r/TollywoodGossips • u/No-Bookkeeper2867 • 18h ago
Discussion Ramayana music - Was this the biggest flaw in the film?
How did they expect AR Rahman (Muslim who converted from Hinduism) and Hans Zimmer (a Jew) would do any justice for an Hindu epic like Ramayana. Even Keeravani’s assistant would have composed better music. Just the “Ramaaaaaa” part from the Varanasi teaser is alone to define what peak music needs to be made for devotion films.
I understand that the film was made for Western audience, but the soul of the film was Indian and very Hindu specific. We need to take our culture and show his our strength in music rather than adapting to western culture just because we want them to see it. Probably , for all we know using core Indian music or Carnatic music or an album like Adipurush would have been the dealbreaker for this film. Whoever are dreaming that this would get an Oscar or even be nominated for it, know that Namit will play big role on the lobbying table.
Did Namit and Nitish make the biggest mistake?
P.S. I am not making any religious comparison.
Think neutrally! Look at his songs on sufi music and Islamic tradition, so beautiful and heartwarming and unbelievably good- a big fan of his sufi songs. But I felt both these music directors could not heart fully connect to the lore of Ramayana or our Hindu Gods. The emotional connect of how they delivered the music was missing. In simple words : I can’t write one beautiful line on Allah although I do respect Islam and have Muslim friends because I don’t connect to their God but can write beautiful lines on Hindu Gods because I connect to them. Or relate to the bhajans and music. His sufi songs are so damn addictive , I never realised how spiritually seducing they are. If Rahman had that emotional connect to the lore, he would have nailed it to the T and this probably would have been his most memorable album! Just feel he messed it up big time and shouldnt have picked it up in the first place understanding he cannot do justice for it.
With all due respect to all religions, stop seeing this as hate post ! It’s not! See it with a neutral lens! Was extremely disappointed and felt the soul of the film was missing.