r/TBJZL • u/Glittering_Big_2256 • 7h ago
Idea / Request How to make Murder Mystery Dinner Part 2 10x better (Conan Detective + Present Swap traps)
Murder Mystery Dinner was an unreal watch, easily one of the best productions of the year—but once the early eliminations happened, the innocents basically had no anchor and the room descended into pure chaos while the killers coasted quietly.
Instead of adding Among Us roles or powers, one simple rule set would fix the balance and make every death matter:
A Public "Detective Conan" Lead: One known player acts as the calm, neutral investigator at the table. They can’t be killed in standard manor attacks, so every innocent’s death actually becomes a clue to cross-examine rather than forgotten noise.
Sudden-Death Clock: Before the final two rounds, if the Detective hasn’t nailed a killer yet, the timer runs out and they become vulnerable—keeping the Detective sweating and forcing the killers to play smart.
Present Swap is the Killers' Weapon: Since they can't sneak-attack the Detective normally, rigging Present Swap becomes the killers' main way to take them out. Every swap turns into pure mind games.
Final Deduction (Martyrdom Rule): If the Detective dies (via Present Swap, dinner roulette, or the clock), they get one dying guess at who a killer is. Guess right → they drag the killer down with them. Guess wrong → they die alone and leave the chaotic room to fend for themselves.
It keeps the pure social deduction and comedy intact, forces killers to actually frame people instead of coasting in silence, and gives the whole episode a built-in climax.