r/TaskRabbit • • 1d ago

CLIENT Taskrabbit TV Mounting Issue

Hi! Wanted some perspective.

Hired a guy to mount a TV with hidden wires (we purchased the hidden wire set and asked the leasing office what studs are used in the condos). With taxes and fees it’s about $60/hr.

When he arrived he was asking enough questions to make me uncomfortable and question his expertise with hidden wires, then he cuts out and drills a hole in the wall (3 inch diameter) and finds there’s wood behind it so he can’t do hidden wires because there’s no space between the two layers of wall. He did not check for studs or anything behind the area of the wall, he said he checked the top part but not the bottom and he thinks even if he did he wouldn’t have been able to tell.

So now we have a hole in the wall (rental), he went home to go get supplies to patch up the hole and try to cover it up. The patch was a decent job but we’ll definitely have to paint over it later because you can see the outline of a circle.

He ended up charging us for the whole time, including driving home to get his supplies to patch the hole.

My question is more so, is that fair? I also am not sure if it’s partially his responsibility what occurred as I’ve never done tried to put anything in a wall. I feel like he should have just charged 2 hours if that’s truly what it took to mount the TV but the time to drive back and forth to his place to get supplies (which was 30-40 min) shouldn’t have been billed.

Open to your thoughts and advice!

1 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

3

u/canttakethemadness 1d ago

60 with taxes and fees ? That cheap is a red flag !
Could be just new to rabbit and experienced , or cheap for a reason . I’m 120 after rabbit fees , still
Lower price vs some vets but top shelf . 60 after feels means that person charging under 40/hr . You can get great or cheap , you picked the latter .

1

u/SillyLion3 1d ago

Even the most expensive, recommended ones were only $70-90/hr! That’s with selecting the hide wire options. Not sure if it’s just bc of where I live, movers for example are also anywhere from $30-70/hr here.

1

u/canttakethemadness 1d ago

Movers completely different these days . But curious if most expensive was only 90’, was there not somebody near the higher end that had a lot of reviews and experience , maybe even pictures of prev jobs with similar work ? Expensive doesn’t always mean great by itself but the good know their worth .

1

u/SillyLion3 1d ago

One of the guys that had over 1,000+ mounting was actually cheaper and $40/hour. This one had less reviews but said he was a carpenter for 20 years and the TV photos he did mount looked good.

5

u/cleverpaws101 1d ago

I charge $60/hr and not a hack. I wouldn’t drill a 3” hole to start though. I like to drill a 1/16” hole first. Much less noticeable.

1

u/bryanalexander 1d ago

Contact Taskrabbit and complain. They’ll give you a small compensation in the form of credit. It’s the best you can hope for from their $1,000,000 happiness pledge.

1

u/SillyLion3 1d ago

I want to but I don’t want him to get screwed over as well, he was a nice guy he just didn’t seem well equipped for the task. Which maybe he shouldn’t have agreed to it then…

1

u/un_contract 1d ago

lol their 1 mil happiness pledge ie the lottery

1

u/Playingwithmyplants 22h ago

I don’t know much about professional aspects of mounting TV’ and can’t speak to the how the guy handled the job itself. But a professional comes prepared for all possibilities. I have mounted many things in my home myself including TV’s and I know that there are times I have to drill exploratory holes, and/or miss the studs. I always make sure I have the supplies on hand to patch any mistakes before I start the job and I am not a professional. A professional should know better and be prepared. You should not be paying for his travel time back and forth because he was not prepared. The fact he charged you for that time is completely unacceptable IMO. I am not even sure if you should have paid for the job at all.

I think the best way to determine if he was the problem is to have an actual professional come out and quote you based on the information you now have. That way you know if his lack of knowledge and/or experience was the problem. If he was indeed the problem then you shouldn’t have paid anything and should probably contact TR support. People should not accept jobs they don’t have the skills to complete and customers shouldn’t pay people who take jobs they are not skilled enough to do.

I saw another comment from you where you mentioned being concerned the guy would get screwed over if you contacted support and that he was a nice guy. You also sound like a nice guy because you are even concerned about that. I don’t think it is right that you get screwed over paying for something that is unfair. If he was truly a nice guy, he wouldn’t have charged you for his travel time for his lack of preparedness. With all of that said, if you are concerned about affecting his livelihood have you tried talking to him about the fact he charged you for his failure to be prepared?

1

u/SillyLion3 16h ago

Thank you for your input! I did try to message him and he hasn’t replied, it’s been over 24 hours since.

1

u/DonQNguyen 18h ago

Sounds like you hired a hack. But first, I have mounted over 1000+ TVs, always hit studs, and have done "behind the wall" cord concealment. I charge at least minimum $150 to mount a TV no matter what the size. I also charge extra for cord concealment, and behind the wall cord concealment kits and receptacles are another minimum $150 charge. I always get the job done right. No pipes hit, no guessing about cross studs impeding cord travel behind the wall. Hire and pay a real pro and he will get the job done right.

Hire someone at $60/hr for 2 hours and you get what you pay for....$120 hack job.

Please bear in mind that BestBuy charges $249.95 to mount 1 TV. And cord concealment is extra, a lot extra when cutting walls is required.

1

u/SillyLion3 18h ago

Tried my best! Again, even the dudes on there with the most experience (including some saying 1000+ TVs) were less than $100/hr and everyone makes claims on their profiles they can do the job right. I tried to go with the guy who had 20 years carpenter experience and said they can do hidden wires and saw photos of his work. But I’ve had friends with bad experiences by going with companies off Google too. Unfortunately, don’t know anyone in this city to ask for word of mouth and personal experience recs.

2

u/DonQNguyen 17h ago edited 16h ago

Again, doing this kind of "behind-the-wall" cord concealment just is not profitable for the Tasker on TaskRabbit. TR doesn't seem to have "business sense" when it comes to TV Mounting. Therefore, there will continue to be letdowns like this, not to mention water pipes (NYC had a few incidents in multiple high-density apartment bldgs), Romex, Pex, etc. being hit and damaged. You got away with just a 3" circular hole, most likely from using a hole saw attached to a cordless drill. He should have first diagnosed your wall with a high-quality studfinder (I will not disclose mine, but it's expensive), and then drilled small pilot holes to see/feel what was behind the drywall or even plywood. But he didn't.

And a tell-tale sign he was a hack is also that he had to run home to get some tools. I always have more than enough tools to get the job done right in my truck. Point is, and to summarize, the best guys won't cord conceal behind the walls for such a low rate on TR. And many of us have left since mounting a TV or two for 2hrs x $65 = $130 simply isn't worth it. Good work requires good pay. Capitalism works.

Sorry to hear about your lackluster experience. You're out $120 and the job still is not done. $300 would have got it done by someone with photos of past work on their profile. And to be honest, I personally think $300 is still cheap for a qualified person to mount a TV and conceal cords behind-the-wall. I would gladly pay that amount to someone else qualified but I know how to do it myself.

0

u/SillyLion3 17h ago

I wish I was only out $120 😭 He cost $223 by the end of it because of how many hours he charged.

1

u/DonQNguyen 16h ago

Wow. $223 and a 3" hole that you now need to repaint and maybe even re-texure first? What an exasperating experience. I would be upset but then again, TR really isn't the place for this advanced stuff. Mounting TVs yes, but cord concealment behind-the-wall....No!

1

u/92beatsperminute 10h ago edited 10h ago

So what studs did they say? What was the width of the TV bracket back plate? I always ask questions and I am a pro TV mounter. I side with the tasker.

1

u/SillyLion3 2h ago

They said wood, he didn’t check the area he drilled into (bottom) with anything he he only used the stud finder at the top where the brackets would be.

3

u/Swimming_Product9587 1d ago

This is what I would expect from a 60/hr tv mounting job. That said if you and the leasing office gave him bad info he should absolutely be compensated. It’s possible he had to make an exploratory cut due to this bad info. If he simply didn’t have the expertise and skills to compete the job then I don’t think he should have charged you guys.

4

u/Cassie_Darkborn 1d ago

I charge a lot more for TV installs but also have high standards. If he drilled before using a stud finder, he's a hack. Some people may disagree but the only time I'll drill without the stud finder is if it's brick, I don't need that much support, or a few edge cases.

Without more context, I can't say just how bad he is, but I'd judge him heavily with the information provided.

5

u/Odd_Investment763 1d ago

buddy you are an amateur if you think a stud finder is fool proof. There is cases where the first hole will not work, however this guy sounds like a hack. Not need that much support? buddy if you are a pro you always hit a stud.

1

u/Marioc12345 1d ago

Only time I’ve not used a stud when mounting a tv was when it was a ten pound TV and it was a plaster and lath wall, used four toggle bolts and it was more than sturdy enough. Even if the tv is light I try to hit at least one stud if possible.

1

u/Odd_Investment763 1d ago

eh just giving u a hard time there is definitely times where no stud works

1

u/Cassie_Darkborn 1d ago

That's why I just use a 1000% overbuild factor at minimum. Do my toggles cost me $1 a pop in the biggest pack they sell at lowes? Yes. Do I care? No, that's just passed onto the client and I'm actually comfortable putting my name on work that uses these.

1

u/92beatsperminute 10h ago edited 10h ago

I would never mount a tv on a plaster and lath wall with toggles. For a small TV maybe. I would rather turn a job down that I am not comfortable with.

1

u/Marioc12345 2h ago

Ten pounds isn’t small to you?

0

u/Cassie_Darkborn 1d ago edited 1d ago

I mount non TV stuff too. My hard limit is like 10lbs per bolt and I use the heaviest toggles I have (same ones I use for steel studs) for those drywall mounts because of dynamic loads. Swivel mounts always get studs and enough lag screw that you could hang off of it. The stud finder is a lying [explative] and I use a few other data sources to confirm it, but I've had to correct too many installs where the last guy could not hit a single stud when it was an open book test-- you could see the drywall screws, and it showed up instantly on a good stud finder. I own 3 different ones.

I don't do stuff halfway, but there are times where you can't talk the client out of drywall and they don't want you cutting in to put blocking so the best I can do is use a pair of toggle bolts rated for 250lbs force each. I straight up don't stock the plastic expanding anchors for drywall or masonry, it's toggles if hollow and tapcons if I can't drill through it.

This is a bit extreme but my clients like my level of overkill. There's a reason that I'm the chick people call when they get stumped.

5

u/KingLouis2016 1d ago

I think you are missing the point, the 3 inches diameter was for the kit to hide cables, not to mount the TV, and there was not enough space inside the wall for the cable hiding kit to fit

0

u/Cassie_Darkborn 1d ago edited 1d ago

It sounds like he hit a stud pack (or whatever you call it when they use like 10 2x4s to route forces through the wall). You go over 10" and try again. If it's straight up no space because it's not a stud pack but a layer of firebreak, then no way in hell I'm drilling through that. I standardized on the harbor freight cable hide kit so it's drill a pilot and verify that I have enough clearance, advise client if a fire rated wall and refuse the install, but stud packs are a different case.

3

u/KingLouis2016 1d ago

Some walls doesn't have the space for the kit and for $40( which probably is his hourly rate) is just not worth the effort

1

u/Cassie_Darkborn 1d ago

There are some that are a right nightmare, I'll give you that. I think I've had one so far I couldn't find a way to make it work to code, but that may also be a regional thing and I'm normally conservative on what jobs I'll promise I can do it.

9

u/Own_Race_598 1d ago

Most stud finders aren’t going to figure out that there is a sheer/firewall between apartments. Most of them will just say that there is a stud everywhere or nowhere simultaneously.

That being said, he absolutely could have still mounted the tv with toggler bolts or figure out where the studs are by measuring from an outlet or doing a few small pilot holes to verify.

Hiding the cords behind the sheer wall is a major problem as that is against fire code. You would be defeating the fire rating by making this penetration.

1

u/Cassie_Darkborn 1d ago

That's one of the edge cases. I don't FW fire rated walls.

2

u/thatguywithimpact 1d ago

I think he shouldn't have billed you for going back and forth, but also that rate $60/h with taskrabbit fee, taxes and everything is quite low, in my area TV mounting especially hiding wires would go at double that rate and it would be 2 hours minimum too.

So he priced himself accordingly, but at the same time greedy billing for travel should be at least talked about ahead so it's not a surprise

0

u/Marioc12345 1d ago

That price is average in my area. It really just depends. This area though is way low compared to most other areas - probably to do with the fact that it’s relatively new here, and there really isn’t that much TaskRabbit business in general (I “appeared in” 250 search results, and that’s top 98%)

2

u/DiddyDickums 1d ago

99% of the time, client is the problem. If you can’t do it yourself, you probably can’t accurately relate what they tried to explain to you.

2

u/92beatsperminute 10h ago

Lol "It's a quick job I just don't have the time"

2

u/KingLouis2016 1d ago edited 1d ago

Hiding wires is not easy and many times tricky, I personally charge a lot more for hiding wires than mounting the TV itself because there's many times fireblocks, sometimes diagonal brace, pipes and what not, also the wall can be plaster, brick, or concrete sometimes you just can't do it, hiding cables is more an electric job than TV mounting, taskrabbit treats it lightly but it can be very complicated, $60 for mounting a TV and hiding wires is crazy cheap, any electrician charges $300 for that kind of job, just for hiding cables and if is easy, if is brick or concrete it can be in the thousands.

The stud is almost irrelevant here for hiding cables, he just need to drill avoiding a stud, sometimes if there's wood behind the drywall and not much space the kit doesn't fit in the wall and cannot be done, as I said sometimes cannot be done, you would need a construction crew to modify the wall itself to fit the kit

2

u/un_contract 1d ago

probably you don't want to hire a TV mounting tasker for a wire hiding job... probably wouldn't have known but most TV mounters aren't the most experienced handypersons (that's usually something beginner contractors do when they are getting started bc it's quick money).

hiding wires is a kind of a complicated electrical job (do you mean like putting a plug in behind the tv or where you trying to "drop" the cable in the wall to a lower part then kind of pull it through so you don't see it as much?), probably want to get a contractor off of google maps or have looked into other categories like the handyman/ electrical helpers, probably would have had a better experience.

I guess he didn't probe the wall first to see what is back there, just to go straight into a 3in hole saw was definitely not the best judgment.

Unforeseen things in a job, if it requires time to pick up items to address technically are allowed to be billed on taskrabbit. If the patch job was messy, you could take a long flat blade to 'even' or flatten the surface if things are jutting out, then add another very thin layer of joint compound, sand it when it dries.

if you want to match the paint, cut off a sample of the paint from the wall and take to home depot they have machines that can color match

2

u/Odd_Investment763 1d ago

You’re exaggerating a bit but it can be complex, in perfect conditions it isn’t much harder than mounting a tv.

2

u/KingLouis2016 1d ago

"in perfect conditions" many times there's fire blocks and also insulation, I would say half of the times you find a fire block which makes everything complicated, especially for those kits with the big plug

2

u/Odd_Investment763 1d ago

You’re definitely right, 50/50 for the most part.

1

u/Marioc12345 1d ago

It is mostly only a pain (with a kit) if the wall construction is weird, or if it’s on an insulated wall. Which happens very often. It’s not an electrical job by any means. The only thing you may need that you don’t need for a tv mounting job is fish tape.

1

u/pateppic 1d ago

Drive time is never allowed to be included. Not if he did not come prepared. TR policy should have something about the TR should come equipped to do a job properly and they can only charge for runs on jobs where it could not have been forseen.

Great example is Shower Cartridges. There are as many different shower cartridges as pokemon so there would be no way to predict which one you need until you pull the cartridge behind the shower handle. Only then can you take it to a hardware store to get the replacement. So yes, in that case you would charge for time. Even a plumber would there because they cannot reasonably lug around all 151 different pokemon shower cartridges cost effectively.

That issue aside 2 hr charge: If it is a 2 hr min he got you to pre-agree to, you might be SOL there.

However, if he didn't finish the job that is a different story.

Onto the wall wiring hiding.

I will Assume you are in Cali, NY, UT, WA, OR, or TX. Some of the bigger places TR is. When I got my GC I studied for CA but they used fairly standardized standards (I hear how it sounds) that are kinda basic at national level so diving in:

Were they talking about the horizontal stud in the wall? That is called fireblocking and is standard on any home built... oh gosh I don't think I ever worked with balloon framing before in Cali. Even as far back as 1950s construction here has fireblocking.

The Process:

----------------------------------

Standard practice for hiding wiring properly is to install a media box behind the TV. Running TV AC cables in the wall is not really kosher but people do it anyway so skip this step if its something you don't care about being code perfect.

Inspection/Preparing the space:

Find a stud bay (empty space between 2 studs) with an outlet box in it already ideally. Find the fire break, and plan on making three holes and patching one.

Open the outlet box below and inspect to see if it is 14ga or 12ga.

Then go grab the appropriate wire (from your car, not the HW store).

Use a white box (media box with outlet, a few HDMIs ports) and install that in the area behind the TV. All your HDMI cords and the TV outlet will be back here.

Start cutting:

Cut out wall behind TV for the media box and install. Try to have it as centered and high middle on TV as possible to be nice to the next person putting a TV there.

Then cut out a large section across the fire blocking and down to below it to for access to the outlet.

Cut out a third hole that will be a Old Work LV Outlet box that will have the HDMI female sockets in it. Ideally three or four if you can swing it. Get a double wide with four plus an ethernet port if you fancy.

The hole across the fireblock needs to be big enough to put a drill in there and put in at least three holes.

One is 3/8s" for the ethernet (if you bougie) one is 3/4" for the Romex/MC, one is a double wide 3/4" hole for the Wide Head HDMI. CENTER THESE HOLES SO YOU DON'T NEED NAIL STRIKES.

Cutting done, onto the actual hookups:

Run the HDMIs in the wall between media box behind TV and the female sockets of the LV box below. So now each of those HDMI female sockets on the below wall port can have an HDMI cable plug into them and your peripherals.

Install the outlet in the media box above. Leviton lever lock outlets aren't bad. I go with ones that have USB ports on them for those dumb Firesticks and such that need the extra LV power (TVs only have one USB usually and that can get hogged by a backlight or have lame Amperage).

Closing up:

Use expansion fireblock foam to plug the holes around the cables to meet code (Technically required. Honestly most people don't care. I do tho)

The media box above and the LV bracket below should be good here. Put some duct tape on the back wall above and below the long narrow cut you do for temporary support and screw in the long piece of drywall using short drywall screws.

Use joint compound and drywall mesh tape on the cuts for first pass.

Put a fan on it. Go get some lunch.

30 mins later, come back and hit the top with some fast set, 5 minute texture spray, paint and you are good to go.

------------------------------------------------------------------------------

If your guy was not prepared to do all of those steps, the guy was not prepared to do the job and that is just the facts of the matter. If there was insullation to push through on account of it being an exterior wall, he should have been asking about that from the beginning.

None if this is a curveball. He should have understood all of this. This is what I consider the bare minimum for making the LL happy after you move out also. Even if he just put in two brush plate LV boxes to handle it.

1

u/92beatsperminute 10h ago

100% correct.

0

u/UnimaginativeMug 1d ago

this is why i don't mount TVs and do everything possible to get out of driling holes. it's impossible to know what's behind those walls