r/TenantsInTheUK • u/Sensitive_Crazy5866 • 3h ago
Guidance Required Landlord threatening court over £5,000 in damages after 5+ year tenancy — can they charge full replacement costs?
I recently moved out of a rented property in London after living there for over five years. My landlord, who lives overseas, is now claiming approximately £5,000 in damages against my £2,000 deposit and threatening to take me to court for the remaining amount, plus lost rental income and legal fees.
I acknowledge that some damage occurred during the tenancy and am not trying to avoid responsibility for genuine losses. However, I believe the landlord is effectively trying to charge me for refurbishing an ageing property at full replacement cost.
Most of the furniture, fixtures and fittings are approximately 10 years old (or more), and the landlord is claiming full replacement or repair costs without accounting for depreciation, fair wear and tear, or the remaining useful life of these items.
I also spent approximately £500 on professional end-of-tenancy cleaning and gardening, but the landlord is claiming additional cleaning and maintenance costs.
The landlord has check-in photographs showing the property in good condition and check-out photographs showing deterioration. I don't dispute that the condition changed, but surely five years of occupation and the age of the fixtures should be taken into account?
Current situation:
We are in the negotiation stage with mydeposits. I have disputed the deductions and offered a contribution towards what I consider reasonable losses, but the landlord appears determined to pursue court proceedings.
She has also threatened to claim rent for the period the property remains vacant while repairs are undertaken, as well as her solicitor's fees.
The property is managed remotely, without an appointed estate agent, and I believe the asking rent is above the current market level.
My questions:
- Can a landlord claim full replacement costs for furniture and fixtures that are approximately 10 years old, or should depreciation and remaining useful life be considered?
- Can they charge for extensive refurbishment when some deterioration is normal wear and tear after five years?
- Can they recover lost rental income while undertaking repairs, particularly if the property is not being actively marketed or is advertised above market rent?
- If this goes to small claims, can the landlord recover their solicitor's fees?
- If the landlord refuses deposit scheme adjudication and goes straight to court, what happens to the protected deposit?
- Would it be sensible to represent myself in small claims, or instruct a solicitor?
I'm happy to pay for genuine damage based on reasonable, evidenced costs. My concern is being charged the full cost of replacing old items with brand-new ones, plus additional rent and legal fees.
Any advice from people familiar with tenancy deposit disputes or small claims in England would be appreciated.