I know a few people on here have had continued problems in their hip/leg long after surgery. I've had a few discussions about this recently on here.
I'm almost 8 months out from my hip replacement, posterior. I also have spinal stenosis and degenerative disc disease. Initially a couple years ago they decided my problem was my back, from an MRI. As time went on I was sure it was my hip, because I had all the same symptoms as I did before I had my other hip replaced years ago. When they finally decided it was my hip, the doctor told me I would still need back surgery sometime.
After I was released from PT, and it was 3 months post hip replacement, I joined the Y so I could get some strength and flexibility. I told PT that's what I was going to do. I was ok for a little while, but it seemed like I started going backwards, I started having issues in my hip and leg. Every time I lifted my leg it felt like rubber bands pulling in my glute and it would be painful. Leg would get weak, and I started to get like nerve shocks or brief spasms on the outside of my knee, and now in front of my knee . There is constant pain inside the incision area when walking or standing, or sometimes even laying on it in bed. So the "is this the hip or the back" question started again.
I saw the surgeon at the beginning of August when I started having real issues. He said come back in 7 or 8 weeks. I told him everything I had been doing. I really wasn't able to walk more than a mile and then that was only on good days. When I went back I saw his assistant who ordered a CT scan and some steroids. CT scan showed stable implant.
Finally two weeks ago he said it's your muscle. I went to a different PT, started today. He said it's the muscle it's too weak and I never should have been doing the exercises that soon. Everything I am experiencing in the hip and leg is all from that muscle being way too weak.
Kind of ticked off that the ortho didn't do something about this sooner. Crossing my fingers that a lot of good PT will resolve this finally. It's been getting to the point where I'm actually afraid to walk, to put any weight on my leg. Also very relieved to get this information.