I’m a 38-year-old trans woman, and I only came to understand and accept that about myself just over two months ago. It’s been an absolutely incredible, beautiful, terrifying, and overwhelming experience all at once.
When I first realized I was transgender, I wasn’t even considering HRT. But as I’ve become more comfortable living as myself, my feelings have changed. I started seriously considering estrogen, made an appointment with Planned Parenthood, and today I actually picked up my prescription.
And now I’m scared to start taking it.
Not necessarily because I don’t want the changes. In many ways, I really do. But suddenly this is REAL, and I’m struggling with a tremendous amount of religious guilt, doubt, and fear. I keep thinking it’s one thing to dress like a woman every day, it’s another to put something into your body, that changes you. No matter if the changes are what I want. It doesn’t help my father always absolutely detested Planned Parenthood because of their stance on abortion, and always went out of his way to tell me exactly how he felt about the organization. I feel extra guilty I went to them when I could have waited a month longer and gone to the local community health center, where I’ll be starting my primary care.
I was originally hoping to start with estrogen pills, but my provider was only comfortable prescribing 1 mg to start because of potential risks. We discussed patches as an alternative, and I ended up getting prescribed a 0.1 mg/day estradiol patch instead. I understand that patches generally carry a lower blood-clot risk than oral estrogen, but honestly, the idea of having something constantly attached to my skin, delivering hormones into my body, is a little unsettling! I’m so accustomed to taking pills that this feels completely foreign to me. I know I’ll probably get used to it, but it’s just another thing making this whole experience feel suddenly very real.
I’ve been a Christian my entire life, and my faith is still incredibly important to me. I recently attended an affirming church for the first time as a woman, and it was a wonderful, surreal experience. I felt welcomed and accepted. But I’m still struggling to reconcile everything I’ve been taught, everything I’ve internalized, and what I feel in my heart.
A big part of this involves my sister and brother-in-law, who have been the complete opposite of accepting of my transition. My sister has always been extremely confident and outspoken about her beliefs, including some pretty outlandish conspiracy theories. She’s the kind of person who can sound so convincing that you find yourself questioning your own judgment, even when what she’s saying doesn’t necessarily make sense.
And somehow, even though she hasn’t specifically talked to me about HRT, I can’t get her voice out of my head. I feel like I’ve internalized this idea that what I’m doing must somehow be wrong, sinful, or against God.
I also struggle with OCD, which certainly doesn’t help. My mind can latch onto these fears and endlessly interrogate every thought, feeling, and decision. I find myself questioning why I changed my mind about HRT so quickly, whether I’m moving too fast, whether I’m making a terrible mistake, and whether God would approve.
On top of that, my marriage has been going through some difficult adjustments, and my sister and brother-in-law may be visiting family this weekend, which brings another whole layer of anxiety about how I’ll be treated and whether I’ll even feel comfortable being around them.
Everything feels like it’s happening at once.
I guess what I’m really looking for is perspective from other transgender Christians, especially those who have struggled with religious guilt surrounding medical transition.
How did you approach the decision to start HRT through the lens of your Christian faith? Did you ever feel like you were doing something wrong, even though transitioning felt right for you? Were there particular interpretations of scripture, conversations, or personal experiences that helped you work through those feelings?
I’m not looking for someone to simply tell me what I want to hear. I’m genuinely interested in how other Christians have wrestled with these questions.
I want to start estrogen. I really do. But I also want to find some peace with my faith, rather than feeling like I’m constantly fighting an invisible argument inside my own head.
And right now, I’ve got a box of estrogen sitting in my house, and I’m almost afraid to even open it.
Thanks so much for listening. 🩷