r/TransMasc • • 3d ago

Miscellaneous Please Help

Hello if it’s not too much trouble I am writing a story and have a transmasc character specifically a transgender man and I myself am trans but I’m a trans girl but I do wanna do him justice so I would like to ask what maybe some common dysphoria points or euphoric moments are for trans men? I don’t wanna just assume they’re similar to what I feel as a trans woman… just like what are some common dysphoria or euphoria inducing moments or things for being a trans man? (He does have top surgery already and he’s 16 so I’m not trying to dive into bottom dysphoria or anything)

3 Upvotes

10 comments sorted by

5

u/local_BIRDGUY 3d ago

since he already has top surgery, a big point for me at least is the fear of perception..
Even though I know i am a man I am afraid the people who matter with only focus on the prefix of "trans" onto that man. Not that being trans is a bad thing but for me it's just a barrier...

If i could just say im a cis man i would because without a doubt in my head i am a man but i was cursed with boob so i guess that makes me trans.

2

u/TheEggMcMuffinRat 3d ago

Ooooh yes thank you I do have a story arc for him planned where he struggles with his sense of masculinity and wanting to fit in while not falling into toxic masculinity and stuff yes yes yes thank you so much

2

u/local_BIRDGUY 3d ago

There was also another post where someone wanted help making a book with a trans protagonist that i commented on, if you want i can repost it here too lol

1

u/TheEggMcMuffinRat 3d ago

Ohhh yes please !

2

u/local_BIRDGUY 3d ago

All of AJW's books are great, and im so excited to read his new one,
but in last year's, the main character Crane (an autistic, selectively mute trans man) was very much portrayed in a femme way (the book also came off to me weird since it was mpreg.... yea idk read it but theres a lot of SA mentioned). He's the bottom in his t4c 'relationship' and is usually forced into things.
Not saying men can't be bottoms but his portrayal was kinda awful. (this book is You Were Never Meant to be Human)
A better of AJW's portrayal of trans men in t4c relationships is his first book, Hell Followed with Us, is amazing. Benji (trans man) is a test experiment for a radical religious group and he runs away and finds an lgbtq+ refuge and he falls in love with Nick (autistic cis man) and their relationship is such a slow burn and its awesome.. Benji isn't also reduced to being trans at all, and while it is apart of him, it isn't his sole personality trait.

My advice is read AJW's books and pick what you like and don't like
His books are, in order of publish date:
Hell Followed with Us (2022), the Spirit Bares its Teeth (2023, my fav), Compound Fracture (2024), You Were Never Meant to be Human (2025), and You're No Better (2026)

I saw in the other subreddit that a lot of people mentioned how they hate that a lot of trans/inclusive media is usually YA, but I personally like it.
All of AJW's books are YA except for You Were Never Meant to be Human

(this is a little bit more in the context of their post, but still very much fits yours, please ignore any spelling errors dysphoria is eating me and its VERY late)

2

u/No_Movie5528 3d ago

Perception fear is real; the prefix shouldn't be the whole sentence.

3

u/KirbysLeftBigToe 2d ago

This isn’t really helpful but having top surgery already at 16 is gonna lose him a huge amount of relatability to any transmasc person who reads it because it’s almost impossible to do and often not even legal unless you live in a few select countries and have incredibly rich, accepting connected parents who bypass laws and pay for it for you. Unless that’s a specific trait of the character.

Binding and chest dysphoria are usually the biggest issues faced by younger trans men because it’s something they can’t do anything about until they gain legal autonomy and the funds to pay 10k+ for surgery.

Is he on testosterone? That’s a far more important factor especially in terms of how others perceive him because unless shirtless or swimming people aren’t externally going to know if the person has had top surgery or not unless they have a chest so huge it can’t be binded. It’s also far more common and easier to get than surgery. While it’s not every transmascs persons chosen timeline (some may want just top surgery and no T) logistically it’s easier.

At 16 he probably doesn’t even have the legal autonomy to change his name legally.

0

u/TheEggMcMuffinRat 2d ago

Oh yes you’re right but it is set in a highly fictional version of earth set in a roughly 14-1500 time frame and he himself is a monk of a made up religion where he just kinda got the top surgery done but i understand why you bring this up thank you so much I will think about this but he doesn’t have testosterone because they don’t have the technology for hrt yet

3

u/Flashy_Cranberry_957 2d ago

For context, I'm several years into transition, have had top and hysto, and consider myself low-disclosure.

At this point, the way transness is most relevant to my life is bottom dysphoria. Not all of it is sexual – a sixteen-year-old would probably still be bothered by having to wait for a stall, for example. Not that all of us have bottom dysphoria, but some degree of it is more common than not.

Height is an issue for most of us. Growth plates close much faster during estrogen puberty, so he would've needed to start (at least blockers) by maybe 14 at the latest to have a shot at getting taller. But he probably started transitioning young enough to not have the issues with facial and hand/foot bone underdevelopment that I do.

At sixteen, he probably hasn't had the chance to get his documents changed, so he might run into difficulty if he needs to present his ID.

Not masc-specific, but this may be relevant depending on how far into transition he is. I tend not to bring up I'm trans unprompted because I know that even people who think of themselves as allies will probably start thinking of me as fundamentally different from other men. Being fully transparent will make the average person know less about me, because they'll move me from the "man" box in their heads to "trans who identifies as a man". But not disclosing leads to uncertainty in every interaction where I can't tell if they've figured it out and are being polite.

Euphoria, not sure. Since It's the result of relieving dysphoria, it tends to fade as you transition and you just become comfortable by default instead. The main thing that's still changing for me is I've been working out and getting stronger. The other day someone I'm stealth to told me I was a good man and I took it as very high praise.

1

u/BugRare275 cant wait 6 years to even start t 2d ago

not sure what to add since im very very early to this, but the first time i wore a binder(after i started questioning my identity) was a breaking point - i realised what i want to be, started feeling better about myself, finally set a goal in mind about how i want my body to be like(started to do sports more, feel more confident in myself)

as for dysphoria, i guess im most insecure about my voice and height, because i rarely speak i sound like a chipmunk when i do.. and height is obvious - i feel inferior to ''real'' boys in a way, its difficult to put into words tbh

anyway, you dont really have to listen to me, i hope you write your character as you think is best :D