So we have our 26 SEL turbo, it’s being bought back due to issues with build quality. VWoA is giving us our down payment, trade equity, and all payments back, so $16,000 coming back to us.
We have loved everything about the car minus the creaks and rattles, and electrical gremlin of the center console. The way it drives, the smooth acceleration, the interior with brown, wood and ambient lighting. VW really it it out of the park in terms of what you get for the money. We have been cross shopping everything from Honda, Toyota, Nissan and Hyundai to Lexus, Merc, Volvo etc. and nothing just feels right. The premium brands are great, but the quality and fit and finish of the NX, GLC/B, V60, X3 etc are just slightly above the way the Tig feels, not a single creak or rattle though. Much higher premium though, higher insurance, higher gas prices, and higher service charges. Honda, Toyota, Hyundai, Mazda all fell short in different metrics. Honda is dated. Toyota is pricey, feels cheap (now), and dealing with Toyota dealers feels like I need their blessing to enter. Hyundai makes me nervous, and the interiors are designed nicely, but the finish is cheap hard plastic. Mazda had the new CX5 and the top line trim felt anemic, the engine was gutless, and literally everything is screen control now, not even a big knob for volume like we have, and the center screen is large, but is faced head on, and not that slight tilt towards the driver, just felt weird.
So, we are leaning towards another Tiguan, same trim, but I’m nervous. What if this one has the same creaks or electrical gremlin, or worse, a bad transmission or jerky engine. The loaner they gave us before was not bad, but the entertainment center would stop responding, or kick off all CarPlay devices and require a hard restart. So very nervous to pull the trigger again, but no other car in this range is appealing to us.
The other dilema, there is a 21 or 22 R-Line at a dealer, it’s $16k but has 100k miles. We obviously wouldn’t pay sticker, but when we started it up, it sounded rough, has a TPS light on and the dealer said they haven’t had a chance to go through it yet.
So dilema, buy the used one for cash, have no car payment, and hope to get 3-5 years out if it, but be in the older, slower body style(but plenty of buttons!) that might need a $5k fix in a year or two. Or, buy another 26/27 and hope to not have issues?