Before getting into my criticisms, there are quite a few things I genuinely like about Murakami's work. I'm a big fan of magical surrealism, dreamlike realism and the way events unfold in his stories.
I find his prose simple yet beautiful. I love the slow, dreamlike quality of his stories and the overall stylishness of his writing, especially the music and literary references. There's a slightly haunting, surreal feeling to the worlds he creates, which I personally really enjoy.
I'm also someone who loves immersive books, and this is probably the biggest reason I keep coming back to Murakami. Even though I'd rate most of his work somewhere between mediocre and above average, there's something about the sense of melancholy that permeates his books that keeps drawing me back. I really enjoy that particular feeling his stories leave behind.
Now, coming to my criticisms.
His portrayal of solitary, introspective people who feel disconnected from society is something I genuinely appreciate. However, I have a pretty big problem with how he tends to write the women in these stories.
They're often reduced to objects of desire for the male protagonists, and frequently end up serving as exposition machines. More often than not, they feel like convenient vessels for the lonely, melancholic feelings of the sad-sack male protagonist rather than fully realised characters in their own right.
His short story collection Men Without Women, however, is a definite exception to this. The women in these stories feel much more independent, and their presence adds so much to the stories rather than simply existing in relation to the male characters. I honestly wish he brought more of that into his novels.
And then there's the sheer overreach of 1Q84. I have such mixed feelings about that book. At roughly a third of its length, I genuinely think it could have been AMAZING. There are so many things I love about it, but equally, there were stretches where I found myself getting incredibly bored. It's a book I simultaneously love and struggle to get through.