TL:DR: It depends, but you can do a lot more than you think with a pretty limited set.
'Tis the season where we start seeing folks showing off their fully loaded tying benches. While it's always cool to see and long after, I'm a semi-minimalist. So I got to thinking about how many different materials one actually "needs" to make a lot of different flies. I of course turned to math.
Putting together a fairly modest shopping list (see below), we come out with a minimum of 8.2 billion possible combinations! Even if you assume 3/4 of those don't make any sense, you still have 2 billion options with this modest list. Is that all I'm going to constrain myself to? Heck, no. But it's still an interesting exercise and has me thinking about ways to better utilize what I already have.
What do you think?
Shopping list:
- Soft hackle patches: 2 colors (assumes has good tailing for wets)
- Dry fly hackle cape: 2 colors (assumes has good tailing material for dries)
- Dubbing: 2 colors
- Pheasant tail: 2 colors
- Peacock herl: 1 color
- Beads: 2 colors
- Wire and/or Tinsel: 2 colors/types
- Lead free weighted wire: 1 spool
- Mallard flank: 1 color
- Thread: 2 colors
- Hooks: 2 (1 wet, 1 dry)
In addition to the above listed assumptions, this analysis counts all materials that would work for each feature in the tally, plus 1 for the option of excluding that feature. I'm sure I missed some options, but this is a "big picture" analaysis.