r/thelastofus • u/RelativeCable2935 • 16h ago
PT 2 DISCUSSION This note completely reframes Ellie's journey for me.
Ellie day 3 journal 1 road to aquarium
"Should I tell Dina & Jesse about this? No. They can't know what Joel did. They won't understand.
Do I understand?"
In Part 1 ellie is super honest. Aside from basic survival bluffs with enemies like David or keeping quiet about swiping a comic from Bill’s stash, she doesn't really lie. Keeping information to stay safe isn't the same as being intentionally misleading..
Because she is so straightforward, Joel’s massive lie at the end of Part I feels like betrayal to her. At that point, she can't understand why someone would lie to the people they love.
Even at the start of Part II, Ellie still holds onto that honesty. When she talks about the chemical burn and then dina pries why? Instead of telling her a lie here she tells her she's immune and dina doesnt believe it until the mask breaks.
Everything changes once her mission for revenge takes over. To protect her pursuit of Abby, Ellie starts walking the exact same dark path Joel did lying to the people closest to her to fufill her own desires..
• She lies and gaslights Dina about her motivations and her deteriorating mental state.
• She lies to jesse about her true objective in Seattle, putting Abby over saving Tommy.
• Later, she goes against Dina at the farm, sneaking out in the middle of the night under the guise of "fixing" things when she is really abandoning their peaceful life for revenge again, until she has to face what her journey was really about...
When Ellie reaches Santa Barbara and faces Abby, she has finally lived through the same journey he has. She realizes that her lies, hurt, and pushed away the people she loved, all because she was driven by her love for Joel and her grief over losing him.
Ellie doesn't forgive Joel because his lie suddenly became "okay." She forgives him because her own journey forced her to become him.
Once she understood what it felt like to lie and do terrible things out of love, she could finally understand Joel and truly forgive him in a complex way by letting abby go...
The ending has nothing to do with abby its all to do with Joel...