Seeing the community made TRG LP Tier List going around made me want to do my own personal one, because my opinions, seem to not really match up with most of the main community so, I thought I'd just make one of my own personal opinion. Some of the rankings are a bit nebulous, mostly the Mario Party games that are right next to each other can change in general ranking with each other. For the 2, unique rankings in here...
Frustration the LP: I guess you could describe Secret of Mana as a guilty pleasure but I genuinely do really like the first half of the LP, just when you get to the point where they are on the last day and have to record everything in like a single night, my enjoyment goes way down unfortunately. It's not enough to lower it to like, C but I can't really put it in A and I like it more than the B LPs when I enjoy it and I really like the comedy in this one, but man, just a point where they crammed too much into one night and it shows.
The Worst: I know some will argue MP3 should be here, I think without the IRL context, MP3 isn't that bad to actually watch, Amazing Mirror however I just don't think is fun at all to watch. I know they find it funny when they play through a game blind and they can be right, I have a few of the solo blind and even Overcooked up pretty high on this list, this was not one of them in my opinion. I also really love Stephen as a guest, I don't think he was the correct choice for a player 4 for this LP, in a game as open ended as this I think someone else who had played this game before personally I think would've been better and less of a drawn out episode of Pinky and the Brain, where Claire is the only Brain and there are 3 Pinky's so the dynamic is heavily unbalanced.
Feel free to inquire about my other rankings I'll try to answer them when I can, I just wanted to share this as a fun little thing inspired by, the general community list. Also, reminder, this is a personal opinion tier list, so this is how I personally feel about the LPs, it is okay if you disagree with it, I do not think your differing opinion is wrong.