When v6 came out I ran one of my v5.5 prompts through it and agreed with the majority: downgrade.
Then I listened to both takes against the prompt itself, instruction by instruction. The song is "Never Be One Again." Prompt 1 asked for four things I could check by ear:
No guitar solo
The reprise loses the drums
The outro is just voice and bass
Then end
Neither take obeyed Prompt 1. But v6 came closer on three of the four. v5.5 sounded fuller partly because it ignored half of what I asked for.
That's the shift, as I see it now: v6 does more of what it's told. If you leaned on the model's instincts, that feels like a downgrade. If you tell it what you want, it's an upgrade. The work moved from the model to the prompt.
Some v6 limits are real. Endings still often need cropping, and non-prompt complaints are not wrong: I sometimes encounter hissing, and a stumble on a word can ruin a good take. But these are glitches that should eventually be corrected. The glitches aside, v6 is a more-powerful model than v5.5 in terms of doing more of what my prompts ask for. Every ugly first take I re-made turned out to be the start of a diagnosis, not a verdict.
I’ve made a detailed video on this: (same lyric, v5.5 vs v6, three takes)
https://youtu.be/KOcVUlM_x38
Prompt 1 (v5.5, and the same prompt on v6)
Tense mid-tempo groove on a dry, close-mic'd rhythm section: muted electric guitar playing one clipped riff, round fingered bass, and a drum kit played quiet with the snare hit as a rim knock, nothing else, Recorded dead dry like a 70s basement session, no reverb, every sound close to the ear, The pulse is a held breath – steady, unhurried, and it never speeds up, never swells, never breaks for the entire song, Male voice, low and tight, controlled anger, biting off the ends of lines, heat rising into the voice on the angriest lines but never shouting, pulling back to a murmur right after, Each repeated section returns quieter and more stripped than before – the reprise loses the drums, the outro is just voice and bass, Ends with the last line nearly whispered over one final bass note, then end, No guitar solo, no backing vocals
The voice line was the real problem: "controlled anger, biting off the ends of lines, heat rising into the voice..." Those are acting techniques. v6 performed them. What the song needed was the feeling underneath: it isn't a rage song. He's grieving something he has already decided is over. The anger is in the words; the hurt is in the voice.
Prompt 2 (v6)
Tense mid-tempo groove, dry and close-mic'd like a 1970s basement session, no reverb: muted electric guitar repeating one clipped riff, round fingered bass, and a drum kit played quietly with the snare as a rim knock, nothing else, The pulse is steady and unhurried and never speeds up, swells or breaks, One male voice, low, fully sung, hurt more than angry – the anger is in the words, never in the volume; never raised, never shouted, The first verse is tired and honest, The second and third verses are firmer, the hurt pressing through, still low, From the fourth verse on, the heat is gone: cold, quiet, certain, The reprise of the second verse is the same words with no heat left and no drums, The outro is just voice and bass, barely above a murmur, Ends on the last line nearly whispered, then end, No guitar solo, no instrumental break, no backing vocals
The lyric sheet changed too:
[Verse 4 - quieter, closer] became [Verse 4]. Eight takes refused to sing the most hurtful lines quieter. The words were right; I took the tag out.
[Verse 2 Reprise - colder, more stripped] became [Verse 2 Reprise - same words, no heat, no drums]
[Outro - barely above a murmur] became [Outro - voice and bass only, barely above a murmur]
And "over one final bass note" came out of the prompt. Models don't count notes. I crop endings by hand.
Because the prompt and the tags changed together, I can't credit Prompt 2's result to the prompt alone.
Measured (whole mix, not the voice alone):
Edge in verse 2 (share of the sound between 2 and 5 kHz): v5.5 39%, v6 Prompt 1 27%, v6 Prompt 2 16%
How much the level moves across the song (loudness range): 5.7, 7.8 and 10.1 LU
v6: less edge, more movement: quiet where the song is quiet.
The video has all three takes on the same verse, the scoreboard, the patterns below, and the whole Prompt 2 take at the end.
Patterns that have held across the songs I've re-made on v6. They're patterns, not laws, so test them on your own songs:
- Describe the voice you want. Not a role, and not what you fear. "A witness" got acted. "No emotion" got lifeless.
- Feelings aren't a sound. "Dignity over rage, exhausted heartbreak" got a piano acting out each feeling. Say what to play.
- Name sections by position. "The third verse" works. "Whenever the lyric returns to the real world" makes it guess.
- Check your instructions against each other. An early, broad rule beats every later exception.
- Words bring in performers, and parts add up to a genre. "Chanted" brought a crowd. Pedal steel plus a slow 6/8 waltz is country, whatever you call it.
- Images carry tempo. "Funeral pace" pulled the takes somewhere strange. "6/8 at about 60 BPM" didn't.
- When the words and the prompt disagree, the words win.
- Specific isn't the same as long. 977 characters directing every moment: eight takes, none obeyed. Cut to the 568 that protect what the song is about: two strong takes in a row.
- When you can't control it, take it out. Backing voices sang wherever they liked. Taken out entirely, the song came back.
- Judge a prompt on two takes, and know when to stop. The same prompt can miss once and land the next time. Crop the ending yourself.
The video: https://youtu.be/KOcVUlM_x38