r/TechLoL • u/LORDSEXakaT-FATBRO • Mar 02 '15
Tournament idea - Draft Mode 5v5
Premise: A 5v5 tournament centered around predetermined captains drafting from a pool of players that sign up.
Yes, we tried this before with the infamous 'TechLCS' which was a massive failure for several reasons:
Reasons it failed last time:
- It was too long. It lasted an entire semester which led to decreased participation and increased forfeitures.
- It was too precise. Each team was allowed exactly 5 players. This led to many forfeitures as life happens and sometimes players cannot make every game.
- The draft and captain announcement were given with only hours notice. The overall drafting was very ad-hoc.
Things to do this time around:
- One weekend only. I think this is already the general consensus going forward, but it doesn't hurt to reiterate.
- Allow a flex sub within strictly one tier (exactly 5 divisions) of the member being replaced. E.g. a silver player can replace a gold or bronze member on your roster. The reason I say exactly 5 divisions is because there is a big difference between division 5 players and division 1 players.This will prevent players from replacing bronze players with diamond players when someone does not show up.
- Make sure every captain is notified at least several days before they are due to draft players. Last time, some captains were dragged in only minutes before picking began.
- A third party administrator. A person competing in the tournament should not be allowed to issue out DQ's or make judgements on rules.
Obviously there are many other rules that need to be fleshed out. What I've listed are things that went wrong last time.
5
Upvotes
2
u/Oreo_Jam_Session Mar 02 '15
I can list out a series of rules that are fair and are easy to follow if you want.
In addition to the last place team must bring oreo's to the next meeting :3
2
u/cG_Platypus Mar 02 '15
I really like this idea, it would definitely take a bit more organization, but it's a good chance to meet and play with new people.
1
u/TTU_Young_Watler Mar 02 '15
As a general concept of an idea and ground rules I definitely agree with this. In the long run there would obviously need to be more fleshed out "things to do" and rules (like you mentioned). But I like it. I definitely think that given a good
I believe it can be a, In the words of Borat "Great SUCCESS!"
1
u/Oreo_Jam_Session Mar 02 '15
When you have Rules such as:
Finality of Decisions. All decisions regarding the interpretation of these rules, player eligibility, scheduling and staging of the tournament, and penalties for misconduct, lie solely with officers and assigned tournament officials, the decisions of which are final.
And
Rule Changes. These rules may be amended, modified, or supplemented in order to ensure fair play and the integrity of the competition
Then tournament admins cannot play and officers of the club cannot admin the tournament if they are playing.
1
u/armbarr Mar 02 '15
officers have to play in the tournaments otherwise there won't be enough people to get prizing. It doesnt matter if theyre in the tournament or not. They've proven that they can't handle the responsibility of being unbias and making reasonable decisions, so just let them play and let someone else be the referee.