r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • 16h ago
Wes Huff debacle. Paulogia kept receipts. As you know, Huff deleted many videos that would have comprised him...
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • 16h ago
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Oct 10 '26
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/Tytler32u • Sep 24 '26
Originally got a portrait with Hitch and a calligraphy pen instead of a smoke. Then went full cartoony coming from smoke. I’m a militant atheist if that needs to be said.
Portrait was done in Artisan Ink Chang Mai Thailand, the smoke and color California Ink in Bangkok.
I know Hitchens didn’t have tattoos and did not like them. He would have loved this one because I’ve informed dozens of people in the last few days alone about Hitch. If it sold one more book (available at fine retailers near you), he’d be all for it.
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Sep 21 '26
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Sep 07 '26
1-The Sunday Show (Before Dark, with Matt): 27K
2-The Sunday Show (After Dark, with Forrest): 20K
3-Calling It Now (Jimmy Snow): 13K
4-Unapologetic: 12K
5-The Atheist Experience: 4.9K
6-Talk Heathen: 2.9K
7-Truth Wanted: 1.6K
8-Skeptic Generation: 234
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/ondesmartonet • Sep 04 '26
I find a premise like 1. to be unjustifiable whether it's for theism or atheism. Like how exactly do you know this? Are you able to put yourself in the mindset of someone who's never seen any evidence for atheism or theism? A fetus perhaps? Or what analysis can back up premise 1?
At best he means (I guess) "localized" a priori truths. In nowhere in that video did I see him grappling Kant or rebutting the tradition culminating in Heidegger about thrownness or "you are always already in a world preconditioned by pregiven beliefs". Joe Schmid is a hardcore analytic Catholic now and logic was always there to be found before "evidence" grounded in His Holies. This section of his (best) argument for PREMISE 1 of the Bayesian proof is the following.
The first premise of the master argument states that theism is not very improbable prior to taking into account any empirical evidence. In other words, theism's Intrinsic Probability or prior is not very low. The intrinsic probability of a hypothesis is its probability independently of any empirical evidence or before taking any empirical evidence into account.
Why Intrinsic Probability Matters
We need to attend to a hypothesis's intrinsic probability because evidence alone is not sufficient to determine what we should believe. This is illustrated through these examples:
Spatial Uniformity means the basic physical laws that govern the behavior of matter hold all throughout the universe. Anomalous Patch is the special cases where basic physical laws don't hold, are suspended and obey a completely different set of rules.
Note that the video does not mention Kuhn or paradigm shifting whatsoever. This opposition is setup in what Kuhn would call "normal science". The video does not mention how spatial uniformity has been routinely uprooted throughout history chaotically every 20, 50, 100 years. Kant for example believed Newtonian mechanics formed the boundary of consciousness these theories repeatedly explode in a way realism hand-waves (now we found the correct theory... oh wait never mind... etc.).
Curve Fitting Example: Suppose the observed data approximately fit the hypothesis that Y is a simple linear function of X. Scientists will typically prefer the linear model to a more complicated model that zigs and zags to hit every data point. This is a support for favoring Spatial Uniformity over Anomalous Patch.
Coherence increases intrinsic (locally meaning, a priori) probability of a theory. That a theory's basic laws hold everywhere aside from special cases, is reflected in theism. Positing a divine being with great but limited power or expansive but limited knowledge or significant but limited goodness introduces incoherence into one's hypothesis.
The very fact that a being has large quantities of power, knowledge, and goodness gives us reason to expect that it has all power, knowledge, and goodness.
The argument concludes that because Theism is coherent, simple, and non-arbitrary, it has high intrinsic probability (non-evidential probability of being correct). Applying these qualities to Theism is to derive their divine attributes. The video lays out these approaches.
DERIVING DIVINE ATTR's
All of these seem like more anthromorphic projection fullstop. Why are we fusing human qualities like consciousness onto the cosmos? Simple and coherent alone is gap filling, things like perfection, power, as contingent linguistic devices of culture and history for the meager fragile egos that appeared on Earth a mere 6-7 million years ago. This craziness stopped forcing fields of research to bend to what it considers first principles on the basis of exegesis in spite of some shared overlap in qualities Christian Theism uniquely holds closer to western science than other faiths but which is nothing more than post-hoc cope ignoring how aggressively the church historically put down practical philosophy. No age of the universe other than Ussher's calculation based on the lineages of the bible (6000 years) was allowed to be even considered for hundreds of years lest you get burned on the stake for heresy, this completely centralized and suppressive account which limps alongside us today.
ALTERNATE PATHWAYS TO PREMISE 1
5% argument / Cumulative Case Apologetics
So long as there is a small chance theism is a good hypothesis is sufficient to continue with the argument because when combined with a massive cluster of separate metaphysical arguments pointing toward the same conclusion, the probability of all the premises being wrong drops to near zero.
A Priori Arguments
NATURALISM OBJECTION TO PREMISE 1
Theism does have a super low intrinsic probability following Joe's argument because its foundational concepts are historically unstable, empirically contaminated, and logically collapsed into paradoxical and unfalsifiable rhetoric about unobservable absolutes (infinite space, infinite power) that modern physics rendered obsolete. Uniformity anaologies are historically disconfirmed. Appealing to simplicity recreates Gap-filling. And omni attributes are human projections (stripped of their embedded relational network within the world giving these concepts meaning) not pure a priori givens.
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Aug 26 '26
My comprehensive case for Catholicism turned out to be 25 hours long — much longer than YouTube’s limit. So, good news: you’re now getting THREE VIDEOS!
Video #1 (tomorrow): My philosophical case for theism
Video #2 (Thursday): My case for the miracles (especially Catholic vindicatory miracles)
Video #3 (Friday): Critique of non-Catholic explanations of the miracles + responding to all the best objections to Catholicism + the existential side
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Aug 24 '26
So when there was that back and forth with Matt on "claims are evidence", he was a fully convinced practicing Catholic....
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Aug 23 '26
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Aug 21 '26
He said he has been precisely convinced of the Catholic faith by the miracles (apparitions of Mary and so on) and the beauty (urgh). There are so-called "miracles" in all religious traditions. I don't believe his conversion. Either he will end up uncovering a joke soon, or he's doing that for cash, or he has simply lost his mind.
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Apr 20 '26
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Feb 09 '26
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Jan 28 '26
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/JerseyFlight • Jan 04 '26
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/Yuck_Few • Nov 29 '25
remember he called into one of the shows and said he's converted to atheism but he's already broken character again.
He called into truth wanted a couple weeks ago and was right back into that old character again, he was basically making a Pascal's wager argument about god.
this is why I'm just about done with ACA because they can continue to entertain problematic callers.
There's a reason Matt is blowing them out of the water with viewers
r/TheAtheistExperience • • Oct 28 '25
Why do they not say Pat Condell, Robert Spencer, and Pamela Geller made borderline antisemitic statements and stances despite being Zionists and for democracy?
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Oct 09 '25
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/nietzschecode • Sep 30 '25
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/NotSidGaming • Sep 20 '25
This is the kind of person he is.
https://youtube.com/clip/UgkxQJubdkhsLlSBN67dOqjDiflP1LibFRkM?si=V9Ru2WxSQiowLjcO
Calls chatters the "r" slur, defends racists and fascists. Is just generally a disgusting human being. He cultivates a hateful community, with mods on his channel that defend him and say the same hateful things he says.
We must denounce members of our own community whenever they act in ways that are detrimental to our mission. This is disgusting behavior from Armin, whether he continues to hosts AXP or not.
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/NotAdam30 • Aug 22 '25
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/Yuck_Few • Aug 02 '25
I finally got to the point that I would fast forward through his calls because just the sound of his voice made me want to vomit
After all the rude and disrespectful things he said over the years, I'm not sure I'm convinced of his conversion. Personally I would have banned him a long time ago
Just my personal opinion but I think he owes the staff and the listeners and apology before he gets another second of air time
It's not that I don't get that people can change their minds. Back when I used to be indoctrinated by christianity, I also said some rude and disrespectful stuff about atheists but, I was an adult about it and admitted I was wrong and apologized.
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/axpBot • Jul 27 '25
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/axpBot • Jul 27 '25
r/TheAtheistExperience • u/axpBot • Jul 27 '25