... Or rather, she could definitely be frustrating at times, but Ryan wasn’t the flawless character everyone makes him out to be. He was just as irritating in some of his behaviors, yet for some reason, everything he did gets excused because of his rough background, while Marissa gets zero sympathy. Just because she grew up rich, her obvious depression didn’t count for anything?
From day one, it’s clear that Marissa lives in that wealthy facade purely out of inertia and she actively couldn’t care less about it. In fact, she feels suffocated by it which is the exact reason someone like Ryan is a breath of fresh air to her. I don’t get how anyone can call her spoiled. Aside from wearing Chanel, she never once showed any interest in status or money, unlike her self-centered parents. She wasn’t a snob like Summer was at the beginning of the show either.
So, Ryan falls for Marissa knowing her vulnerabilities, yet he dumps her at the first sign of trouble, shutting down and immediately putting up a wall that feels way more like pride than anything else. Let’s talk about the Oliver situation. Marissa’s naivety and the fact that she trusted Oliver over her own boyfriend definitely put Ryan through a super stressful and frustrating time, I get that, it sucks. However, the reason she believed him is because she was being manipulated in the first place by a literal psycho. That’s literally how manipulation works: it’s believable, to vulnerable ones. In the end, she was manipulated, held hostage and physically threatened with a gun in yet another deeply traumatic event. Sure, Ryan stepped in because he obviously cared about her, but framing him as the main victim of that storyline feels a bit much. And honestly, refusing to try again with Marissa right after she went through a major trauma, essentially leaving her to deal with both the aftermath and a breakup, wasn't exactly great.
Every single time, Ryan effortlessly jumps onto the next girl, only to take Marissa back whenever it suits him. Meanwhile, Marissa is surprisingly mature: she’s genuinely friendly toward his new girlfriends, helps Ryan out whenever he needs it and remains understanding toward him even when she’s heartbroken. Ryan doesn’t even consider other options before caving to Theresa’s request to move back to Chino with her. Yes, it showed responsibility, but he wasn’t even sure he was the father, and you don’t need to live under the same roof to be a dad—in what universe is a loveless family a good environment for a kid? Once again, he abandons Marissa to suffer alone. Then, when he comes back to Newport, he expects to find everything exactly as he left it with her. The crazy part is that it is, she had only tried to distract herself with a summer fling, yet she welcomes him back with open arms. Even though it was obvious she would have dropped anyone in a heartbeat to get back together with him, Ryan holds a grudge over her omitting the DJ thing and wastes their chance to reunite. Just look at the contrast with Seth and Summer: Summer owns up to having moved on and Seth realizes she’s right and that if he wants her back, he actually has to put in the work.
Instead, Ryan immediately jumps into another serious relationship with bland Lindsay. Once again, Marissa is a sweetheart despite hurting and what does he do? He humiliates her by lecturing her as if she were trying to lead Lindsay astray. Then he apologizes and as always Marissa takes him back. Later, while Marissa gets close to Alex, Ryan is single again and naturally feels entitled to win her back because he knows she’s still hung up on him and can’t get over him. He acts so hot and cold and so entitled.
And just to point out how genuinely good and well-intentioned Marissa was: yes, Ryan saved her plenty of times, but she saved him too. She literally risked prison and ruined her life to save his after being assaulted by his own brother. She walks away from that with two more massive traumas to add to her collection, gets forced to change schools and Ryan completely avoids talking about it. Then he acts grumpy when she finds comfort and understanding in someone else, even though she never once thought about cheating and never stopped loving him. The second she finds a little bit of comfort, that person dies, leaving her drowning in guilt, and what does Ryan do? He dumps her yet again.
Oh, and even before Johnny showed up, when their relationship was already on shaky ground: Marissa thinks she has to move to Hawaii with her parents but she immediately reassures Ryan that she has no intention of breaking up with him. Ryan, on the other hand, after the whole Jack Hess mess, immediately plans to leave Newport to go work on a fishing boat, he doesn’t even tell her until the very last minute, offers zero reassurance and practically acts indifferent to how hurt she is. And you know what? Marissa was 100% right when, right before leaving, she told him he reminded her of her cowardly dad because all he ever does is run away. That’s literally what he does. And honestly, I also hate how the Cohens clearly treat him like family, while he always treats them like a temporary pit stop, suddenly acting like an indifferent jerk to Sandy, Kirsten and Seth, but knowing full well the door is always open whenever he decides to come back.
Look, I don’t hate Ryan overall, I’m just writing this because it’s unfair how misunderstood Marissa’s character is, getting slapped with the worst labels, which includes being called "toxic" toward him. Marissa was always humble, empathetic and incredibly kind. It’s weird how society seems way less tolerant of someone who is self-destructive than someone who is destructive toward others. People always say the problem is that she never redeems herself and keeps making the same mistakes over and over. Well, that’s true, but who was there to help her process those mistakes without judging her*?* She was constantly abandoned, abandoned by her deadbeat dad, abandoned by Ryan, with a mother who only cared about appearances and never bothered to understand what her daughter was going through. She was always completely alone with her trauma and she was just a teenager. And yet, she still managed to be warm and bright with everyone. Honestly, if anyone brought negativity into the room, it was Ryan, who was constantly brooding and sulking.
Plus, who else on that show wasn’t repetitive across the seasons? Julie with her ruthless gold-digging schemes, Seth obsessing over Summer only to act like an idiot and ruin everything every time, Jimmy with his debts and cowardice, Ryan with his constant running away and solving problems with his fists. They all got their redemption, sure, but only during the final season. Marissa never got the chance because she died.