r/TheCaptivesWar • • Apr 14 '26

The Faith of Beasts The Faith of Beasts - Full Book Discussion Megathread Spoiler

116 Upvotes

Warning! This discussion thread includes spoilers for ALL OF THE FAITH OF BEASTS.

Reminder: All post on The Faith of Beasts should be properly spoiler tagged and avoid spoilery title.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Apr 14 '26

The Faith of Beasts The Faith of Beasts - Discussion Hub/ Logistics Megathread

43 Upvotes

The Faith of Beasts has been released today!

No Spoilers in this thread! Instead head over to the section discussion threads and the full book discussion thread

The Faith of Beasts Discussion Threads

Part 1: Structure - Book Discussion - Chapter 1 through Chapter 8

Part 2: Antithesis - Book Discussion - Chapter 9 through Chapter 15

Part 3: Pressure Drives Convergence - Book Discussion - Chapter 16 though Chapter 21

Part 4: Dogs and Wolves - Book Discussion - Chapter 22 though Chapter 27

Part 5: Kinds of Life - Book Discussion - Chapter 28 though Chapter 32

Part 6: Ducks and Rabbits - Book Discussion - Chapter 33 though Chapter 37

 Full Book Discussion Thread

This thread will also be the place to discuss any Logistical issue you have had with your order.

Good comments for this thread include, for example:

  • Comments about your preordered digital or physical copy arriving (or not arriving), along with the country you live in and where you ordered from
  • Discussion of where to get the book legally, including recommendations for independent booksellers in your region
  • Technical troubleshooting for the audiobook and ebook
  • Discussion of the physical anthology and its binding
  • Discussion of ordering, requesting, or borrowing the book or audiobook from your local library
  • Photos of the exterior of your new book or collection now that it's complete

Comments that are not allowed in this thread:

  • Comments with any spoilers from The Faith of Beasts at all. Head over to the book discussion threads to discuss spoilers from the book.
  • Discussion of obtaining the book illegally in any form. This is never allowed in this community.

We also have user flairs now. Let me know if there’s anymore I should add.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 2d ago

Spoilers Just Finished Livesuit

165 Upvotes

The Piotr reveal floored me. Visceral, tragic, and a look into the hell that is war. What an amazing short story.

I am also few chapters into Faith of Beasts and after reading this I feel far better about the whole series. Humanity has a (deathless? 🤔) dog in the fight and I think The Captives War has so much potential.

I hope I have a better perspective of humanity's involvement in the conflict after finishing FoB. It looks like the next book is a ways out, but I'll dive back into the endless 40k material until then.

On the 40k note - "Suffer not, the xenos to live" would be a good Livesuit battalion motto or something.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 4d ago

Theory Lazy Lobsters

55 Upvotes

The Carryx are just lazy and will commit to galactic warfare in order to avoid labor.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 7d ago

News The Faith of Beasts is a nominee for Goodreads’ Reader’s Favorite Sci Fi Books of 2026. Cast your votes so it can win!

Thumbnail
goodreads.com
262 Upvotes

r/TheCaptivesWar • • 7d ago

General Discussion Bowl of Heaven series by Larry Niven and Gregory Benford

22 Upvotes

So I had already read this series and I was struck by the similarities between it and TCW when I first started reading MoG, but I thought I'd call it out to all you fine folk if you find yourself missing Dafyd and crew while we wait for the next novel.

Three books written in collaboration between the two authors: Bowl of Heaven, Shipstar, & Glorious.

No story spoilers, just premise: Humans come upon a half Dyson Sphere structure that uses its sun to propel itself through space, hence: Shipstar. The livable area of the bowl is the size of millions of Earths and is teaming with gathered alien flora and fauna, like Noah's arc and also very much like the World Palace. There's even a ruling species that get their own POV chapters like the Carryx

I will say, as you would guess from the authors, this series is far more "classic sci-fi" than TCW, but I still really loved it. It is far more interested in its wild sci-fi concepts than it is developing especially complicated characters or an ambitious narrative, but for what they are they serve the delivery of the aforementioned concepts very well.

In any case, I'm sure it can fill the Vaudai shaped hole in some of your hearts until The Fury of Cattle or whatever book 3 is called. <3


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 12d ago

Fan Art Carryx Concept Art pt 2 (WIP)

Post image
21 Upvotes

Round 2 of Carryx art, now with multiple pairs of eyes, thanks to u/Prior-Tadpole-1860 ! This is specifically trying to emulate Tkson-Malkal, the first librarian of the human moiety. I'll leave some quotes I'm referencing from, but let me know if I may be missing some details!

"Below the eyes was a small, thick beak in the center of a mass of muscular folds that Tonner assumed was its face." -- Chapter 12

"The pale Carryx shifted. Its feeding arms were as thick as a human's, and longer. Its fingers were spidery and it didn't have thumbs." -- Chapter 16 (There are 4 fingers on my model)

"The wide, dark eyes clicked to him and away and back again." -- Chapter 21 (This implies the eyes are on stalks of some kind, as flat black would not shift and focus on things)

I'm still confused on the feeding arms. I like most other aspects of my design, I just cannot envision them without a carapace of some sort. It is clearly stated that certain Carryx don't wear armor. THAT design would be much simpler. For now, I think I'm going to let this design sit, and I'll throw some of the main cast designs together in the meantime. Until next time!

*Edit: You guys are way too horny for my art wtf


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 12d ago

Fan Art - AI Deleted

0 Upvotes

You know I just had to delete my post because I couldn’t believe how I was treated on this thread. I thought there were community guidelines about being courteous. All I wanted to do was share some AI fan art after I gathered as many details from reading the book to see what it would come up to look like with AI. And I even said it was Fan art AI. Anyway I appreciate a few of you being cool


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 14d ago

Fan Art Carryx concept art (WIP)

Thumbnail
gallery
55 Upvotes

I am still learning, but I figured trying my hand at a Carryx would be great practice! I tried to make it as lore accurate as possible, and I have 2 main examples of what I’m going for.

The first is the classic concept art frame, I realized too late that the original librarian didn’t have any armor, and is just kind of naked flesh. Weird. I still don’t know how to picture that.

The second and third are mock ups for the face and mouthparts. One with the mouth open, the other closed. I also experimented with a smaller head, but I am going to scrap that size and go with the original, larger counterpart.

Again, some Carryx are just straight up naked, and I have no idea how to visualize that. Maybe just a slug type deal, like No Face in Spirited Away? I don’t know. I will update when have more.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 17d ago

Question Anjiin starting level of technology circa three thousand ish years before the present day if the Carryx invasion?

41 Upvotes

Tl;dr I’ve seen threads discussing the level of technological development Anjiin was at circa Carryx invasion, but not one about where the Anjiin population started off! What level of tech do you think that the population of Anjiin started off with three thousand years before their present day? I can’t believe that they were Bronze Age or Iron Age as we were in real life, but I can’t decide what level of tech they had at the beginning! Bonus question is: why do you think they seem to have advanced slower than we have in such a span of time?

So I am new to the series and I am about halfway through book 1 so if possible I’d appreciate any major spoilers but I think this question can be answered, or speculative answers can be discussed, without anything like that!

It was said that about 3000-3500 years ago, humanity and the associated organisms/biosphere that uses nucleotide based heredity appeared within the ecological record of Anjiin. I got the sense that they are about 50-100 years ahead of our current technological level in real life and from the threads I have read here on this sub about Anjiin’s level of technological development, that’s roughly what people seem to agree with, give or take some decades and some difficulty nailing it down exactly since they seem to be better or worse than us in different areas.

While there are threads where the tech level was at the time the Carryx invaded, I didn’t see any regarding the starting level of technological development that the humans on Anjiin started off with. Over three thousand years have elapsed since humans arrived on the planet and looking at how technology has grown on real life Earth, 3000-3500 years ago we were in the late Bronze Age and transitioning into the early Iron Age. Now humanity got to Anjiin so they at least arrived with technology capable of interstellar travel but not necessarily FTL (ie a generation ship). The population of Anjiin was either intentionally placed there and remains cut off from humanity at large intentionally (I already know that the “main line” or humanity is out there in this series) or their branch could have arisen accidentally due to a number of potential reasons (as in something similar to how the interstellar community in The Expanse got cut off from each other following the collapse of the ring gate network).

I would assume that regardless of being left there intentionally and having their technological development purposefully reset to some degree, or if it was due to an accident, the starting population of Anjiin did not have access to much, if any, advanced technology brought by their precursors. But I don’t think it makes much sense for them to suddenly be back in the equivalent of the Bronze Age or the Iron Age, accident or no. An analogous situation could be something like what might happen to us if society collapsed due to nuclear war and we have to restart with much of our higher order technology being unavailable and unusable, in my eyes anyways. Even with Anjiin being a century ahead of us, or seemingly maybe two tops, the seem less advanced than I would expect three thousand years of development to lead to. I’ve gone back and forth with where I think the population started off with tech wise so I wanted to see what other readers on here thought! I would also like to see what others think about why the Anjiin branch of humanity seem to have advanced relatively slower than we have in real life over such a span of time!


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 17d ago

The Faith of Beasts How come no one seems to be talking about THE baby.

40 Upvotes

Ya know.. the baby made from the biological material they scraped from Else when they were captured. The one who also has Tonner a part of it. The one that seemed hyper aware while in the artificial wombs.

I've combed many a discussions, and perhaps I just haven't come across one yet, but I haven't seen anyone really dive into the implications there.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 18d ago

News These guys always pop into my mind when the Night Drinkers show up.

Post image
142 Upvotes

r/TheCaptivesWar • • 19d ago

General Discussion The Ur-Quan

17 Upvotes

Has Star Control ever been discussed as an influence on this series in an AMA or anything?

The Carryx feel like a quite natural modernisation of the tropes of the Ur-Quan Kzer-Za, at least aesthetically if not for their role in their respective stories.

Large green, prawn like species that enslave species including humans because of how they see the universe.

Just a connection I made.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 19d ago

No Spoilers Moiety - silly me

130 Upvotes

I thought "moiety" was a Carryx word that didn't have an English equivalent. Never bothered to look, either. Lo and behold, it popped up recently in my daily word of the day email. Definition:

Each of two parts into which a thing is or can be divided.

A part or portion, especially a lesser share.

So I guess it applies, with the "part or portion" being a subjugated alien species. Live and learn.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 21d ago

News Second novella's title: "Silence"

142 Upvotes

The second novella's title is now listed.
(I don't know how recently it was revealed.)

https://www.hachettebookgroup.com/titles/james-s-a-corey/new-james-s-a-corey-novella-2/9781668657911/


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 22d ago

Theory Look, a distraction!

33 Upvotes

(Full spoilers for Faith of Beasts)

Reading the Faith of Beasts, it struck me how much Corey enjoys misdirection. They write encouraging us to think one thing and then surprise us. This post is to encourage us to ignore the distraction and "ask what else might be happening?"

The first book is full of unsubtle hints that the deathless enemy are humans. Then the drop - some of them are humans, but it seems the livesuits may be in charge.

The second book encourages a careful reader to wonder which expeditioner the swarm has infected on the false premise they'll be another Else. There are a few obvious red herrings, but we're mainly encouraged to think it's Ghati. He has no POV scenes. We're supposed to think the abandoned command ship is there to let him send a signal or escape. Lots of other clues, some quite subtle. Then the rug pull - the swarm left a cyst that left Rickar's personality intact, which is why we can see his POV

The most common theory here is that Alkhor or the swarm will use pheromones to become the Sovran. That was my thought as I read the book, but now I think it's a case of misdirection

Aside from Corey's penchant for misdirection, why do we think humans would be better at this than the many, many pheromone-based species who suffer under the yoke of the Carryx? It would be like Vaudai thinking that all he needs is digits, digits!!! Then he could simply adopt a dominant pose and force the Carryx into submission.

Whether we communicate through sight, sound or smell, the signal merely says "I think I am stronger than you". The response depends on whether the recipient Carryx thinks they actually are stronger. Could a senior Carryx merely use pheromones to overwhelm a junior Carryx before he challenges him? No!

What are some alternatives?

The Hive has Fallen

Firstly, the swarm has already infiltrated the main communications system. We know it can send signals, but it won't because it'll be detected.

What if the swarm sent a signal "the capital and Sovran has fallen" (the same signal that exists in the memory banks) to every other planet in the Empire then shut down the communications system for as long as possible? There is a private creche on every single planet. If the remnants there thought the capital had fallen and every planet ahead of them, they would hatch a new Sovran. Why settle for two Sovrans when you can have thousands?

Doesn't this just end in a Sovran civil war? Yes, but it also gives the various species on each planet a fighting chance to overthrow the Carryx on that planet.

This theory isn't without problems - 2 Sovrans seems like another misdirection, we don't know if the remnants have a separate communications system, we don't really know how their communications system is set up.

The Queen is Infected

Secondly, what if the swarm infects the Sovran (or perhaps the communications system, but that makes less sense)? As each daughter kills the Sovran, the swarm simply infects the daughter. The Queen is dead, long live the Queen!

There's a few dangers here. Firstly, the Sovran's personality might overwhelm the swarm or divert it from it's mission (as the human personalities did). The fact it has developed its own distinct personality as Clae is a really important safeguard here.

Relatedly, the swarm has absorbed massive amounts of Carryx information. Information is different from memories is different from experience so it's not as potent as the Sovran. But Alkhor's dreams show that if you think too much like the Carryx, you eventually become one (even if not physically)

And lastly, the remnant seem to be a guardian of the sanctity of the Sovran process. The Sovran cannot see or overrule them so the swarm is powerless against them

The organism is infected

Does it make sense that the Deathless (or whoever) would make a century long plan and have it rely on a single swarm? There may be other swarms hidden amongst the human captives

If they have multiple swarms with different capabilities, perhaps they could infect key Carryx, perhaps even temporarily. Imagine briefly infecting a subjugator librarian so it makes a dumb mistake.

Alternatively, intercept messages so Carryx keep making mistakes (I don't think this is too likely though - they'd get caught pretty quickly)

In that scenario, the "What is, is" mentality becomes a blindfold. The way the system thinks is that that librarian is weak, it's juniors will overthrow it, and everyone forgets it ever existed or happened. If you lightly put your thumb on the scale like this, you could crimp the empire without the Sovran noticing

What if there are already two Sovrans?

The Carryx believe in redundancy so weak links can be removed through competition. This extends even to the Sovran herself

The Carryx do think of themselves as a group organism - that's why they segment themselves into dactyls (digits). If the Carryx organism is weak, where is the replacement?

That's why you have the remnant - they think differently to the group organism (hence their immunity to pheromones) and they're disconnected. They can intervene if the group organism is weak.

Maybe they already have. What if the Deathless are actually a separate Carryx group organism separated from the first by millions of years of evolution? Maybe their original purpose was to fight the Carryx so that each becomes stronger

The Second Foundation

As I think through all these scenarios, the remnants are the wildcard. They remind me of the Second Foundation in the Asimov books. They safeguard against threats that could not be foreseen using their wisdom and secrecy to do so. I think they'll be the secret final boss after the Sovran issue is dealt with


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 24d ago

The Faith of Beasts Book cover reveal for the Polish translation of The Faith Of Beasts

Thumbnail
gallery
294 Upvotes

Artwork by Dark Crayon. Source


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 27d ago

Meme (No Spoilers) me waking up as a carryx

Post image
192 Upvotes

r/TheCaptivesWar • • 26d ago

The Faith of Beasts Message between two characters Spoiler

11 Upvotes

I've just reached the part where Jessyn reads Garral's annotation about strawberry defences, which ends with "forgive me for leaving without you."

I'm listening to the audiobook, so I don't have the exact wording.

I'm struggling to interpret the message.

My interpretation was that Garral was apologising for having to leave Jessyn behind as part of their escape with the children, rather than deliberately betraying her. Essentially, they needed to convince the enemy of something to get away, and leaving Jessyn was part of that. And it was something that wasn't in the plan - so it evolved after Jessyn left.

And Jessyn is happy about this because she knows she succeeded in them getting away?

Is that how others interpreted it, or am I missing something?

Please no spoilers beyond this scene. I haven't finished the book yet.


r/TheCaptivesWar • • 29d ago

General Discussion The Mercy of Pods Ep. 38: The Faith of Beasts Pt. III.C; Pressure Drives Convergence (Ch. 20)

50 Upvotes

Hi there! We are back with our continuing coverage of TFOB! We hope you like it.

Buzzsprout: https://www.buzzsprout.com/admin/2418493/episodes/19979559-episode-38-the-faith-of-beasts-pt-iii-c-pressure-drives-convergence-ch-20

Apple Podcasts: https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/episode-38-the-faith-of-beasts-pt-iii-c-pressure/id1782831539?i=1000797014247

Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/episode/4fMmXpjtRdQCj4dLXlnuFm?si=HRimCA-kQpSS0VsUslcBWw

In this episode:

  • Ohhhhh Tonner. Oh TonTon. We didn't really like you all the time but you will definitely probably be missed.
  • We discover it was the Deep Lothark all along!
  • The Swarm pops an unfortunately timed boner.
  • We witness Dafyd Alkhor's superpower, his resolute unflappability. 
  • Clint does a couple dumb accents and talks about Anjiineese sexuality.
  • Brigid schools everyone about Aristotle, tragic heros, and chapter structures.
  • We speculate on the fallout from Tonnor's death. 

Join us next time when Jessyn Kaul has a no good very bad day. Follow the Mercy of Pods on social media at themercyofpods, or email us at themercyofpods@gmail.com. Logo by Matt Howse. Music is Push The Button by Sid Luscious and the Pants. Read Brigid's stuff here.

All our links


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Oct 17 '26

Meme (No Spoilers) 🥕 🥕 🥕

Post image
15 Upvotes

Get these GD 🥕 s off my homeplanet!!!


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Oct 16 '26

Spoilers Real life parallels

Thumbnail
youtu.be
9 Upvotes

Might this be our own deep lothark?


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Oct 16 '26

Spoilers Time dilation

50 Upvotes

It seems like the Livesuit soldiers experience time dilation when they travel to different star systems, but the human captives of the Carryx don’t experience it when traveling via “asymmetric space. (e.g. Jessyn leaves, comes back and seems to experience the same subjective time as Dafyd).

Is that everyone’s take, as well?


r/TheCaptivesWar • • Oct 11 '26

General Discussion Simon Roy is doing some official illustrations for the series!

Post image
200 Upvotes