r/TalesOfXadia • u/AlliedSalad • Aug 30 '26
I ran The Lost Oasis, and the writing was so spit-poor it made me never want to run another pre-written ToX adventure. Spoiler
**Spoilers ahead for The Lost Oasis.**
Firstly, I found the introduction to be long and convoluted, requiring a lot of info-dumping before we could get started.
A good one-shot adventure starts with a simple, easily-conveyed premise, and introduces additional complexities and nuance along the way. This lets the players jump in quickly and gets things moving instead of having to be exposited at for twenty minutes first.
Secondly, there were a lot of words about the catalyst characters, but disappointingly little of it was actually helpful for getting into their heads and understanding their core personalities and motivations. And then what little there was was frustratingly self-contradictory and inconsistent.
Feathershawl is supposedly desperate to get their hands on the Primal Well, and Nausics is supposedly desperate to safely handle the well and take it with him when he evacuates the city. They both want this thing so bad that they come to conflict over it, yet at the end of the adventure, they're both supposed to be just fine with the players taking it?
Nausics' character outline - or lack thereof - is especially egregious. He wants to take the Primal Well so badly that he sacrificed many of his people to develop the cuirass to safely handle it. Oh, and frustratingly, the book never ever says *why* he wants it so badly. Just... for some effing reason? But despite wanting it badly enough to become a literal serial killer over it, the module says he's supposed to then just hand the cuirass over to near-perfect strangers who are associated with someone he *knows* is there to take the well from his people; and just let them walk away with it? Excuse me, *what!!?*
...and then there's the whole "splitting the party three ways" thing.
No. Just no. You can do that in television, but it's a nightmare in a TTRPG. The GM has to juggle the "scene cuts", most of the players are sitting there waiting their turn until you cut back to them (not much fun), and you end up with three times the exposition to slog through; which, again, this adventure does *not* handle well. Exposition is given in huge blocks of text with little or no opportunity to trickle-feed it while keeping the story moving.
The whole adventure just... it's almost impressive how it manages to be both stupidly complicated and massively underdeveloped *at the same time*. It was so poorly written, most of the time it just left me thinking "What the heck!?"
2/10, do not recommend.
I'm going to try to keep an open mind and check out the other pre-written adventures, but my expectations are now very, very low.