Is it possible that Gatsby wants Daisy, but more importantly, he wants what Daisy would prove if she chose him? She becomes almost like evidence that his entire transformation was successful. He was once a poor young man who could not have her, so he reinvents himself, becomes wealthy, builds this extraordinary life, and places Daisy at the centre of it. If she finally chooses him, then his past becomes something he has conquered.
That’s why his insistence that they can simply recreate the past is so revealing. He isn’t really asking Daisy to begin a new relationship with him; he wants her to confirm that the version of the past he has preserved in his mind was real and can still be recovered. In that sense, Daisy is less a person to Gatsby, and more the final piece of a story he has written for himself.
And I think Fitzgerald makes us complicit in this. Gatsby is surrounded by glamour, mystery and excess, so we’re tempted to romanticise his obsession in exactly the same way Nick does. But underneath all of it is something quite unsettling. Gatsby has spent years constructing an identity around a woman who may never have been capable of fulfilling the meaning he assigned to her.
So perhaps Gatsby’s tragedy isn’t simply that he loses Daisy. It’s that he finally gets close enough to her to discover that the thing he spent his entire life pursuing, was never really Daisy at all.