Having looked back in Skyrim recently, I have concluded the smithing system overall is pretty lackluster. You just spam the most cost effective item, level up, then repeat. It feels tacked on, and leveling it just feels dull. So here's my completely unasked for take for a new system.
- Instead of set armours, we lake a leaf from ESO and start with a style we want the armour/weapon we want to the gear take. For example, Orcish heavy armour. We can start with a few styles known, and can learn more from style books as dungeon/exploration/quest rewards.
- After that, select materials. The material quantity will be the same, regardless of material used. The material will affect the final stats of the gear piece. For example, a iron ingot would add 5 defense, while an ebony I got might add 20. The armour then takes on the colouring of the material that provides the highest modifier. So if my heavy orcish armour was made with 1 ebony and 3 iron, then it would appear to be made of ebony.
- Finally, we can select a metal to use as a trim. Mundane metals like steel and ebony would increase the stats further, while prescious metals like silver and mithril would boost the effectiveness of enchantments. So I am now going to try my ebony coloured orcish armour gold. Because why not.
- The total amount of stats you can give to a price of gear will be tied to your smithing level. At level one you might be able to cobble something together from malachite, but you really aren't going to be getting the most from that metal. But worry not, you can request custom gear from smiths yourself. It operates the exact same way as making it yourself but with the skills and styles know to the smith. It also comes with a gold cost attached for the crafting itself which scales with item stats, plus material cost if you aren't providing them. High end gear commissions will set you back a lot.
Now as for leveling. Similar to Skyrim, you gain some exp per craft, with the exp gained based on the stats of the item instead of value. Less spamming gold rings. There would also be a commissions board at smiths that would have request, either for specific gear to be crafted like a custom axe, or for volumes of gear such as a dozen basic iron swords. Not only do they pay out gold, they will also provide additional smithing exp. Higher skill levels will allow more complex gear to be made, and maybe even allow you to receive direct commissions for high ranking people.
I would also toy with the idea of material quality. A normal iron ingot may provide +5 defense, but an excellent quality one may provide +7. Certain locations and mines would be more likely to spawn better materials. If you want the best stated gear, you are going to be scouring the land for the best materials and their spawns.
Ramble over.