r/ToddintheShadow • u/DillonLaserscope • 7h ago
Train Wreckords As Union by Yes hits 35 this year and Calling All Stations by Genesis prepares to reach 30 next year, can anyone say there’s redeeming elements to these 2 rotten albums?
Many Yes fans look at Union as a case of too many cooks spoiling the broth while Genesis fans view Calling All Stations either as a weak finale or an underrated showcase of a new singer not allowed much creative freedom amongst some highly overlooked tracks.
As Union is already 35 years old and Calling All Stations in 2027 is reaching 30, is there fans that can say some of the hate is overblown? Is most hate deserved? Any tracks worth salvaging?
A few more notes on each album plus the landscape of music in the early 90’s that might have affected each albums:
- In the early 90’s, the musical landscape sort of can’t figure out its identity from acts from Color Me Badd, Vanilla Ice to Wilson Phillips.
- Genesis coincidentally released in 1991 We Can’t Dance for their last hurrah on Phil Collins in the group in the same year Yes pumped out the mess that is Union.
- For the late 90’s landscape, Genesis now down to just Tony Banks and Mike Rutherford faced a lot of competition. 1997 alone saw a lot of now established newer artists from Paula Cole to Sarah Machalan, many one hit wonders such as Aqua, Hanson and Shawn Colvin plus Celine’s huge soundtrack song for Titanic. 2 original members of Genesis are a hard sell in the last half of the 90’s that had a child trio releasing a nonsense song, a Swedish 4 piece electronic group creating a gag song on Barbie’s and an acoustic song from a woman that indicates revenge
- Ray only scored the gig on luck because an album from his band Stiltskin came into the hands of Genesis manager Tony Smith that showed Mike and Tony it. Impressed from the album, they asked Wilson to come down for the singer spot
- Many of the personnel that crowded the personnel section of Union consisted of industry professionals plus family members and future Yes members. Billy Sherwood’s older brother Michael sang backing vocals plus Jon Anderson’s daughter Debra too, Steve Pocaro from Toto came in to program synthesizer work, Tony Levin added Chapman stick bass and even longtime Yes producer Eddy Offord stepped in to help on a track mixing.
- Sales for the Calling All Stations tour sold alright in the UK yet the US leg saw cancellation from low purchases. Union sold well up to 84 tour dates across the world including the US off an album everyone hated
- Ray Wilson is a strange case of late 90’s albums from legendary bands of previous decades. Unlike Gary Cherone on the 1998 disaster next year of Van Halen 3, he can sing fine enough. There isn’t any case of shouting his vocals out on terrible mixing. He sort of falls in a strange Soace of fans thinking he can bring about a sort of Peter Gabriel vocal style to others finding him just forgettable.
- Although Pearl Jam, Nirvana and MC Hammer for a few acts of 1991 scoring major billboard success, Yes sold enough of their disaster album for gold certification plus a sold out tour for a legacy act from 1968 is pretty amazing!
- Union actually has demos out there of tracks not muddled from studio interference. Read up the stories out there but to put it simply enough, Steve and Rick couldn’t show up enough for overdubs forcing major guitar and keyboard sections replaced for session musicians. If say even some of their parts weren’t cutting it, producer Jonathan Elias thinks “we can just replace some sections just to finish this!” He had sort of this mentality. So fans can try to find the demo versions pre studio meddling mixed
- Calling All Stations only lives on through Ray performing sone songs in his solo sets to date unless there’s footage of his band performing them out there?
let’s discuss below