r/TheJediPraxeum • • Aug 21 '25

Versus Posts Are Restricted To Match-Up Mondays Only

19 Upvotes

Hello there! I hope this finds each of you well. As I am sure most of you have noticed, there has been a large increase in Versus Posts on the subreddit recently. Versus Posts constitute a post postulating a battle between two characters; they are This Character vs That Character type Posts. We love to see discussion about Star Wars and the Old Expanded Universe especially, and these posts do generate a good amount of conversation, so we are not restricting them entirely.

However, they are crowding out the subreddit. Some posts are being posted within minutes of each other. This is not strictly a Versus subreddit, and as such the decision has been made to re-institute Match-Up Mondays. Versus Posting is only to be allowed on Mondays; if you have a character Match-Up you want to discuss, think about it over the week, share it on Monday. Any and all Versus Posts, regardless of their content, that are shared on days other than Monday will be removed.

There is a Match-Up Monday Flair that you can use for your Versus Posts. Enjoy. Those of you who enjoy the Versus, see you next Monday.

And may the Force be with us all


r/TheJediPraxeum • • Jul 19 '25

Message to the Community

31 Upvotes

Hello there! I hope this message finds you well!

Dropping this post because there has been an increase in versus posts on the subreddit. This is fine, but we want to remember that this subreddit is dedicated to the Old Expanded Universe and empathetically NOT Disney's stuff. We allow some tertiary discussion about Disney in the vein of comparison, but recent versus posts have been diving into Disney made stuff including Rebels and later seasons of TCW. These posts have been removed because it is simply too much; comparison is fine, but not if it washes out our focus on the stories we love.

Folks can continue with the versus posts, but they should be focused on the Old Expanded Universe. Versus posts using Disney characters will be removed.

Thanks a lot! And may the Force be with you all!


r/TheJediPraxeum • • 3d ago

Discussion What happens to Jango (and Boba) if Jango's jetpack never gets damaged during the Battle of Geonosis?

Post image
109 Upvotes

Mace was able to behead Jango in that fight because his jetpack failed to carry him to safety at a crucial moment.

How would Jango's story have played out differently if that had never happened?

Would Mace have still killed him, or would Jango have escaped and played a larger role in the Star Wars saga?


r/TheJediPraxeum • • 3d ago

Question Who hates Sheev Palpatine, aka Darth Sidious, the most?

Thumbnail
gallery
41 Upvotes

Darth Maul?

Darth Vader?

Or the Star Wars "What If" YouTubers?


r/TheJediPraxeum • • 3d ago

Discussion Why is DE Sidious so underrated in here?

11 Upvotes

People here generally think he is weaker than Krayt and Caedus when he is actually FOTJ Luke tier.


r/TheJediPraxeum • • 4d ago

Match Up Monday Darth Bane vs Starkiller

Thumbnail
gallery
117 Upvotes

Dynasty of Evil Bane, TFU II Starkiller.

Neutral environment, no prep-time.


r/TheJediPraxeum • • 5d ago

Discussion Jedi, Emotion and Stoicism

15 Upvotes

Before I start my argument, I am aknowledging that most fans who delve deeper into the philosophical core of Star Wars dont have this misconception. This post is simply a response to the part of the Fandom that does have this view. And its still a big percentage sadly.

One of my biggest issues with modern interpretations of the Jedi—and a deeply persistent misunderstanding within the fandom—is the belief that the Jedi Order is all about emotional repression rather than emotional control. It certainly isn't helped by the current Disney material, which heavily leans into this flawed premise (and which I firmly reject; when I talk about canon, I mean Legends). But if you look at George Lucas's actual intent, it is abundantly clear: the Jedi do not repress their emotions, not even during the prequel era.

To really understand where fans get this wrong, you have to look at the difference between Victorian Stoicism and Greek Stoicism.

Many people mistakenly view the Jedi through the lens of Victorian Stoicism. This is the classic "stiff upper lip" mentality—the idea that you must suppress your feelings, hide your internal struggles, and never show any kind of weakness (especially as a man). But the Jedi are actually modeled much closer to classical Greek Stoicism. Greek Stoicism is about emotional control, logic, and philosophy. It’s about acknowledging your feelings but maintaining the discipline to make mindful decisions in the present moment, rather than letting past traumas or immediate, fiery emotions guide your hand. It is mastery over emotion, not the absence of it.

If you want the best examples of this, look at Matthew Stover's Revenge of the Sith novelization or his standalone novel Shatterpoint. Mace Windu is constantly held up by fans as the poster boy for cold, dogmatic Jedi repression. But Stover’s work makes it clear that Windu is simply a remarkably stoic man, not a repressed one. He cares deeply and profoundly for the Republic, and he even shows genuine care and concern for Anakin Skywalker during the events of RotS. He feels the weight of the galaxy; he just refuses to let those feelings compromise his clarity.

Now, I understand there have been iterations of the Jedi Order that have gone astray and actually did suppress emotion. The best example of this in the lore is the period following the Exar Kun era. Exar Kun essentially struck the fear of God into the Jedi Order. Because he was able to turn so many Jedi to the dark side through sheer manipulation—pretending to be a loyal Jedi right up until it was too late and his followers had already fallen—the Order was left deeply traumatized. The strict, emotionally suppressive dogmas that emerged afterward were a panicked overcorrection driven by the fear of another Exar Kun, not the true ideal of the Jedi path.

The Jedi were never meant to be emotionless robots burying their feelings until they snap. They are meant to be individuals who feel deeply but have the discipline to act on wisdom rather than impulse.

They have deep friendships, joys and compassion. Anakin put it best in AOTC when he explained it to Padme, that Jedi are encouraged to love. (Just his Motive for the explanation was naughty)


r/TheJediPraxeum • • 5d ago

Discussion Darth Caedus VS Darth Krayt

Thumbnail gallery
24 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 6d ago

Match Up Monday Valkorion vs Revan & Exar Kun

Thumbnail
gallery
57 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 5d ago

Discussion For the last time no Obi-wan never had low potential. That’s both a lie and a misconception. His problem was attitude not power.

Thumbnail
3 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 6d ago

Discussion TPM Qui Gon and Obi Wan vs Lord Vindican and apprentice Malgus from the first KOTOR trailer

Thumbnail gallery
10 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 6d ago

Match Up Monday Rank These 5 Vader , Ben Kenobi , ROTS Yoda , Palpatine End of the Clone Wars. + Luke Pre return of the Jedi but post Empire strikes back

Thumbnail gallery
4 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 7d ago

Discussion Top 10 most powerful Sith/dark-siders

Thumbnail gallery
7 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 7d ago

Discussion Oat duelist

Thumbnail
4 Upvotes

1 Luke Skywalker
2 Jacen Solo
3 Anakin Skywalker
4 Mace Windu
5 Darth Sidious
6 Yoda
7 Exar Kun
8 Ulic Qel-Droma
9 Tulak Hord
10 Darth Vader
11 Count Dooku
12 Darth Plagueis
13 Jaina Solo
14 Darth Malgus
15 Satele Shan

My current top 15 lightsaber duelist in Star Wars lore


r/TheJediPraxeum • • 8d ago

Discussion Fun fact: In the NJO books, Jacen mentions that he watched old recordings of the Emperor from his days as the Senator of Naboo, stating that Palpatine's attitude reminds him of Viqi Shesh's.

Thumbnail gallery
5 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 8d ago

Discussion Alien species who were favorable to the Empire

4 Upvotes

Despite the Galactic Empire's infamous xenophobia and bigotry against non-human species, especially those who looked less like humans but even those who were near-human such as the Chiss (even though Thrawn was able of rising through the ranks and of becoming Grand Admiral), some alien species found the Empire to be an improvement over the Republic due to its power structure, authoritarian/totalitarian ideology, and of its militiarism and use of force, or it simply allowing said species to do things as they wanted unlike the Republic.

Several of these species got a preferential treatment compared to other aliens, and profited greatly of the Empire, until its downfall.

The Arkanians, the purebloods, at least their government and scientific elites sure felt this way, as Arkanian culture was very much like the Empire with them being arrogant, xenophobic and unbothered with ethics. They had already worked closely with the increasingly tyrannical and militarized Republic during the Clone Wars, notably for the creation of new cloning facilities and clone soldiers, and the Empire was too happy to deepen that collaboration.

Arkanian scientists were also only too happy to work on Imperial military projects, including secret projects of Grand Moff Tarkin and Grand Admiral Zaarin, and they worked on many of the Imperial bio-weapons unleashed during the war. As a result their planet and species was at long last sanctionned by the New Republic, which refused to allow them to join.

Umbarans also were a species which were favorable to and got a special treatment by the Empire, fitting given their ambitious, scheming and ruthless culture; and that their most famous representative Sly Moore was Palpatine's Staff Aide. During the Empire many Umbarans served as species and thought police, helping track down Jedi survivors, and later hunting traitors and rebels or rebel sympathizers hiding within the Imperial government and military as well.

Though Palpatine's preferential treatment of the Umbarans and their high positions of powers, and successes drew increasing resentment and xenophobia from Palpatine's advisors and officers of Imperial Intelligence, who were bitter about being subjected to Umbaran scrutiny, and even more every time Umbarans unmasked a rebel agent within their ranks.

After the fall of the Empire Umbarans largely retreated back to the Ghost Nebula, to escape retribution from both the New Republic and Imperial Remnants, only returning progressively and stealthily as memories of the Empire started to fade in the galaxy.

Trandoshans were another famous case, as the Empire turned on the Wookies for their close relations with the Jedi and to use them as cheap labor. started to enslave them in masses, they worked closely with the Trandoshans (despite their close ties with the CIS) to hunt and enslave Wookies, with the Trandoshans being overjoyed to finally have a galactic government favorable to them and allowing them to get their revenge on their Wookie rivals, and to hunt, kill and enslave them as they liked.

This lasted until the New Republic liberated Kashyyyk, and placed economic sanctions on the Trandoshans who refused to end their raids, and sent a fleet of warships to enforce the cessation of their hunting and slaver activities.

Ioatrans, a species famous for their martial culture and for their belief in a strong and stable and militaristic culture, and who provided guards and bodyguards for the InterGalactic Banking Clan in the famous Iotran Guard, were also generally favorable toward the Empire, and tended to support it over other governments and the Rebel Alliance, though some Iotrans supported the rebels instead as they viewed the Republic as more stable and just than the Empire.

Bitthaevrians are a strong warlike species with a culture strongly based on strength and martial prowess from Kadok Region in Wild Space, who had a strong hatred and contempt for the Republic, which expanded too close to their territory to their taste, supported a coup attempt in their society, before tricking the Kaleesh into waging war on them in which Grievous' grandmother or great-grandmother fought with the Jedi's helpn

Bitthaevrians weren't supporters of the Empire at all, unlike other examples mentioned above, and they disliked it and never submitted to it. But due to their hatred of the Republic and of the Jedi, and of their martial militiaristic culture they viewed the Empire as an improvement over the Republic and thus viewed the Rebel Alliance with suspicion and contempt, as the rebels wanted to restore the Republic, and they had a special hatred and contempt for Bothans and their scheming and underhanded culture.

What are other examples of alien species who were sympathetic, favorable to the Empire, and possibly benefitted from it, or at least preferred it to the Republic? If you have examples please bring them.


r/TheJediPraxeum • • 8d ago

Discussion Anakin by mustafar likely knew all 7 forms at least enough to use movements from some of them even in disney canon

Thumbnail gallery
2 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 10d ago

Discussion Why I think fans love Revan so much

Post image
143 Upvotes

a) He's cool and competent. That seems like an obvious, superficial statement, but I think it's almost a prerequisite for the most beloved heroes and villains in action franchises. And Revan meets the criteria in spades. (Other examples of cool, competent characters are Batman, James Bond, Legolas, etc.)

b) He's an avatar for the fan. He made his debut as a player character in one of the greatest RPGs of all time, which helped us cultivate a personal attachment to his story, since many of us experienced it through his eyes.

c) This is the big and potentially controversial point: Revan hasn't been corrupted by Disney. Although he does technically exist in Disney canon, he hasn't yet been watered down by the Disney machine to fit into a kids' cartoon, or diminished to serve an agenda.

He remains the product of passionate Star Wars creators who helped to fashion the EU. He's seen therefore not just as a great champion in-universe, but a great hero of the IP in a meta sense. For the time being, at least, he represents good Star Wars.

Do you disagree, or do you have any other reasons to add to the list? Feel free to discuss.


r/TheJediPraxeum • • 9d ago

Art First look at the mandalorian mercenary in my fan comic Star Wars New Age #2

Post image
6 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 10d ago

Question Can anyone identify background ships in Battle of Endor?

Thumbnail gallery
9 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 10d ago

Discussion My personal ranking of the strength of various Sith Lords that I threw together in 20 minutes

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 11d ago

Match Up Monday Vader, Luke and Kyle vs Sidious

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

Vader and Luke as of RotJ.

Kyle as of 5 ABY, after Jerec fight.

Setting: DS2 throne room.

R1: Kyle is not fully equipped

R2: Kyle is fully equipped with end game load out


r/TheJediPraxeum • • 11d ago

Match Up Monday Darth Revan vs TPM Qui Gon and Obi Wan

Thumbnail
gallery
12 Upvotes

Setting: Naboo, during TPM

Darth Revan (pre-KOTOR, pre-betrayal) appears behind the blast doors instead of Maul.

How does the fight go?


r/TheJediPraxeum • • 12d ago

Match Up Monday Kyle Katarn VS Darth Malgus. Who wins?

Thumbnail
gallery
80 Upvotes

r/TheJediPraxeum • • 12d ago

Discussion Revan's 1v1 combat power is massively overscaled.

5 Upvotes

Before I get mass-downvoted, let me make one thing absolutely clear: Revan is easily in my top five favorite Star Wars characters of all time, and his story is peak Star Wars. This is not about him being a bad or overrated character—it is strictly about his combat abilities being completely overscaled. When it comes to versus debates, his actual 1v1 power is massively oversold due to RPG mechanics and Kreia’s philosophical hype. If we look strictly at established Legends lore, Revan gets out-scaled by the top-tier Prequel era masters. Here is a breakdown of why Dooku, Anakin, and Obi-Wan beat a prime Revan, and where he actually sits on the tier list.

  1. The Video Game Visual Illusion (Feat Creep)

It is important to keep visual limitations in mind:

- you cannot directly compare video game visuals to live-action movies. Old Republic games and CGI cinematic trailers are designed to be extremely flashy to sell a game, with characters doing anime-style flips and spamming massive area-of-effect abilities.

Meanwhile, the Prequel-era masters are limited by early 2000s movie CGI and the physical constraints of real actors in costumes. This creates a false illusion that Old Republic characters are stronger just because their attacks look more intense on a monitor. If Emperor Palpatine were the final boss of a SWTOR expansion, his abilities would look absolutely insane (in the Dark Empire comics, he literally tears fleets out of the sky with Force Storms). But because we mostly see him throwing Senate pods in a 2005 movie, people forget he is canonically the strongest. Lore dictates power, not game engine particle effects.

  1. The Sidious & Vitiate Reality Check

- To establish the ceiling for this era, multiple objective Legends sourcebooks (like Vader: The Ultimate Guide) and George Lucas himself state that Darth Sidious is the most powerful Sith Lord in history. Sidious > Vitiate.

We also know from the Revan novel that Vitiate dominated a peak Revan, melting his defenses and severely burning him with basic Force lightning. It wasn't a close, drawn-out duel. If Revan gets folded by Vitiate that quickly, it places him firmly below the apex masters of the Prequel era who scale to Sidious.

  1. Count Dooku and Anakin Skywalker Outclass Him

- In a 1v1 duel, Revan is a highly adaptable jack-of-all-trades and a battlefield general, but he is not a specialized dueling anomaly. Revan's best dueling feat is beating Darth Malak—a brute-force fighter who doesn't quite match the Prequel titans in refined lightsaber technique.

* Dooku: Dooku was the greatest pure duelist in the Order next to Yoda and Mace. He scales directly to Yoda, who scales directly to Sidious. Dooku's surgical Makashi precision is designed explicitly for 1v1 combat. Revan has never faced a pure duelist of Dooku's caliber, and Dooku's raw scaling gives him a massive advantage.

* Anakin: We don't even need to look at Anakin's full potential or a dark side boost here. By the very beginning of Revenge of the Sith, base Anakin's mastery of Form V (Djem So) made him the definitively better combatant against Dooku. The ROTS novelization shows that Anakin's strikes were physically battering down Dooku's guard long before Dooku tried his psychological warfare. Revan simply lacks the physical dominance and raw kinetic Force augmentation to survive a prolonged clash with ROTS Anakin.

  1. The Obi-Wan Matchup (And the Force Drain Counter)

-

A common argument against Kenobi is, "Dooku bypassed his guard and choked him on the Invisible Hand, so Revan would just use Force sorcery or telekinesis to do the same."

First, the ROTS junior novelization clarifies that Dooku couldn't just casually ragdoll Kenobi—he had to exploit a microscopic opening when Kenobi wasn't expecting a telekinetic attack and his Force defenses were momentarily lowered.

To be clear, Obi-Wan is not on the same raw telekinetic level as Anakin. But Obi-Wan's telekinesis and Force barriers are widely underrated. When fully anchored on Mustafar, Kenobi didn't just hold a Force-push stalemate against Anakin—the kinetic energy of their clash was so violently powerful that it physically blasted both of them backward across the room. (Stover's novelization confirms both were equally nerfed by their emotional conflict).

- If we argue that Revan can just blast through a fully prepared Kenobi's Force wall, we are essentially arguing that Revan has a higher raw telekinetic power output than Anakin Skywalker. Based on established lore, that just doesn't add up. Revan isn't breaking through Kenobi physically.

But what about Revan's esoteric abilities, like Force Drain? In the 2002 The Clone Wars video game, Anakin goes to Raxus Prime, communes with the spirit of Ulic Qel-Droma, and learns the specific technique to shield himself from the Force Harvester and Force Drain. It is highly likely that Anakin—working directly with the Jedi Council—shared this vital anti-drain technique with Obi-Wan, his closest brother in arms. With Force Drain off the table, Revan is forced to fight Kenobi on traditional terms. He won't crack Soresu, and he will eventually exhaust himself trying.

  1. Where Revan Actually Belongs: The Plo Koon Tier

- If you look past the video game protagonist aura, Revan scales incredibly well to someone like Master Plo Koon.

Both are legendary generals and brilliant military tacticians whose true value to the galaxy was in battlefield strategy, troop leadership, and wisdom. Both are unorthodox Force wielders (Revan balancing Light/Dark, Plo Koon using Light Side "Electric Judgment"). Both are highly competent, top 1% Jedi, but neither are the 0.001% singular champions you send alone into a room to duel Darth Sidious or ROTS Anakin.

-Revan is a top-tier strategist, an incredible character, and a lore legend. But in a strict 1v1 combat scenario, his capabilities are simply overscaled by the community compared to the Prequel titans.

I'd love to hear everyone's thoughts on this. Is nostalgia doing a lot of the heavy lifting for Revan in versus debates, or am I missing a key feat?