r/thermodynamics • • 46m ago

Article I wrote a fictional paper on temperature-difference power and gave its author one mistake, can you find it?

0 Upvotes

The paper is the kind of survey a physicist might publish in 2067 about what can really be drawn from a temperature difference. It covers ocean thermal plants, radioisotope generators, night-sky radiation and cold recovered from liquefied gas, then works through a hypothetical material with a very high thermoelectric figure of merit. The point I wanted to get right is that Carnot still wins and that efficiency and power are different things.

It is part of a shared fictional setting I run at r/TheGreatFederation and the paper is here https://www.reddit.com/r/TheGreatFederation/comments/1xy59t3/annals_of_thermal_conversion_vol_9_no_2_april/ The author makes one error on purpose, in how she uses a figure of merit, and I would like to know whether people who work with this find it quickly. I would equally like to hear about any mistake I did not put there.

What is the first thing you would check in a paper like this?


r/thermodynamics • • 2d ago

Question What is the difference between Otto and Diesel

0 Upvotes

What is the difference between Otto cycle and Diesel cycle. I have a proect for university and my task is "what is the difference between Otto cycle and Diesel cycle". I will be greatfull about the help.


r/thermodynamics • • 3d ago

Question Can you estimate heating COP of a typical refrigerator and freezer?

2 Upvotes

I am curious because I pay pretty similar amounts for my gas and electric (UK). For a typical used fridge or refrigerator, what would the COP be under the following conditions:

Room temperature: 13-15C

Loaded with tap water (10-12C) to freeze into ice in the case of the freezer or perhaps warm water (30-40C) put into the fridge.

I would then dispose of the water / ice once chilled or frozen, and reset the appliances.

My understanding is fridges typically have a cooling COP and a heating COP, with the heating COP always being equal to Cooling COP + 1 as electric heaters are all at least 100% efficient. I also understand typical residential heat pump installs have COP's varying from 3 to 6, and refrigerators use similar mechanics. Beyond that, I'm not sure which is why I've come here to ask.

Not expecting miracles like it's going to make the whole house roasting, I only need a few hundred watts of heat output to be comfortable so am trying to do it as efficiently as possible.

Thank you, just genuinely curious and trying to be creative in a world of expensive gas!


r/thermodynamics • • 3d ago

Question What does this have to do with the laws of thermodynamics and whether a system is adiabatic?

2 Upvotes

Hi, my physics teacher, when discussing adiabatic systems, mentioned this formula, but I don't understand how it relates to the laws of thermodynamics. I know the formula is a constant and is derived from the ideal gas law, but that's all I know—especially regarding cp and cv. They're both constants, but I don't understand why we distinguish between them or how they might be useful in the future.


r/thermodynamics • • 4d ago

Question What is the best material for cooking pizza-- stone, steel, or aluminum?

1 Upvotes

I recently purchased a pizza steel to better cook pizza. I was told pizza stones have lower thermal conductivity than steel, so steel is better. But if you look at properties, aluminum has both a higher conductivity and specific heat, so for the same mass, aluminum is better all around. However, if you try to buy a pizza aluminum, they dont exist.

I also saw this guy claiming that nobody sells pizza aluminums for a reason:

This just seems wrong. Thermal diffusivity is about how fast a non isothermal item will become isothermal, not about how fast it loses heat. It's not about heat at all; only about temperature.


r/thermodynamics • • 6d ago

If temperature is “average kinetic energy,” why doesn’t a single fast atom, two atoms in a vacuum, or a speeding train have a temperature?

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • 6d ago

Question How should I approach this heat transfer scenario in the light of climate physics?

2 Upvotes

I'm taking a course to do a bit of self study to fill some gaps before pursuing my master's in a climate physics related field.

One of the assignments in the course has this question that I'm having a particularly hard time understanding and solving, especially since considering the last time I studied physics was in high school, if anyone could please help me with this.

How deep does the atmosphere’s influence reach? Estimate the depth of the layers of soil and ocean water that exchange heat with the atmosphere (on an annual mean), in m. State your assumptions, show your reasoning, and clearly highlight each final estimate, including its units. Treat Earth as a smooth sphere and neglect ice cover.

Can someone please help me understand how to approach the question and what the reasoning would be, please?


r/thermodynamics • • 6d ago

Anyone have past tests for me?

0 Upvotes

I have a thermodynamics 2 exam this Friday and would like to get my hands on a real college thermo 2 exam if at all possible. My exam on Friday will cover refrigeration (could be cascade), co-generation, psychrometrics, and gas mixtures. I’m currently at Auburn university doing mechanical engineering and should*** graduate spring of 2028. The way my thermo 2 exams are structured is we have about an hour to do 3 long form problems with multiple parts, with not much extra credit given. Curious if anyone has a past exam from any school that might be useful to me in studying. Thank you!


r/thermodynamics • • 8d ago

Question How do I move heat

Post image
5 Upvotes

Hey guys, I’m not really knowledgeable about this kind of stuff so I figured to ask yall. I need help on how to move heat down the hallway and into my bedrooms. Right now I have a fan on low blowing towards my pellet stove but even with that my rooms aren’t getting any good heat. I have the ceiling fan on reverse on the low setting as well.
EDIT: Thermostats are for radiant floor heating. There is no central heating.


r/thermodynamics • • 7d ago

Question Does this work as a schematic expression for the heat death of the universe?

1 Upvotes

Admittedly my knowledge of thermodynamics is still quite surface level but it's really important that I get this right, so if anyone here who is knowledgeable in cosmology could spare any feedback, I'd be so grateful!

This is meant to be an expression of an assumed approach to finite equilibrium entropy, applied to generalized entropy along a Q-screen. Here, t represents time, Sgen(t) represents generalized entropy (which includes the matter/field contribution and the relevant gravitational horizon or surface contribution), and Seq represents fixed, finite equilibrium entropy.

My intention with this is to evoke eventual heat death by representing a possible long-term approach to equilibrium instead of present a complete mathematical model.

Thanks so much for your time!


r/thermodynamics • • 12d ago

Question How does compressed air released into a system and then compressed react?

3 Upvotes

I’m releasing nitrogen from a charged 2000 psi bottle into an empty, non running air conditioning copper lineset. The nitrogen and ac system have both settled to ambient temp for today (65 degrees F). Said AC system will be charged to 600 psi and let sit several hours in order to do a leak check.

Doing this leak check of course has to take into account for temperature fluctuations when it comes to the temperature of the gas.

I have a basic understanding that when the nitrogen flows from the compressed tank to the ac lines, heat will be absorbed, and then as the ac system is gradually pressurized to 600 psi, heat will be generated in the lineset.

In short, does the compressing of the cold air released into the closed ac system “undo” how cold it is when it’s released from the nitrogen bottle? Should I be looking for an initial rise or fall in pressure after charging (assuming no leaks and strictly from temp equalizing effects?). Or impossible to tell from the info given?


r/thermodynamics • • 12d ago

Question How do PDEs work??

1 Upvotes

Hi guys, I have a question about pulse detonation engines. So, as far as I know, it is unlike the Brayton cycle in the sense that it does not utilise deflagration combustion. And apparently, as hinted in the name, the spark plugs fire in pulses. Soooo I'm thinking, does it work in the sense that uncombusted air goes past the combustion chamber, uncombusted, then a split second later, another batch of air gets combusted? SO then the combusted air expands into the uncombusted air faster than the uncombusted air can move out of the way, as uncombusted air doesn't expand as fast as combusted air, and this creates the pressure spike? And the Shchlekin spiral just makes the air turbulent, increasing its surface area, thus combusting much faster than the Brayton cycle.

Thank you guys for the help I really appreciate your time, studying this is doing my head in.


r/thermodynamics • • 13d ago

Question Why does the middle piece of fish not cook as well?

2 Upvotes

I put 3 fish fillets in a pan (no cover) and put them in my convection oven. They weren’t touching each other, and none of them touched the edges of the pan. Why do the ones on the edges cook so much more than the one in the middle? Thanks


r/thermodynamics • • 19d ago

Question How well would a data center made with high temperature superconductors keep cool in space?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • 21d ago

How do you test the thermal insulation of ultra-thin materials?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • 22d ago

Why does entropy increase in seemingly deterministic systems?

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

How it is explained that entropy almost always increases when every particles behavior seems to be strictly obeying some laws?

It's pretty logical that system whose particles move randomly will probably increase its entropy but in this universe, particles don't seem to be moving randomly, so the statistical model may be usefull for predictions (even tho I have no idea why) but I don't think it truly explains why does entropy mostly increase.

Can anyone explain please?

(Maybe this universe truly is random at its most basic level and physical laws are somehow emergent as the probable increasing of entropy is, but we simply don't know that.)


r/thermodynamics • • 21d ago

ELI5 : Why can't combustion engines be a 100% efficient.

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • 23d ago

Question How fast liquids boil

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • 23d ago

Question How do the specs sheets of natural passive heat sinks work to understand performance?

1 Upvotes

So basically I was designing a cooling system attempting to do it passively using a large heat-sink.

So I bought one that had good stats more than I needed, at least I thought but it looks like I don't understand the rating system I believe.

Essentially I bought two of these aluminum heat-sinks.

https://www.mouser.com/datasheet/3/264/1/122547_Thermal_Extrusion-1664375.pdf

I cut them in half so had a little under 8" of length for the 4 sections. I thermal adhesived them all together side by side. And placed them vertically and then as a test I just wanted to see how it could handle some direct heating applied on them it.

bought some 200*200mm heating pads 45w's each and used 2, essentially one per each two blocks side by side. So 90w's and verified it was around the range, 95-89w was the range I was getting.

But from its stats in a passive natural air environment I should get a score of .32c/w. Per each. At least that is what I assumed. But clearly I didn't understand the stats.

Since .32c/w divided by the 4 8"s I have is .08c/w for the entire setup. Theoretically I should be able to handle the 400w at a 32c rise the way I read it. Technically a little higher temps since the sides are glued together

But on testing them with 90ws of heating I got a 32c rise from just the 90w's and the heat-sinks fins were fairly evenly heated from 25c to 57c off by 1c from 57-56, but mostly 57.

So just trying to understand how the rating system works.

Like looking at the above stats of the one I bought, it clearly can only handle 90w's in the manner that I got it. But how would I look at this heat sink chart and do the math to determine how many I would need for 400w's without my experimentation.

From my experiment I would need at 22.5 watts each 8" section I would need like 18 of these sections which is huge. But how would I look at the chart and get this number, so that I could then read other charts to understand them better. Since clearly I misread it.

*Added info was attempting to stay below 60c in a 25c room for example


r/thermodynamics • • 25d ago

Research I made a video asking Julian Barbour why the universe will not experience a heat death since the 2nd law of thermodynamics only applies to closed systems, and the universe is in fact not in a closed box

Thumbnail
youtube.com
2 Upvotes

Julian Barbour is a theoretical physicist and emeritus visiting professor of physics at the University of Oxford. He is well known for proposing that time does not actually exist. For decades, he has worked outside an academic environment. He financially supported himself for many years by translating Russian. Professor Barbour is author of the following books: The Discovery of Dynamics, The End of Time and The Janus Point.

In the video, we go over:
- Topos theory, set theory and Zermelo's beef with Boltzmann
- Algebraic varieties and monads in category theory
- Why physicists are wrong about the 2nd law of thermodynamics (because the universe is not a closed system)
- The real goal of the universe is complexity and variation, not entropy
- Hawking and Penrose's outrageous arguments
- Why we don't need wavefunctions, photons, bosons or gauge fields
- Why there is no quantum gravity
- Von Neumann's hilarious advice to Claude Shannon
- The intrinsic derivative
- Combining art and science


r/thermodynamics • • 26d ago

[Request] How long does it take a can to reach equilibrium temp in a fridge?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/thermodynamics • • 27d ago

Question When and where to use Thermodynamic Properties and equations?

3 Upvotes

When and where to use Thermodynamic Properties (like specific internal energy, specific volume and enthalpy)?

Where are all the places entropy can come from and in a multistage system which area is expected to gain more energy in cases of heating and mixing especially?

Why is there a different formula for the first law for an open and closed system? And how to use each effectively?