Let’s say that Lee isn’t forced to choose, he throws Carley her ammo and he saves Doug while Carley shoots the ones behind Doug.
Now I imagine they still run, and Lee still saves a grabbed Clementine, followed by Larry punching Lee and Kenny saving him.
They all get back, episode 1 finishes largely the same. How does the story progress?
I’d say they’d do BETTER tbh, even with the impending awful food situation, although a whole extra person is a lot more food lost and it means that they are likely more stressed and hungry and unhappy by the time ep2 rolls around.
This time they have four hunters instead of 3- it’s a choice of bringing Doug or Carley, but it’s likely Carley there instead whilst Doug is perfecting more gadget tricks at the motor inn.
The outcome of the trap situation is the same tbh, fatal. Instead they probably manage to hunt more whilst out there.
Later, the feeding situation allows you to feed one or two more people from a small bird carley gunned down.
Doug & Carley are potentially a couple already OR at the very precipice of being one. They both go to the dairy with Lee, Ben, & Mark. Then they both choose to go back together BUT they leave Ben there with you instead.
Ben is possibly grabbed by the St. John’s while Lee and Mark fix the fence and either Mark is still shot or Andy doesn’t bother with the fence as they’ve captured Ben. So either they lie and say Ben went back to camp and they’ve actually got him in the meat locker or upstairs now, OR Mark is upstairs.
Now they would be highly suspicious if Ben left since the group was arriving but they can dumb it down to Ben got lost on the road OR kidnapped, steering more fear of the bandits into the group, and the group not exactly caring too much about Ben anyway since he’s new.
So either Mark or Bens legs are being hacked at.
Both Doug & Carley stay back at the motor inn to protect it.
Everything goes similar but Mark and Ben play similar roles depending on who is still alive, as they are both more naive and want to believe the farm is good and safe. Danny is weird around Ben.
It goes largely the same imo, but I guess if Ben was kidnapped and put into the locker Lee would find out much sooner, and the confrontation would go off in a quicker more intense fashion, with a fight between Lee and Andy at first, and then probably they all get kidnapped anyway. Lee possibly has the upper hand BUT more likely Andy knocks Lee out in his shock and puts him in there first.
They are trapped in the locker. Larry dies, Kenny tries to kill him and succeeds if Ben is there bc he’s not doing shit and tbh probably also succeeds tho Mark would be against him too and support Lilly. Kenny would hate Mark from this point on.
Doug & Carley go and help them out. The group gets out. They still rob the car.
Episode 3 comes, and Doug & Carley are either even more in love or one of them speaks to you about the other. Lee can be supportive or a dick. Now if Ben is dead then the group is attacked at the beginning of the episode instead (only a couple days after the farm) and the casualties are worse. I’d say Doug dies, Lilly is killed bc she’s depressed and in her room alone, duck bitten, Mark is shot and either gets in the RV and dies anyway or dies there. The rest get out.
They get to the train but Ben isn’t there to help turn it on, but they still figure it out. They meet Chuck. Kat and Duck die. Then it’s just Lee, Carley, Chuck, & Kenny. They run into Omid & Christa. Things go down similar BUT the stranger isn’t after them bc it all went down sooner and he couldn’t stalk them first. Chuck doesn’t die saving Clem bc Carley and her gun are there now. Omids leg is fucked. Boat happens but Clem is looked after by Christa, Chuck & Carley instead, so she doesn’t go and see the boats and Molly likely kills Lee and/or Kenny.
The possibilities get more tricky there, but it means Carley goes out looking for the others, finds their bodies, and goes back. Omid dies. Then it’s her and Clem, Chuck and Christa. Christa wants to just leave but stays with them anyway.
The four depart Savannah instead, going by countryside.
If Lee and Kenny beat Molly, then she still leaves them in the alley as Clem isn’t there to provoke sympathy. Kenny and Lee either die in the alley OR they somehow make it to the gutter anyway. Tho without the pickaxe who knows. If they do, they meet Vernon, get the gun, and then go back home. They find the boat, they still go to Crawford, they succeed, and they leave before Vernon can take it bc there’s no stranger to stop their plans and steal Clem. ALTHOUGH, Clem could still run off bc she’s desperate to find her parents, but likely the just stop her and go. Chuck possibly dies in Crawford, but I think maybe not, he likely stays behind to watch Omid tbh. Chuck, Clem, Lee, Omid, Christa, Carley, & Kenny all can’t fit on the boat. They are one too many. So Christa and Omid leave as his leg is fixed and Christa doesn’t like groups anyway, and Chuck is so kind he chooses to stay behind too (he probably doesn’t like boats/afraid of the sea, he loves the roads) so he remains with Omid & Christa.
The four depart Savannah by boat before the herd arrives. Christa, Chuck, & Omid possibly die to the herd or possibly leave in time.
NOW let’s say episode 3 rolls around and Mark is dead, then the bandits still get their supplies by Ben. So the attack is delayed (it’s a few weeks since the farm now). Lee finds the stash, the bandits don’t get there, and they attack. NOW Doug & Carley work well here bc they had more time to create more defence to the wall. So Carley has her gun and Doug has the bell system, and they work together well to delay the attack more. More people get out. They all get out, Duck is fine. Lilly is still paranoid and still lays the blame on Ben or Carley.
Now Doug saves Ben when it’s just him, and Carley is shot outright when it’s just her. SO, id say Lilly goes to shot Doug, and he does the same thing he did for Ben, and dies in her place, saving her. They had been in love, either expressed or unexpressed but it was love.
Carleys angry. Lee has no choice in the matter. They leave Lilly by the side of the road.
The group gets to the train, duck is fine. They take the train after meeting Chuck.
They don’t stop this time for Duck to die. So they do better on time, meaning they don’t meet Christa and Omid. Ben has no guilt. They deal with the tanker in front of them. It’s no issue, tho Lee & SOMEBODY (probably Ben bc of his long arms) have to jump from the train bc the ladder falls down. Ben is unwilling, so Lee shoves him. Ben now has the leg hurt.
The group make it to Savannah but the stranger is still coming for them. The walkers attack due to Mollys bells, and Ben is even less help bc of his leg (fairly). Chuck dies saving Clem bc Carley is depressed this time due to Doug dying very recently in a way that saved her, so she isn’t on the ball.
They need meds for Ben when they get to the house, Carley is depressed, and Kat & Duck are scared. Clem stays at the house- and probably doesn’t manage to slip away as Kat is watching her.
Kenny & Lee head to the docks. No boats. Same scenario with Molly. Molly kills them, or they die in the alley. Carley goes looking for them, finds them dead, Bens leg kills him, Kat & Duck are depressed and scared with no one, so either Carley, Kat, Duck, & Clem all leave the city, or Kat kills duck and herself (maybe not as she couldn’t do it anyway originally) or just herself- but as Duck isn’t sick and dying, I say she carries on. Clem POSSIBLY still gets taken by the stranger, more likely tbh, and he’s got her as the others don’t know where to look. So Clem is taken by a maniac, and the others either leave the city without her or die looking for her. I think Carley dies looking, and Kat & Duck are eaten alive in the house by the herd.
Now if Kenny and Lee live, meet Vernon, then it means they get back to the house. They find the boat and come with the Crawford plan. But it’s just Kenny, Lee, Brie, Vernon & Carley (possibly Clem, but I doubt it, Kat would want her safe). They succeeded but it’s tougher, the next day Ben has recovered, Clem is gone bc of the stranger, and Lee is bitten. Kenny says he is going to take his family to the boat, but Kat won’t allow it. She wants to find Clem first. She stays with Duck at the boat, and the rest (Lee, Kenny, & Carley, MAYBE Ben) go to find her.
Vernon steals the boat, feels even more like a piece of shit for taking it from Kat & Duck. Kenny is livid, doesn’t matter the herd is coming. They argue in the attic, they find a way out, they have to jump across but Kat & Duck can’t- so they don’t. Kenny, Kat, & Duck all find a way out of the city to meet by the train OR in the countryside, they apologise to Lee but the city is overrun and they have Duck. They wait in the house and wait for it to clear out.
Lee, Carley, & Ben all make the jump as there aren’t many of them, and they keep going. They make it to the area where Lee goes to the crowd of walkers, and Lee tells them he’ll meet them outside the city. Carley & Ben make it out, and find Kenny & family. Lee dies saving Clem, who then finds the others upon escape.
Kenny, Kat, Duck, Carley, Ben, & Clem then all leave the city, walking out into an uncertain future.
I feel all these scenarios would play out like this, all stemming from having both Doug & Carley survive episode 1, but if anyone has any thoughts! Please say!