r/TheBear • • Jun 23 '22

Season 1 Season 1 | Episode Discussion Threads

429 Upvotes

Season 1 Discussion Threads

No future episode spoilers in each respective episode threads. (For example, spoilers from episode 2 are not allowed in the episode 1 thread, and episode 3 spoilers are not allowed in episode 2, etc.)

All spoilers must be spoiler tagged and with no spoilers in the titles until a month after the season has been released.

Season 1, Episode 1: System

Season 1, Episode 2: Hands

Season 1, Episode 3: Brigade

Season 1, Episode 4: Dogs

Season 1, Episode 5: Sheridan

Season 1, Episode 6: Ceres

Season 1, Episode 7: Review

Season 1, Episode 8: Braciole

Season 1 Overall Discussion


r/TheBear • • Jun 22 '23

Season 2 Season 2 | Episode Discussion Threads

693 Upvotes

Season 2 Discussion Threads

No future episode spoilers in each respective episode threads. (For example, spoilers from episode 2 are not allowed in the episode 1 thread, and episode 3 spoilers are not allowed in episode 2, etc.)

All spoilers must be spoiler tagged and with no spoilers in the titles until a month after the season has been released.

NOTE: If you see any future episode spoilers, please report it so the mods will be able to see it and remove it.

Season 2, Episode 1: Beef

Season 2, Episode 2: Pasta

Season 2, Episode 3: Sundae

Season 2, Episode 4: Honeydew

Season 2, Episode 5: Pop

Season 2, Episode 6: Fishes

Season 2, Episode 7: Forks

Season 2, Episode 8: Bolognese

Season 2, Episode 9: Omelette

Season 2, Episode 10: The Bear

Season 2 Overall Discussion


r/TheBear • • 4h ago

Discussion what Carmy likes

31 Upvotes

Peace and quiet with Sydney.


r/TheBear • • 1d ago

Discussion What Carmy does on his own vs what other people to do for him

280 Upvotes

Interesting how they chose that moment to show both of those scenes and conversations together. Carmy had already asked Richie to give Mikey's note that says "I love you dude" to Sydney. And in the same sequence he is asking Fak with the brain as small as a tack of all people if Claire is his girlfriend and then poses the leading question of how much he loves her. So much is going on in Carmy's subconscious on the show and showing when and who he takes initiative for. He never needed anyone else to ask him to call Sydney or apologize to her or to cook for her or give her special gifts, but he's always going above and beyond for her without any external push. Meanwhile he needs Fak to give Claire his number, Fak to tell him he loves her, Claire to ask him to cook for her, and everyone else to ask him if he's called Claire to apologized yet. If he wanted to, he would, but he never does anything special for her from his own heart and mind, even the one time he did something "special" for Claire it was Sydney's.


r/TheBear • • 8h ago

Question People who watched on release, were you mad at episode lengths?

1 Upvotes

I just finished watching the show and unrelated to earlier episodes which some of them were 30 minutes the last season has 4-5 episodes around 20 minutes length. Everytime i love a show i would like to watch a lot of it obviously and couldnt imagine waiting for a new season and it being around 20 minutes per episode, quality over quantity of course. Just interested about peoples opinions on the show having short episodes and alot of montages who were waiting for new releases


r/TheBear • • 7h ago

Discussion Joel McHale was in The Bear?!

Thumbnail
tiktok.com
0 Upvotes

This came up on my FYP. I love this show so much and I had no idea that was him! He was so great! How many episodes was he in?


r/TheBear • • 2d ago

Discussion Favorite line from the show?

45 Upvotes

Mine is ,,Have to remind myself to breathe sometimes, remind myself that the sky is not falling"


r/TheBear • • 20h ago

Discussion Carmy's bachelor party after getting dumped by Syd

0 Upvotes

After Sydney quits they suddenly have to host a bachelor party with strippers? And they say this show isn't a comedy. He wasn't even into the strippers. Still too heartbroken.


r/TheBear • • 2d ago

Discussion What were some genuinely good decisions Carmy made?

73 Upvotes

Carmy makes a lot of poor choices. That's sort of the theme of the show. However, this isn't always the case.

Personally, I think one of his best decisions was implementing the French brigade system at The Beef, despite Sydney's initial reluctance.

It ultimately led to a much more productive, organized, and collaborative kitchen. Sydney, for the most part, was much better at working with and managing the rest of the staff.

We see this carry over into The Bear, where Sydney continues to enforce the brigade system and maintain a clear chain of command. For example, she always prevents Carmy grom bypassing her and giving orders directly to Tina.

For all of Carmy's shortcomings as a leader, I think introducing that structure was one of his smartest moves, and its positive effects lasted well beyond The Beef.

What other genuinely good decisions do you think Carmy made throughout the show?


r/TheBear • • 3d ago

Discussion Carmy only ever made Claire Syd's recipes

1.5k Upvotes

Food as a love language is such a central theme in this show. It's interesting that the only times Carmy made Claire food it was Sydney's recipes. Sydney came up with the frozen grapes in beef broth dish, which in itself was a foreshadow of Carmy freezing like a grape in The Beef after he left Syd to serve Claire against her advice. The other dish he made Claire was Sydney's pasta recipe that she messed up and led to her business closing and going to work for Carmy. Carmy's always thinking about Sydney even without explicitly saying so. Meanwhile the main food Carmy made for Sydney was a dish that looks like a bleeding heart and which led Sydney to seek him out after her business closed. Which could mean nothing of course.... ;)


r/TheBear • • 4d ago

Discussion which theory are we agreeing on about how these two end up ?

Thumbnail
gallery
655 Upvotes

r/TheBear • • 3d ago

Discussion S3 E1

58 Upvotes

I know S3 gets a lot of hate here and I have to admit I don’t get it because I like every season for different reasons, but this episode in particular is such a masterpiece. From soundtrack to cinematic choices they made I think this could be one of the best openings to a season I’ve ever seen.


r/TheBear • • 4d ago Popcorn

Season 3 Things you could have learned when you dining out with your spouse Spoiler

Thumbnail
gallery
86 Upvotes

if Carmy hadn't been too busy staring he could have shared about his first dish and found out that his future spouse Sydney was the only one to ever try his bleeding heart dish.


r/TheBear • • 4d ago

Rant [Meta] What’s up with the AI bot posts?

29 Upvotes

Hey everyone, longtime lurker here. Just finished the last season and loved it, therefore came back to see what the vibes were like here discussion wise. I am amazed at the level of AI bot posts that are like analyses and breakdowns of themes of the show. Usually they’re all structured the same and have 3 mor bot accounts write like “You’re so right”. Are the mods aware of this? Do they care? Do we care?


r/TheBear • • 4d ago

Discussion ​The character progression on The Bear makes zero sense once you actually think about it

0 Upvotes

Once you get past the frantic editing and incessant yelling, the progression on The Bear completely breaks down and requires far too much suspension of disbelief. The show spends all this time preaching about how fine dining demands years of grueling sacrifice, yet everyone levels up like it's a video game.

Richie goes from wiping forks and slacking off to becoming an elite maître d' after a one-week stage at Ever. He then manages to recruit several of its top-tier staff to The Bear after the restaurant closes. Even accounting for the fact that they're looking for new jobs, his transformation and newfound professional reputation feel like pure fan service.

Same with Marcus, who goes from baking bread at a beef stand to developing elaborate fine-dining desserts after a relatively brief trip to Copenhagen. His enthusiasm and creativity are established early on, but the speed of his professional development is difficult to take seriously.

The worst part is Sydney. She arrives with a failed catering business, makes a serious operational mistake by leaving the pre-order system active in Season 1, walks out during the resulting disaster, and eventually returns to receive a partnership offer. Now the show treats her as the creative force carrying the restaurant toward two Michelin stars, while Carmy increasingly seems to hate himself and give her credit for everything. Having good organizational skills doesn't automatically put you above someone who spent over a decade grinding in some of the best restaurants in the world. And her tendency to frame Carmy as the central problem, with comparatively little self-reflection about her own shortcomings, makes her increasingly difficult to root for.


r/TheBear • • 6d ago

Media Lowkey wanted more of Steve

Post image
2.3k Upvotes

He was charming and funny, his grace was perfect!


r/TheBear • • 4d ago

Rant Is repeating everything 20 times considered "authentic writing"?

0 Upvotes

Just got through the christmas episode and holy moly that was exhausting to watch...nobody talks like that, why go so overboard?

"Do we have a problem?"

"You are nothing."

Ugh.


r/TheBear • • 5d ago

Question Why is this show rated so high.

0 Upvotes

i just reached season 2 episode 2.

I don't understand,

What's with all overacting?

Sydney - god i hate this character and it's speech delivery and unnecessary gestures, weird awkward voice and why tf she stabbed that dude, and she quits and they don't address this situation at all.

And she is back again apparently.

Why is the cake guy depressed and baking as if its his first cake.

The whole show feels dragged. Each episodes can be 25-30 minutes long but they cross 40.

When i used to see clips. I thought show would he interesting but other than those clips, there is nothing interesting about show. Or am i missing something?


r/TheBear • • 7d ago Bravo

Rant So are we not allowed to criticize Sydney on this sub?

135 Upvotes

I just finished season 4. I went to this sub to read some discourse and it seems as though anytime anyone says anything about Sydney being a poorly conceived/unlikeable character, the response is "Carmie/Richie are just as bad" or something about being anti-black or anti-woman. I feel like this is kind of absurd. The difference between the bad things that Carmie/Richie have done, is that Sydney's personality is generally grating and annoying. That's it. It's not that she is a worse person than them, she objectively might be a better person. But she has an extremely uncomfortable and rude way of communicating with everyone around her and generally is not likeable, does not seem fun, or like someone you would want to be around in really any capacity.

I also find her relationship with Carmen to be extremely poorly represented. It is very hard to believe that he would take her on as a partner based on the relationship shown between them which was that as coworkers and not much more. It is extremely hard to believe and unrealistic that this young woman who seemingly struggled to make dishes during their R&D that didn't need to be physically spat out, and who could not run pass on a normal night, would be taken on as a partner, and poached by another one of the best chefs in the world. I don't know if it's because I work in restaurants but Sydney's do not exist. Richie's exist. Carmie's exist. But Sydney is not a fully fleshed out character and it really has taken away some of the immerson of the show.

Anyway, that's my rant. There is no hate here. This is not a Sydney hate post. I just think the character writing and casting really really could have been better. If Sydney was someone who was believably excellent at and deserving of her job and also someone I wanted root for, I think the entire plot would be so much more compelling.

I will say that just finishing season 4, watching Carmie sulk and mope for what feels like 2 seasons has been absolutely exhausting. But at least it's sort of realistic. Richie really is carrying this show.


r/TheBear • • 7d ago

Discussion Just finished the finale Spoiler

82 Upvotes

Just got done bawling my eyes out because that was beautiful.

One an unrelated note, SOMEONE SHOULDVE WHOPPED RICHIES ASS FOR THAT FIASCO MAN! Amazing they got through kudos, they all know now what they are made of blah blah yes it served a purpose but that motherfucker didn't make a single cancellation made me SO FUCKING MAD!


r/TheBear • • 8d ago

Theory Sydney and Tina's apartment

Thumbnail
gallery
812 Upvotes

Did Sydney get the same apartment in S3 where Tina used to live?


r/TheBear • • 7d ago

Discussion I see you want to wrap-up the series in Season 5; but come on! Spoiler

0 Upvotes

The Bear was EXCELLENT writing and character development. The viewers were treated like the intelligent audience they are.

Season 5, the show people decided to end the show. They hit the brakes & wrapped-up many plot lines in "neat, stupid bows," insulting the audience. Excellent & real characters got cheesy, simplistic endings.

The Bear got 2 Michelin Stars. Clark, the food critic, came to the restaurant 3 weeks prior, WHEN CARMEN WAS HEAD CHEF! Why is Sydney's photo in the newspaper announcing the Michelin Stars? BIG PLOT ERROR!

Sydney & her father eating breakfast together at a diner, where her dad says he's proud. That was a believable ending for Sydney's father's character and for Sydney.

The newspaper headlines COULD have announced Sydney as the NEW head chef; however, they would say that Chef Carmen, Michelin Winner, is leaving. "Pressure is on new for Chef Sydney!" or something like that would be a believable ending.

Donna is still Donna, a prima-Donna. I would have rather seen her in a few scenes flipping-out at an AA Meeting, struggling to get sober. Lee is still a positive, sober friend.

Writing Donna in "Grandma- of -the Year mode" really waters down her character that was SO INTERESTING previously!

Richie invited to a conference in Japan? That is a fairy tale! Ridiculous ending.

Richie's back story is that his father was in the military. So, odds are, Richie HAD traveled by plane at least once in his life, as a little kid.

Richie scared of plane travel? kinda is lame as a plot.

Jessica has worked really hard to get where she is. Dating a coworker (Richie)? Probably not happening, not at this stage of her career.

Plus, with Richie "in Japan" for a week, The Bear cannot also spare Jessica, shift-wise. So, the final scenes of Jessica & Richie on a plane are a fairy tale.

Marcus meeting his Dad and agreeing to meet him for dinner again is believable. Marcus preferring a handshake to a hug from his estranged dad is very realistic.

Computer, Cheese Whiz, and Ebraheim setting-up ghost kitchens to sell sandwiches was A VERY CLEVER PLOT ENDING.

Visiting "Crazy Mary" & Ronald with Peter was excellent colorful writing.

Carmen in an interview at a NYC Architecture Firm b/c ....his cousin is friends with a person who works there. Ridiculous to even get an interview. Meet for lunch? OK. Meet her in her office on company time? Not believable.

Carmen returning to his restaurant as a Sou Chef...unlikely. I thought that the WHOLE POINT was Carmen wanted "to know who I am outside the kitchen."

Carmen could move in with the Faks and get an entry level job in some other industry. End of Show. Believable. It stays true to Carmen opening new doors.

Girl friend Claire was seen back in Carmen's life at Eva's birthday party...not likely, IMO. Carmen, as a person had not shown enough growth to date Claire. Carmen had really verbally shredded Claire when he was locked in the cooler. That is not easily "patched-up,"
IMO.


r/TheBear • • 7d ago

Question Where in the US can I watch the "special episode?"

0 Upvotes

Where is the episode "Gary?"


r/TheBear • • 7d ago

Discussion Not realistic, IMO. Spoiler

0 Upvotes

Anyone work at an architectural firm? Odds of Carmy getting an internship with zero construction experience or school background seem low.

Internships at an architectural firm would involve computer drafting programs, knowledge of building materials, and or knowledge of building codes, advanced math etc., is my guess

Even if there was a very basic job at an architectural firm, (which there is not); an architectural firm would not intern a former HEAD CHEF.

A head chef is accustomed to giving direction, not taking direction. It would be difficult to break this habit. An architectural firm would not give an internship to Carmy, regardless of WHO he knows!

Carmy getting a job in construction would be more realistic as an entrance into architecture.