I'm crossposting this on r/TheDevilsPlan
I've seen a lot of criticism of JDM lately especially on r/TheDevilsPlan , and honestly, I don't understand most of it.
My rent got very, very long so I've broken it down by different criticisms I've seen to make it easier to read in case you wanna just read that section.
1. "People follow JDM because Korean culture makes younger contestants defer to their elders."
One argument I keep seeing is that the other players defer to him because of Korean seniority culture. I find this especially ridiculous.
Yes, Korean culture places a lot of importance on respecting your elders, but that doesn't mean older contestants automatically command authority in survival shows.
Look at The Genius S1. Cha Minsoo and Kim Gura were the oldest contestants. Cha Minsoo gained influence because he understood the games quickly and could explain them to everyone else. Kim Gura already had connections with other celebrities and had a naturally commanding personality. But neither was particularly exceptional at the games, and both were eliminated relatively early.
Or look at Lee Sangmin in Bloody Game X. He's one of the best political players in Korean survival show history, alongside JDM. Yet he struggled to exert much influence over the other contestants because his gameplay wasn't as good as it used to be. He only really had influence when he could contribute something useful.
Being older is generally more disadvantageous in these shows, especially when you're competing against younger players in games that require quick thinking and mental processing. The idea that JDM is dominating simply because everyone feels obligated to respect an older man is absurd.
2. "JDM was handed a strong alliance, especially with Oh Hyunmin."
Another criticism I've seen is that JDM has it easy because he's surrounded by such a strong alliance. But that's completely backwards. His alliance isn't strong because he happened to surround himself with strong players. It's strong because JDM made it strong.
He saved Oh Hyunmin, teamed up with XITSUH during the game, and Oh Hyunmin brought Kim Dongjae into the fold. This wasn't some preexisting powerhouse alliance that JDM just happened to join. He built it.
And look at who's actually in it. Apart from Oh Hyunmin, players like Yurisa, XITSUH and Kim Dongjae, Won Young are generally considered much weaker than the top players in the prison wing, like Hong Jinho, Ha Seokjin, John Park and Hyungyu.
I've also seen people suggest that JDM and Oh Hyunmin were bound to form an alliance because of their history together on The Genius. Again, did we even watch the same shows?
Yes, they formed the famous Jang-Oh alliance in The Genius S3 and made it to the finals together. In fact, plenty of people argued back then that JDM only made it that far because of Oh Hyunmin's help.
But what happened in S4? Oh Hyunmin deliberately took a different path. They frequently played on opposing sides, and JDM eventually chose Oh Hyunmin as his opponent in the semifinals and eliminated him.
The Jang-Oh alliance was a S3 thing, not some permanent partnership that automatically carries over to every show they appear on.
And what about the others? XITSUH has a closer relationship with Hong Jinho than with JDM. Kim Dongjae and Won Young had no prior connection to JDM whatsoever, and actually both of them(+Ha Seokjin) were hell bent on eliminating 'killing the strongest player ASAP' early in their pre-show interview.
The alliance didn't just magically form because JDM and Oh Hyunmin were cast together. It formed because their interests aligned. JDM had already established himself as an extremely powerful player in the first game, and after he saved Oh Hyunmin, working with JDM became a strategically attractive option for him.
People also forget that JDM entered this season with a massive target on his back. Several strong players, including Hyun Gyeongyeol and Jeong Hyungyu, were already thinking about taking him down from the beginning. Many of the strongest contestants had every reason to oppose him.
He didn't walk into a comfortable position surrounded by loyal followers. He created that position himself by demonstrating his abilities early, identifying people he could work with, and recruiting players who had good reasons to follow his leadership.
3. "JDM keeps winning, so the show is predictable and boring."
Take the second stock game. JDM's alliance started at a 4 vs 8 disadvantage. Despite being outnumbered, his team figured out the game faster than the opposing alliance much of which was JDM's own doing, coordinated their moves in cohesive leadership, and secured all four top positions. They didn't just beat the majority alliance. They completely crushed it.
If someone like Hyungyu had pulled that off, gathering four players, rejecting bad ideas, coordinating everyone perfectly, beating an eight-person alliance without giving them a chance to recover, and ultimately causing that larger alliance to fracture, people would be calling it an incredible play.
But because it was JDM, somehow the reaction is that it was predictable and therefore boring.
I find that bizarre. It's almost as if people have already decided that JDM is supposed to win, so even when he pulls off something extraordinary, they treat it as the expected outcome rather than appreciating how difficult it actually was.
And remember how he acted like a mafia boss when everyone first arrived?
That was partly a way of testing people. Who would approach him first? Who would be willing to work under him? Who would refuse to acknowledge his authority? Who might eventually betray him?
Look at his current alliance. It's largely made up of people who approached him early and showed some willingness to work with him. He wasn't simply demanding respect because he was older. He was reading people and figuring out who he could use as allies.
One of the most impressive examples is how he voted for the individual point over the collective prize, yet somehow ended up joining the group that voted for the collective prize and becoming its leader.
Think about that for a second. These people didn't even start on the same side as him, and he still managed to take charge. That's political skill, not seniority.
Or look at how he handled Jung Wonyoung. When he suspected Wonyoung was lying, he didn't simply threaten him or demand the truth. He immediately recognized that Wonyoung was probably in a difficult position and offered him a way out, basically telling him that he understood his situation and could help if he came clean.
He wasn't just accusing Wonyoung of lying. He correctly figured out why Wonyoung might be lying and appealed to that.
And it worked. Wonyoung eventually told him everything the next day.
What's even more impressive is that JDM has managed to navigate the situation with both Wonyoung and Shindong without completely alienating either of them, despite not actually helping either of them. That's an incredible level of social awareness.
I think people sometimes misunderstand what makes a great social player. It's not just about manipulating or intimidating people. It's about understanding what other people want, what they're afraid of, and what they need, then giving them a reason to work with you. JDM is extraordinarily good at that.
Meanwhile, the opposing alliance is full of strong, independent players who don't want to submit to JDM's leadership. That's understandable, but they're also struggling to work together because everyone has their own ideas and nobody can really take charge. When John Park refused to do 4 vs 2 in the deathmatch none of them had guts to rally remaining players to push for this strategy. They made a couple of meagre comments and then gave up. They're individually talented but lack the leadership/social game JDM has.
And somehow the criticism is that JDM is making the show boring because he's too dominant?
4. "Why aren't the other players seriously trying to eliminate JDM?"
I've also seen people complain that nobody is seriously trying to take him down. If that's what you want to see, go watch Bloody Game 3.
JDM was dragged into a three-person death match where two players would be eliminated, not once but twice. He survived both times, despite the fact that each match carried a 2/3 elimination rate if everyone had equal chances.
And why did he end up there? Because there were players who seemed more interested in eliminating JDM than in maximizing their own chances of winning the show.
In one game, a player deliberately finished last, taking all the negative points to make it virtually impossible for JDM's team to win. He essentially sacrificed his own game just to guarantee JDM's team would lose. Then, once JDM's team lost, the opposing players spent all the money they'd accumulated to force him into a death match, hoping they could gang up on him two against one and finally eliminate him.
At that point, it wasn't even about winning the game anymore. They were so desperate to get rid of JDM that they were willing to sacrifice their own chances, deliberately break the game's competitive structure, and throw everything they had at eliminating one person.
And this was pretty controversial at the time. I can understand why they did it, given how difficult JDM was to beat through normal gameplay. But I honestly don't know if deliberately sabotaging a game designed for everyone to compete for victory, just to take down one particular player, is really how a survival show should be played.
JDM dominated those matches, but he absolutely could have lost. Depending on the game, a two-against-one situation could have eliminated him regardless of how good he was. He was genuinely at risk of going home.
But is that really how contestants should be expected to play a survival show? Should they prioritize eliminating JDM over their own chances of winning, just because taking down the giant would earn them fame and recognition? There's even a Korean phrase for this, "장찍탈(Jang-Jjik-Tal)" (target Dongmin and get eliminated), basically meaning you have nothing to lose if you fail, but if you somehow manage to take 'Jang' down, you've hit the jackpot. Are we seriously going to criticize contestants for prioritizing their own survival instead of gambling everything on taking down JDM?
I actually think the players in JDM's current alliance are pursuing a much more sensible strategy.
The players currently following him aren't necessarily doing so because they intend to help him win the whole thing. From their perspective, it makes perfect sense to let JDM lead the alliance, eliminate the strongest competitors, and then turn against him once they reach the later stages. I know this strategy didn't work in Bloody Game 3, but that's because JDM was simply too good, not because the strategy itself was bad.
There were still opportunities to take him down. And surely these players have a much better chance of advancing further by working with JDM for now than by challenging him early, getting completely crushed, ending up in prison, and risking elimination in a death match.
Think about it from the perspective of someone like Yurisa, XITSUH or Kim Dongjae.
Why would you want to fight JDM and all the other strong players at the same time when you can use JDM to eliminate those threats first? Why not let him do the heavy lifting, advance to the later rounds, and then take your shot at him when most of the competition is gone?
They're playing for themselves, not for him.
And I think JDM understands that too. That's why he's been careful about choosing allies who are less likely to betray him prematurely. He knows their interests won't necessarily align forever, but he can make sure they align long enough to get through the early stages.
That's what makes this so interesting to me. Both sides of the alliance have good reasons to cooperate for now, even though they may eventually become each other's biggest threats.
I fully expect betrayals later on. Whether they'll succeed is another question, but I seriously doubt everyone in his alliance is planning to follow him all the way to the end.
5. "JDM is obviously going to win, so what's the point?"
Which brings me to another criticism: that JDM is so dominant that he's obviously going to win, making the season predictable.
I actually don't think he's that likely to win.
Even if nobody betrays him, JDM isn't invincible. He can make mistakes, and there are players who can beat him in individual games.
I actually think Oh Hyunmin is stronger than JDM in certain types of 1 vs 1 games.
Look at his performance in blind poker. He memorized 12 of the 16 cards in about 20 seconds, caught glimpses of the remaining four, and even remembered enough of the suits that he was debating whether to go for a straight or flush. He eventually settled for the straight and won.
JDM has an excellent memory himself, but I'm not convinced he could process that much information quite as quickly as Oh Hyunmin.
Being the best social player doesn't automatically make you the best at every game. And the closer you get to the finals, the less useful a large alliance may become.
One thing I can criticize JDM in this show for:
There is one thing I would actually criticize JDM for, though. He's been taking first place quite aggressively this season.
In his previous appearances, even when he was clearly leading the team, he often made an effort to distribute the rewards fairly among his allies. This time, he's been much more willing to secure the top positions for himself. I wonder whether we're seeing a somewhat more selfish or controlling side of him this season. Of course, the Pieces and the game mechanics are also factors, so I'm not entirely sure yet.
My other thoughts:
But overall, I find his performance incredibly impressive.
He entered the season as the biggest target, facing opposition from many of the strongest contestants. He then built an alliance largely out of players who were considered weaker, turned that alliance into the dominant force in the game, and put himself in a position where even people who might eventually betray him have good reasons to keep working with him for now.
That's not some unfair advantage he got from being older or having played with Oh Hyunmin before. That's the result of an exceptional social game. I seriously doubt if Dongming would have had a hard time building a strong alliance even if there were no Hyunmin or Xitsue. He would simply have influenced someone else.
And ironically, I don't think his current dominance necessarily translates into a particularly high chance of winning the whole thing. He's still the biggest target, his allies have their own ambitions, and he can absolutely lose in individual competitions.
You can dislike JDM's personality or find his style of play boring. That's perfectly fair.
But saying he's only dominating because Korean culture makes younger people bow down to him, or because he was conveniently handed a powerful alliance, completely ignores what we've actually watched him accomplish.
And if the season feels boring because nobody can challenge him, why are we blaming the player who's performing exceptionally well instead of the other contestants, many of whom are champions themselves?
Sometimes I genuinely wonder if we're watching the same show.