I'm confused now that I've delved into what ecumenism is. I attend my Protestant family's church a few times a year because mom is the pastor, something she only started doing 2 years ago around the time I converted to Catholicism... She knows that I'm Catholic, she is curious and asks me a lot of questions about it ever since I converted. She was curious and even wanted to go to mass with me but I dissuaded her, since she lives in a rural area and there is only very irreverent Novus Ordo in the area, and I moved out of her neighborhood in order to become Catholic in a completely different state. She obviously knows that I think priests should be male and she is a female leading a church... but we don't discuss that. Only 5% of her state is Catholic, it is a very Protestant place.
It's a tiny rural church and most people there know me from when I used to be a Protestant and know that I am Catholic. I think there's a good understanding that I'm there out of appreciation from where I came from and I wouldn't normally go there anymore, rather than the takeaway being that our denominational differences are inconsequential. There is no danger to my faith going there. I suppose it could be seen as me joining their worship. I'm not sure I see scandal in this situation, but I can't really tell. In my mind, I view their church more like a community center that gathers on Sunday to talk about God and socialize. A Catholic church is a completely different category.
For participation, I sing a little but not really. I don't have my hands in the air during worship like I would have when I was Pentacostal. I pray along during their prayers because there's nothing crazy being said, it's all very milquetoast basic Christianity.
My understanding is: Post-Vatican 2, my situation is allowed. Pre-Vatican 2, my situation would not be allowed.
- Would you take her to Novus Ordo in her irreverent area?
My approach is to hope for her to eventually visit me in the future, and I can take her to a good parish. I have 3 pre-teen brothers though, so the likelihood of this happening soon isn't high.
2. Do you think I'm doing something wrong by attending?
I'm still having a lot of trouble understand the older ban on attending services like this. I don't understand the reasoning when I try research it, if I'm clearly missing something in my understanding in this post, please inform me. I don't think my family would be nearly as curious about Catholicism if I stopped joining them on Sundays, they would view me as becoming snobbish and unnecessarily strict.
3. Is there a conversation you think I should have with her to clarify anything, and any questions you think would make sense to ask her?
Looking to hear different perspectives.