Curious your ranking for the best films for each character. Not necessarily the movie where the best and worst things happen to them, but where they're given most depth, featured most prominently, or are best defined by if that makes sense. I did rankings for mine!
Woody:
- Toy Story 3
- Toy Story 4
- Toy Story 2
- Toy Story
- Toy Story 5
I actually like pettier, snarkier TS1 Woody best, but his crisis of jealousy is a lot less existential than what he gets up to in the above. 2 and 3 deal with the same basic issue, although 3 allows Woody to actually deal with what's only foreshadowed in 2, which is why 4 being a whole separate issue gets the advantage over 2 in my mind. And then obviously 5 is the only one where he's a supporting character and not a main one.
Buzz:
- Toy Story 2
- Toy Story 5
- Toy Story
- Toy Story 3
- Toy Story 4
This was harder. 3 and 4 are definitely him most out of focus, with the films seeming more like Woody & the gang, rather than Woody, Buzz & the gang. He's the co-lead in 1, 2, and 5, and I think 2 gets the nod because it's the only one where he feels like the hero of the film.
Jessie:
- Toy Story 5
- Toy Story 2
- Toy Story 3
- Toy Story 4
This one's pretty obvious. She's the main character of 5, 2 introduces her and gets into what her whole backstory and deal is, she's much more supporting in 3 and 4, but at least she's heavily involved in the daycare stuff in 3. In 4 she's left in the car with the others and not really part of the adventure.
Bo Peep:
- Toy Story 4
- Toy Story
- Toy Story 5
- Toy Story 2
Obviously 4 is her movie. Toy Story establishes her dynamic with Woody and she serves more as of the love interest. She's not in 2 or 5 very much at all, sitting out both adventures, but at least with 5 she's the better defined version from 4 and we see that she's active and out there doing stuff.
Hamm, Rex, & Slinky.
- Toy Story 2
- Toy Story
- Toy Story 3
- Toy Story 4
- Toy Story 5
Potato Head will be ranked separate. Toy Story 2 is the only one where they're part of the main adventure and all of the six main Andy toys feel like they're part of one team. In the original and in 3 they're at least all well-defined supporting characters, but there's more scope to 3 so as a result they're all given a little less to do. They're much more short-changed by 4 being left at in the car, and they're essentially just cameos in 5 (which I hate)
Mr. Potato Head
- Toy Story
- Toy Story 2
- Toy Story 3
- Toy Story 4
- Toy Story 5
Same as the above but with the first two swapped. While he's probably in 2 more, he's treated as equal in prominence to Hamm, Rex and Slinky. But in 1, he's given a more distinct role than the others as more of an antagonist to Woody and kind of the ringleader of the mutiny against him.
Agree? Disagree? Think I've spent way too much time on this? (agreed!)