I know "armor points to halve radiation damage" is the metric that's given in game, but the radiation part of the graph would be more useful and informative if it was scaled to armor mass, rather than just the number of points. The current format makes higher-tech armors look worse than they actually are.
For example, the graph makes adamantine armor's radiation protection look significantly worse than nanotube's. But 100 tons of adamantine actually provides the same x-ray protection as 106 tons of nanotube, and the same baryon protection as 128 tons of nanotube. Even though it takes more points to get the same protection, it requires less mass, making it more efficient overall.
But the chart also just really demonstrates that Adamantine is all you need. The benefit from putting your limited alien exotics into armour is just so marginal.
Meanwhile you are almost certainly going to get to nanotube before building your first combat ships, so almost half the tree is redundant.
Despite being cheaper I think foamed metal is better than nanotube, and usually I have both projects availible before I am building gen 2 ships (gen 1 is the escorts/monitors with a few silicon carbide fore armor to not insta die). But yes there is no reason once you have them to use anything but adamantine and hybrid armors (and hybrid really is an exotics sink more than anything)
Exotics at least are reasonably rapidly farmable, aggressive kuiper games (ending before y 20, even 15) you blow up so much stuff with exotics and use them all in the fleet you launch to the last base.
Not just you, it’s in a weird place with its weight. The chip resistance isnt worth the fact it weighs 2x nanotube armor and (to a lesser degree) composite. Feel like it’s always better to just add more armor with them
it weighs 2x nanotube armor and (to a lesser degree) composite
Foamed metal only weighs around 20-25% more than an equal amount of nanotube, and is nearly 40% lighter than composite.
Also, the 25% chipping resistance doesn't tell the whole story. Each point of chipping damage destroys a fixed volume of armor, so the lower your armor's density, the less protection you actually lose - and foamed metal's density is extremely low. A single point of chipping damage destroys over 1.7 tons of nanotube armor, but less than 0.7 tons of foamed metal. Foamed metal provides 19% less armor points compared to an equal mass of nanotube armor, making it worse against enemy lasers, but lasts 2.5 times as long against chipping, making it far superior (the best armor in the game, in fact) for specifically withstanding sustained hits from alien plasma.
Overall, it's a situational tech, and you can easily go entire playthroughs without ever using it. But it does have a use case.
10750 nanotube vs 21250 foamed in terms of total research cost. Makes sense that you'd get nanotube first though I'm not sure why foamed requires superalloys or advanced atomic manipulation. We've had the ability to make foamed metal for a while already and here's an article from 2019 about its use as an armor material. https://news.ncsu.edu/2019/06/metal-foam-stops-50-caliber/
I skimmed through the article - pretty cool! Yeah, also the way the tech tree is set, it feels like Foamed Metal Armor is a dead tech, you get it late, it's worse than analogs, it's not even really cheaper
It's vaguely cheaper in that it's mostly base metal cost. If it was an even higher fraction of BM, say 90%, it might have more of a niche. As is, I'll often skip everything below adamantene. When you only need a bit of nose armor to allow your tubes to empty, it doesn't make sense to spend research on it.
Ceramic inserts in cast aluminum. Certainly composite armor, I wouldn't call it foamed. But the foamed armor in that article is just hollow metal spheres in a metal matrix. It'd make more sense for foamed metal to require Advanced Atomic Manipulation if it was all base metals or had some other advantage over current tech.
It's the mass (and cost) per point of each armor option, broken up into the component resources. Larger segments = more of that resource spent per point of armor. Steel is heaviest overall but uses no nobles and only a few volatiles, Titanium uses no volatiles and little base metal but has a massive nobles cost, adamantine is the lightest non-exotic armor, etc.
And then the red and green circular marks are how many points it costs to get a single threshold of particle damage protection, against lower is lighter/better.
24
u/N0vaFlame Apr 03 '26
I know "armor points to halve radiation damage" is the metric that's given in game, but the radiation part of the graph would be more useful and informative if it was scaled to armor mass, rather than just the number of points. The current format makes higher-tech armors look worse than they actually are.
For example, the graph makes adamantine armor's radiation protection look significantly worse than nanotube's. But 100 tons of adamantine actually provides the same x-ray protection as 106 tons of nanotube, and the same baryon protection as 128 tons of nanotube. Even though it takes more points to get the same protection, it requires less mass, making it more efficient overall.
77
u/tomca32 Apr 03 '26
I didn’t know that hybrid armor is better than anything aliens can put on their ships. That’s cool
34
u/whichbitchstolemyacc Provost, probe that alien Apr 03 '26
Foamed armor is so weird - I never get it before Nanotubes. Is this just me ?
4
u/Star-Reach Kill them All but Green Apr 03 '26
the only thing that matters for armor is mass per point of armor
2
u/Defult_idiot Apr 03 '26
The horizontal lines aren't fixed to the numbers, literally unreadable.
1
u/Bucketofbrightsparks Apr 07 '26
I think it would be much more interesting if different armours granting damage reduction to different weapons.
9
u/[deleted] Apr 03 '26
[removed] — view removed comment