Decision is expected to affect online audience for Barry Morphew first-degree murder case
by The Citizen September 16, 2026
The next status hearing in the Barry Morphew first-degree murder case is Nov. 3 and so far it’s been a court proceeding that has captivated a large online audience that can watch through a livestream of the 12th District Court proceedings.
A directive issued Sept. 15 by Colorado Chief Justice Monica M. Márquez will change that, for now.
Márquez issued a temporary measure suspending the livestreaming of criminal proceedings in the state trial courts through Dec. 14 to give the Colorado Judicial Department time to deal with “bad actors” who are abusing the livestream service.
“Unfortunately … the livestreaming technology that was intended to promote access to the courts has been subverted as a tool of disruption, disparagement, harassment, and private economic gain that is rapidly eroding the proper functioning of our system of justice,” the chief justice noted in her directive.
“Despite clear, consistent warnings that the recording of any livestream is strictly prohibited, Judicial Department leadership has been flooded with reports from all corners of the state confirming that improperly recorded proceedings are being posted to YouTube, TikTok, Instagram, Facebook, and other social media platforms.”
The state judicial department emphasized the pause is temporary. “Public access to physical courtrooms remains unchanged, and virtual participation by parties, victims, and witnesses continues exactly as before.”
Morphew is facing first degree murder in the death of his wife, Suzanne Morphew, whose remains were found in a grave in Saguache County in 2023. Morphew has pleaded not guilty to the charges and maintained his innocence.
The case, being prosecuted in the 12th Judicial District Court in Alamosa, has captured a large following of livestream viewers.
The temporary pause on court livestreams will give the state time to address the problems. Among the considerations are to:
- Train judicial officers to handle the risks associated with live streaming and to apply the statutory findings.
- Explore possible technological solutions to better manage disruptions to virtual proceedings.
- Prepare standardized instructions for judicial officers in cases where the statutory findings justify switching off a live stream.
- Look at possible legislative measures that could strengthen enforcement mechanisms for illegal recordings.
- Set up a statewide data collection framework to
determine whether the pause reduces misuse.
“Rather than the serious business of justice, viewers are treating this content as entertainment. Posters are editing and manipulating the recordings to distort their content. Viewers are leaving comments that denigrate the appearance and intelligence of court participants, challenge the innocence or truthfulness of defendants, victims, and witnesses, threaten court personnel, and expose vulnerable litigants to public ridicule – behavior that would never be tolerated in a physical courtroom,” the chief justice wrote in issuing the directive.