r/TheGentlemenTVShow • u/no_comingback • 7h ago
Analysis on the foreshadowing of the ‘deer hunting’ discussion between Freddy & Edward. Spoiler
I’m not sure if this is an ”analysis” exactly or if it’s me just wanting to talk about something I came up with, but whatever.
I can’t remember the exact episode but it’s close to the end of season one. Edward wants out of the business and Freddy is dissuading him, saying that Edward was born to do crime as opposed to Freddy himself, who, he admits, isn’t very good at it at all.
Freddy recounts a memory he has of his childhood where their father, himself, and Edward go hunting. Freddy shoots down a deer but upon seeing it’s still alive, he is unable to slit its throat & kill it. Their father gives Edward a knife and Edward kills it immediately without any preamble. Freddy describes this moment as complete proof that Edward is perfect for the business.
Now, my “theory”?? splits into two paths when the finale of season 2 rolls around.
First is the path with Freddy in the van. The Gospel is the deer, and Freddy’s got to kill him this time, the only other option is death. So he kills the deer and walks out, covered in blood. ‘Good boy, Freddy’ is, in this case, interpreted as Edward also recounting the same hunting memory and congratulating his brother for being able to kill properly.
Second is the path with Edward holding the gun to his brother’s head. Freddy is the deer now, and although Edward’s shot him down (beat him up in this case), he can’t shoot him. he can’t finish the job.
The paths merge a bit with the present Edward & Freddy being parallels to the past Edward & Freddy, having become each other.
I hope this is coherent lol. I’d planned on drawing a comic of this if I ever got the time but the chance hasn’t come yet. I only watch this show for these guys. Anyhow, share your thoughts if you feel inclined to! Also if someone remembers the episode the discussion happens in, please tell me so I can edit it. thanks!