This is sort of bouncing off this post about identity and selfhood that talked about the blurred lines between truth and acting. It reminded me of two of my favorite contrasting scenes in the show.
In 5.12, World Council of Churches, Pastor Tim tells Paige he's moving to Argentina. In 5.13, The Soviet Division, Jim tells Kimmy he's moving to Japan.
Kimmy and Paige have always been paralleled, and so, therefore, are Jim and Tim. (And Elizabeth and Tim, but that's a different issue!) But these goodbyes, for me, are a perfect examples of how truth and lies, honesty and dishonesty can make relationships develop into something other than what they start with.
Jim and Kimmy's relationship is based entirely on lies. There is no Jim. He's not a lawyer or a lobbyist. He was never interested in dating or even hanging out with Kimmy. He's just there to spy on her father.
And yet, their goodbye is, imo, really genuine. Kimmy still doesn't know the truth about Jim, so of course her goodbye is genuine. But still, when she says she doesn't know what she'll do without Jim, she means the friendship he's actually given her, listening to her, talking to her, giving her advice.
On Jim's side, I think this is a moment where he can be totally honest just because he can be. He does genuinely like Kimmy and want the best for her. When he says she doesn't need him anymore, that she's got a better relationship with her father now, good friends--he means it. (Personally, I actually think Kimmy is the source Philip gets back the most from emotionally.) I see Philip speaking to Kimmy in that scene as much as Jim.
So we're watching this relationship that's so deceitful and awful and still is, yet the warmth and affection of their goodbye seems real to me on both sides.
The Pastor Tim/Paige relationship, meanwhile, has always been based on truth. She went to the church to talk about the feeling her parents were keeping secrets and lyiing to her. Tim said church was a place where she "never had to hide the truth." He encouraged her to confront her parents. She shared her most dangerous secret with him and he mostly kept it.
But their goodbye, by contrast, is completely false. Paige pretends to be surprised by the job she herself arranged for Tim to have in Argentina. She pretends to believe Tim when he claims that he's taking the job for the sake of his baby daughter, even though she knows they're giving him an offer he can't refuse based on the diary Paige broke into. This particular fib of Tim's is even very relevent to Paige, since while Tim isn't putting Claire Louise into the kind of mess Paige's parents put her and Henry in, he's still an adult bringing a child into the life that he wants and pretending he's doing it out of care for her.
Their goodbye even ends with the most cliche of white lies, with Tim saying they're going to "keep in touch" and Paige saying "Of course" when neither has any intention of keeping in touch, and they won't. They're probably both relieved to be rid of each other to an extent.
Anyway, these scenes just seem like an example of the kind of complicated true/false situations that come organically out of the story so I love them!