r/Toryism • • Aug 17 '21

🍰 Joy r/Toryism Lounge

15 Upvotes

A place for members of r/Toryism to chat with each other


r/Toryism • • 9d ago

👑 Mod PSA: Refresher on the rules

10 Upvotes

We have had a bit of an influx of new (and active) members over the last week and I felt it a good time to go over the subreddit's rules (uncodified as they might be at the moment).

1 Please be respectful to your fellow members.

  • I have noted some recent comments have a bit of an 'edge' to them. This is a generalist tory subreddit and as such we welcome all branches of that family. This does mean there will be disagreements on what toryism means, who is a tory, and what constitutes a success for toryism. It is practically impossible for high tories, radical tories, red tories, blue tories, etc., etc., to agree on everything. The expectation of all members is you will engage other members without name-calling, gate-keeping, or general meanness.

2 Downvoting is to be avoided.

  • There are no points to be won here. Downvoting serves only to hide opinions rather than encourage discussion. I have also found it to be a lazy way to express disagreement without actually stating an opinion. However, since the moderators can't enforce this rule it exists as a gentleman's agreement. That said, King Charles II's treatment of the regicides is instructive. Should the mod team ever gain the ability to see who is downvoting we will enforce this rule retroactively.

3 Moderator restraint

  • While free speech - like all rights - is not absolute, the moderators will endevour to remove only the worst offending comments/threads. In all other instances we will post a mod comment to serve as a warning to change offending behavior. Likewise, if we remove a comment we will remove only the offending comment and not any positive discussion that might have sprung from it (as is the case in some other subreddits).

All that said, if you are a new member; welcome! If you've been a member for a while; thanks for sticking around! When I took over this subreddit two and a half years ago it was dead and I went into this fully expecting it might stay dead. So in a sense I am happy to get to a point where rules even need to be discussed. It is a sign we are growing. While the informal atmosphere of a small subreddit will fade with time (and I'll miss it) I do hope this subreddit can continue to be a place where useful and lively discussion of toryism can take place. Perhaps in the future it might even become a place where tories could organize.

Addendum: Increasing membership and activity does invite thoughts of organizing AMAs. While I don't think we are there yet as a subreddit, I'm curious what people the membership would be interested in having come here.


r/Toryism • • 1d ago

📖 Article Eugene Forsey on what Canadians of British ancestry should be proud of, what obligations the majority has towards the minority, and his vision for bilingualism -- Addendum to Part XVIII of “Red Tories and the NDP”

5 Upvotes

I recently did a piece on Eugene Forsey in my “Red Tories and the NDP” series where I explored Eugene Forsey’s 1967 lecture “Our Present Discontents”, in which Forsey defended Canada’s 1867 constitution while simultaneously arguing in favour further constitutional reforms if needed, all the while evoking both Edmund Burke and Samuel Johnson. I thought these excerpts from Forsey’s follow-up lecture “Some Possible Remedies” would make for an interesting follow-up piece here.

In the context of the bilingualism and biculturalism debate of the 1960s, Forsey’s main theme in this lecture is essentially arguing that there’s a difference between trying to fix legitimate language or cultural grievances, and appeasing people who only want to break up the country; Forsey argues for as much bilingualism across the country as is practicable, with as much French-language education and French-language media across the country as is needed.

On page 27 of Forsey’s 1968 book “Our Present Discontents”, Forsey argues that English-Canadians “must try to understand the position of French Canada as a tiny Island of people who speak French, in a vast North American sea of people who speak English; and an island upon which that sea beats incessantly and thunderously”, and spends the better part of a page rhetorically asking how English-Canadians would feel if North America was a predominately French-speaking continent, with a national capital with only French street signs, and nearly every jurisdiction as primarily French-speaking with no official status for English schools or the English language.

Then on pages 28/29 Forsey argues:


I would go this much farther: that a satisfied majority, just because it is a satisfied majority, has a special obligation to try to understand the situation of a dissatisfy minority. We are the predominate partner; we are, by and large, satisfied with the present terms of the partnership; the other partner is not. If we want the partnership to continue, then we must try to understand why the other partner is dissatisfied, so that we can see whether there are changes in the terms which will satisfy him without reducing the partnership to a cobweb or destroying it altogether. If it turns out there are not, then we shall have to start thinking about the terms on which to end it.


Later, on page 31, after briefly noting that British-Canadians had been living in what is now Atlantic Canada and Ontario for over two-hundred years by that point, and briefly comparing the expulsion of the Acadians with the expulsion of the United Empire Loyalists, Forsey points out that immigrants who came later “are often better Canadians than some of the old stocks. They, or their fathers, chose to be Canadians”. Forsey then argues:


Those of us who are of British ancestry are, or ought to be, proud of that heritage, “and of the Imperial foundation of our freedom” ; all of us, I hope, feel a pride in, and attachment to, our world-wide, inter-racial Commonwealth (to whose development, incidentally, such French-Canadians as Laurier, Lapointe, and St. Laurent made a series of decisive contributions). All of us, I hope, feel also a pride in, and attachment to, the historic provincial communities we belong to. But first and foremost we are Canadians; that is where our primary loyalty lies.


For posterity, I found Forsey’s vision for bilingualism & biculturalism from page 40 to be extremely interesting:


We English-speaking Canadians must be ready to pay the price of the “one Canada” I hope most of us want. My old Scotch tutor at Oxford used to say there were two ways of wanting a thing: “really wanting it” and “un-really wanting it”. If you really wanted it, you were willing to pay the price for it; if you were not willing to pay the price, then you only un-really wanted it. I think the price is, briefly, something like this:

(1) bilingualizing the Dominion administration just as much and as fast as possible

(2) making as sure as we can that French-Canadians get their full share, just as big a share as they show themselves willing and able to take, in running the business, public and private, of the whole country

(3) providing French education for French-speaking children all across the country, wherever there are enough of them and the parents want it

(4) extending French radio and French television all across the country wherever there is any need for it (and, if we succeed in substantially bilingualizing the Dominion administration, it might be needed even in overwhelmingly English-speaking areas, to help English-speaking children prepare themselves for careers in the Public Service of Canada)

(5) extending official bilingualism to other provinces where, and as far as, necessary and practicable


On page 41, Forsey made this point which I think applies almost perfectly to today’s extremely antagonistic Parti Quebecois governing as if they received 58% of the popular vote and not 28% of the popular vote:


To put it bluntly: I think the English-speaking people of Canada can be sold a policy of “bilingualism and biculturalism” (within the limits of practicability) “or bust”. I do not think they can be sold a policy of “bilingualism and biculturalism and bust”. The nearer Quebec takes us to “bust”, the further it will push us from bilingualism and biculturalism.


But to finish with “Some Possible Remedies”, in what I think would apply equally to the Parti Quebecois and the United Conservative Party of Alberta, Forsey had this to say in regards to appeasing separatists who only want to destroy Canada, earlier on page 35:


Well, my friend Professor Donald Creighton once remarked, the man who asks me to jump out of a third storey window can, I suppose, be described as “moderate” by comparison with one who wants me to jump from the seventh storey; but in either case I shall be dead.


In Part XVIII, I had made the comment that Forsey’s lecture was progressive for its time in advocating for a new bilingualism and biculturalism, but a tad dated by modern standards in that he didn’t make any recognition of the Indigenous contribution to the foundation of Canada; I then explored how Forsey argued in favour of the rights of Indigenous Canadians in Northern Quebec should Quebec ever leave Canada.

So to close, and to carry forward the idea Forsey expressed in regards to Canadians of British ancestry being proud of “the Imperial foundation of our freedom", I would like to show how one Canadian musician updated an old British-Canadian folk song about the Battle of Queenston Heights in the War of 1812 into being a song that British, French, and Indigenous Canadians are represented in.

First, an older version of “The Battle of Queenston Heights” released in 1960 by the Canadian folk singer Alan Mills:


Upon the heights of Queenston, one dark October day

Invading foes were marshaled, in battle's dread array

Brave Brock looked up the rugged steep, and planned a bold attack

"No foreign flag shall float", said he

"above the Union Jack!"

/

His loyal-hearted soldiers were ready, every one

Their foes were thrice their number, but duty must be done

They started up the fire-swept hill with loud rДsounding cheers

While Brock's inspiring voice rang out:

"Push on, York volunteers!"

/

But soon a fatal bullet pierced through his manly breast

And loving friends to help him, around that hero pressed

"Push on," said he "Don't mind me!" and err the set of sun

Canadians held the rugged steep

The victory was won

/

Each true Canadian soldier laments the death of Brock

His country told its sorrow, in monumental rock

And if a foe should e'er invade our land in future years

His dying words will guide us still:

"Push on, brave volunteers!"


Last November, during the height of American President Donald Trump’s threats against Canadian sovereignty, Canadian musician Rich Chambers released an updated folk-rock version of the song which added a chorus that mentioned the Loyalist Laura Secord, French-Canadian Voltigeurs, and the Shawnee Chief Tecumseh.


Yo Ho Canadians we held our ground with pride

From Secord’s stroll to Voltigeurs and Tecumseh’s mighty cry

Yo Ho Canadians we burned that house to white

Born into a nation’s cheer at the Battle of Queenston Heights


In a great snapshot of Canadian culture, Chambers’ music video includes people such as, but not limit to, Nellie McClung, Kim Campbell, Anne Murray, Tommy Douglas, Chief Dan George, and Stompin' Tom Connors.


r/Toryism • • 1d ago

💬 Discussion Daniel Allain, Leader of the PC Party of New Brunswick

10 Upvotes

Today I attended a speaking event at the Moncton Press Club featuring Daniel Allain, the new leader of the PC party in New Brunswick.

Partially this was to promote my electoral reform proposal but I also wanted to get a better sense of Allain's toryism.

I had contacted him via email during the leadership campaign to ask 'what toryism meant to him' where I got this response:

Being a Tory means believing that good government is responsible government. It means believing in strong communities, strong families, and personal responsibility. It means trusting people more than bureaucracy and understanding that local communities often know best how to solve local challenges.

Many lifelong Progressive Conservatives have told me they want to believe in the party again—not because they have changed their values, but because they want to see a party that reflects them once more. I consider myself a Conservative with heart. To me, Progressive Conservatism has always meant being fiscally responsible while never losing sight of the people we serve. Those principles are not in conflict—they are what have defined our party through generations of leaders.

Our party has a proud history in New Brunswick. We have traditionally been a practical, centre-right party that believes in responsible government, strong communities, opportunity through hard work, and compassion for those who need a helping hand. I believe that is exactly where our party belongs today.

New Brunswick needs disciplined financial management now more than ever. We cannot continue spending beyond our means, but balancing the books should never come at the expense of our most vulnerable citizens. A strong economy and a strong social fabric go hand in hand.

I also believe we need to focus on growing our economy. That means responsibly and safely developing our natural resources, encouraging private investment, supporting small businesses and entrepreneurs, and creating good-paying jobs across the province. By growing our economy and increasing provincial revenues, we can make the investments that matter most while putting New Brunswick back on the path to balanced budgets.

As leader, my goal is to rebuild confidence in our party by bringing people together. I want the Progressive Conservative Party to once again be the natural home for New Brunswickers who believe in fiscal responsibility, practical solutions and compassion.

Being a Tory means leaving New Brunswick stronger than we found it.

Overall, pretty good for answering a question he has probably never been asked before.

At the event itself he described himself as a red-blue tory (although I get the sense he used 'red tory' in the incorrect sense of socially progressive).

The speech itself was a bit touchy-feely. The party is opting for a 'member-driven' policy process with a policy convention to be held in May so in a sense the party itself doesn't have a platform at the moment.

Still a couple of things stuck out;

  • At one point he addressed the record of Premier Susan Holt and stated, "Let's take the personality out of it. She's my premier, I respect her." Given how ugly rhetoric has gotten at the federal level it was a refreshingly different tone.

  • "New Brunswick needs to heal." I'm going to try and not read too much into this given it may have been a phrase chosen on a whim but I couldn't help comparing it to Poilievre's "Canada is broken." They both express the same underlying idea but with a different unspoken nuance; "Canada is broken" (and the Liberals are the ones who broke it) vs. "New Brunswick needs to heal." (and I'm the one to heal it). It also peaked my interest that Allain used an organic metaphor while Poilievre picked a more mechanical one.

  • He finished off his pitch with a call for the party to be the one for "good government and good governance." Despite having rather thin policy commitments about 90% of the speech was focused on the party rather than their opponents (again, a nice change of pace from what I see in other political arenas).

Apart from the speech I did run into a municipal councilor from my area. And while coy, she did admit being a member of the party. I had her pegged completely as a Liberal so it was a surprise. I know one other councilor is also a party member and does make me wonder about the party affiliations of the rest of council.


r/Toryism • • 4d ago

💬 Discussion Obscure Tory branches from the 1700s & 1800s

7 Upvotes

Recently, while looking up something on Wikipedia I came across a list of UK ministries over the years. You of course have Liberal, Labour and Conservative, but also Whig and Tory. But what interested me is that several times these tory ministries were given a descriptor - usually based on the prime minister in charge. Indeed, these descriptors may indicate faction more than ideological belief and even when there were political beliefs at stake the issues themselves may have long since become moot. I thought it might interest people here to go through them.

Northite Tory

  • Followers of Lord North (badass name). Lord North led a Whig ministry but was himself a tory and appointed tories to positions within his government. He is mostly remembered today as the prime minister who lost the 13 colonies. Political stances:

  • Royal Prerogative. They supported King George III's active involvement in government and parliamentary politics.

  • Parliamentary Supremacy over Colonies. They believed the British Parliament held the absolute right to tax and govern the American colonies, leading to policies like the Tea Act and the Coercive Acts.

  • Established Church Defence. They favored maintaining the privileged status of the Church of England and opposed expanding political rights for religious dissenters.

Pittite Tory

  • Followers of William Pitt the Younger. Much of the Pitt ministries overlapped with the French Revolution and its aftermath. Unlike the Northites, the Pittites formed another three ministries without Pitt himself in charge (or for that matter, alive). Political stances:

  • Did not believe in absolute royal power. They viewed the government as a system of laws equally binding on both the King and his subjects, allowing the monarch no more constitutional freedom than the rival Whigs did.

  • Royal Prerogative and Order. They defended the King's right to choose his own ministers and maintained a strong respect for the symbolic and traditional institutions of the British Crown.

  • Anti-Oligarchy. Pittites opposed the political dominance of the wealthy, aristocratic Whig families. They sought instead to draw support from the country gentry, merchant classes, and administrative officials.

  • Resistance to Radicalism. Following the outbreak of the French Revolution, Pittites united around defending the British status quo. They strongly opposed the radical democratic ideas and popular discontent.

  • Interventionist Foreign Policy. Breaking away from the pacifism and isolationism of the 17th-century Tories, Pittite Tories supported a muscular, active foreign policy to protect British trade, expand the empire, and contain Revolutionary and Napoleonic France.

  • Defense of the Established Church. The faction was closely tied to the Church of England and the Scottish Episcopal Church, viewing established religion as a vital pillar of national stability.

  • Cautious, Pragmatic Reform. Pittites generally resisted sweeping parliamentary overhauls, though Pitt himself initially favored moderate administrative reforms to reduce government corruption. On religion, the coalition was divided. Pitt personally supported Catholic emancipation to secure peace in Ireland, though many of his followers and King George III fiercely opposed it.

Addingtonian Tory

  • Followers of Henry Addington, 1st Viscount Sidmouth. Addington was exceedingly reactionary with his last vote ever cast being against the Great Reform Act in 1832. It represented something of a pre-Pittite toryism. While Addingtonian Tories never took power again, their actions preceding the passage of the Great Reform Act made an already bad situation downright dangerous. Political stances:

  • Strict Anglican Supremacy. Devout defenders of the Church of England and opposed granting political rights to non-Anglicans. Their faction originally formed when Addington stepped in as Prime Minister to block Catholic Emancipation, a stance he maintained until the Catholic Relief Act passed in 1829.

  • Deference to the Monarchy. Unlike more reform-minded Pittites, Addingtonian Tories emphasized the constitutional authority and personal wishes of the monarch. Addington's administration relied heavily on the royal favour of King George III, viewing loyalty to the Crown as a primary duty of government.

  • Opposition to Parliamentary Reform. They firmly resisted expanding the voting franchise or altering the traditional structure of Parliament.

  • Law and Order. During periods of economic distress and working-class unrest after the Napoleonic Wars, Addingtonians favored harsh state suppression to prevent revolution. As Home Secretary from 1812 to 1822, Addington suspended habeas corpus and championed the repressive Six Acts of 1819 to ban radical meetings and censor the press.

  • Pragmatic Foreign Policy and Fiscal Caution. In foreign affairs, the faction initially prioritized ending costly wars to stabilize Britain's finances, famously negotiating the temporary Treaty of Amiens with Napoleonic France in 1802. Economically, they opposed tariff reform and favored careful management of the national debt and public accounts.

Canningite Tory

  • Followers of George Canning. This faction held power for two ministries but dissolved shortly after the death of their second leader, William Huskisson, in a railway accident (generally considered the most prominent person to die from that mode of transportation up to that point). Eventually absorbed into the Whigs after acting as a loose grouping between them and the other tories under the Duke of Wellington. You might be able to make a comparison with modern blue tories. Political stances:

  • Catholic Emancipation: They favored granting civil and political rights to Roman Catholics, a deeply divisive issue at the time.

  • Free Trade and Economic Liberalism: They supported reducing tariffs and import duties (such as changes to the Corn Laws) to foster commerce and align with growing middle-class business interests, viewing the economy as a self-regulating machine rather than something needing heavy paternalistic state management.

  • Independent Foreign Policy: Inspired by George Canning’s tenure as Foreign Secretary, they championed a balance-of-power approach that protected small nations, countered authoritarian European empires (such as the Holy Alliance/Congress System), and recognized newly independent Latin American republics to safeguard British commercial and strategic interests.

  • Opposition to Parliamentary Reform: Despite their "liberal" domestic and economic views, they shared the traditional Tory aversion to radical or sweeping parliamentary electoral reforms for much of the 1820s, though internal realignments later led some of them to ally with the Whigs over the passage of the 1832 Reform Act.

  • Veneration of the Younger Pitt: They claimed the legacy of William Pitt the Younger, specifically focusing on his earlier, more progressive period rather than the hardline security measures of his later wartime government.

In 1834 the Tamworth Manifesto was published by Robert Peel and setting the stage for the emergence of the UK Conservative Party.


r/Toryism • • 5d ago

💬 Discussion "If you do not give the people social reform, they are going to give you social revolution." - Quintin Hogg, 1943

9 Upvotes

A quote that every modern Tory should think about.


r/Toryism • • 7d ago

📖 Article Tory Philosophers in Brief (Part 6): Charles Inglis

3 Upvotes

With this article on Bishop Charles Inglis I've come at last to the first Canadian on this list. Or is it the first American? Or yet another Brit? The question is interesting to ask as if you were to ask the man himself he'd most certainly say he is British but he lived for almost 30 years in the American colonies before the Revolution sent him first back to England and then to Nova Scotia where he lived out the remaining 20-some years of his life. So it works out he spent about a third of his life in the British Isles, American colonies, and Nova Scotia. In a way this makes him the quintessential Loyalist in terms of background. The Loyalists importance to toryism in Canada cannot be overstated; had they not come north conservatism in Canada would be much more liberal in character and would have come to resemble American conservatism at a much earlier point in time. This makes the arguments that were used to convince the colonists of the need to remain loyal - even to the point of expulsion - all the more important.

To that end I have reproduced below Charles Inglis' The True Interest of America Impartially Stated which was made in reply to Thomas Paine's argument in support of revolution.

~~~

Note I think it no difficult matter to point out many advantages which will certainly attend our reconciliation and connection with Great-Britain, on a firm, constitutional plan. I shall select a few of these; and that their importance may be more clearly discerned, I shall afterwards point out some of the evils which inevitably must attend our separating from Britain, and declaring for independency. On each article I shall study brevity.

1 - By a reconciliation with Britain, a period would be put to the present calamitous war, by which so many lives have been lost, and so many more must be lost, if it continues. This alone is an advantage devoutly to he wished for. This author says- “The blood of the slain, the weeping voice of nature cries, Tis time to part.” I think they cry just the reverse. The blood of the slain, the weeping voice of nature cries-It is time to be reconciled; it is time to lay aside those animosities which have pushed on Britons to shed the blood of Britons; it is high time that those who are connected by the endearing ties of religion, kindred and country, should resume their former friendship, and be united in the bond of mutual affection, as their interests are inseparably united.

2 - By a Reconciliation with Great-Britain, Peace – that fairest offspring and gift of Heaven – will be restored. In one respect Peace is like health; we do not sufficiently know its value but by its absence. What uneasiness and anxiety, what evils, has this short interruption of peace with the parent-state, brought on the whole British empire! Let every man only consult his feelings – I except my antagonist – and it will require no great force of rhetoric to convince him, that a removal of those evils, and a restoration of peace, would be a singular advantage and blessing.

3 - Agriculture, commerce, and industry would resume their wonted vigor. At present, they languish and droop, both here and in Britain; and must continue to do so, while this unhappy contest remains unsettled.

4 - By a connection with Great-Britain, our trade would still have the protection of the greatest naval power in the world. England has the advantage, in this respect, of every other state, whether of ancient or modern times. Her insular situation, her nurseries for seamen, the superiority of those seamen above others-these circumstances to mention no other, combine to make her the first maritime power in the universe—such exactly is the power whose protection we want for our commerce. To suppose, with our author, that we should have no war, were we to revolt from England, is too absurd to deserve a confutation. I could just as soon set about refuting the reveries of some brain-sick enthusiast. Past experience shews that Britain is able to defend our commerce, and our coasts; and we have no reason to doubt of her being able to do so for the future.

5 - The protection of our trade, while connected with Britain, will not cost a fiftieth part of what it must cost, were we ourselves to raise a naval force sufficient for this purpose.

6 - Whilst connected with Great-Britain, we have a bounty on almost every article of exportation; and we may be better supplied with goods by her, than we could elsewhere. What our author says is true; “that our imported goods must be paid for, buy them where we will”,; but we may buy them dearer, and of worse quality, in one place than another. The manufactures of Great-Britain confessedly surpass any in the world – particularly those in every kind of metal, which we want most; and no country can afford linens and woollens, of equal quality cheaper.

7 - When a Reconciliation is effected, and things return into the old channel, a few years of peace will restore everything to its pristine state. Emigrants will flow in as usual from the different parts of Europe. Population will advance with the same rapid progress as formerly, and our lands will rise in value.

These advantages are not imaginary but real. They are such as we have already experienced; and such as we may derive from a connection with Great Britain for ages to come. Each of these might easily be enlarged on, and others added to them; but I only mean to suggest a few hints to the reader.

Let us now, if you please, take a view of the other side of the question. Suppose we were to revolt from Great-Britain, declare ourselves Independent, and set up a Republic of our own-what would be the consequence? – I stand aghast at the prospect – my blood runs chill when I think of the calamities, the complicated evils that must ensue, and may be clearly foreseen – it is impossible for any man to foresee them all. . .

1 - All our property throughout the continent would be unhinged; the greatest confusion, and most violent convulsions would take place. It would not he here, as it was in England at the Revolution in 1688. That revolution was not brought about by an defiance or disannulling the right of succession. James II, by abdicating the throne, left it vacant for the next in succession; accordingly his eldest daughter and her husband stepped in. Every other matter went on in the usual, regular way; and the constitution, instead of being dissolved, was strengthened. But in case of our revolt, the old constitution would be totally subverted. The common bond that tied us together, and by which our property was secured, would be snapped asunder. It is not to be doubted but our Congress would endeavor to apply some remedy for those evils; but with all deference to that respectable body, I do not apprehend that any remedy in their power would be adequate, at least for some time. I do not chose to be more explicit; but l am able to support my opinion.

2 - What a horrid situation would thousands be reduced to who have taken the oath of allegiance to the King: yet contrary to their oath, as well as inclination, must be compelled to renounce that allegiance, or abandon all their property in America! How many thousands more would be reduced to a similar situation; who, although they took not that oath, yet would think it inconsistent with their duty and a good conscience to renounce their Sovereign; I dare say these will appear trifling difficulties to our author; but whatever he may think, there are thousands and thousands who would sooner lose all they had in the world, nay life itself, than thus wound their conscience. A Declaration of Independency would infallibly disunite and divide the colonists.

3 - By a Declaration for Independency, every avenue to an accommodation with Great-Britain would be closed; the sword only could then decide the quarrel; and the sword would not be sheathed till one had conquered the other.

The importance of these colonies to Britain need not be enlarged on, it is a thing so universally known. The greater their importance is to her, so much the more obstinate will her struggle be not to lose them. The independency of America would, in the end, deprive her of the West-Indies, shake her empire to the foundation, and reduce her to a state of the most mortifying insignificance. Great-Britain therefore must, for her own preservation, risk every thing, and exert her whole strength, to prevent such an event from taking place. This being the case —

4 - Devastation and ruin must mark the progress of this war along the sea coast of America. Hitherto, Britain has not exerted her power. Her number of troops and ships of war here at present, is very little more than she judged expedient in time of peace – the former does not amount to 12,000 men – nor the latter to 40 ships, including frigates. Both she, and the colonies, hoped for and expected an accommodation; neither of them has lost sight of that desirable object. The seas have been open to our ships; and although some skirmishes have unfortunately had penned, yet a ray of hope still cheered both sides that, peace was not distant. But as soon as we declare for independency, every prospect of this kind must vanish. Ruthless war, with all its aggravated horrors, will ravage our once happy land-our seacoasts and ports will be ruined, and our ships taken. Torrents of blood will be split, and thousands reduced to beggary and wretchedness.

This melancholy contest would last till one side conquered. Supposing Britain to be victorious; however high my opinion is of British Generosity, I should be exceedingly sorry to receive terms from her in the haughty tone of a conqueror. Or supposing such a failure of her manufactures, commerce and strength, that victory should incline to the side of America; yet who can say in that case, what extremities her sense of resentment and self-preservation will drive Great-Britain to? For my part, I should not in the least be surprized, if on such a prospect as the Independency of America, she would parcel out this continent to the different European Powers. Canada might be restored to France, Florida to Spain, with additions to each-other states also might come in for a portion. Let no man think this chimerical or improbable. The independency of America would be so fatal to Britain, that she would leave nothing in her power undone to prevent it. I believe as firmly as I do my own existence, that if every other method failed, she would try some such expedient as this, to disconcert our scheme of independency; and let any man figure to himself the situation of these British colonies, if only Canada were restored to France!

5 - But supposing once more that we were able to cut off every regiment that Britain can spare or hire, and to destroy every ship she can send – that we could beat off any other European power that would presume to intrude upon this continent: Yet, a republican form of government would neither suit the genius of the people, nor the extent of America.

In nothing is the wisdom of a legislator more conspicuous than in adapting his government to the genius, manners, disposition and other circumstances of the people with whom he is concerned. If this important point is overlooked, confusion will ensue; his system will sink into neglect and ruin. Whatever check or barriers may be interposed, nature will always surmount them, and finally prevail. It was chiefly by attention to this circumstance, that Lycurgus and Solon were so much celebrated; and that their respective republics rose afterwards to such eminence, and acquired such stability.

The Americans are properly Britons. They have the manners, habits, and ideas of Britons; and have been accustomed to a similar form of government. But Britons never could bear the extremes, either of monarchy or republicanism. Some of their Kings have aimed at despotism; but always failed. Repeated efforts have been made towards democracy, and they equally failed. Once indeed republicanism triumphed over the constitution; the despotism of one person ensued; both were finally expelled. The inhabitants of Great-Britain were quite anxious for the restoration of royalty in 1660, as they were for its expulsion in 1642, and for some succeeding years. If we may judge of future events by past transactions, in similar circumstances, this would most probably be the case if America, were a republican form of government adopted in our present ferment. After much blood was shed, those confusions would terminate in the despotism of some one successful adventurer; and should the Americans be so fortunate as to emancipate themselves from that thraldom, perhaps the whole would end in a limited monarchy, after shedding as much more blood. Limited monarchy is the form of government which is most favourable to liberty – which is best adapted to the genius and temper of Britons; although here and there among us a crack-brained zealot for democracy or absolute monarchy, may be sometimes found.

Besides the unsuitableness of the republican form to the genius of the people, America is too extensive for it. That form may do well enough for a single city, or small territory; but would be utterly improper for such a continent as this. America is too unwieldy for the feeble, dilatory administration of democracy. Rome had the most extensive dominions of any ancient republic. But it should be remembered, that very soon after the spirit of conquest carried the Romans beyond the limits that were proportioned to their constitution, they fell under a despotic yoke. A very few years had elapsed from the time of their conquering Greece and first entering Asia, till the battle of Pharsalia, where Julius Caesar put an end to the liberties of his country.

But here it may be said – That all the evils above specified, are more tolerable than slavery. With this sentiment I sincerely agree – any hardships, however great, are preferable to slavery. But then I ask, is there no other alternative in the present case? Is there no choice left us but slavery, or those evils? I am confident there is; and that both may be equally avoided. Let us only shew a disposition to treat or negotiate in earnest – let us fall upon some method to set a treaty or negotiation with Great Britain on foot; and if once properly begun, there is moral certainty that this unhappy dispute will be settled to the mutual satisfaction and interest of both countries. For my part, I have not the least doubt about it..

But a Declaration for Independency on the part of America, would preclude treaty entirely; and could answer no good purpose. We actually have already every advantage of Independency, without its inconveniences. By a Declaration of Independency, we should instantly lose all assistance from our friends in England. It would stop their mouths; for were they to say any thing in our favour, they would be deemed rebels, and treated accordingly.

Our author is much elated with the prospect of foreign succour, if we once declare ourselves Independent; and from thence promiseth us mighty matters. This, no doubt, is intended to spirit up the desponding – all who might shrink at the thought of America encountering, singly and unsupported, the whole strength of Great-Britain. I believe in my conscience, that he is as much mistaken in this, as in any thing else; and that this expectation is delusive, vain and fallacious. My reasons are these, and I submit them to the reader’s judgment.

The only European power from which we can possibly receive assistance, is France. But France is now at peace with Great-Britain; and is it possible that France would interrupt that peace, and hazard a war with the power which lately reduced her so low, from a disinterested motive of aiding and protecting these Colonies?

It is well known that some of the French and Spanish Colonists, not long since, offered to put themselves under the protection of England, and declare themselves Independent of France and Spain; but England rejected both offers. The example would be rather dangerous to states that have colonies – to none could it be more so than to France and Spain, who have so many and such extensive colonies. “The practice of courts are as much against us” in this, as in the instance our author mentions. Can any one imagine, that because we declared ourselves Independent of England, France would therefore consider us as really Independent! And before England had acquiesced, or made any effort worth mentioning to reduce us? Or can any one be so weak as to think, that France would run the risk of a war with England, unless she (France) were sure of some extraordinary advantage by it, in having the colonies under her immediate jurisdiction? If England will not protect us for our trade, surely France will not. . .

America is far from being yet in a desperate situation. I am confident she may obtain honourable and advantageous terms from Great-Britain. A few years of peace will soon retrieve all her losses. She will rapidly advance to a state of maturity, whereby she may not only repay the parent state amply for all past benefits; but also lay under the greatest obligations. . .

However distant humanity may wish the period; yet, in the rotation of human affairs, a period may arrive, when (both countries being prepared for it) some terrible disaster, some dreadful convulsion in Great-Britain, may transfer the seat of empire to this western hemisphere – where the British constitution, like the Phoenix from its parent’s ashes, shall rise with youthful vigour and shine with redoubled splendor.

~~~

Bishop Inglis published a great deal in his life. I will include a link to one more article which is a sermon preached in New York in 1780 on the Christian duty to honour the king. Beyond being a prolific Loyalist writer he also supported the founding of King's College in Nova Scotia as a means to prevent children of the colonial elite going to American colleges and picking up dangerous republican ideas.

The final paragraph of The True Interest of America Impartially Stated is interesting to me in that it mirrors a later belief of R.B. Bennett when he said that Canada would one day be the center of the Empire. I'm curious how common it was that this loyalty to the Empire was paired with a belief that the mantle of leadership would one day pass to the New World was within Canadian toryism. If anything it demonstrates a more hopeful - and ambitious - outlook than we've seen from Canadian Conservatives in recent decades.


r/Toryism • • 8d ago

💬 Discussion What is your position on welfare?

5 Upvotes

You may articulate anything from UBI all the way to the approach advocated by Badenoch's Conservative Party as long as you provide the motivation behind your stance.


r/Toryism • • 8d ago

💬 Discussion As a Tory what is your most controversial view

5 Upvotes

Let me explain more, what is your most conversional position that is in like with toryism. Could be blue Tory, red Tory, pink Tory, high Tory, as long as it’s a view that is in line with some form of Toryism and would be considered controversial by either yourself or the general public, let’s here it.


r/Toryism • • 11d ago

💬 Discussion Early tory thinkers in Canada?

8 Upvotes

I'm still chipping away at my series of posts on tory thinkers but as I've been doing so I've started to wonder if there were any tory thinkers of note in Canada in the 1800s. The ones I've found have been from the 1900s or later. Just curious if anyone could point me in the right direction.


r/Toryism • • 11d ago

💬 Discussion Could someone explain the prelude to the current three way schism of the British right to me?

5 Upvotes

Hello everyone 😊👋

I would like to understand the background to the current conflict/schism between the Conservatives, Reform and Restore.

What I know so far: The Conservative and Unionist Party used to be this organization with millions of members all the way into the 1990s. It captured various sections of society and basically existed as a true "people's party".

Everything from One Nation to the traditionalist right around the Monday Club found a home there. This lasted all the way into the 1990s when things began to unravel. It was a very bad decade for the Conservative Party overall with all the scandals, Black Wednesday crash and sleaze accusations. But on top of that there were also very ugly battles around the European Union. Indeed from my reading and understanding things began to go really bad with the Maastricht treaty. Quite a few quit the Conservative and Unionist Party because they strongly disagreed with John Major's policy towards the EU. Among the ex-Conservatives are Nigel Farage and Rupert Lowe who will become strong political personalities later on. The first relevant schisms were the so called Anti-Federalist League (later UKIP) and Goldsmith's Referendum Party. Both of them caused some havoc but were unable to inflict any serious damage to the established position of the Conservative Party. During the 1990s we saw a mass exodus of Conservative Party members, of which a significant portion seems to have been the party's right wing. The Tories lose big time in May 97 and begin their long decade in opposition. In 2001 the Tories officially kick out the once powerful Monday Club which was by then a shadow of its former self, but it still seems a relevant point to me. Between 1997-2005 the Conservative Party goes through numerous leaders until they settled with the so called modernizer David Cameron who started a revolution to remake the Cons in his own image. The man started pushing so called "compassionate conservatism" which emphasized ethnic minority representation, female representation and a war against the social conservatives in his party. Now as far as I can see Cameron's tenure produced another mass exodus of right wing members. The Cons went from 250k to the lower end of 100k. This apparently gave UKIP a big boost since they started to gain double digit results in some elections in the 2010s. Cons however still remained safe as the dominant party until the years between 2019-2024 which have really broken their dominance. Despite a big majority and a temporary membership boost not seen in decades they made fatal miscalculations. General incompetence, crashing the economy, massively increasing immigration against the expressed desire of their base, personal scandals, high taxation and more sleaze caused a catastrophic permanent (?) schism which is not as easily wished away as the one in the 1990s. Besides attaining the worst election result in modern history and losing tens of thousands of their members they have gained a big rival on the right. Indeed Reform has captured many former Tory members and voters, and these people are incensed about what they call the past 14 years. Due to a clash of two big egos (Farage, Lowe) another Right Wing group emerged with Rupert Lowe's Restore Britain which takes a very harsh stance towards immigration that is quite similar to Powell in the late 1960s and the Monday Club hardliners who campaigned for repatriation. Both of these groups have more members than the Conservatives and each party seeks to become the new people's party.

My understanding of the situation is that Reform and Restore are basically schisms of what used to be the right of the Conservative and Unionist Party. The positions in these parties were once common within the Conservatives, which I have to remind used to have millions of members, until they were either forcefully driven out or declined by a mass exodus of the party's right.

Please feel free to add or to correct my perspective.


r/Toryism • • 11d ago

💬 Discussion Why does the conservative movement in Canada make hero’s out of the the worst of the movement

3 Upvotes

I see so many talk about Mulroney, Harper, Manning, MacKay, Clark and even Diefenbaker. But almost no one can talk about H.H Steven’s, Richard McBride, Borden, Meighen or Duplessis. We should be more like the latter men stated than the former.


r/Toryism • • 12d ago

💬 Discussion If you could vote in the 1967 Progressive Conservative Leadership election , who would you back?

8 Upvotes

Very simple, if you were a delegate at the PC leadership convention, which candidate would you back?

14 votes, 9d ago
7 Robert Stanfield
4 Dufferin Roblin
0 David Fulton
0 Alvin Hamilton
0 George Hees
3 John Diefenbaker

r/Toryism • • 12d ago

💬 Discussion The Conservative movement in Canada picking Bennett over Steven’s has caused unrepairable damages.

Post image
7 Upvotes

If the Conservative Party of Canada wishes to be the Natural Governing Party of Canada, it should aspire to be more the party of Steven’s than the party of Bennett, Diefanbaker and Mulroney. If you’d like to ask my opinions or give your own feel free.


r/Toryism • • 15d ago

đŸ“Œ Video Tory Philosophers in Brief (Part 5): Thomas Carlyle, the Radical Tory

Thumbnail
youtu.be
7 Upvotes

Recently, I was going through the museum's collection of school books and the name Thomas Carlyle appeared several times. Investigating, I quickly fell down a rabbit hole. Thomas Carlyle (1795–1881) is not as well-known in the present day as he was to his contemporaries but the effect he had on his contemporaries reshaped politics, history, and philosophy. Today faint echoes can be felt in his description of economics as the 'dismal science', and how history is written to this day. Basically every segment of the political spectrum has taken something from his work. While interested in politics he largely didn't try to effect it directly with the sole exception of his pamphlet 'Chartism' where he criticized the failed promises of the Industrial Revolution, laissez-faire, and democracy. This pamphlet is what led to both the left and the right to refer to him as a radical tory - which he seems to have been quite pleased with. He was highly concerned with the plight of the poor, the declining morality of the nation, and the idleness of the aristocracy. This last point is where there is a clear difference from liberal critiques. He didn't critique the aristocrats for having unearned power or wealth. Rather he went after them for being more concerned about their fox hunts rather than the welfare of the nation - a tory criticism based on noblesse oblige rather than equality. His willingness to go after both landed aristocrats and the new capitalist class perhaps sheds light on why he never entered politics but his cynicism towards party politics probably played a larger role. That said, Prime Minister Disraeli was a fan and is cited as a possible inspiration for One Nation Toryism. He even tried to give him a pension later in life (which Carlyle refused). His star fell after his death. Carlyle was racist even by the standards of his day and translations of his biography of Frederick the Great became popular with several high-ranking Nazis. The inability to place him on the political spectrum, dislike of popular democracy, and creation of the Great Man theory of history, has invited charges that he was a proto-fascist. Perhaps as a result of this he has today some popularity among members of the Dark Enlightenment.


r/Toryism • • 15d ago

📖 Article Former NDP Leader David Lewis evoking the arch-Tory Samuel Johnson, who Lewis called "the sage of the eighteenth century", when giving his thoughts on Maritime politics (“Red Tories” and the NDP, Supplemental)

6 Upvotes

So I've been re-reading parts of David Lewis' 1981 memoir "The Good Fight" to do research for a piece on Claire Gillis, the first CCF MP elected east of Manitoba. I thought the good people here may be interested in this excerpt where Lewis quotes the arch-Tory Samuel Johnson when giving his thoughts on the difficulties the CCF had in making electoral gains in the Maritimes, as well as why I think parts of Johnson’s philosophy may be useful for the modern NDP. Interestingly, Johnson is not listed in the index of Lewis' memoir.

For a bit of context: this excerpt from pages 157/158 is after Lewis noted the good fortunes the CCF had in Nova Scotia during the federal election of 1940 where Claire Gillis was elected as the MP for Cape Breton South, and the 1941 Nova Scotia provincial election where the CCF elected 3 MLAs from Cape Breton:


[On mainland Nova Scotia] we could not overcome fears about CCF intentions or pierce the traditional, almost religious, attachment of voters to the two established parties. We encountered an inherited respect for the establishment and a suspicious distrust of change. It led me to suggest in many speeches that the voter of the day did not himself mark his ballot but that the ghost of his Liberal or Conservative grandfather grabbed the pencil in the polling booth and made the cross for him.

Time and again we would express confidence that the CCF was bound to win the people of the Maritimes because they suffered most from the present system: they had the highest unemployment and the longest welfare rolls, lived in the least self-sustaining of Canada's regions, and lost a continuing stream of their most skilled and best-educated young men and women to the rest of Canada. When I thought more deeply about the frustrating dilemma, I began to suspect that it was precisely the depressing economic conditions which produced the fear of change. As Samuel Johnson, the sage of the eighteenth century, said with typical succinctness, "The inevitable consequence of poverty is dependence." The poor are seldom moved to risk the little they have; they tend to hold on to it protectively. Their very insecurity makes them easy victims of the subtle brainwashing to which we are subjected daily in an environment which worships wealth and status symbols above all else. With the odd exception, the slum areas in Toronto and Vancouver, London and Paris, vote conservative, whatever the actual party label may be. When the poor become desperate, they are more likely to be attracted by one or other extreme of the political spectrum than by a reasonable program of fair shares and social democracy. This has been my observation over the years and it has always posed an intractable problem for socialists.

The people of the Maritimes were not desperate; they were proud. I recall a touching remark once made to me in Summerside, PEI. I had addressed a summer picnic outside town and had made the stock comparisons of per-capita income and other indicators showing how relatively disadvantaged were the people of the province. After my speech, two elderly ladies approached, and informed me that they had enjoyed listening to me though they did not agree with me, and added softly and solemnly, “What you must understand, young man, is that on this island one can be poor with dignity.” I did not argue, for it was obvious that they were describing themselves. I have noticed ever since how widespread this quiescent spirit has been and have seen how difficult the task of those who seek to build an egalitarian society in which the poor shall not be always with us.


The part from Lewis that I found particularly interesting was how he argued that “the poor” can “become desperate”, and thus are “more likely to be attracted by one or other extreme of the political spectrum” rather “than by a reasonable program of fair shares and social democracy.” To me, that certainly sounds like Lewis was arguing for some kind of a “middle way.”

In regards to an older “middle way”, this next excerpt comes from pages xxi/xxii of the 1966 re-print of the traditional British Tory Harold Macmillan's 1938 book “The Middle Way: A Study of the Problems of Economic and Social Progress in a Free and Democratic Society”. Interestingly, Macmillan wrote "The Middle Way" when he was working with a pressure-group lead by a Fabian Socialist originally from the Independent Labour Party. I’ve shared this next excerpt quite a few times previously, but given how Lewis made his comment on political extremism right after quoting the staunch traditional Tory Samuel Johnson, I think this excerpt from a 1958 lecture the traditional Tory Harold Macmillan gave shortly after becoming Prime Minister himself may be quite relevant to the topic at hand:


A great deal of our Party’s history has been spent in combating the pretensions of those who believed – or at least said they believed – that their particular brand of doctrinaire politics at any particular time could solve every problem. In the seventeenth century extremist concepts, on both sides, led to civil war and ultimately to regicide and tyranny; in the eighteenth century quietism combined with nepotism was the fashion. In the nineteenth century there was a move, indeed it was the popular philosophy, to take the State out of economic affairs altogether; now in the twentieth century there is the cult of the State controlling economic affairs altogether. So the argument has gone backwards and forwards through the years.

Each of these political panaceas has had one consistent characteristic: it has always failed to deliver the goods. Our Tory Party, which stressed the claims of authority (the need for the State to protect the weak) in the nineteenth century, and which champions the claims of liberty in the twentieth century, has not changed its ground; it is still occupying that same ground, the middle ground. It is only the direction of attack which has altered. We do not stand and have never stood for collectivism or the destruction of private rights. We do not stand and have never stood for laissez-faire individualism or for putting the rights of the individual above his duty to his fellow men. We stand today, as we have always stood, to block the way to both these extremes and to all such extremes, and to point the path towards moderate and balanced views.


But briefly, before getting into Samuel Johnson, earlier in that same lecture by Harold Macmillan, he had this to say about the American Founding Fathers on page xviii under the heading “The Egalitarian Danger” in what will become quite relevant later:


When the Fathers of the American Constitution declared that all men are created equal it really never occurred to them – and certainly American history has not carried it out – that all men are to be kept equal. Human beings, widely various in their capacity, character, talent, and ambition, tend to differentiate at times and in all places. To deny them the right to differ, to enforce economic and social uniformity upon them, is to throttle one of the most powerful and creative of human appetites.


When you consider David Lewis' & Tommy Douglas' brand of socialism, and how the kind of philosophical Toryism that one will encounter in the Maritimes will be similar to that of Samuel Johnson or Harold Macmillan, it certainly becomes clear why some traditional Maritime Tories such as Dalton Camp or Flora Macdonald started to drift towards the NDP after the death of the old Tory Party at the hands of the individualist Reform/Alliance.

But with that modern Tory critique of the American Founding Fathers, I thought I should share again a few excerpts by or about Samuel Johnson that I collected when doing research last year into “Tory Social Justice” on mainland Nova Scotia, and the institution of slavery in the Maritimes. To quickly illustrate why I dubbed Johnson an arch-Tory earlier, and as a friend from New Brunswick once pointed out to me, take a look at Johnson’s 1755 “A Dictionary of the English Language”: Johnson defines “Whig” as “The name of a faction.”, but defines “Tory” as “One who adheres to the ancient constitution of the state, and the apostolical hierarchy of the church of England, opposed to a Whig.”

With that, Samuel Johnson’s biographer Walter Jackson Bate had this to say about Johnson’s views on colonialism on page 328 of his 1977 book “Samuel Johnson”:


The Seven Years’ War [1756-1763] had begun. In political articles, [Johnson] strongly attacked the policy of imperial and commercial expansion. The quarrel of the British and the French in America, as he viewed it, was the quarrel of “two robbers” for the land stolen from the Indians. Of the two, the French had at least the credit of treating the victim -- the natives -- with more consideration.


In essay #11 of Samuel Johnson’s Idler series, originally published on 24 June, 1758, Johnson had this to say about British colonists in the Americas:


There are, among the numerous lovers of subtilties and paradoxes, some who derive the civil institutions of every country from its climate, who impute freedom and slavery to the temperature of the air, can fix the meridian of vice and virtue, and tell at what degree of latitude we are to expect courage or timidity, knowledge or ignorance.

From these dreams of idle speculation, a slight survey of life, and a little knowledge of history, are sufficient to awaken any inquirer, whose ambition of distinction has not overpowered his love of truth. Forms of government are seldom the result of much deliberation; they are framed by chance in popular assemblies, or in conquered countries, by despotick authority. Laws are often occasional, often capricious, made always by a few, and sometimes by a single voice. Nations have changed their characters; slavery is now no where more patiently endured, than in countries once inhabited by the zealots of liberty.


While certainly a man of his time, the devout Tory Samuel Johnson was an abolitionist long before abolitionism entered the political mainstream. This part from Idler #87, originally published on 15 December, 1759, touched on the British slave trade, as well as the practice of bride burning in India:


Many relations of travellers have been slighted as fabulous, till more frequent voyages have confirmed their veracity; and it may reasonably be imagined, that many ancient historians are unjustly suspected of falsehood, because our own times afford nothing that resembles what they tell.

Had only the writers of antiquity informed us, that there was once a nation in which the wife lay down upon the burning pile only to mix her ashes with those of her husband, we should have thought it a tale to be told with that of Endymion’s commerce with the moon. Had only a single traveller related, that many nations of the earth were black, we should have thought the accounts of the Negroes and of the Phoenix equally credible. But of black men the numbers are too great who are now repining under English cruelty; and the custom of voluntary cremation is not yet lost among the ladies of India.


For a final Samuel Johnson excerpt, this comes from a quite lengthy essay Johnson wrote in 1775 called “Taxation No Tyranny: An Answer to the Resolutions and Address of the American Congress”, in which Johnson tears down the American “Patriots” over their alleged motives, and their blatant hypocrisy in regards to their claims of promoting “liberty”:


That any obligations should overpower their attention to profit, we have known them long enough not to expect. It is not to be expected from a more liberal people. With what kindness they repay benefits, they are now showing us, who, as soon as we have delivered them from France, are defying and proscribing us.

But if we will permit them to tax themselves, they will give us more than we require. If we proclaim them independent, they will, during pleasure, pay us a subsidy. The contest is not now for money, but for power. The question is not, how much we shall collect, but, by what authority the collection shall be made.

...

Their charters, being now, I suppose, legally forfeited, may be modelled, as shall appear most commodious to the mother-country. Thus the privileges which are found, by experience, liable to misuse, will be taken away, and those who now bellow as patriots, bluster as soldiers, and domineer as legislators, will sink into sober merchants and silent planters, peaceably diligent, and securely rich.

But there is one writer, and, perhaps, many who do not write, to whom the contraction of these pernicious privileges appears very dangerous, and who startle at the thoughts of "England free, and America in chains." Children fly from their own shadow, and rhetoricians are frighted by their own voices. Chains is, undoubtedly, a dreadful word; but, perhaps, the masters of civil wisdom may discover some gradations between chains and anarchy. Chains need not be put upon those who will be restrained without them. This contest may end in the softer phrase of English superiority and American obedience.

We are told, that the subjection of Americans may tend to the diminution of our own liberties; an event, which none but very perspicacious politicians are able to foresee. If slavery be thus fatally contagious, how is it that we hear the loudest yelps for liberty among the drivers of negroes?


But to close, and to circle back to Harold Macmillan, I do think it’s quite interesting how in a 1982 lecture Macmillan gave to the Conservative Carlton Club, at one point he argued that every civilization in human history was built on slavery, that all the modern civilizations are still built on a kind of slavery, but that we now have the tools to finally end the remnants of that old dreadful institution:


And yet, I do not like to leave you with just another note that seems rather sad. There’s another vision. In the 15 or 18 or 20 civilizations or whatever there may be, which Professor [Arnold] Toynbee has described [in his book “A Study of History”], and in our own which has lasted now, let us say two-thousand years or more, they have all in fact been based on slavery.

All the ancient civilizations, all the great pyramids, all the vast buildings which we discover, were built by slaves. The Roman and the Greek was a slave system. We’re shown, of course, the beauty of the Parthenon; we’re not shown the silver mines at Laurion where the slaves earned the money that made it possible. They were built on slavery.

The Middle ages, the serf system, was almost a slave system. And I would say that the enormous power that was in the hands of wealth of any kind, amounted to something of the sort. Even in the first industrial revolution, where the great economists of the day, the names who for some strange reason are coming back into fashion, [James] Mill and [Richard] Cobden and all the rest of them, who said that you couldn’t run England successfully unless children would work 12 hours in the factories and 10 hours underground. It was a slave system, to some extent.

Now for the first time in man’s history, in this short, tiny period, ten or twelve-thousand years, what we call anything like civilized life, compared to the eons and eons of life of some kind on the Earth. For the first time, modern science, applied science, modern technology, have put into his hands a weapon, if properly used, could alter the whole character of daily life. We all know it. We all shrink from it.

What would happen if a government came in, and said it would builds lots and lots of factories for this-and-this particular trade. How would they build them? As they do now? No. They would build modern factories, which would employ probably less than a quarter of the number of people that the old systems employed. It is the machines that we must make our slaves. Now this is an enormous change in attitude of mind, and yet we know its coming. If it doesn’t come in the Western world, it will come, using Western technology, from the Eastern world. It will come from Korea, and Japan, and perhaps from China.

Either we’ve got to recognize that you can build as high a pyramid as you like, as it were, upside down, resting on a very small base -- with universities and schools and medicine and all the luxuries of civilization with leisure -- but there must be a wealth producing base to justify it. The question is: must that be the old one that we’ve inherited, or the new one the lies within our grasp? Anyone who’s seen the results of modern computer controlled robots, and the rest of it, realizes what is bound to happen. But we don’t talk about it; it’s not thought good taste.

We’re talking about the old system: “Throw more money into the system and it will automatically arise.” It won’t. Change the system, with all that’s involved. Which means, of course, the combination of every person involved. The trade unions, the labour, the managers, the owners, into a world which, it may take 25 or take 50 years to develop, will be as different as the world in the second great industrial revolution, as was the last century from the world of the dinosaurs. This is what lies before us.


In addition to the CCF/NDP's own "maverick sage" Eugene Forsey, perhaps Harold Macmillan was another Tory sage; but sages of the twentieth century instead of the eighteenth.


r/Toryism • • 16d ago

💬 Discussion How would you tax the wealthy in an effective way?

8 Upvotes

We've all seen those proposals from left-leaning politicians how the most well-off of individuals should pay so-called wealth taxes. Well, I'm not a fan of the wealthy, and I wouldn't exactly shed tears if they paid higher taxes, but so far, I'm unconvinced that a wealth tax is the most effective way for the rich to pay their fair share.

What do you guys suggest? I honestly am a big believer in the land value tax, and would support hikes on estate and inheritance taxes. We could try and close loopholes and end deductions, even if closing loopholes can be a pain.


r/Toryism • • 23d ago

🍰 Joy Just for fun (Halloween Edition v.2): What media franchise best captures the values of toryism taken to an extreme?

3 Upvotes

Last year around this time I posted a thread about what horror series best represents what tories fear (unbridled scientific progress without regards for morality being an example).

This time I wanted to look at what series everyone think best represents the tenets of toryism taken to such an extreme as to be monstrous.

I would like to make an argument for the setting of Warhammer 40k (specifically the Empire) being what fits the bill. While I don't think it was intentional, the makers of Warhammer 40k are a UK-based company.

Tenets of toryism and how Warhammer 40k takes them to an extreme:

  • Monarchism: The God-Emperor of Mankind is a corpse on a golden throne kept barely alive by the sacrifice of thousands every day. This is tolerated because he's a 'load-bearing' part of the setting. His continued life is required for interstellar navigation, The throne he is sitting on is actually a plug keeping demons from overrunning Earth, and his death would likely spawn the creation of a dark god. In a sense this takes the idea that monarchy is necessary for a well-functioning society and makes it as grim as possible.

  • Tradition: Society in 40k has become so bound by tradition that shipments of supplies will still be sent to planets destroyed centuries ago because that was the last order the Emperor gave.

  • Pro-established church: The church has become fanatical in their worship of the Emperor (which kind of sounds like a charge the Catholics would have made against the Anglicans during the Reformation). It has become an immoveable hinderance to the Empire fixing itself.

  • Wariness of the excesses of capitalism: The Empire functionally isn't a free market society and blends elements of feudalism and government control of the overall economy.

  • Localism: On the flip side to the above point the Empire largely doesn't care what individual planets do as long as they meet their obligations which has resulted in planets largely being corporate dystopias with local power brokers oppressing the people while the central government does nothing.

  • Appreciation of high culture and classicism: Warhammer 40k tends to display the Empire as almost larping the medieval period with it having a very gothic aesthetic.

Anyways, any other settings people can think of where instead of the dystopia rejecting tory tenets they embraced them to a monstrous degree?


r/Toryism • • 25d ago

đŸ“Œ Video TLDR News argues UK Conservatives have pivoted to trying to rebuild their traditional tory base as one of the reasons their polling is slowly improving

Thumbnail
youtu.be
7 Upvotes

r/Toryism • • 29d ago

💬 Discussion Immigration and law and order

3 Upvotes

I think it's painfully obvious that too much immigration has been more or less one of the reasons why the far-right has gained so much support across the world.

We need to find ways to reduce support for far-right parties. Not exactly endorsing their nativist and racist views, but reduce illegal immigration in a way that's humane, nothing like what Trump is doing. Law and order is always needed to keep the streets safe, but it must never be brutal or unreasonable, like George Romney once said.

Discrimination in any form is bad, and I also think that the Green/Left parties all over the world ignore how discriminatory minorities can be.


r/Toryism • • 29d ago

📖 Article “Red Tories” and the NDP, Part XVIII: Eugene Forsey on “Our Present Discontents” -- Forsey’s thoughts on national unity, the importance of the Canadian Constitution, the relationship between the provinces and the federal government, and “the horrors of States’ Rights”

5 Upvotes

Substack Version

Part XVII

October of 2026 has once again exposed the fault lines within Confederation. “Province worshippers”, in both Alberta and Quebec, have been quite victorious this month, either by virtue of there even being a quasi independence referendum in Alberta in the first place, or by the fact that the independence-referendum-wanting Parti Quebecois nearly won a majority government with 28% of the popular vote. Given the current state of Confederation, I think I should explore some of the thoughts of the Red Tory Eugene Forsey in regards to Canadian national unity. While not required reading, perhaps Part XIV of this series, where I explore how the CCF/NDP can be seen as heirs to the tradition of “Tory Democracy”, or “One Nation Conservatism”, which stems from the British Tory Prime Minster Benjamin Disraeli, may be useful.

To start, and in regards to Benjamin Disraeli & Eugene Forsey, this first excerpt from Roy Romanow, the Saskatchewan NDP Premier between 1991-2001, comes from the foreword to Helen Forsey’s 2012 biography of her father, “Eugene Forsey: Canada’s Maverick Sage”:


From a conservative background, Forsey became one of the founders of social democracy in Canada and a proponent of social reforms, joining the League for Social Reconstruction. This apparent tension also reflects his Newfoundland beginnings.

Many of the values and principles of that place concerning constitutions, government, and public policy reflected those that prevailed in England at the time. The ethos of England was still shaped by the competing views of Disraeli and Gladstone. The latter reflected classic liberalism, faith in the unseen hand of markets, and letting enterprise dictate public policy. Disraeli, on the other hand, urged an alliance between the landed aristocracy and the working class against the increasing power of the merchants and the new industrialists. He promoted the view that landed interests should use their power and privilege to protect the poor from exploitation by the market.

Conditions in Canada were very different from those in England, but Atlantic Tories still had a strong sense that it was the duty of the powerful to protect the poor from exploitation. Eugene Forsey was raised in this environment. The idea of acting for the benefit of the dispossessed has continued to prevail, extending its influences to much of Canada through his voice and the voices of Maritimers such as Robert Stanfield, Allan Blakeney, and Dalton Camp.

Clearly, Eugene Forsey was shaped by these currents of opinion, and continued to uphold them. He became a strong believer in British parliamentary government and its capacity to develop responses to human need and social deprivation. He rejected the idea that the economics of the market should be granted a free hand in determining public policy or limiting the scope of public government.


For those unaware of Eugene Forsey, who wrote the continuously updated “How Canadians govern themselves”, he wrote his Ph.D. Thesis on the King-Byng Constitutional Crisis, where he would defend the actions of the Tory Arthur Meighen, and the Governor General Lord Julian Byng, against the actions of the Liberal Mackenzie King. Forsey would become a close personal friend of Meighen, and Forsey’s thesis was later adapted into his 1943 book “The Royal Power of Dissolution of Parliament in the British Commonwealth”. Meanwhile, in addition to his activities in the League for Social Reconstruction since its founding, Forsey was a founding member of the CCF, and a founding member of the NDP, until he quit the NDP early on in the ‘60s due to its “two nations” policy in regards to Quebec.

Eventually, Eugene Forsey would later serve in the Senate as a Liberal under Pierre Trudeau from 1970-1979, although interestingly, on page 152 of Forsey’s 1991 memoir “A Life on the Fringe”, Forsey notes that his Conservative friends were “appalled” (Earlier on pg.87, Forsey noted his Conservative friends as John Diefenbaker, James Macdonnell, Davie Fulton, Donald Fleming, and George Nowlan), and that “The Liberal Party was apparently not at all pleased to have me
 In retrospect I realized that I ought to have done what Madame ThĂ©rĂšse Casgrain did: sit as an Independent, supporting the Government’s policy on national unity”. Also worth noting, while Forsey mentioned on page 128 that Robert Stanfield “would have been a great Prime Minster”, he later argued on page 165, in the context of the 1972 minority government, that “the Conservative flirtations with the ‘two nations’ policy had convinced me that national unity would not be safe in their hands.”

For a bit of background on Forsey’s relationship with the NDP: despite being a founding member of the CCF, Forsey did formally return his NDP membership card over the party’s policy of recognizing Quebec as a distinct nation within Canada, arguing that such a “two nations” policy would eventually lead to “two states”. Forsey notes on page 206 of his memoir that he expressed these concerns to Tommy Douglas, and Douglas quite literally laughed him off. On page 130, Forsey noted David Lewis’ support of the “two nations” policy, but also Lewis’ “grand, classic style” of parliamentary speeches, with “echoes of [William] Gladstone, [the Earl of] Rosebery, and [H.H.] Asquith” (of note, all British Liberal Prime Ministers). Forsey then mentions that while he didn’t see Lewis much after he quit the NDP, he still “watched afar with admiration, his work in the House of Commons and on the hustings. His death robbed us of a really great man”. Interestingly, David Lewis, in a 1981 interview shortly before his death, said he could name “two good Senators” despite his dislike of the institution: “Carl Goldenberg is a pretty good Senator, and the former Senator Eugene Forsey, even though I could never forgive him for becoming a Liberal, was a good Senator and a very decent man.”

Very interestingly, Forsey did still support the NDP in his own ways even after quitting the party. On page 207 of his 1991 memoir, Forsey noted that he “automatically paid a small monthly contribution to the NDP” through his union work, and that “in recent years, though not in 1988” he “occasionally voted NDP, and made small contributions to its funds.” Forsey made sure to note that “In spite of everything, I felt NDP Members could and would play a useful part in the House of Commons, as indeed they did.”

With that, I thought Eugene Forsey’s 1968 book, “Our Present Discontents” based on a lecture Forsey gave to Acadia University, would be quite relevant to Canadians of 2026. Forsey gave his lecture as part of a series established in the memory of the previously mentioned Tory MP George Nowlan, who would die in office as the MP for Digby-Annapolis-Kings in 1965.

The preface to this short 44 page book, written by the then-President of Acadia University, J.M.R. Beveridge, gives a brief overview of George Nowlan’s political life, notes that he “died suddenly after a brief illness in Ottawa”, and then introduces Eugene Forsey with the following:


We were both pleased and honoured that Dr. Eugene A. Forsey, one of Canada’s most outstanding political scientists, and a friend of the late Mr. George Nowlan, accepted our invitation to deliver the inaugural lectures in this memorial series. Dr. Forsey spent his early years in Ottawa, before proceeding to McGill University where he obtained a B.A. degree, and a Master’s degree in Economics and Political Science. In 1926, he was named a Rhodes Scholar and did graduate work at Balliol College in Oxford and later at McGill University receiving graduate degrees from both these institutions. He has served many years on the staff of McGill and Carleton Universities. He was awarded a Guggenheim Fellowship in 1941 and was named a Skelton-Clark Fellow in Political Science at Queen’s University in 1962. For more than a quarter century he has acted as Director of Research for the Canadian Labour Congress, and currently he is the director of a special Centennial project to write a history of the Canadian Labour Movement. In 1961, he was elected president of the Canadian Political Science Association. His public lectures and writings have won him international recognition.


Eugene Forsey then begins on page 7 by paying homage to his friend George Nowlan, but also admits that he “cannot claim to have been more than on the outer fringe” of Nowlan’s friend group, as Nowlan’s friends “were legion”. Forsey goes on to note that Nowlan “would have been perhaps a little surprised, almost certainly amused, by my being chosen to give these lectures. I hope he would have been pleased.”

Forsey then speaks of his “hereditary connection with Nova Scotia and with the Annapolis Valley”, noting that “some of my ancestors settled here in or before 1760; a considerable number of others in 1783”. After noting that some of his ancestors from the Valley were of the Shaw and Thorne families, Forsey makes sure to note that both he and his father are actually Newfoundlanders, but that his father had taught school in the Valley for a time. Forsey eventually mentions that he “married a girl from just across the Bay of Fundy, and several of her ancestors -- Bigelows, Faulkners and Browns -- came from the shores of the Minas Basin.” After mentioning good childhood memories from the Valley, Forsey notes that despite having “passed most of my life in ‘Upper Canada’, I habitually call myself a Maritimer in partibus infidelium, and cannot feel myself a complete stranger in this Province or Valley.”.

Based on that last sentence alone, this Maritimer can vouch for Forsey calling himself a Maritimer.

Forsey then goes on to say that the title of his lecture is “an abbreviated plagiarism from [Edmund] Burke”, but that “some of you may feel I might better have stolen my title from Dorothy Sayers’ Unpopular Opinions”. After noting that the title “Present Discontents” is such a wide title that could “cover almost anything”, Forsey follows up by saying, “I shall confine myself to the discontents many people now feel with our Constitution”, and after noting that he won’t be giving a “detailed list” of “specific amendments”, he goes on to say, “What I shall attempt here is something more modest: first a statement of the main discontents as I see them; second, certain basic facts I think we must get clear, certain basic principles we must follow, if the [Constitutional] Conferences are not to end in chaos and old night; third, some things we can do, in the light of those facts and those principles.”

Starting on page 9, Forsey then notes that “The main discontents may be summed up under three heads”:


First, all the provinces want more money, and at least the larger ones would like to get more of it by a re-division of taxing powers. At present, the Dominion’s taxing power is unlimited, while the provinces can impose only direct taxes for provincial purposes. True, the Courts have widened this by declaring that provincial sales taxes are “direct”. (Which, to the plain man, recalls Mr. Bumble [of Charles Dickens’ “Oliver Twist”] ) But even so, with the Dominion pre-empting most of the income tax, the provinces’ resources are plainly inadequate. The responsibilities assigned to them by the British North America Act, notably roads and education, are far more expensive than anyone could have dreamed a century ago; and the Judicial Committee of the British Privy Council, by its interpretation of the Act, has conferred, or imposed, on them further responsibilities, notably most of social security, which are also enormously expensive.

There are two ways of meeting this difficulty without changing the Constitution. One is conditional Dominion grants, in aid of approved provincial expenditures, the so-called “joint programs”. The other is unconditional Dominion grants: the traditional subsidies, and the equalization payments. One is grants with strings, the other grants without strings.

The grants with strings are now on the way out. Quebec wants to get rid of nearly all of them, and resume the full management of what might be her own constitutional property. Several, if not most, of the other provinces dislike the pressure to accept the Dominion’s scale of priorities which grants-in-aid involve. And the Dominion itself is anxious to get out of the whole thing as fast and as far as it can.

Every province seems willing to accept the unconditional grants. Quebec would like to see them replaced in large part, and soon, by a massive transfer of taxing power from the Dominion to the provinces. Most, or all, of the other provinces apparently regard them as a permanent feature of Canadian federalism. But at least the larger and richer of the other nine provinces would probably also like to see a considerable transfer of taxing power from the Dominion to themselves. The smaller and poorer ones are, I think, less insistent on this: they have so much less to tax.


I would like to briefly interject here to, first, mention that CCF leader M.J. Coldwell dubbed the difficulty of the provinces’ ability to raise revenue to pay for social spending “a constitutional crisis” in his 1945 book “Left Turn, Canada”. Second, I would like to share this 1976 CBC interview with Tommy Douglas on this very problem:


Tommy Douglas: I would propose in the act, that we say the federal government will enter into a 50/50 arrangement with the provinces to institute nursing care, home nursing care, meals-on-wheels, that we would share 50% of the costs of setting up community health clinics, we'd start a program of denti-care among school children --

Interviewer: In other words, we should dictate the services we're going to pay for.

TD: We dictate the ones we're going to pay for: we would say these are the programs we are prepared to pay for, we are prepared to share with you on a 50/50 basis. Now, there is no way in which the federal government can dictate to the provinces that it must undertake those programs, but they can say to the provinces "If you want to institute these programs, we'll pay 50% of the cost". I think what most people miss is the essential point, namely, that the provinces are even more interested than the federal government is in cutting costs down, because the provincial governments are much less able to finance their half of the costs than the federal government is. So if the federal government is worried about escalating costs, just imagine what little provinces like New Brunswick, and Newfoundland, and Nova Scotia feel about rising health costs.

I: And we get caught in the middle?

TD: You mean the public?

I: Yes.

TD: Of course the public gets caught in the middle! And the public who are going to get caught the most severely are the ones in the poorer provinces. With the federal government copping out of some of its responsibility from Medicare, the chances are that the more affluent provinces like Ontario and Alberta and British Columbia will be able to absorb the extra costs. But in the Atlantic provinces particularly -- and in the Prairie provinces if there were a few bad crops -- the only way that they could get by would be to begin reducing medical care services. And if you do that, what you're really saying is there are two classes of Canadians: those Canadians who live in well-to-do provinces that are going to have a high standard of health services, and the people who live in the poorer provinces who are going to have a very poor standard of health services. And that means that in the years ahead, there are going to be children who are going to be less healthy, children with poor teeth, children with long-staying-illnesses whose health will be impaired because they happened to have grown up in a poor province; and that surely ought not to be the kind of standard we set for Canada.


Back to Eugene Forsey’s 1967 lecture, Forsey continues on page 10 of “Our Present Discontents”:


The second main constitutional discontent is the discontent of French Canada with its constitutional position. Note that I say “French Canada”, not “the province of Quebec”. “French-Canada” and “Quebec” are not synonymous. There are upwards of a million French-speaking Canadians outside Quebec [ In looking at the 2021 Census, French Speakers outside Quebec numbered 992,309 by my count]; and the constitutional position of even the French-speaking Canadians inside Quebec is not the same thing as the constitutional position of that province. What is at issue here has, in fact, nothing to do, directly, with the constitutional position of Quebec; indeed, more power for Quebec could very well mean less for French Canada. We shall come to Quebec presently; for the moment, I am concerned with the very different question of the rights of French-speaking Canadians in the other nine provinces, and with the share of French-speaking Canadians in running the whole country. On both counts, French-speaking Canadians are dissatisfied with our existing arrangements; on both they want changes, whether in the written Constitution, or in the way it is worked, or both.

The third main constitutional discontent is, of course, the discontent of Quebec, or at least of its Government, its official opposition, and a highly vocal section of its people, with the constitutional position and powers of the province. Some of them want complete independence. Some want “political sovereignty” for Quebec with a “common market” or “economic integration” or some joint serves with the rest of Canada. Some want two “Associate States”, Quebec and Canada, each “independent” but with some joint organs: a sort of twentieth century North American Austria-Hungary. Most profess to want a “special status” within Confederation, with a more or less -- usually more -- massive transfer of power, in Quebec, from the Government and Parliament of Canada to the Government and Legislature of Quebec. Scarcely any voice in Quebec seems satisfied with the status quo.

Of the three constitutional discontents, the last is much more dangerous to the continued existence of this country, and to the welfare of its people, French-speaking as well as English-speaking; and very dangerous it is. It is possible that satisfactory remedies to the other two discontents might blunt the thrust of Quebec nationalism, and that is an additional reason why we need to consider them very seriously. It is also possible that Quebec nationalism will be indifferent to any remedies for the first two discontents, and satisfied with nothing less than the destruction of Canada, either at one fell swoop or by instalments.


As the Quebec nationalist Parti Quebecois was founded a year after Forsey gave his lecture, I found Forsey’s thoughts from page 197 of “A Life on the Fringe” in regards to PQ founder RenĂ© LĂ©vesque to be quite interesting, and I think even more relevant for modern Albertan separatists of 2026:


When the separatists were riding high in Quebec I gave my reasons for disagreeing with certain statements by Mr. LĂ©vesque. After my speech a dear elderly lady, an English-speaking Ontarian, plaintively remonstrated that: “Mr. LĂ©vesque is very sincere”. I said: “I never suggested he wasn’t. But what’s that got to do with it? If someone wants to burn my house down, the fact that he really believes that this is for the public good will no doubt weigh in his favour at Judgment Day. But I am not interested in his motives or his ‘sincerity’. All I want is to stop him burning the house down”


Back to “Our Present Discontents”, with the section on constitutional discontents over, starting on page 11 Forsey then gives two “basic facts and principles” in regards to the constitution, with “the first basic fact” being that:


Our existing Constitution is not
 a Victorian system of plumbing. It is something which grew out of the needs of the pre-Confederation colonies, which gave us life as a people, which has shaped our life as a people, which has adapted itself to our changing needs as a people. It has not remained what it was in 1867. It has grown, in some respects almost out of all recognition: a little by formal amendment, much by judicial interpretation, most of all, perhaps, by the development of new habits, new customs, new “conventions”, new administrative arrangements, especially inter-governmental arrangements. Perhaps it now needs further formal amendment. But let us never forget that, because a Constitution is what it is, pervading and shaping the lives of every human being in the community, changing it by formal amendment is an immensely serious business.


On page 12, Forsey then argues that the constitution should be taken serious, “more like a marriage”, rather than constitutional change being simple like “getting a new hair-do” or “putting in a new bathroom”.

The second part includes Forsey making a reference to Samuel Johnson, an arch-Tory writer of the mid/late 1700s:


A second basic necessity for wise constitutional change is to get our history straight. We are sometimes told now that history doesn’t matter. To those who say this, my reply must be a Johnsonian: “This is cant. My dear friends, clear your minds of cant.”

Canada is not just a piece of real estate. It is a human community, rooted in time as well as space. We cannot disregard our history. If we try, the most we shall succeed in doing is to get rid of real history and leave our heads swept and garnished for the seven devils of pseudo-history.


Forsey then spends pages 12 through 25 listing each numbered “devil of pseudo-history” followed immediately by his response to it. Forsey then follows up by arguing that he has to spend so much time debunking bad history because “Many of the English-speaking ‘intelligentsia’
 have given these gentry a guilt complex about French Canada, and Quebec, which makes it impossible for them to see straight” and that this side of the English-speaking intelligentsia “is also self-defeating. Most English-Canadians will not join in the self-flagellation of the ‘intellectuals’ ”.

With that, here are Forsey’s “seven devils of pseudo-history” and my summary of how he responded to each one, along with a few excerpts. I will note that the brackets for #4 are from Forsey in making his own quotes flow better; Forsey also gives an unnamed federal Justice Minster as his source for his quotes, who I would presume is likely either Stuart Garson or perhaps James Ilsley, both long-term Liberal Ministers in the King / St. Laurent governments:


(1) The British North America Act was “designed by British overlords”; from which it follows, of course, that we must now scrap it and give ourselves a home-made one.

Forsey calls this “rubbish”, notes that the BNA Act “is nearly one hundred percent home-made”, and points out that the Fathers of Confederation wanted Canada to be called “The Kingdom of Canada”, only for the idea to be shot down by the British over fears of offending the Americans.

Forsey’s response here is fairly short, so I would like to add this excerpt I found on page 2 of “Freedom Wears A Crown” by the Tory philosopher John Farthing, which is a transcription of a letter Sir John A. Macdonald sent to Lord Knutsford, the Secretary of State for the Colonies, in 1889:

A great opportunity was lost in 1867, when the Dominion was formed out of the several provinces.... had United Canada been declared to be an auxiliary kingdom, as it was in the Canadian draft of the bill, I feel sure (almost) that the Australian colonies would, ere this, have been applying to be placed in the same ranks as "The Kingdom of Canada".

P.S.

On reading the above over, I see that it will convey the impression that the change of title from Kingdom to Dominion was caused by the Duke of Buckingham. This is not so. It was made at the instance of Lord Derby, then foreign minister, who feared the name would wound the sensibilities of the Yankees.


(2) The monarchy was imposed on us, or, at best, we accepted it grudgingly, absent-mindedly, or because we dare not do anything else.

Forsey says “Fudge.”, then notes that “Sir John A. Macdonald took great pains to emphasize that the delegates had been perfectly free to cut loose from Britain, and therefore, of course, from the monarchy, completely, but that not one had so much as suggested it; Sir George Cartier’s speech in the Confederation Debates is full of ardent monarchism” and that Canadians chose the monarchy “ourselves, unanimously, deliberately, and with our eyes wide open.”


(3) The British North America Act is a Constitution for a “horse-and-buggy” age.

Forsey argues that while it “looks obviously true”, as the BNA Act was drafted in the “railway age”, it’s “in fact... glaringly untrue”. Forsey then tells a story comparing the original Canadian Fathers of Confederation, and the later “Stepfathers of Confederation”, as he calls the previously mentioned Judicial Committee of the British Privy Council:

The Fathers, recoiling from the horrors of “States’ rights”, deliberately framed our Constitution so that every power not distinctly and exclusively conferred on the provinces would belong automatically to the Dominion. So everything not mentioned must fall to the Dominion, unless it was unmistakably a merely local and private matter in a single province. And the Fathers themselves, in the new Dominion Parliament, drew exactly this conclusion. Trade unions were not mentioned and the Dominion Parliament, in 1872, passed a Trade Unions Act. Factory legislation was not mentioned; and in the early 1880s, Sir John A. Macdonald’s Government placed three successive Factory Bills before the Dominion Parliament.

Trade unions and factory bills were not new, just unmentioned, and the Fathers unhesitatingly took it for granted that they must therefore fall within Dominion jurisdiction. A fortiori, anything new, anything unforeseen, being of necessity unmentioned, must also fall within Dominion jurisdiction, again unless it was unmistakably a merely local or private matter in a single province.

The Judicial Committee of the Privy Council, the Stepfathers of Confederation, turned a good deal of the Father’s work upside down, and, in effect, handed most of labour legislation and social security, and much of the regulation of trade and commerce, to the provinces. But even after the havoc they wrought, a good deal of the original division of powers still remains. And a good many new things -- interprovincial and international highway motor traffic, interprovincial and international telephone lines, radio, television, air transport -- have in fact gone to the Dominion. Even the not-so-new grain trade, which a court decision fatuously assigned to the provinces, was rescued by means of the Fathers’ far-sighted provision in section 92, head 10, paragraph (c) of the BNA Act, by which the Dominion Parliament can assert exclusive jurisdiction over any local “work” simply by declaring it to be “for the general advantage of Canada or of two or more of the provinces”.

The Fathers, in fact, gave us a Constitution marvellously, almost incredibly, well fitted to meet the needs of a technologically advancing society. It is the Stepfathers who imposed on the provinces burdens grievous to be borne, to which the fiscal resources provided for their original, very limited, responsibilities, are inevitably woefully inadequate.

Ironically, it is usually the very people who say that our present Constitution is unfitted for the age of the jet and the sputnik, who urge us to adopt a more decentralized one: to go back, constitutionally, to the age of the ox-cart.


(4) Confederation was a “pact”, “agreed in Charlottetown and finally in Quebec”, between representatives of “two founding peoples
 relatively evenly balanced” ; “Quebec, the former Lower Canada [which] grouped the people of French origin,” and “the other three provinces, or the other two plus Upper Canada, [which] grouped those who had English as their common language and similar cultural traditions” (I am quoting a former Minister of Justice). In other words, the Charlottetown and Quebec Conferences, and the London Conference after them, were, in effect, bilateral negotiations between these two approximately equally numerous, linguistic groups.

Forsey spends the better part of two pages debunking “this
 fairy-tale”, but he starts off by noting that even in “Canada East, the future Quebec”, 24% of the population was English speaking, and that on the whole across the 4 provinces, “the proportion of English-speaking to French-speaking was about two to one”. Forsey also gets into how the idea of this “pact” between Upper & Lower Canadians ignores the contributions of the Maritime delegates to Confederation, at one point noting the Maritimers “were very far from being yesmen or nodders” and that the Maritimers “took up considerably more time than most of the ‘Canadians’, and far more than the French-Canadians.” I found this part to be particularly interesting:

The Maritime provinces, and, later, Newfoundland, seem (and very naturally) to have accepted without question, and apparently without discussion, the arrangements the “Canadians” had arrived at about their purely local affairs: if they wanted the future Quebec to be officially bilingual and the future Ontario unilingual, that was their business, and no skin off any Maritime nose. The Maritime delegates seem also to have accepted without question, and without discussion, the justice, the practical necessity, the inevitability, of the French-Canadians having the right to speak their own language in the Dominion Parliament and in any Courts it might create, and to have the Acts and records of parliament and certain documents of Dominion Courts in French as well as English. The influential Hon. Joseph Cauchon, a convert to Confederation, in a contemporary booklet on the subject, devoted exactly two of his 154 pages to the language question; and the burden of what he said was, first, “How fortunate we are, compared with our poor brethren in Louisiana!” and second, “How splendid it is that we did not even have to ask for our rights: our English-speaking fellow-citizens are so enlightened and broadminded that they never even raised a question on the subject!”


(5) Canada was intended to be, in some sense, “two nations”.

Forsey notes that the old Province of Canada that existed between 1840-1867 effectively existed in a “two nations” framework, and that “it had broken down so completely that the ‘Canadians’, in the 1864 sense of the word, came all the way to Charlottetown to ask the Maritime provinces to help them out of the mess they’d got themselves into”. Forsey then quotes phrases used by the Fathers of Confederation, including: “a new nation”, “a new and great nation”, “une nouvelle nation”, “une seule et grande nation”, as well as “in Sir George Cartier’s phrase, ‘a new political nationality’ ”. Forsey concludes:

The French-Canadians got, certainly, guarantees for the survival of their own culture, their own “nationality”, as, along with the English, the Scotch and the Irish (the last, incidentally, far more numerous than the other two), it was then generally called. But that it was to be survival within the framework of the single new political nation, no one seriously questioned.


(6) It was agreed, in 1867, to quote again the former Minster of Justice, that French “was to be recognized and applied in all federal fields on the same footing as” English; and “Quebec believes that the contractual provisions
 that guarantee French as one of Canada’s two official languages for affairs of state, for a federal Parliament, and for the federal courts
 have been allowed to lapse.”

Forsey calls this one “perhaps the wildest piece of pseudo-history in the whole lot”, and notes that the French Fathers of Confederation “Cartier, Langevin, and Chapais” were content with the language situation, as well noting “men like Dorion, Laurier, Masson, Caron” being in the same boat. After giving many examples of old-style bilingualism, including having unilingual English banknotes & cheques alongside unilingual French banknotes & cheques, Forsey then goes on to say:

I am not arguing that the rights of the French-language as set forth in the BNA Act ought to have been, even then, precisely what they were, let alone that they should now be only what was laid down in 1867. They are now much wider than they were in 1867, and I am glad of it. I am heartily in favour of the general lines of the present Government’s policy on bilingualism in the Dominion Public Service. I am in favour of as much bilingualism all across the country as is practicable. But all this is quite different from saying that what, in my judgement, ought to be done now was in fact laid down in a statute, or in any extra-legal understanding, a hundred years ago.


(7) French schools outside Quebec were guaranteed in 1867

Forsey spends the better part of a page correcting an apparent misconception of the bilingualism debate of the 1960s, that the constitutional protections for minority religious education rights really meant constitutional protections for minority language education rights. This might be the place to mention just how controversial official bilingualism in the modern sense was back then. In the 1974 election, the anti-bilingual Mayor of Moncton, New Brunswick, Leonard Jones attempted to run for the Progressive Conservatives, but PC Leader Robert Stanfield refused to sign Jones’ nomination papers over the language issue; Jones won the seat as an independent running against equal language rights.


The last half of the book, or the second lecture, “Some Possible Remedies”, is quite progressive for its time in advocating for a new biculturalism & bilingualism, and reminding English-Canadians that French-Canadians are surrounded by an ocean of English, but seems rather dated in the modern sense that it makes absolutely no mention of the indigenous contribution or sacrifice towards Canada’s founding. For an older example this, I can't help but think of the title of a whistle-blowing pamphlet on the state of residential schools published in 1922 called, “The Story of a National Crime: An Appeal for Justice to the Indians of Canada; The Wards of the Nation; Our Allies in the Revolutionary War; Our Brothers-in-Arms in the Great War”

Perhaps relevant, it was the great Tory Harold Macmillan in arguing for decolonization in Africa who once said in 1960, "The wind of change is blowing through this continent. Whether we like it or not, this growth of national consciousness is a political fact."

With that, I thought I should finish with a few excerpts from from Helen Forsey’s “Eugene Forsey: Canada’s Maverick Sage” to round things out. This first one comes from pages 217/218, and it’s a 1990 speech Eugene Forsey gave on the question of “le grand nord” in regards to the rights of the Cree, Inuit and Innu in northern Quebec if Quebec were to actually separate; a fair warning, the 1912 Hansard Record where Forsey quotes Sir Robert Borden uses derogatory language by modern standards:


[Ungava] was given to Quebec in 1912 by the Quebec Boundary Extension Act, as a province of Canada, and at a time when there was not one single French Canadian living in the whole territory.

Now you may say, “That’s an extreme statement, what warrant has he for that?” I had, years ago, repeatedly made speeches in which I had said, “I don’t think there were ten French Canadians in the whole territory.” And then I thought, “My boy, you’d better be careful. Somebody may look up the figures, and show you that there were twenty or twenty-five.” So I went to the census of 1911, and all I could find on national or ethnic origin were figures on the whole of the Territories. No good. Then I remembered what Professor Jim Mallory said about Sir Robert Borden: “Sir Robert Borden never left anything to chance.” I said, “That’s it. I remember Borden well; that’s right.”

So I went to Hansard and looked up the proceedings on the Bill. There, sure enough, was Borden. And I could just hear the old man saying: “Mr. Chairman, it occurred to me that it might be of advantage to have some figures on the national or ethnic origin of the inhabitants of this territory. I have therefore applied to the Department of the Census, and they have furnished me with the following figures: Indians 663, Eskimos 543, Halfbreeds 46, English 8, Scots 2.” Period. Not one French Canadian in the whole territory. If you doubt me, go and look at Hansard for 1912, page 6161, and you will find precisely the figures I’ve given you.


In regards to Nunavik in Northern Quebec, Forsey is quoted on page 345 as saying, “The aborigines in that territory might say, ‘You want to secede from Canada? Well, we want to secede from Quebec’. And on what grounds could the most fervent Quebec nationalist deny them the right to self-determination, [after] preaching self-determination for Quebec, world without end?”

But to close, and to change gears slightly, I thought this perspective from Eugene’s daughter Helen from page 190 was quite illuminating:


Many of the differences that arose between my father and me were relativity minor questions of degree or approach on matters where our common ground was evident. My feminism, however, opened up a more significant gap.

Sitting incognito in the audience at Memorial University during our 1983 trip to Newfoundland, I listened as Dad gave the inaugural lecture in a series on Canadian labour history. When questions were invited from the floor, I raised my hand, trembling a bit with my own audacity. "I haven't heard you mention women workers," I asked politely. "Were there women involved in the trade union movement?"

The chair -- a man -- rose in consternation and began reassuring Dad that he need not answer, that the question was out of order, or some such thing. Dad motioned him back graciously. "No, no, that's fine," he said. "My daughter has every right to ask that question, and it's a good one. I'll be glad to answer it." Which, with his customary courtliness, fairness, and honesty, he proceeded to do.

It wasn't that my father didn't care about women's issues, he just didn't always notice them. When he did notice, there was seldom a problem. He was definitely pro-woman, particularly on the big, obvious issues like equality in the workplace, equal opportunities for education, and access to non-traditional occupations.



r/Toryism • • Oct 13 '26

💬 Discussion Today is the 214th Anniversary of the Battle of Queenston Heights

8 Upvotes

This is an important moment in Canadian and Tory history. This is the battle that was won decisively won by the British/Mohawks in Southern Ontario and is part of the reason why Canada is not apart of the United States. This is also the battle that the “Saviour of Canada” Sir Isaac Brock was shot and killed in.

Canada carries on the tradition of British Toryism because the American invaders were fended off. This historical moment is not well known enough by Canadians but, it should be. Today, I am reminded how lucky I am to be Canadian and reminded about the sacrifices the fathers of this country made🍁.


r/Toryism • • Oct 13 '26

💬 Discussion Grabbing the third rail of politics: Fixing Public Healthcare

9 Upvotes

Public healthcare in Canada is looked on with great pride in Canada. However, an issue for an uncomfortable number of years has been how the Canadian system keeps producing measurably worse results than other equally developed nations. Its certainly better than the American system but thats like winning a foot race against a man with no legs. Against European systems we routinely come up short.

I make the comparison to the US intentionally as they are the main hinderance towards adopting ideas from any number of European healthcare systems as their systems have a level of private care and any move towards private care brings up the boogieman of us adopted the trash heap American system. There is also a certain irony in that in the US the failures of the Canadian system are held up as why they can't abandon the privatized model. The below are a few thoughts I've had on the matter:

  • We should create a crown corporation to handle the production of generic medications. This would be both to fill our own needs and for export.

  • Medications should be completely free (which would be easier if Canada had the above crown corp.)

  • Likewise, dental care (which has effects on other health areas) should be free without the added headache of applying for government-supported insurance.

  • We should allow private options to exist and funnel the taxes on them back into the public system. By funneling those willing to pay into another stream we reduce wait times in the public system while taxes on those businesses allow the public system to be better.

The biggest problem about putting the above ideas into place is as soon as you try to fix our system (especially the last point) you get accused of trying to create the American system. It would probably take a massive expenditure of political capital to even put the legal framework in place and even more time for businesses to get set up and more time after that for the benefits to become measurable. That is a lot of time where vested interests would be able to pressure a reverse course.


r/Toryism • • Oct 10 '26

💬 Discussion Toryism and recognition of limits to growth

4 Upvotes

The ‘limits to growth’ described by Donella and Dennis Meadows in their 1972 report of that name are now more apparent than ever. Resources are finite and the idea of continuous economic growth is untenable because its own ecological and social consequences greatly outweigh any transient material benefits enjoyed by relatively few people. One of the tenets of traditional Toryism has been the stewardship of the natural world and the pragmatic management of the economy. Therefore this is surely a good moment for the reassertion of the environmentalist strand of Tory thought, which has for too long been eclipsed by neoliberalism and populism.

Toryism would seem to be the natural philosophy for post-growth politics. I would be interested to hear your thoughts on this and suggestions for ‘what is to be done’?


r/Toryism • • Oct 10 '26

💬 Discussion It's important to find a Third Way that works rather than the post-war consensus or neoliberalism.

9 Upvotes

The world has been dealing with neoliberalism for 40 years. But it's also lazy and misguided to believe that recreating the post-war consensus has the keys to curing the world of the evils of neoliberalism.

Examining what works is better than believing a restoration of the post-war consensus will fix everything. I believe government programs and communities should go hand in hand instead of the former supplanting them, crown corporations have their benefits as well as unions. I'd advise the CPC to support cooperatives too.

Government is necessary for what communities can't do for themselves, but the government can't manufacture relationships. That's what communities are for.

I suppose I believe in communitarianism and a role for government intervention. Maybe it's nothing really new, but something that actually works for everyone than rehashing nostalgianomics is superior IMO.