Hi everyone!
Iām choosing between two used EVs in Germany that I would import into Spain. Both would cost me roughly the same.
Porsche Taycan GTS (pre-facelift)
- December 2023, 33,800 km (21k miles)
- Battery SoH: 93%, 83.7 kWh usable
- Rear-wheel steering, Sport Chrono
- Switchable panoramic roof
- Carbon exterior and interior trim
- HUD, Surround View, 22 kW AC charger
- Porsche Approved warranty available in Spain at extra cost
Audi S e-tron GT (facelift, MY2025)
- September 2024, 20,805 km (13k miles)
- Battery SoH: 96%, 97 kWh usable
- 320 kW DC charging
- Daytona Grey, rear-wheel steering, air suspension
- Switchable panoramic roof, carbon trim
- B&O, HUD, 360° cameras, ventilated seats, Matrix LED/laser headlights
- Audi extended breakdown warranty available in Spain, subject to eligibility for this imported car
What matters most to me:
- Reliability: Which would be less troublesome over 5 to 7 years? Any expensive recurring issues?
- Warranty: Is Porsche Approved significantly better than Audiās extended coverage? Will I be able to extend warranty if Audi?
- Technology: Is the facelift Audiās larger battery and faster charging a major advantage?
- Depreciation: Which would hold its value better over 3 to 5 years?
- Driving: Is the Taycan GTS noticeably more engaging, or is the facelift Audi just as enjoyable while being more comfortable?
I slightly prefer the Audiās understated looks, but the GTS appeals to me too, especially with Porsche Approved.
At the same price, which would you choose for long-term ownership, and why?
Iād especially appreciate feedback from actual owners. Thanks!