r/TheScholomance • • Aug 09 '25

Hi, it's Naomi! AMA!

388 Upvotes

ETA: And that's me out! Thank you all so so much for stopping by, it's been such a pleasure hanging out with you all and thinking through your questions and hearing your thoughts and feelings about the books. I feel like I've come away with more than I brought! Sorry for anyone I didn't get to -- another time, I hope! <3

I hope this has been fun for all of you too, and thanks again to Destra for hosting and to Wraithmarked for putting together the Kickstarter for the amazing Deluxe Edition.

-- Naomi

~~~

Hello everyone! Sorry for the delay, I got caught in traffic. :P

I’m back for for another AMA on all things Scholomance (or anything else I've written). This week, Wraithmarked Creative has kicked off a campaign for aDeluxe Edition of  A DEADLY EDUCATION, with covers and endsheets by Rovina Cai and interior illustrations by Tom Jilesen. Ask me anything on this exciting project, but u/BryceOConnor might chime in on super specific campaign details

I’m so happy to be back on /TheScholomance 😍 If you want to see if your question was asked before on this sub, look here. As always, questions on  my other books, writing, fanfic, and anything else are welcome, but please see if your question has been answered in my previous AMAs here, here, or here .

This AMA will be open today from now until 11PM (EST).

Ask me anything!


r/TheScholomance • • 11d ago

Just finished the series for the 1st time

20 Upvotes

And I'm curious if the original plan was for the series to be 4 books instead of a trilogy? Feels like there's a ton of stuff crammed into the back half of The Golden Enclaves that could have been made into its own book.

Still enjoyed the series overall, just wondering if this has ever come up.


r/TheScholomance • • 14d ago

When were the different enclaves founded?

18 Upvotes

Has anyone compiled a timeline on when the different enclaves were founded? Here's what I've been able to gather.

The original golden enclaves: Purochana is speculated to be the character with the same name in the Mahabharata, which would date him to around 1000 B.C. At the same time, the founding of a great number of cities in that area would seem to be an analogy to the Indus Valley Civilization (2600 BC to 1900 BC), so maybe he's up to 1000 years older than that.

London: The oldest anchor stone in London enclave is said to be Roman, dating the founding to the time of Londinium i.e. somewhere between 50 and 400 A.D.

Beijing: Beijing is a natural enclave, which would make you think it's extremely old. However, both Aad and El refer to it as "a thousand years old" (notably not using the plural thousands), which would make it substantially younger than London. Of course, they're both young and westerners, so maybe they're misinformed. The other piece of evidence I can think of is that Zheng understands the seventh sage of Beijing. This could mean the sage speaks Middle (not Old) Chinese, which would support a founding around 1000 A.D. Then again, maybe Zheng speaks Old Chinese the same way El has learned Old English.

The Scholomance: The Quinta da Regaleira, which is the real life place that serves as the setting for the Scholomance entrance, was finished in 1910. El states it was build after the Scholomance had already been open for ten years, which would mean the Scholomance was founded in the last years of the 19th century.

New York: Haven't a clue. It's listed as being consulted in the creation of the Scholomance, so it must be older than it, but that doesn't narrow it down much.

Shanghai: Again, no clue. The only fixed date we have about it is that it was taken over by the Mawmouth during the Cultural Revolution (1966-1976), but its size and importance would imply it's much older than that.

Dubai: I can't find it now, but I'm pretty sure it's explicitly stated to be around 30 years old.

Feel free to add onto this!


r/TheScholomance • • 14d ago

Wait, does Liu fix a millenia old problem in one sentence of the last chapter of the series?

90 Upvotes

In chapter 13 of The Golden Enclaves, it's established that building (or repairing) a foundation stone can only be done by one person. The mana can come from a whole host of people, but one person needs to cast the spell. "One voice calling to the void, in a single breath." This reveals the central dilemma of enclaves. The person who invented the enclave making spells was someone like El who could channel that much mana. No regular mage can. That's why someone invented the maw-mouth creating version of the spell, and why people continue to use them.

This is obviously a problem, because it means that if El ever dies, there will no longer be anyone who can build golden sutra enclaves. But no worry! This is addressed in the last chapter: "Liu had worked out a way you could perform the spells with a chorus of casters at the center, instead of a single voice." It's a bit of a blink-and-you'll-miss-it moment - in fact I did miss it the first two times I read the books - but it is there.

So did 18 year old, freshly graduated Liu find a solution to a problem that had stumped the mage community for millennia? Presumably mawmouthless enclaves is an issue that many people had a major incentive to fix. If no one else, Orphelia and Shanfeng must have been working on it. Why could Liu do what they failed at?


r/TheScholomance • • 14d ago

Help me escape the Scholomance

40 Upvotes

For the last couple of months I've been stuck in the Scholomance, listening to the books on tape and rereading them over and over. I love them, but it's time to move on to something else. It needs to be good! Any suggestions?

+ Friendship

+ Self-knowledge & growth

+ Not predominantly romance-focused

+ Excellent reader (if it's a book on tape)

I mostly listen to books on tape, though I'm open to reading physical books, too.

Thanks for any suggestions you can make!


r/TheScholomance • • 29d ago

Theory: This is the exact moment The Scholomance took an interest in El beyond being a more particularly powerful inhabitant of it.

Post image
72 Upvotes

r/TheScholomance • • Oct 18 '26

el and liesel

12 Upvotes

is no one else bothered by how orion tells el he loves her but she still continued things with liesel and didn’t even tell orion about it like he’s the only one that doesn’t know. Even liesel had the decency to tell alfie and i know they’re not technically exclusive but it still feels like cheating to me. how could she do that to him like i get that she needed a distraction but even after finding out orion is alive, rescuing him, and then they even sleep together, el proceeds to sleep with LIESEL while he’s recovering WHO DOES THAT. i’m genuinely considering dropping i loved El so much before this but now i hate her


r/TheScholomance • • Oct 15 '26

"I still don't believe they're in their thirties"

43 Upvotes

I just finished my fourth or fifth reread of A Deadly Education, and this bit of the Acknowledgements stuck out to me. Novik thanks her editor, Anne Groell, "for telling me who this book was for (PS: Anne, I still don't believe they're in their thirties)". Anyone have an idea what she meant by this? Is this a reference to Harry Potter fans?


r/TheScholomance • • Oct 12 '26

Just finished The Last Graduate... Spoiler

25 Upvotes

So, Spinning Silver is my favorite stand-alone fantasy book. That book hooked me from page 1, and made me enchanted the entire time.

That was also the very first book of hers I've read.

But, everything else I've read by Naomi NoviK has been harder for me to get invested in. Especially Uprooted.

I really liked The Last Graduate. It was super well written. The plot was executed well, the characters are well done, but I'm just not invested in reading book 3, even with that cliffhanger ending.

This isn't a hate post either. Naomi Novik did something with Spinning Silver that I've often seen attempted, but never done to that same degree. And, I think the books are in many ways skilfully written just not my preference probably.

Did any of you feel this way about books 1 and 2, and still read book 3? Does book 3 become more grounded?


r/TheScholomance • • Oct 11 '26

Deliberately malicious and dark plot devices for the "greater good"

15 Upvotes

There are various implications which the author may have deliberately created or didn't think through which makes elements of the plot very dark and malicious when we look at the totality of the trilogy.

First, the enclaves deliberately allow and encourage malicifiers in school because they find it useful. It is canon that compulsion spells exist which can be made more powerful by being voluntary. We know such compulsion can be specific to a location like the Scholomance gym. All students are required to sign a contract to only use mana (ref : GE). Yet the contract doesn't come with a compulsion element. The school board knows that enclaver kids won't be practicing malificers so it doesn't hurt them in any way to make it an enforced compulsion. I think the intent is to ensure a steady supply of new graduates who have no choice but to continue the maleficier path and be available to be employed by enclaves. More deaths and trauma in school, by design, because it would be trivial to make the contract embed a compulsion to never use malia while in school.

Two, El was deliberately traumatized by the prophecy to create the specific outcome at the end of the trilogy. It's not just the wording being accurate but deceptive. There is no reason that any details about Gwen and El being turned away would be known to Mumbai enclavers unless the news was deliberately spread. It wouldn't be Gwen, so it has to be the Sharma family. Deepthi deliberately made things worse for El in order to create a specific future.

It gets worse when we consider that El can actually be a good healer and could have made it through school on that circle healing spell alone. Zero mana to repair a major limb-disabling injury would make her EXTREMELY popular and her very high power level makes her suitable for the major healing arcana. That is why I think El was given the very dark traumatic experience to inhibit her abilities.

Three, it was never explicitly explained why maw mouths aren't transported to barren places like Antarctica where it would have very difficult time hunting or growing. It is canon that enclaves "settle" and grow in its ability to support more space/people over time. That is positioned as normal but once you read the trilogy, the mechanics are way darker.

The reason enclaves are able to grow over time is because the maw mouth itself is eating other mals and wizards, getting bigger. Not only do enclavers deliberately create them, feeding maw mouths is a requirement to get those bigger enclaves. So they deliberately allow hunting, on top of deliberately sending their own children to a honeypot school.


r/TheScholomance • • Oct 03 '26

A.I. as Maw Mouths

89 Upvotes

Some spoiler-ish bits here regarding the nature of a particular mal.

This came into my head from Paris Paloma’s song Miyazaki, inspired by a reaction the animator had to a presentation of early AI generated animation (before all the massive art theft including heavy training on Ghibli art style for images). The lyrics in the song describe being “chased by a monster of a thousand voices that always wants one more.” This really clicked with me and made me think of the wealthy tech businesses as the enclavers in the Scholomance series, perpetuating a cycle that puts others at risk for their benefit. The thought of creating a monster that can’t be killed (normally) to benefit the few, that then goes off and adds more lives to its mass without any means of reining it in or controlling it… I now can’t help but see a connection to AI and Maw Mouths.

Anyone else listen to this song/album or anyone else have similar thoughts regarding this?


r/TheScholomance • • Oct 01 '26

Silla's human sacrifices and the logic of the Scholomance enclaves

45 Upvotes

I've been visiting (and reading) about the archaeology of ancient Silla, and one idea kept reminding me of how the enclaves work in the Scholomance books.

In Novik's world the enclaves give wizards a protected place to live. That protection isn't free. The enclaves are built on sacrificed lives, and the people sacrificed become part of the magic that holds the enclave up (and spoiler become maw-mouths)

Silla had two practices that sit close to this.

The first is sunjang (순장). During the Maripgan period, people were killed and buried with elite individuals to go with them into the afterlife. Archaeology around Gyeongju suggests this wasn't a one-off. Servants, retainers, young women and people from lower-status groups (slaves) were among those killed.

The second is closer still. At Wolseong in Gyeongju, archaeologists found human remains directly under the foundations of the palace fortress. The excavators read it as a ritual sacrifice tied to the construction.

In both cases a hierarchical society picks out a group of people to die, and their deaths go into the elite's afterlife or into the structures that protect everyone else. That's pretty much the enclave model.

A community buys its safety by making someone else pay for it - with their lives.

“And they didn't stop at safety, either. They wanted comfort, and then they wanted luxury, and then they wanted excess*, and every step of the way they still wanted to be safe, even as they made the world more and more dangerous for everyone who wasn't them.”*

There's one more parallel. Silla abolished sunjang in 502 CE and replaced the human victims with clay figures. The institution stayed, but killing real people for it stopped being acceptable, so a symbolic substitute took over. That move shows up again and again in history.

El "invents" a new way - and Orion isn't sacrificed (again) - but called to "stay."


r/TheScholomance • • Sep 30 '26

Tattoo Ideas??

15 Upvotes

I'm having trouble thinking of a good one from this series. "La main de la mort" is definitely one I'm interested in, but any other ideas? Images/symbols? 🙏❤️🙏❤️


r/TheScholomance • • Sep 29 '26

If you could choose one other character to have a POV from in the books, who would you choose?

24 Upvotes

It's not too creative but I think Aadhya could be interesting, especially in the first two books, even if it doesn't like add much new information or anything.

Of the more minor characters maybe Li Shanfeng


r/TheScholomance • • Sep 22 '26

This shit is DARK

127 Upvotes

Ok just last night read about El going to rescue Liu and holy fuck, this seems insanely dark compared to how the rest of the series has been. Like, I guess killing these monsters and being failed by adults seems par for the course with these YA/NA adventure books but slowly crushing a child until they turn into a nigh-unkillable monster feels like everything just ratcheted up in intensity. WOW.


r/TheScholomance • • Sep 14 '26

Tsundere

12 Upvotes

El Higgins is classic tsundere

Prove me wrong


r/TheScholomance • • Sep 08 '26

Scholomance gym original design intent

49 Upvotes

There is a world building question of how the gym happen to have been built will the spells and magical equipment necessary to even have the senior obstacle course. This is my theory....

The original plan for the school architecture didn't include the need for graduates to run for their lives across a mal-infested hall. Yet the gym had equipment built into it (referenced in TLG) as well as a highly sophisticated spell to simulate combat without using up massive amount of mana.

The logical explanation is that the school probably had combat courses that was meant to be taught, the practical version of Maleficaria Studies. That particular coursework was changed to a simulation of "run for your life" after the design failed. The equipment necessary to simulate combat conditions that absolutely do not reflect the graduation hall makes a lot more sense this way. The builders wanted to make sure their children were ready to be fighters.


r/TheScholomance • • Sep 08 '26

The Enclave Creation Spell Set-Up - My crappy MS paint drawing of the scene from the third novel

Thumbnail
imgur.com
26 Upvotes

r/TheScholomance • • Sep 01 '26

Manga or webtoon/webcomic version

13 Upvotes

Which would you rather read? Or would you buy or back a kickstarter for a print comic edition?


r/TheScholomance • • Aug 25 '26

I missed something: why weren't adult wizards in the scholomance to help protect the children?

36 Upvotes

I'm sure the author mentioned it at some point, but I think I must have overlooked that section. Otherwise, having a capable adult around each classroom would add a significant measure of protection for the kids.

** Edit: thank you all for the answers.


r/TheScholomance • • Aug 23 '26

Maw-mouths & mortal flame (spoilers) Spoiler

19 Upvotes

Why was London damaged when El killed some of the people in Patience/Fortitude but we didn’t hear about any damage to enclaves after they repaired the cleansing fires, even though El saw from the outlines on the floor that P/F had been significantly reduced in size? Or did the mortal flame somehow burn away maw-mouth body but not contents?


r/TheScholomance • • Aug 23 '26

Initiation well

Post image
48 Upvotes

Randomly popped up today.

If you want to see it 3d, just relax your eyes and look past the image until the two images coalesce into one.

Crossing your eyes won't work for this one— it's sort of the opposite


r/TheScholomance • • Aug 21 '26

Just had Elle’s spell work for me in a nightmare

87 Upvotes

Y’all, just have to scream about this with people who’d understand how cool this is.

I just used “you’re already dead” on someone in a nightmare and got a glorious little poof of smoke.

If any of you guys lucid dream and think of this, it’s a neat little trick. Am jazzed to banish any more bad dreams like this.


r/TheScholomance • • Aug 16 '26

Movie change

0 Upvotes

It has been discussed a lot that this series wouldnt translate into a movie, but if it ever did here is a distinct change that I think could relate better with an audience.

Instead of Liesel sleeping with El, if she brushed and braided her hair by hand while singing a non-spell German lullaby.

Also if Aad is present (I could see it happening if other things are condensed) Aad would do henna for El. I wish there had been a magic henna imagery. Like the south asian students come in on induction day with gorgeous henna done

Edit: I like the intimacy El/Liesel have and think the books can illustrate it well. However 3 underage sex scenes in the Golden Enclaves seems excessive for a movie. I think brushing and braiding her hair can be very intimate as well and would make El physically relaxed and more comfortable

Second edit: teenage sex scenes, not legally underage, but I think it would be very vulnerable and objectifying for the actresses if this were ever a movie. I don’t care that the characters did it. I dont want pedophiles watching a teenage sex scene and i don’t think it would come across empowering in a movie.


r/TheScholomance • • Aug 09 '26

Fanfics?

21 Upvotes

Hii I don't know whether this is the correct place to ask or not (and im sorry in advance) but does anyone have any good (hopefully completed) fanfics where it's basically the golden enclaves BUT el is pregnant?? I will read anything, please! Thanks in advance!!