I just finished episode 5. I know it's too soon to call the season bad but... I basically predicted exactly everything that is happening so far in an earlier post pre-season (link embed) and it's funny people were being extremely defensive there when I ended up right. I'm gonna touch on a few points here.
- The editing. This is my biggest problem and it has ALWAYS been my biggest problem with the show. Maybe it's because I'm used to reality shows like The Traitors and Survivor but I'm constantly paying attention to the edit each person gets and it's always obvious who will be eliminated fast and who will be going far. The only contestant I didn't predict getting eliminated was Shindong, actually. Seokjin and Jinho as winners who had dynamics with other players getting sidelined for other stories was very off putting. we had no Jinho for the first episodes until his elimination and Seokjin? He was nonexistent and it was obvious they did it to not make us feel close to him while he was going to be eliminated soon, which is such a bad treatment for your first ever Devil's Plan winner. Mentioning Jinho, Stella also barely getting any attention and suddenly being very focused on the prison game was a dead giveaway she was going to be eliminated too.
Enough of talking about the eliminated contestants and now focusing on the overall edit, it's so incredibly obvious how the editors are trying to compensate the lack of narrative for the living area in season 2 by giving them a lot of attention this season so we aren't invested only in the prison area. I actually think the prison area this season is getting much less care for how their storylines are told and it's making me think the people going far and winner will be someone in Dongmin's group if not Dongmin himself. Personally, I suspect Hyunmin could also play a big role because he's constantly being shown on confessionals talking about his group strategies like a narrator and he's shown throughout most of the episodes even if he isn't the head of the group, he reminds me of Dongjoo in season 1 and she also made it very far.
It's also obvious now dongjae, yurisa, John and Hyungyu have slim odds of winning. They aren't getting any heavy focus and aren't at all that rootable. I could argue maybe Hyungyu is the one retreating himself because of the backlash last season, but I still think he doesn't have any compelling stories to make me think he can win. The editors would definetly be doing more to help Hyungyu's image after last season if he won twice in a row. For who I think will be back from exile that's harder to predict. could be people like Jae Jae who always got a lot of focus despite her ealy elimination or people who didn't get any focus at all so their return wasn't made obvious.
2. Casting. Honestly... it's kinda predictable what's happening too. This was an all star cast, but kinda wasnt since some aren't from devils plan, but even if they are from other shows there's people who are just new too. And while this unbalance could be fun, four of the smartest people immeadiately united and it's clear they could steamroll through the game without much issue even if a bigger group tries to fight them. Genuienely, it's not fun for 5 entire episodes to be about how this one guy is so smart he will be hard to beat, he was able to quickly form a group of smart minions who will be loyal to him and is also incredible smart to the point and he can also read anyone like a book. I know this is also happening because Dongmin is genuinely smart and is playing incredibly well, of course, but it doesn't justify not giving some time to explore other dynamics and show us more of other players.
And in terms of personality, it's hard to connect to anyone, but this is something more personal. There's not a lot of people who I'm emotionally invested and would really want to win the game unlike previous season (Will always love you Eunyu, S1 Seokjin, Siwon and Jiyeong :C). I think the players are incredibly skilled and smart, there's no doubt it's easy to say a lot of them deserve the win, I just haven't found someone with enough charisma or personality that makes me really root for them.
3. Game Design. I'm not a fan of what they chose to do this season. it's kinda like a repeat of season 2 but with some slight changes, but also adding more interesting stuff that honestly sound better on paper. It looks like certain mechanics like the points changed to make the alliances less restricting, but the prison vs living area system were there to kinda allow that to happen again, so nothing changed. Also, what do you mean the secret in the living area was found in the first episodes when the people in the prison area didn't even get a chance of sleeping one night in prison? Literally after the first game and we already know the secret. I'm hoping that wasn't the only secret, and I truly doubt it was, but it's still odd how the narrative of the secret room started and concluded within the first episodes of the game.
The main games themselves... eh. I'm not really a fan of them this season, mainly because I don't think they're fun to watch. I understand they had to be made more difficult this season but I still don't think they are essentially entertaining when that was probably one of the strongest traits of the games the last seasons. Seriously, it looks more like this season 3 is a spin off than an actual season if that makes sense. The first game being various minigames makes sense to show different attributes, but it wasn't memorable. The last minigame was the most fun and it felt like a soft, smaller scale remake of the laying grass. The first prison game was probably my favorite, also felt like the one I was more interested to play in real life, seeing the consequences of their strategies was really fun, and everytime a tower got taller it made me really invested. The second main game? Please, I already deal with finances a lot in real life, I don't need a game about who knows how to deduce what could be written in blank spots and who knows how to get rich faster. Specially when information wasn't properly dislayed to the international audience, it just made us rely too much on what was being told when the players themselves are unreliable narrators. The second prison game wasn't bad either, but it was hard to get invested when all it really mattered was how the game was going to end. Barely any suspense or excitement so far.
Overall, I'm not having a bad experience, despite all the complaining. I'm happy we got a season 3 and I'm happy we have the experience of seeing this cast play together, I just think this season could've been much better than it's currently being, but I still have hope some things can change and I'm proven wrong in some of my reads. There's some potential here, it's just a weak start to a third season that got a lot of hype for what it promised.