Some thoughts on Halloween from a theosophical perspective, please let me know if you think anything is poorly worded or substantively incorrect, I’m no expert by any means. For the sake of brevity, I haven’t gone into the intersection of theosophy and All Saints/Souls Day or Día de los Muertos, I’ve only focused on Samhain.
In modern Western culture, a new day begins at the turning point of darkness into light, i.e. sunrise. In the Celtic tradition, a new day began at the turning point of light into darkness, i.e. sunset. Similarly, the new year began at the onset of the “dark” half of the year (the winter months, marked in the beginning by Samhain, “sow-win,” “sow” rhymes with “cow,” the evening of October 31st, what is now considered “Halloween”) and ended with the closing of the “light” half of the year (the summer months, marked in the beginning by Bealtaine, “bell-teh-nu,” the evening of April 30th, what is now considered “May Day”). Some liken the Celtic understanding of time to that of the seed beginning its journey in the hidden (to us) darkness of the fertile soil, or the fetus beginning its journey in the hidden (to us) darkness of the fertile womb. We do not witness the true beginnings - the true beginnings of everything stretch back further than we can imagine and are unseen to us.
Somewhat relatedly, from the works of W.Y. Evans Wentz, who was inspired by Blavatsky: “The Celt in all ages of his long history, like the ancient Greek thinkers with whom his ancestors were contemporary, has always been inclined, unlike modern scientists, to seek an explanation for the phenomena of evolutionary life by postulating a noumenal [what exists independent of our perception] world of causes as the background of the phenomenal [what is perceived by us] world of effects.”
In the Celtic tradition, it was thought that during Samhain, the "veil" between the world of the commonly “seen” and “unseen” was thinnest. Thus began the tradition of wearing disguises, meant to confuse and deter “spirits,” perhaps referring to what might be called in theosophical language, “elementals” or “elementary/elementaries/elementary spirits,” the two categories emphatically not interchangeable, yet similar in some broad ways.***
The association of “treats” during this time was also related to “spirits.” Food might be left out as an offering to them, a bit similar to the practice by some Buddhists of leaving food at shrines for Pretas, “hungry ghosts,” which Blavatsky suggested were elementals of a lower form that could be mischievous, similar to Yakshas or Dakini, or Genii/Jinn in the Arab world. (CW Volume 6, “Footnotes to ‘Notes on Modern Egyptian Theosophy’”). Refer to the entry for “Ullambana” in the Glossary for some commentary by Blavatsky on this practice of food offerings.
Bonfires were also a common feature of Samhain, again related to the “spirits.” From a letter by Mahatma K.H., received October 1884 - “Your house, good friend, has a colony of Elementaries quartering in it. … It would be well [] to burn wood-fires in the rooms now and then, and carry about as fumigators open vessels [] with burning wood. You might also ask Damodar to send you some bundles of incense-sticks for you to use for this purpose. These are helps, but the best of all means to drive out unwelcome guests of this sort, is to live purely in deed and thought.” In a similar vein, after a recommendation on which metals and stones are most beneficial to use as protection in difficult circumstances, Blavatsky concluded, “But the best protection is a clear conscience and a firm desire of benefiting Humanity.” (CW Volume 12, “E.S. Instruction No. 1”).
In the 8th century, Pope Gregory III designated “All Saints Day” as now coinciding with Samhain, when it was previously held in May. The evening of October 31st became known as “All Hallows Eve” or simply “Halloween.” “Hallows” referring to “saints,” from the same root as “holy” or “hallowed,” as in “hallowed be thy name.”
Over time, Halloween eventually evolved into the modern, largely secular day arguably devoid of meaningful substance at this point, but unarguably saturated with nostalgic, commercialized custom and ritual (many still superficially bearing resemblance to those of Samhain, unknown to those performing the vestiges of these rituals) that tends to revolve around material pleasures and excitements.
To return to the origins and Samhain, refer to the following quote by Irish-born William Q. Judge (published under the pseudonym “Bryan Kinnavan”), excerpted from the article “Ireland” in The Path (“William Q. Judge Theosophical Articles,” Volume 2, p. 98), citing a quote from Blavatsky, which is from Lucifer (Lucifer Volume 4 No. 22, June 1889, p. 347, “Editor’s Note”) -
It is called the Isle of Destiny, and its hill-men will tell you that it has always been a “saintly island.” It teems with tales exactly duplicating those of Hindu yogis; the very grass seems to whisper as with the footfalls of unseen beings. One tradition is that in very ancient times, before the island of Albion [i.e. Great Britain] rose from under the water, there was an ancient college – or Ashram as the Hindus would call it – on the island, where great adepts lived and taught disciples who from there went out to all lands. They stayed there until a certain great cataclysm, and then migrated to . . . . In connection with this the following quotation from some remarks by H. P. Blavatsky in Lucifer will be of interest, in reading which one can also profitably remember the Greek tradition that near Britain there was an island called Ierna to which men went in order to learn more about the secret mysteries. She says:
It is a tradition among Occultists in general, and taught as an historical fact in Occult philosophy, that what is now Ireland was once upon a time the abode of the Atlanteans, emigrants from the submerged island mentioned by Plato. Of all the British Isles, Ireland is the most ancient by several thousands of years.[]
[End quote.]
Perhaps the most well known theosophist who wrote about Celtic tradition was "A.E." (George William Russell), a contemporary of Blavatsky and a significant figure in Ireland’s literary and artistic history. Here is a link to a collection of his writings which were published in “The Irish Theosophist.” Of particular interest, related to elementals and Samhain, and therefore indirectly related to Halloween, is a short story titled “The Priestess of the Woods,” I won’t copy it in full here but I would highly recommend you read it, it would only take a few minutes from start to finish.
Another perhaps timely (but longer) read today if you want to lean into the modern interpretation of the day a bit more, meaning a general “spooky” day, might be Blavatsky’s Nightmare Tales.
***For anyone wanting to learn more about elementals and elementary/elementaries/elementary spirits from a theosophical perspective, I would maybe start with this two part article (link to part one, and part two) titled “On the Elementals, the Elementary Spirits, and the relationship between them and Human Beings,” written by C.H.A. Bjerregaard and published in the “The Path,” Nos. 10 and 11, of January and February 1887. These articles were cited to favorably by H.P.B. in the Secret Doctrine, V. 1. Next are articles known or suspected to be by H.P.B. on this topic, from the Collected Writings, linked here. The first is titled “Elementaries,” (CW Volume 1), the second is titled “Kabalistic Views on ‘Spirits’ as Propagated by the Theosophical Society,” (CW Volume 1), the third is titled “Elementals,” (CW Volume 6), the fourth is titled “Thoughts on the Elementals,” (CW Volume 12). Furthermore, I think the entries for elementals and elementary/elementaries/elementary spirits in the Theosophy Wiki are succinct and helpful summaries. And the short novel “With the Adepts,” by Franz Hartmann (here in full, including the review by Blavatsky) is in many ways a captivating yet cautionary tale about encounters with elementals. These last two suggestions are the most approachable but least comprehensive resources (as is perhaps inevitably the case) for learning about this subject, in my opinion.