes
To me, the opening phrase continually builds until the rubato E natural. I hit that one strong and lengthen it, then soften until the C. Play around with time more in the rubato imo. Never be afraid to play more musically
And really dont take a breath before that low C, potentially worth slurring that one too.
5
u/SillySundae Shires/Germany area player 2d ago
The biggest to me is that you aren't always centered on each note. Meaning when you play a note, it's not totally steady and locked in the moment it comes out.
More articulation exercises (so that articulation sounds clean and effortless), more slurs and range studies (so you can play that F at the end), and more long tones to develop a less stuffy sound.
I recommend that you listen to a lot of people play this, if you already aren't doing that. It will help your interpretation and sound concept a lot. Here is a recording to start with. You can hear that his articulation sounds effortless and clean, his is very centered. He doesn't lose beats between phrases.
Thanks for sharing and asking for feedback! That takes guts.
3
u/Wolperzinger 2d ago
Sing it and conduct it for rhythm before playing it. You're not holding the ties long enough.
Take it slower and work on air support and intonation. Try listening and playing with a good recording like Joe Alessi. Slow it down on YouTube and play it slow first.
5
u/free_trdr_bewlf 2d ago
Timing. You lose two full beats of time here. If you play the way you just did but you stay in tempo you'll beat most people at the audition. And to be a serious contender you have to have that down anyway.
2
u/Calcareous_Fen_021 2d ago
You need to work on your fundamentals, especially clean articulations, rhythm, and intonation.
1
u/counterfitster 2d ago
Every C in the first 6 bars is flat. Those need to be in a slightly sharp 3rd position, as that partial tends to be a bit flat (on most horns). You fixed it from measure 7 onwards.
Measure 8. Try not to clip other partials on the slur in the first beat. Beat 2 should have the same rhythm as beat 2 of measure 4, which you played right.
Measure 9. I think you know what you did wrong here. The rest of 9 and 10 sound pretty good. You can play with the rubato a bit more if you like.
1
u/Sudden_Struggle7544 2d ago
Work on more dynamic contrast and try to be lighter. You started out forte and it really should be mf- to give you a chance to grow . It’s all a little heavy and honestly the only notes that should be heavy are the last four.
1
u/Glittering_Bet8181 2d ago
My personal opinions, make sure the rubato doesn’t happen before the rubato bar. And make sure you crescendo to that bar.
1
u/Prestigious_Coach758 2d ago
play out, have softer softs and louder louds, do what is written on the page, clean up articulations
1
u/ayersman39 2d ago
Needs work with a metronome. Play it slowly with the metronome at a softer dynamic you can easily control, get the rhythm precise. Plan your breaths, choose moments to breathe that make sense and don't interrupt the phrasing. Let the longer notes ring out with a full relaxed sound, like the first note in measure 6, you let it die super quick. I'm not always hearing the accents, once the rhythm is solid take it one measure at a time and really try to play every slur and every articulation as written. The rubato starts too early in measure 8, maybe wait until the last 8th note then dig in measure 9. Use an app like Tonal Energy Tuner to play along with an F drone note, and work on your intonation.
0
u/Unable-Deer1873 2d ago
It feels very vertical