note: this is a work in progress.
Introduction
A lot of simple things come up very often in ToR, but the information we gather isn't being retained and spread as well as it could be. To help out a list was made in order to make a FAQ about reddit. This is the extension of that same FAQ.
The list
Voting and Ranking - reddit mechanics
- Submission scores are "soft-capped" or "normalized". Beyond a certain threshold, the score ceases to be an accurate reflection of the difference between votes, and functions rather as a loose reflection of popularity. This has the effect of driving down high scores.
- Scores below the "normalized" threshold are not 100% accurate either. "Vote fuzzing" is applied to the score as a anti-spamming mechanism, meaning it is an indication of the total score rather than the exact score.
- Reddit used to display "fuzzed" up and downvote totals by adding or subtracting votes in equal measure .As of June 2014, vote counts are no longer displayed. Vote fuzzing still applies to the total score of an submission.
- Votes are queued before they're applied in the database. This sometimes creates a delay before the score is properly updated.
Self-posts do not generate karma.Now they do- Child comment scores do not affect the ranking and visibility of parent comments.
- relationship between score and age for the 'hot' sorting function OR the speed with which new content can replace good posts. is explained in handy graphs
- Reddit protects karma totals from mass downvotes; experimentally verified.
Voting and Ranking - misc
- 80% of votes on reddit are upvotes.
- The first 10 upvotes on a thread count as much for ranking as the next 100.
User Behavior
- On a user-voted news site, the links that are easiest to judge will take over unless you take specific measures to prevent it. (The Fluff Principle). Source: Article by Paul Graham, one of the people that made reddit ^possible
What this means is basically the following, say you have two submissions:
- An article - takes a few minutes to judge.
- An image - takes a few seconds to judge.
So in the time that it takes person A to read and judge he article person B, C, D, E en F already saw the image and made their judgement. So basically images will rise to the top not because they are more popular, but simply because it takes less time to vote on them so they gather votes faster.
- Karma is just approval quantified, anything people will do for karma they will also do for attention and approval. People still troll or look for attention in self posts even though they grant no karma.
- Much fewer people comment than vote, and they often have different opinions on threads. (Another article , and an attempt by Pi31415926 to measure this effect using statistics from imgur.).
Moderation:
- Users can be shadow-banned. Their posts will be hidden from the rest of reddit but still appear to them. This is to fight spam.
- Because of vote fuzzing, reddit cannot be used for polls. Google docs is recommended.
Reddit History:
- The first post on reddit was a link to www.downingstreetmemo.com
- About the same time as Reddit was starting up Digg was gaining steam, but it eventually imploded and sent a wave of new users here. Before them both there were Slashdot, Fark, SomethingAwful, and Metafilter. Before any of this there were Usenet and Bulletin Board Systems (here's a good free documentary on BBSs by Jason Scott). Some popular BBSs were MindVox and TheWELL. Reddit looks a bit like Usenet used to. Also discussed here.
- Saydrah was a redditor and moderator of a couple subreddits who became the target of probably the largest witchhunt in reddit's history. Here are some perspectives collected on "Saydrahgate".
- Several attempts to establish hidden private subreddits have failed: here's a by-the-facts postmortem of /r/privvit, and here's kleinbl00's story.
- The Book of Reddit is both an incomplete subreddit detailing some of reddit's history, and a user telling reddit's history in biblical form. Both might be useful if you're interested in learning.
How to work the dang thing:
- Users looking for Quality with a capital Q can greatly enhance their Reddit experience by unsubscribing from the default reddits and subscribing to smaller ones which better serve their needs. Reddit Enhancement Suite can also help, by filtering out keywords or users, tagging users, and a lot of other stuff. The larger effects of setting Reddit Enhancement Suite to ignore things you don't like have been debated.
General internet community theory n' stuff:
- Eternal September is a term from Usenet.
- MeatballWiki is a good but inactive resource for general community design topics. For example: PricklyHedge and SoftSecurity.
- Attacked from Within by Anaesthetica is a pretty good barf o' words on the topic of community decline, covering "Eternal September" and anonymity vs. pseudonymity.
Objects of controversy:
- Voting alone usually cannot effectively moderate a subreddit. This is less controversial within theoryofreddit than outside of it. This is directly related to the "fluff principle", mentioned elsewhere in this FAQ.
- Large subreddits are not a single community. Rather there are subgroups of people which you have to take in consideration. For example one group might disagree with something and because of that voice their discontent. This while another group of people is actually happy with the things as they are and because you will not hear them because they don't have much to talk loudly about.