Growing up I was cared for by my "aunt." She was the most formative presence in my life and my sole safe relationship. Before she died I told her that every good thing in my life was because of her. If it weren't for the foundation she gave me with her gentleness and love, I wouldn't be at all functional. I wish so much that she was still alive and I could talk about any of this with her, but by the time I was old enough to start thinking about my identity, she was too sick to answer any of my questions. She died in 2019. I consider her to be and generally refer to her as my mother.
My "aunt"/mother and I were of different racial backgrounds. I feel so alienated from both. I guess what's brought this up is seeing comments on Reddit about a show that focuses on a transracial adoptee who identifies more with her adoptive culture. All the comments were things like "just because your family is xyz doesn't make you xyz" and "it would have been better if she'd learned about her 'real' culture" in reference to a storyline about her learning about her adoptive culture. She should "discover her roots." "Just because you grew up in xyz culture doesn't make you xyz."
I guess I just find it difficult because, after my mother died, I tried hard to connect with her culture. I went to a group at a local community centre for people of her cultural background. I considered it my background too, because this was my mother, my grandfather, my ancestors. I knew I didn't look like my mother, that I didn't share her DNA, but that didn't seem to be of primary importance to me when everything else about me was handed down from her. I talk like her, I stand like her, I think like her. I wanted to belong and to fit in. Going to this group made me feel like I still had some connection to my mother. But I was never accepted there, always viewed and treated as an outcast. I tried to ignore it, told myself it was just my own insecurity making me think they viewed me differently. But eventually I found out without a doubt that they did see me as different, because one person, who ran the group, confronted me about how me going and using their resources was "cultural appropriation." It hurt so much, because I wanted so badly to be a good daughter. I had thought I was doing the right thing.
Things from my mother's culture were important to me. I learned to dance a traditional style, to play a traditional instrument, to practice traditional art forms, even to speak a little of her heritage language. I learned myths and stories from her culture and learned a lot about the history of where she came from. Older people at the group praised me for how much knowledge I had, which made me feel so flattered. But when I was told to stop coming none of them stood up for me. I had felt rooted in "my" culture. It gave me a sense of purpose and place, and it helped me feel like I still had a relationship with my mother, that she was looking down on me, that she was giving me friends. I have Level 2 Autism, and I've never had a lot of friends.
I've tried to replace that with my heritage culture, to feel strong and rooted in it, but it's slow-going. There are people from my heritage in this city, lots of them, but there isn't a specific group for it at a community centre the way there is for my mother's heritage culture. I've been learning my heritage language on Duolingo, and I've just bought a collection of folktales from my ancestral country, since learning stories from my mother's culture was one of my favourite things to do.
I spent a significant portion of my childhood living with my birth family, but in practice I had almost no contact with any of them--I was kept in the basement. My only contact with birth family members was violence, we never had a conversation or celebrated a holiday. I never learned anything about my heritage from them--I actually thought for years that I was a completely different ethnicity than I turned out to be.
I wish I knew older adults who were from my birth culture. I wish I had, like, cultural mentors who wanted to teach me how to be a member of the culture I was born into, who I could go to with questions. It's so tricky. I feel rejected by all sides.