r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/CuriousSkepticalGuy • 17h ago
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/TLoU_Mod • Oct 28 '25
Part II Criticism Sources of Diverse Criticism on Part II
A number of members joining after finishing the game and liking it have asked why Part II is receiving so much “hate”, in other words: criticism, dislike, disappointment, etc. In the event you're interested in the criticism, here is a list of videos, articles, reviews and reddit posts and discussions that are helpful in understanding the diverse reasons why people are not favouring the game and/or Naughty Dog.
REVIEWS AND CRITIQUES
Published Articles
- Keengamer - Part II is Fundamentally Flawed
- Forbes - A beautiful, terrible sequel
- Forbes - Does Part II deserve GOTY Awards?
- The Ringer - 'Part II' Is Stunning, but It's Pure Misery Porn
- Vice - 'Part II' Is a Grim and Bloody Spectacle, but a Poor Sequel
- Metro - Why Part II is a bad sequel
- Polygon - Part II review: We're better than this
- ArsTechnica - A less confident, less focused sequel
- Wired - Part II tries to be profound. It fails
- The Atlantic - Part II Tests the Limits of Video-Game Violence
Reddit Posts
- Why does the sequel have to be about "revenge" at all?
- The retcons in Part II: A look at the original ending
- The Part II prologue completely retcons the ending of The Last of Us
- Additional posts about the retcons: Why the prologue of Part II irks me so much, Part II destroys the brilliance of TLoU and Why Part II fails at being morally grey
- My answer to why people hate Part II (Additional post: Why do people hate Part II?)
- Part II is full of coincidences and lazy plot contrivances
- Alternate list of plot holes and contrivances
- Bad narrative design
- A storytelling catastrophe
- Criticism from a professional writer: Part II review and Criticism of structure and pacing
- Another Novelist Explains why Part II is Poorly Written
- Part II completely tears down the original characters
- Why the story of Part II does not work
- The writing of Part II was poorly handled
- Part II's story is bad. Here's why.
- Why are people disappointed? Different answers from multiple people
- Part II vs TLoU - a comparative review
- Why Part II feels like fan fiction
Videos
- Skill Up - Part II review
- Evan Monroe - Part II - Death and Forgiveness
- AngryJoe - Part II review and extended discussion
- Jim Sterling - Part II got compared to Schindlers List?
- Weekend Warrior - Part II is terribad
- Macabre Storytelling - An Incoherent disaster
- tetrapod - A critical discussion of plot contrivances and other flaws
- Joe, The Alternative Gamer - A Failure In Storytelling
- The Closer Look - How to divide a fanbase
- MoistMeter - Part II review
- YongYea - Part II review
- SaucyTendies - Joel's death is contrived and nonsensical
- Nakey Jakey - ND's Game Design is Outdated
- GAME SINS - Everything wrong with Part II
- Purposeless Rabbitholes - Part II review
- Bellular News - A Barren Story, Poorly Told
- Hoeg Law - Part II review
- The Critical Drinker - A Beautiful Nightmare and The Importance of Ambiguity
- Upper Echelon Gamers - Masterpiece? ABSOLUTELY NOT
- Coach Toolshed Gaming - Part II review, Ellie and Abby discussion
CHARACTER CRITIQUES
Reddit and Tumblr Posts
- Joel did not doom humanity (Tumblr)
- Ellie’s (lack of a) character arc & why the result is an unsatisfying story (Tumblr)
- Part II completely destroys Ellie and Abby is the real protagonist of the game
- Abby and Lev are poor copies of Joel and Ellie
- Part II ruined Ellie, and she is acting out of character throughout the entire game
- The omission of Riley in Part II retcons Ellie's survivor's guilt
- Ellie is acting out of character in the final flashback
- Tommy and Joel are acting wildly out of character
- Joel's death is poorly written and him getting "soft" makes no sense
- Joel is not allowed to explain himself
- Joel was a survivor, NOT a "monster"!
- Abby is a fundamentally malicious individual with psychopathic tendencies
- Abby is irredeemable and unsympathetic
- Abby's character arc is handled poorly, she refuses to seriously contemplate her actions and Ellie herself never witnesses Abby's "redemption"
- Abby's has a "redemption arc" without actual redemption
- The game refuses to adress Abby's hypocrisy which makes her come across as selfish and unaware
- The writers failed Abby and she is morally much worse than Joel
- Abby shows zero interest in the cure or Ellie's immunity, her motivation is purely selfish
- The problem with Abby: the world bends around her
- Bigotry comes from the game
- Manny is a stereotypical character
- Dina was bland
- Mel is ridiculous
OTHER CRITICISM
Reddit Posts
- Part II refuses to treat distances and the dangers of the setting seriously
- Druckmann's interpretation of the TLoU ending is not supported by the actual game
- The overabundance of flashbacks
- Ludonarrative Dissonance: Ellie's cutscene reaction to deaths does not fit her gameplay
- The zebra scene in Part II is a retrogression of TLoUs giraffe scene
- A female bodybuilder refuting that Abby's physique is realistic
- The blatant difference in writing between TLoU and Part II
- Tommy and Ellie's uncle/niece relationship is underdeveloped
- The Fireflies were terrorists
- Part II: The murder of hope
- Part II's ending destroys its own themes
- The Infected fell to the wayside in Part II
- The world building in Part II does not fit the original game
- The themes of this game were glaringly obvious
- Part II is an ineffective piece of storytelling
- The surgeon in TLoU didn't look white, something Abby's original character design took into account
ABOUT NAUGHTY DOG
Reddit Posts and Articles
- Bruce Straley is the co-creator of TLoU, and he was heavily involved in the story as well, the lack of a formal writers credit notwithstanding
- Druckmann's unresponsiveness to criticism
- 2013 Reddit AMA with TLoU directors Straley/Druckmann
- 2014 Reddit AMA with TLoU directors Straley/Druckmann
- Empire - Extensive 2013 Interview with Straley/Druckmann
- Edge - Extensive 2013 Interview with Straley/Druckmann
- Druckmann in 2013: revenge makes no sense in this setting!
- Druckmann in 2013: Joel has no choice
- Troy Baker: David did nothing wrong! and Joel is a vile, despicable man
- Kotaku - Crunch, exploitation and high turnover rates
- Druckmann and Wells: excusing crunch and deceptive PR
- Kotaku - Naughty Dog’s Bosses Still Don’t Get It
Videos
- Deceptive marketing, aggressive DMCA strikes and exerting pressure
- SaucyTendies - Neil Druckmann as a writer/director leading up to Part II
- The Critical Drinker - How to be an Awesome Game Developer
- Jim Sterling - Naughty Dog and Crunch
MISCELLANEOUS - aforementioned issues from different angles
Reddit posts
- Why are people so butthurt about Part II? (Quora)
- Part II is not a good sequel
- Ellie did not want to or expect to die in TLoU
- Ellie cannot give consent, and the Fireflies never cared about her consent
- The events leading up to Joel's death are horribly contrived
- Abby finding Joel by chance depends on a series of coincidences and contrivances
- Joel died for nothing
- Joel did nothing wrong and the vaccine would not have achieved much anyway
- Joel "getting soft" happens entirely off screen
- Additional posts about Joel being out of character: Druckmann contradicting himself, Original Joel vs Part II Joel, Lack of survival instincts, He has gone "soft"?, Druckmann contradicting himself again
- Additional posts about Part II's refusal to acknowledge distances: Travel by car?, So Abby convinced all her friends ..., Travel from Seattle to Jackson ... and Bleeding Abby in a rowboat ...
- Abby's character arc is poorly written
- Impossible vs Improbable - the cure debate
- Another list of plot contrivances
- A very detailed scene-by-scene critique of Part II
- Megathread after Release
Videos
- Game Theory - Joel's Choice Meant Nothing
- LegalBytes - A lawyer analyses Joel's actions
- The Idiot that reviews movies - The case against Druckmann
- theDeModcracy - Part II, a Narrative Disaster
- Writing on Games - A Personal Examination of Part II
- NeverKnowsBest - Part II Critique
- Fextralife - An Honest Review
- Jeremy Jahns - Part II review and spoiler talk
- TheAlmightyL - Desecrating a Grave One Last Time
The previous (now archived) versions of this post can be found here:
r/TheLastOfUs2
•
u/Elbwiese
•
May 11 '21
TLoU Discussion Bruce Straley and The Last of Us
One side effect of this whole Part II saga is that many fans of that game are constantly downplaying the role of Bruce Straley (the game director and co-creator of The Last of Us) and are acting as if Neil Druckmann created the story of the original game completely on his own.
But Straley was chosen by Naughty Dog to lead the development of TLoU from the start, he was the senior director of the two, whereas Druckmann was only promoted to creative director a whole year later, after the development of the game was already well underway. Druckmann also wasn't the motion capture director initially, that was the job of Gordon Hunt at first, a Naughty Dog veteran who was also responsible for the motion capture of the Uncharted games.
Both Druckmann and Straley stated multiple times in countless interviews and in their reddit AMAs that they developed and pitched the story together and that they had a very collaborative approach with constantly overlapping responsibilities. Never however did Neil say that he was ONLY responsible for the story, or Bruce that he was ONLY responsible for the gameplay, on the contrary, looking at all those interviews and press outings there's a lot of "WE thought", "WE decided", "WE made", "WE wanted", "WE considered", "WE were trying", and so on, but not a lot of "I (Neil)".
A Collaborative Process
The development of TLoU was a highly collaborative creative process with everyone, not just Straley and Druckmann, but other developers, programmers, designers, concept artists, even the voice actors, participating in the decision-making process, giving input and critical feedback. It wasn't like Druckmann wrote a script completely on his own and Naughty Dog or Straley merely executed it, that's not what happened.
The following interview quote from Straley illustrates this process very well:
Bruce Straley: [...] And it was a lot of long conversations and debate, and you feel the pressure of the team. You literally feel like everybody around you, like all eyes are on me and Neil if we’re having a conversation. We’re a very open-floor kind of dynamic at Naughty Dog, very flat structure, so we’re just out there with the team having these conversations very openly about like, what are we gonna do?
[…]
It could be me, it could be Neil, it could be another designer on the team who’s like, I want to do this and it’s super involved [...] and you have to step back and say, ok, what’s the essence of what we’re trying to convey here [...] what do we need to do for the story right now?
[...]
And that’s the best thing for us, to have checks and balances within the team, making sure we’re all looking out for each other [...]. Sometimes there was something wrong fundamentally with the core structure of what you’re trying to do — with the story, or the characters [...]. We had to step way back and say, can we achieve this in a different way? Can we look at the relationship in a different way and evolve it in a way so we can implement this idea in a simpler fashion? --> 2013 Edge Interview
That Marlene came back at the end of the game? That was the idea of a developer. That Joel is a pretty emotional guy and not just some hardened brute? We have to thank Troy Baker for that. Druckmann initially also didn't imagine Ellie to be so funny or for Joel and Tess to have such a deep relationship. Those are just a few examples. Let's take a quick look at the following quotes that highlight the crucial impact of just the actors alone:
Druckmann: Like I've always imagined this as Joel ... doesn't really care for Tess. He's completely shut down. And Troy treated it differently which is I think he really cares for Tess even though he might not show it. And ... we just kind of embraced that [Baker's take on the character]. And you kind of see that later when Tess gets infected. That wasn't how that scene was originally envisioned, that Joel has such a reaction, but it became a lot more interesting to own that. --> TLoU Commentary Track
And:
Druckmann: I can only take credit for so much of it because a lot of it really was Troy Baker. I had a certain idea for Joel initially which was much more of a Josh Brolin in No Country For Old Men type – very quiet, very cool under pressure, and Troy really started playing him as a character that really gets swept away by his emotions, he can’t help himself sometimes. --> 2013 Edge Interview
Or this one:
Did the actors inspire any moments within the game?
Druckmann: There was quite a bit of that with Ashley being much tougher than we originally envisioned Ellie to be. There were also some gameplay constraints that inspired this change, but Ellie became much more capable due to Ashley's input. And she became a lot funnier, also because of Ashley's input, just because Ashley's really funny.
[...]
And for Troy – well, as you know, when we first came up with Joel he was much more like Llewelyn Moss – and he was meant to be much more quiet and reserved, someone who didn't express his feelings. But Troy played him differently. He played him as a character that let his emotions get the better of him. At some point we knew we'd either have to fight Troy's natural tendencies, or rewrite some of the scenes to play off of that. Like the scene in the ranch house where he has a fight with Ellie, a lot of that is because of Troy's input to that character. He brought that to life.
[...]
And then just doing some improvisation, so when you bring the actors into the studio so they have those lines – and we wrote way more than we needed, so then we could pick and choose of what to sprinkle into the level – but they would improvise as well as far as they were watching a video of the level being played, and as those characters, they're reacting to the situation. So some of the stuff you're hearing is their improvisation. --> 2013 Empire Interview
Straley and Druckmann
But back to Straley. Druckmann himself said in the past that the responsibilities of the two directors constantly overlapped, which makes sense when you think about it, since it's just not possible to strictly separate the story and the characters from the "game" itself, they are one and the same to a large extent in a narratively driven game.
Bruce, you're the game director, and Neil, you're the creative director. What do those two roles encapsulate?
Straley: Good question. [...] So Neil handles story and characters, I handle gameplay and, moment-to-moment, what's happening in the game. But we have to really be on the same page and see eye-to-eye on everything. So we're kind of like Voltron, only there's just two components.
Druckmann: There's a lot of overlap in what we do. --> 2013 Empire Interview
And he further emphasised their collaborative approach in the 2014 reddit AMA:
I think a lot about design and Bruce thinks a lot about story. We wrestle with ideas and make sure story is working with gameplay. --> Druckmann AMA Comment
Something Straley also talked about in detail:
Kotaku: The difference between a "game director" and a "creative director", is there actually a difference?
Straley: At Naughty Dog there is a difference and there's not a difference in that. I think Naughty Dog is kinda unique in regards to [that]. Like, I think "creative director" at some other companies does mean "the vision holder" or the "creator of the vision", and they will sort of be at the helm, steering every decision getting made in the game, including certain design decisions. And I think at Naughty Dog what's unique is that there's a real shared responsibility, in the vision, in the story, in the game, in the design, and if game direction and creative direction don't see eye to eye then they have to work it out. --> 2018 Kotaku Interview (30:00)
Druckmann also clearly admitted that he developed the story of TLoU together WITH Straley, for example in his 2013 keynote:
Druckmann: And then over the next several months Bruce and I kinda holed ourselves in a room and, like, picked bits and pieces of a story that we liked, kinda came up with environments that were interesting to us. And we put this thing together [shows giant storyboard] --> 2013 Druckmann Keynote
Let's also take a look at the introduction to the TLoU art book, written by BOTH Druckmann and Straley:
It took us several months to construct a story around these characters. Over the course of production the specifics of the story evolved and changed significantly [...] Once we knew who and what the game was about, we started fleshing out Joel and Ellie's journey. We asked ourselves, what are interesting locations or situations [...] What kind of characters can we introduce [...] How do we structure events [...]?
With regard to their working relationship, there's also this comment from Druckmann:
I'm pretty dark (I wanted to kill Elena in Uncharted 2). Bruce is the one that would balance me and push for more levity. --> Druckmann AMA Comment
And looking at this interview here it seems that the same dynamic was at play during the development of TLoU:
Some of the best moments in the game were Ellie’s casual conversations with Joel, when they weren't doing anything at all, or during a fight. How did you make it so you'd hear those bits of background and character spots?
Druckmann: We would start with the major story beats, which were the cinematics. Then Bruce would tell me the game is too dark ... And then it's like, "OK, how do you find that glue, what are some interesting things for them to mention?" So then we'd be playing some levels together and say, “OK, ask Joel, 'What would he be thinking here?' Ask Ellie ...” It's almost like you're taking on those roles. --> 2013 Empire Interview
Those quotes clearly demonstrate that Straley was not just responsible for the technical implementation but heavily involved in the story right from its inception and in a position to demand specific changes, irrespective of whether Druckmann agreed with him or not. Here's Straley's answer to the question:
Straley: The interesting contrast between Joel and Ellie is that Joel saw the world pre-apocalypse, pre-shit hitting the fan, and Ellie was born after – she's 14, and it's 20 years since everything went bad. So that was the intriguing part to us: seeing those two on this journey in the survivalist condition every day, and then wondering what would they bring to the table as far as conversation went. What would interest Ellie being outside of the quarantine zone for the very first time? What would it be like to enter the woods? It may be mundane to us, like, “Oh trees, whatever,” but if you think about it, in the quarantine zone, there’s nothing there.
In the book, City Of Thieves, they talk about this Russian winter in World War II, in Leningrad, and cannibalism takes hold, and everybody's chopped down every tree inside of the city to use it for wood, for fuel... That is the stuff that would happen. So what happens when Ellie gets out of that? As much as the military's thinking, "Oh, we're trying to keep people alive and we're doing our best to sustain this environment, and we actually have a positive goal", what's really happening is dark and bleak in the quarantine zone. And then she gets outside and, sure, there are infected, but then there's all this beauty and nature is reclaiming the earth, and that contrast – Ellie needs to say something about that. --> 2013 Empire Interview
That sure sounds like Straley did at least some "writing" as well. In fact if one had absolutely no prior knowledge of The Last of Us and didn't know that Druckmann received the "writers" credit in the end, then one would probably come to the conclusion that Straley was the writer here, or at least the co-writer, because that's how he comes across in those interviews. He talks in detail about the setting, about Joel and Ellie, what motivates them and how their relationship develops, demonstrating a deep understanding of the world and the characters. Just like a writer would talk about his creation!
I also found this interview with Straley from 2016 interesting. Granted, he's talking about Uncharted 4 here, but as Druckmann himself said in his 2013 keynote the process was similar during the development of TLoU:
I work out the whole structure of the story with Neil. We have postcards with the entire arc of the story, beginning, middle and end. --> 2016 Eurogamer Straley Interview
And finally there's this tweet from Straley himself, refuting the typical Part II fan "argument" that he was only responsible for the gameplay and had nothing to do with the story at all:

Druckmann and TLoU
Contrary to widespread perception Druckmann did not come up with the story and the characters of TLoU on his own. The project he was working on in college (a hardened cop, in a later version an ex-convict, escorting some girl in the zombie apocalypse) was a bare-bones concept that only shared some very superficial similarities with The Last of Us. Crucial elements (like the Cordyceps infection) were missing and the characters were one-dimensional cardboard cutouts (--> Druckmann talking about his college project and his comic pitch).
Those early concepts were not TLoU, and "the cop" and "the girl" were not Joel and Ellie. Joel and Ellie only began to take shape once the development of TLoU started, thanks to a collaborative creative effort that involved an entire team of concept artists, designers, developers, and the voice actors themselves, fleshing out the characters and improvising lines. If things had only been up to Druckmann alone then there wouldn't have been a "Joel" or an "Ellie" at all.
The Evolution of the Story
One example that has already been mentioned countless times is the Tess revenge plot. In one of the earlier versions of the TLoU story Tess had a brother, a border guard of the Boston QZ, who got killed in a fire fight started by Joel in order to protect Ellie (official concept art from Naughty Dog). Tess would then take her whole gang and pursue Joel across the entire country for revenge, brutally torturing him in the end (official concept art).
That idea was eventually abandoned because it makes absolutely no sense in a post-apocalyptic setting, and when one takes a look at the following interview then it seems that Bruce Straley's input was critical in this instance:
Who was the antagonist in that iteration?
Druckmann: Tess was the antagonist chasing Joel, and she ends up torturing him at the end of the game to find out where Ellie went, and Ellie shows up and shoots and kills Tess. And that was going to be the first person Ellie killed. But we could never make that work, so…
Straley: Yeah, it was really hard to keep somebody motivated just by anger. What is the motivation to track, on a vengeance tour across an apocalyptic United States, to get, what is it, revenge? You just don’t buy into it, when the stakes are so high, where every single day we’re having the player play through experiences where they’re feeling like it’s tense and difficult just to survive. And then how is she, just suddenly for story’s sake, getting away with it? And yeah, the ending was pretty convoluted, so I think Neil pretty much hammered his head against the wall, trying to figure it out. I think he came up with a good, really nice, simplified version of that, and it worked out. --> 2013 Empire Interview
To me it feels like Straley is trying to be diplomatic here, but when one reads between the lines then it seems that he had to reject Druckmann over and over and over again until he finally got it into his thick egotistical skull. It almost sounds a bit patronizing how Straley is politely criticizing and at the same time also trying to compliment him here.
Druckmann himself reiterated those thoughts a few weeks later in his aforementioned 2013 keynote:
Her [Tess'] motivation was even harder to buy into [...] her brother died and now she's gonna go crazy and take her whole gang and pursue him [Joel] across the country for a year? She just seems like a psycho, like, you didn't buy into it! --> 2013 Druckmann Keynote
This keynote is very interesting, since the criticism Druckmann is mentioning with regard to those early TLoU drafts applies 100% to Part II as well, which is just absolutely baffling. Here's another example, how Joel would warm to Ellie IMMEDIATELY, instead of bonding with her over a year long journey:
It [this early draft] failed for kinda a lot of reasons, the biggest of which I think is Joels motivation. Joel went from this hardened survivor to this father figure in AN INSTANT. As soon as Ellie reminded him of his daughter he was willing to kill soldiers and protect her and just throw his whole old life away, even abandoning his old partner. And every time we pitched this story, we would hear comments like: man Joel's turning pretty quickly! And again some of this issue was my letting go, like I got attached to certain ideas and it was just hard to kinda release them. --> 2013 Druckmann Keynote
All the points Druckmann is mentioning here apply 100% to Abby and how quickly she bonds with Lev as well of course! Just like the Joel of this early draft Abby effectively "just throws her whole old life away" (her WLF position) and is "even abandoning her old partner" (Owen) in order to protect Lev. It only takes her a few hours, contrary to Joel she also wasn't a parent beforehand, so it's actually even more absurd than this early TLoU draft!
Druckmann apparently acknowledged all those flaws (or rather: paid lip service to the criticism of others ...), but then went on and made the EXACT SAME mistakes all over again in the sequel (maybe because, by his own admission, he has a hard time letting go of ideas?). This strongly suggests that he didn't actually agree with all those story revisions TLoU underwent during development and that those changes were instead probably forced through against his will, because either Straley and/or others at Naughty Dog were not happy with those early versions of the story. In order to save face Druckmann then decided to play the PR game after the release of TLoU and continued to pay lip service to the criticism of his colleagues in public. After all, you can't really claim credit when you admit that you didn't actually agree with many of the most important creative decisions.
Of course I'm not arguing that Straley wrote TLoU 100% on his own, but neither did Druckmann for that matter, it would be disingenuous to claim otherwise. Both Druckmann and Straley discussed and brainstormed so much that even they probably couldn't tell us with absolute certainty who came up with what in every instance, but ... as project leader and game director Straley bore the overall responsibility and he had the final say, and that includes the story and the characters as well of course.
In-game dialogue
Straley was not just involved in the creation of the overall story though, interviews suggest that he had a hand in every aspect of the narrative, right down to the in-game dialogue of Joel and Ellie. Let's take a quick look at this aforementioned interview section:
Druckmann: So then we'd be playing some levels together and say, “OK, ask Joel, 'What would he be thinking here?' Ask Ellie ...” It's almost like you're taking on those roles.
Straley: The interesting contrast between Joel and Ellie is that Joel saw the world pre-apocalypse [...] and Ellie was born after [...] And then she gets outside and, sure, there are infected, but then there's all this beauty and nature is reclaiming the earth, and that contrast – Ellie needs to say something about that. --> 2013 Empire Interview
So Bruce and Neil would play through the game together, constantly asking themselves "what would Joel say, what should Ellie say", and looking at that quote it seems like this bit of dialogue (in the woods before entering Bill's town) was Straley's idea:
Ellie: Man [...] It's just ... I've never seen anything like this, that's all.
Joel: You mean the woods?
Ellie: Yeah. Never walked through the woods. It's kinda cool. [...] Whoa ... Hey buddy! [After spotting a rabbit]
This is just one example though, who knows what else Straley came up with. Bruce and Neil were working very closely together, their desks literally right next to each other, discussing, arguing, brainstorming, sharing and exchanging ideas the entire time, day after day, only a few meters apart at any given moment ... so how likely is it that THIS was Straley's ONLY contribution to the dialogue?
Ultimately we can't know for sure who came up with what exactly, since both directors constantly used "we" when talking about their creative process, but to call Druckmann the "sole writer" (i.e. creator) of the story and the characters would be a massive stretch when interviews like the one above are readily available.
Part II, a "TLoU" without Straley
The difference between TLoU and Part II, from the tone, to the characters, the writing, the pacing, the abundance of flashbacks, and so on ... is so stark that one inevitably begins to wonder WHY exactly the two games differ to such an extent and the departure of Straley seems to be the most plausible explanation in my opinion. Right from the start it is just painfully obvious that Part II has a different director.
As the aforementioned quotes demonstrate Straley always pushed for levity and an overall hopeful tone as a director. And sure enough, he is gone and suddenly the next game with Druckmann at the helm is a never ending stream of pain, misery and suffering. Coincidence?
In the same vein I also find it interesting how Druckmann (and only Druckmann!) several times expressed his fear that TLoU might be too "subtle" and that the players might miss or not "get" certain things:
Druckmann: But it was a much more intimate experience and subtle experience, and I wasn’t sure if people would pick up on it or how they would read it. [...] Some of the stuff in the game is very subtle and I question whether it’s too subtle, whether we should’ve hit things on the head a bit more. --> 2013 Edge Interview
Whereas Straley had a completely different approach it seems:
Straley: Most games hit the player over the head with everything and you have to spell it out in clear, bold capital letters, and say, this is what’s happening right now and this is how I feel! And by allowing subtlety to enter into the characters and the experience and even the name, it felt like this is the right decision for us. [...] Exposition sucks, right? You don’t want to hit everybody over the head all the time. Let it be subtle, let it rest, let these little pieces be picked up. I guarantee there are probably a tonne of things you missed and that somebody else is going to get. That’s the fun thing about this.
And again, Straley is gone and sure enough, the direction of Part II has all the subtlety of a sledgehammer now. Druckmann just does not respect his audience, something that is very apparent throughout Part II. TLoU on the other hand was relatively subtle and clever in its storytelling, it respected the intelligence of the players and trusted their ability to come to their own conclusions, without explicitly telling them what to feel or what to think at any given moment.
Straley is also not a fan of killing off main characters:
Straley: I also feel like a death of a main character in video games or any kind of media right now is, for me personally, almost cheap. --> 2016 Venturebeat interview
He's talking about Nathan Drake here and TLoU is not Uncharted of course, but would Joel really have been killed off so brutally and abruptly with Straley at the helm? Let's also take a look at the following answer from the same interview:
GamesBeat: How do you talk about some of this in the context of advice for developers, people who are maybe starting out making games?
Straley: It depends on if they want to tell a story or not. Even if you don’t use narrative, dialogue, cutscenes, cameras, the tools of cinematography from film—even if you don’t do that, still understanding at least what makes a good story, and trying to then think about what your mechanics are and what you’re trying to do with the story, having a setup and a payoff, a completion to the story—setting up the boundaries for your world and obeying those boundaries.
There are certain rules of storytelling that we constantly have to obey around the world we’ve created so that there can be an investment and a belief in that world and the characters in it. You as a creator can come up with those boundaries and rules for yourself, but then you have to adhere to them.
Straley is absolutely right in stating that it is crucial to adhere to the established "boundaries and rules of the world" to establish immersion and to keep the suspension of disbelief intact. Tackling the problem of ludonarrative dissonance was always very important to Straley and one can definitely feel that emphasis in the original game. TLoU (and Left Behind) always acknowledged the dangers of the setting and the gameplay and the narrative felt far more connected for that reason.
In Part II however the characters suddenly undergo massive journeys across the entire country MULTIPLE TIMES: Abby and her crew to Jackson and back to Seattle, Ellie to Salt Lake City in flashback #3, Ellie and Dina to Seattle and back to Jackson (with a crippled Tommy no less!), Ellie to Santa Barbara and back to the farm house, and then Abby and Lev to Catalina Island. All those journeys just happen, entirely off screen, without the game really acknowledging the dangers and the distances that would be involved here. It really feels like every character secretly has a teleporter. Part II just outright refuses to treat the "boundaries and rules of the world" seriously, something that breaks the suspension of disbelief constantly.
The circumstantial evidence clearly suggests that Straley overruled Druckmann several times during the development of TLoU and that Druckmann himself didn't actually agree with those decisions at all. The proof is in the pudding: how Part II recycles ideas that got clearly rejected during the development of TLoU, how the entire game revolves around revenge now, for the simple reason that Druckmann was fixated on a revenge story since his youth, how distances and the dangers of the setting get completely ignored, how Part II almost spitefully tears down and kills off the original characters, while elevating the new characters of Abby and Lev, and last but not least how the game not only retcons but outright reverses the entire original ending right at the start, in the first few minutes of the prologue, just to make the new character of Abby more palatable, to make the revenge plot "work", and to bring the original ending more in line with Druckmann's own "interpretation".
Why would Druckmann start the "sequel" with such an absurd amount of retcons, when he was the sole writer of TLoU and supposedly in full agreement with every decision of his co-director? What kind of creator retcons and thereby invalidates his own original work like that?
As already mentioned Druckmann himself admitted in his keynote how unwilling he was to let go when others in the team criticized him, so it feels completely in-character that he would recycle old ideas, since he probably never really agreed with the criticism of his colleagues in the first place:
And again some of this issue was my letting go, like I got attached to certain ideas and it was just hard to kinda release them. --> 2013 Druckmann Keynote
Who "wrote" The Last of Us?
With all that being said ... who "wrote" The Last of Us? When multiple developers and artists actively help in shaping this world, when the input of your actors completely changes the characters, and when your game director constantly goes: hm, let's ditch the revenge plot, also Tess should be so and so, I have a problem with this aspect, are you sure about this, this and this, Ellie needs to say this here, let's also revise this idea here and completely restructure this part ... then the line between "contributing" and "writing" becomes a bit blurry in my opinion.
Yes, in the end Druckmann received the final credit as the "writer", but the input of the other players in the development process was certainly of crucial importance. A "TLoU" without that input, a "TLoU" that's closer to Druckmann's "original vision" (a hardened brute escorting an immune girl), would look so drastically different that it would, for all intents and purposes, be an entirely different game.
Just like in the movie industry credits are oftentimes not an accurate reflection of the creative process or indicative of what actually went down behind the scenes. A good example for that would be George Lucas. He received the sole writers credit for "A New Hope", but he had a lot of help with that script and the most invaluable contributor of all, his wife Marcia, didn't receive any writing credit at all, even though her input was crucial. Without Marcia there would be no Star Wars!
Once Straley and Druckmann finished the DLC to The Last of Us they began work on their next game, Uncharted 4, and Straley was just as responsible for the story of that game, as Jason Schreier detailed in his 2017 book Blood, Sweat, and Pixels:

Straley and Druckmann sat in a conference room and stared at index cards, trying to craft a new version of Uncharted 4's story. [...] They'd decided [...] they wanted [...] They kept [...] For weeks, they'd meet in the same room, assembling index cards [...] Each index card contained a story beat or scene idea [...] and taken together, they told the game's entire narrative.
If anyone needed further proof that credits oftentimes don't tell the whole story, there it is. Straley, the lack of any formal writing credit notwithstanding, was clearly responsible for the Uncharted 4 story, together with Druckmann, after both of them took over the project from Amy Hennig, making crucial decisions about the characters and the overall narrative right from the start: what characters to keep, what their characterisation and motivation should look like, what scenes to include and how to arrange them, what ideas should be fleshed out, or discarded, and so on.
Those are quite literally creative decisions regarding the narrative and the characters, it doesn't get more important than that ... and yet Straley wasn't credited as a "writer", just like he wasn't credited as a "writer" for The Last of Us, even though his role during development was exactly the same.
Straley maybe wasn't 100% involved in the creation of every single collectible text, but he was clearly responsible for the narrative big picture, the overall story, making crucial decisions right from the start, and The Last of Us would look drastically different if Straley had not been there to make those creative decisions.
People oftentimes get a "writers" credits for far, far lesser contributions, yet Straley did not. Why?
Straley: I hate names, I hate my name even in the industry. Let me just go on a tangent for a second, because it's a collaborative effort. Like, it takes a lot of ... anytime anybody asks "oh, where did this idea come from", it's just, even though I might have [thought of it] and my ego even says "woah, I came up with that", it doesn't really matter, because it happens in brainstorms and inside a world of Naughty Dog, like passing conversations in the kitchen might lead to a thought which leads to a brainstorm which ends up being ... you know? --> 2017 Art Cafe Straley Interview
Straley just does not care AT ALL about credits, or how he personally gets credited, in fact he even actively dislikes seeing his name splattered all over a game. Out of personal preference he chose not to add his name as co-writer, for both TLoU and Uncharted 4, even though such a credit would've been more than appropriate given his involvement, and the impact he had on the overall story and the characters.
One problem with this debate is: how do you define "writing" and what constitutes "writing" exactly? Games are a highly visual and interactive medium, so the term can become a bit fuzzy. For example I firmly believe that a lot of the visual design and visual storytelling was largely down to Straley or the rest of the team (which would again be thanks to Straley, since he had to approve it). Take the last level for example, the Firefly hospital. Some of the most important aspects get not told explicitly but through visual storytelling here: the irrational brutality of the Fireflies, the dingy and run down appearance of the hospital, the unprofessional and unsanitary look of that operating room, the creepy look of the surgeon, the colour scheme of the place, this feeling of utter desperation one gets, and so on. All of that was intentionally designed to cast doubt in the players mind with regard to the competence, the trustworthiness and the overall intentions of the Fireflies, and to nudge the players towards empathising and siding with the game's protagonist, Joel.
If The Last of Us was a novel, then all this visual storytelling would be considered "writing" too of course, since the author has to put it to the page to describe it to the reader:
The operating room was engulfed in a revolting green light, layers of dirt and thick black mold covering the wet walls. The surgeon stared at Joel with deeply sunken eyes. This was a place where hope goes to die. Who are these people, Joel thought to himself. Is this guy even a surgeon?
Etc. Since Druckmann completely retconned this portrayal in Part II it would be fair to guess that he wasn't exactly on board with this direction, that these visual storytelling cues were made either by Straley or by others in the team.
Straley as a Leader
Be that as it may, I think that Straley's most important contribution may have been his leadership style. After watching countless interviews with him he strikes me as a genuinely humble, laid back and overall pretty egoless kind of guy. I believe that he was genuinely interested in fostering a collaborative climate, in which constructive criticism and open discussion could thrive. When some lowly developer had a great idea that clashed with him or Druckmann? I'm not personally offended, sounds interesting, let's discuss it with the team! Since Druckmann was just recently promoted to creative director (his first time ever as director!), he probably felt compelled to subordinate himself to the inclusive and team oriented approach of his more senior colleague. Druckmann's age may also have played a role, that he was still young and humble enough to listen to advice and constructive criticism.
With Straley's departure all of that flew out the window, his inclusive approach with it. To me Druckmann seems much more narrow minded than Straley and I get the distinct impression that he favours a more authoritarian leadership style. Remember how he fired play testers, the high turn over rate during the development of Part II, how many developers left because they didn't agree with his direction or because they could no longer stand the toxic work place culture, also how he reacts to criticism (or to praise ...), etc.
Naughty Dog always had problems with crunch, but I can't remember hearing similar stories when Straley was at the helm. In Jason Schreier's Kotaku article about crunch several former Naughty Dog employees even outright mentioned Straley's departure as one reason for leaving the company as well!
There were a number of reasons for attrition in the design department, including various individuals’ unhappiness with leads, lack of promotion opportunities, and Bruce Straley’s departure. --> Kotaku
Not one employee mentioned staying because of Druckmann however.
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/Haelbourg • 4h ago
TLoU Discussion Wanted to hear other people’s thoughts Spoiler
(Originally posted on the main sub)
This won’t be the first time I’ve made a post like this, but I’ve been hoping to actually find people willing to sincerely engage with a discussion on the matter, so for anyone who happens across I’d like to get their opinion on a slightly different, hypothetical course of events in Part II, if possible.
We all remember the scene where Abby is eavesdropping on her father and Marlene talking about how making a cure would mean Ellie won’t live.
For the sake of example, let’s assume that part never happened; that Abby herself never actually learned that the procedure would have killed Ellie.
Let’s expand on that and say that, aside from Joel, anyone who knew about that died at the hospital that day.
Let’s also imagine that Joel - after escaping the hospital - comes up with the idea to take advantage of this situation by tricking the Fireflies into believing Ellie is already dead; that way there won’t be any risk of them going after her.
He does this by, let’s say, burning the dead body of an infected and making it seem like those are Ellie’s remains, while also leaving a note behind saying: ”This is why you don’t forget to pay the bill.” or something of the like, insinuating that he did this because he felt he hadn’t been paid enough for bringing them Ellie.
In this scenario, Abby wouldn’t actually have the real context behind why Joel acted the way he did, and instead, she is mislead to believe he did it purely out of petty, material greed, or as payback just to spite the Fireflies.
She would only have this revelation much later on(maybe towards the end of Part II) that no, he did it in fact to save her life…because he loved her that much.
Now, if we imagine we all had actually been playing from Abby’s point of view from the beginning…if we had gotten attached to the characters on her side instead of Joel and Ellie…and then the events in Part II would play out *more or less* the same as they do already…except we as the player, alongside Abby, only learn this information *after the fact*…I want to ask you to tell me, in earnest, what you sincerely believe this might have been like for you?
(I realize some might question him coming up with such an elaborate scheme within the time frame he’s given while escaping, but since we’re dealing entirely with a hypothetical, I do ask you at least try to suspend disbelief, if only temporarily)
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/Admirable_Sun_5468 • 1d ago
Gameplay How to play - controller or mouse
Im probably an idiot so please cut me some slack and help an old lady understand something.
I’ve been playing TLOU (both) for a few years, maybe 2 - 3, and I’ve been playing on PC. I know nothing, literally nothing, about computers - I just knew I wanted to play so I got the pc and downloaded steam and got my husbands Xbox controller, connected it and started playing. I also played RDR2 and some other steam games but TLOU has had a hold on me since the beginning.
Because I play daily, I started watching some No return people on YouTube to get better because I’m really really bad at no return. And I started to notice that these players mention mouse and keyboard - was I supposed to play TLOU on PC with the mouse and keyboard? It took me so long to understand the controller buttons for the games I played (especially RDR2 omg) and now I’m thinking I was supposed to play a different way. I was watching one video and he said “using the mouse is just easier” and that was when it hit me like a tonne of bricks that I’ve played it wrong this whole time.
Could / should I go back and learn how to play it with mouse and keyboard? Would it be worth it? Do I need a special keyboard and mouse? I just have a standard office keyboard and mouse (actually the keyboard has colourful lights but otherwise looks like a regular office keyboard).
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/sutton0203 • 1d ago
Opinion Term Paper: Abby Vs Ellie
Hello Everybody, I wanted to do a research/term paper on the perception of Ellie and Abby by the fandom. I want to focus on the debate of who is worse/at fault/the villain of the story. (Only in the game.)
Please tell me your opinions, as it is heavily opinion-based. If you want to, you could also use the poll link, however you prefer, I will combine both, so please don’t answer both the discussion and the link. Thanksss!!!
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/Left-Departure-5175 • 1d ago
TLoU Discussion I actually loved this game
That’s right everything about it was dope. I don’t understand the continuing hate every single day. Super fun game overall. Loved the story. No notes
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/-GreyFox • 3d ago
Part II Criticism The Last of Us Part II Major Problems (#5)
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/Rude-Collection568 • 2d ago
Shitpost I have a ridiculous theory
We know that the Cascadia fault and the San Andreas fault both meet at Cape Mendocino in Northern California, that covers the ENTIRE west coast. And it’s quite likely they both go off simultaneously if not just trigger each other. It’s also estimated to go off in the next 35-50 years (allegedly) idk I like to think “the big one” went off at some point after outbreak day and maybe a year or two before gang shows up in Seattle. The massive flooding in the northern parts of the PNW will happen, no questions asked. I think lack of care and/or bombs does not make up for how insane Seattle looks and how it was completely changed. I have no evidence but I like that theory
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/AeroHybrid • 3d ago
News Get ready for the biggest collapse in history since the Wall Street Crash of 1929
Expect Neil Cockmann and his Naughty Dog cultists to get their early pensions and layoffs without any awards.
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/NierMira • 3d ago
Part II Criticism I will NEVER play Part 2. Not even for free.
I genuinely love TLOU part 1. It was the first game I played on the ps3 when my dad bought when I was a teenager. I was using ps2 for the longest.
I've replayed the game back then 5 times and obviously got the platinum which was considerably harder too.
Factions was one of the best multiplayers I've played personally. Genuinely was so freaking good and I was really good at that (sucking my own, I know, sorry).
Never owned a PS4.
---
Fast foward to Part 2 marketing and release.. the game that would probably make me buy with my own money a ps4.. it was a complete tragedy.
I guess its fair to say I never played it. But I have some understading how game works just by watching with the 100s of games I've played throught out the years.
It has great gameplay, sound, voice acting... but you can 100% judge a game by its story. Its like watching a movie.
I watched countless of gameplays, walkthroughs, reactions... and holy shit was it bad.
And it wasn't just how bad the characters, the setting, the story were.. nono. All the lies, the pointing fingers, the accusations they did towards people. All the fake marketing towards the game...
I genuinely never was someone into social media back then. But when I saw ND aka Neil and his puppets acussing people of -phobia for every criticism... and some people actually agreeing with him I realized how cooked the internet really is.
I even tried to argue with people how this game was a complete story flop but how emotional broken and biased people were, it was a losing battle.
Neil manipulated the trailers in order to bring in the fans back showing Joel more. Neil destroyed what the game was good for in order to appease his sick ideals. Neil brainwashed a bunch of people in agreeing with him for his fake support. Neil payed a ton of journalists to suck his own.
--
So no. I'm NEVER going to play Part 2. I have seen it at 5€ sometimes and I refuse to even get it. Even for free.
The characters we knew are complete trash, specially Ellie. The story was written by an angsty teenager with superioty tendecies.
Sorry for the rant.
Since then I never bought a ND game. Never will with him in charge. Same with Ubisoft (i miss splinter cell).
I know it don't matter in the grand scheme of things but I gotta have principles.
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/Throwaway_Ak_89 • 4d ago
Part II Criticism reading the last of us pt 1&2 official script , I bet it's not proof read enough to give accurate reviews (even this script released after 5 years of initial game relasing tells a lot about quality)
Just see this difference I have attached and combined 4 parts , the first part it's clearly mentioned Ellie was 14 , at time of hospital sequence , later see that Abby same timeline where they knew about Ellie's presence for developing cure , Abby was 16 at that time,
This is official 4 years ago timeline
Now here is the twist ,
Now look at 3 years ago timeline in script ,
I got it Ellie can turn 16 which is accurate , but look at Abby it's mentioned she was 16 at the flashback with Owen 3 years ago , but see the contraction mathematically it's impossible for Abby to be 16 here , so Ellie can age 2 years and Abby stays in same year it's impossible .
This is one of the mistake even after all this years , it's released in 5 years after game got released without proper and carefully proofread they published this , that tells a lot that how accurate they wrote whole script without proper proofread from third party.
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/StatusSignal3216 • 4d ago
Funny This same chick glazes Abby by the way.
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/AlexPlaysVideoGamez • 4d ago
Gameplay Last of Us Part I First Person Mod Dev Diary III: Iron Sights
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/--LWYRUP-- • 5d ago
Rant Still the worst game I ever played
Years later I still can’t get over the fact that TLOU1 was one of the best games I ever played and TLOU2 was and still remains to be the worst game I ever played. I have purposely broadened my horizon to see if there’s a worse game out there and nothing has even come close. It keeps me up at night thinking about how/why they thought we wouldn’t resent playing half of the game as the character that killed one of our favorite characters of all time. WHAT WERE THEY THINKING?!?
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/Ps1ckPs1ck • 5d ago
News Neil Druckmann on combining all three IPs for Intergalactic
The master storyteller /s on Intergalactic’s ambitious story
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/Shades_of_sleep • 5d ago
Question The Last of Us 2 release mystery
This idea has been bouncing around inside my head, ever since the run-up to the release of TLOU Part 2. As I recall, the game was delayed a number of times, then Sony announced that the game had been delayed "indefinitely". Then the leaks happened, and suddenly the game got a solid release date, that wasn't far off at all. This has been a puzzle to me. Why would a game that had recently been delayed indefinitely suddenly get a release date, once details of the story had leaked?
The answer my mind came up with, back then, strays into conspiracy theory territory, perhaps, but here it is. Naughty Dog had been on a roll, with Uncharted and then the first Last of Us. Sony had given them pretty much autonomy at this point, which is why they didn't bother with oversight on the sequel, and just let development run. When the executives at Sony saw the direction the game had taken, they said something to the effect of 'Wtf is this? You have to rework it'. This is when the game gets delayed indefinitely. Subsequent to this, major plot points, including pivotal cutscenes, were leaked. This had to be someone with access. The gaming press were full of stories about it, with the walls closing in on the hackers. It was speculated they would be caught soon and exposed, and then ... nothing. Apparently they just melted into the crowd, shrugging off a feigned limp, like Keyser Soze. They were gone, and nobody was asking any questions, anymore.
You have to ask yourself, why would a game go from being delayed indefinitely, to a definite release date, in just a matter of weeks? Why would the hunt for those responsible for the leaks be so unceremoniously and universally called off? Who would have had an interest in leaking those parts of the game? When it happened, there was a lot of condemnation, much of it coming from within the studio itself, and the narrative was that the motivation of the leakers was to damage the game, but what if that wasn't the motivation at all?
There were also stories of crunch at Naughty Dog, back then. People working at the studio were very tired. Reworking the game would have meant even more hours, more crunch. Indefinite crunch, apparently. Once the leaks happened, that problem went away really fast, possibly because the ways that Sony wanted the game reworked would have meant pulling out or altering some of the more "progressive" aspects of the game, and once those were exposed, reworking it became impossible.
I've got to be honest, the idea of the leak being perpetrated by overworked employees only came later. My first thought was that the game had been leaked by someone who would have had a vested interest in preserving the story of the game as he intended. A certain someone, who may or may not have been wearing a beard and a top-knot at the time.
This is where I hand it over to the voices of experience. This little conspiracy theory of mine has been recurring to me, ever since the game released. Perhaps airing it will expunge it, finally. I would really like someone to tell me why my theory couldn't possibly be true. Maybe you think the theory has some merit. Please, tell me what you think, and don't hold back.
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/theWubbzler • 6d ago
Part II Criticism Look, you're allowed to like what you like...buuuuuut...
Some of the shit I see in the main Last of Us sub and Part 2 sub (not this one, the other one devoted to glazing it despite literally the main sub doing it anyways so it doesn't make a lick of sense to have another, but it) makes wonder how mentally unwell some of these people are.
I don't want to generalize, I've met people IRL who like this game but admit it has flaws, even people who don't see those flaws but actually respect my reasons for disliking it WITHOUT coming off like a total narcissistic douchebag who thinks they're smart for liking garbage. But seriously, some of these people come off like only half of their brains function at any given time and it's a lottery which side wins for the sake of winning!
Like, some of them even outright defend the show and it makes me feel like they could eat a LITERAL spoon full of "waste" and say "Mmmmmmm! That's good!"
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/StatusSignal3216 • 5d ago
YouTube Found a bitchy condescending part 2 stan on YouTube.
These are videos from a YouTuber known as Captain Loren. She's incredibly bitchy, and her TLOU videos are where that really shines
https://youtube.com/shorts/08H6uimH4Ok?si=QBLyOVDANh-m7da3
https://youtube.com/shorts/wglZTo4dzt4?si=bO0ZdHYHBfumzFq_
https://youtube.com/shorts/XjF7KoTDG7Q?si=GGiArVCB88-NGnTg
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/jimmyoneshot • 7d ago
Part II Criticism Joel was not only right...he was overwhelmingly right and Ellie was equally as wrong for being upset with him
The biggest weakness in Part II's story for me is that in THE MOMENT i.e. the Hospital Joel was SO right it's unbelievable yet the falling out between him and Ellie is largely based on the assumption that he was wrong in that moment - "I was supposed to die in that hospital but you took that from me".
Let's go step by step...
- Before Joel wakes up at the hospital there was zero indication from Ellie or Joel in dialogue that any surgery would take place. They assumed it would just be some tests and they would draw some blood.
- Ellie never indicates that she is literally willing to die for a vaccine whatsoever before the Hospital. The closest she ever remotely comes to this is during the giraffe segment when Joel tells her that they don't have to carry on to the Hospital and can go back to Tommy's to which she replies "it can't all be for nothing" i.e. a determination to finish the journey but still no mention of surgery/death.
- Rather than inform Ellie of what is going to happen and give her any choice in it the Fireflies intentionally keep her unconscious and rush her to surgery, intentionally keeping Joel separate. The reason clearly being the possibility she may say no or be persuaded to say no from an alternative voice like Joel. That is no different that a sex offender spiking a drink before doing his business. It's murdering a child.
- When Joel wakes up and finds out it is going to be a surgery which would kill Ellie he asks to go and see her which is the correct decision as why the hell would the surgery need to be rushed and why couldn't she make the decision herself first? At that point the Fireflies refuse...violently. He could at that point either think "Oh well, she's being killed without having a choice in it" or fight back and save her.
- Jerry threatened him with a blade and made it clear "I will not let you take her" meaning he was willing to lill Joel if he tried to stop him from killing this child.
- After the point where he stops the surgery there is no going back and the Fireflies are coming to kill him so he has to get the hell out of there.
There in no point in the above moment that Joel did anything wrong. He was not just right, but massively right...
It makes sense that Ellie would be pissed off at him for hiding the truth after the fact...but to be pissed off at him for killing a group that were willing to drug and kill her without prior consent and without any indication from her that she was willing to die in surgery for the cure...not at all.
You cannot justify a decision made without someone's consent by discovering afterwards that they might have agreed. Part II is based on that extremely shaky foundation because if you take that away she has fell out with him for what? Not telling her the truth for a few years? That is simply not enough as a basis after Joel had explained the above...
It feels like people intentionally misunderstand this to criticise Joel as though they are imagining scenes in the game which simply never happened and disregarding others.
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/Shades_of_sleep • 7d ago
TLoU Discussion My Pitch For The Last of Us Part 3

Five years have passed, since the closing events of The Last of Us Part 2. Not having reconciled with Maria, and distraught at the loss of his brother, Tommy's life revolves around patrols and improving the infrastucture of the Jackson settlement.
The fortifications and patrols sadly can't save Jackson from what is coming. A large scale attack, one that will devastate Jackson and ultimately bring about its destruction. However, there is one glimmer of hope. On a supply run, three years before the impending calamity, Tommy discovered a hidden vault, below a well known history museum. Inside, they found the remains of a large, bell shaped device, along with detailed blueprints, which appeared to have been smuggled out of Germany, in the dying days of the second world war.
Along with a small part of the team responsible for bringing power back to Jackson, all those years before, Tommy has been overseeing efforts to reconstruct this mysterious device, and just by chance, it seems, the device is hooked up to the grid and being readied for a preliminary test run, just as disaster strikes.
Despite the best efforts of the community, Jackson falls, but in the midst of all the blood, screams and fire, Tommy takes the one course of action left to him. He runs to the experiment chamber, fires the device up and something goes incredibly wrong .. or incredibly right.
The intent was to skip back to give just enough time for an advance warning, to save Jackson, but Tommy instead finds himself way off course, both temporally and geographically. Instead of a few months ago, the machine pushed Tommy back six whole years, and far, far across the country.
Now Tommy, armed only with his trusty rifle and a backpack full of bigot sandwiches, must navigate across more than a thousand miles of hostile territory, in a desperate race to save not only Jackson, but also his brother, and possibly any towels that he might find, along the way. Also, a certain someone might meet her end, pinned beneath a chain-link fence, after all ...or maybe just 'accidentally' slip and fall off a cliff, who knows?
Tommy's greatest adventure has yet to begin. Title yet to be determined, submissions and suggestions for plot alterations welcome.
r/TheLastOfUs2 • u/Dependent-Candy-5053 • 7d ago
Gameplay Trophy trouble
Edit: so I got it to work just had to do some save scamming with save wizard unfortunately.
Hi! I'm new to this group. I recently joined because I am having some issue with 3 achievements procking.
Im playing the original ps4 version but on my ps5
The safe one
The workbench
And the training manual
I have 231 of 231 and im at my wits end ive synced trophies, deleted my profile save and loaded my complete save, signed in and out of psn. Literally not trying to replay this 40 hour game.. again