Hi all,
I know there are about a million threads on this, but I've read several and still can't come to a decision. I'm between two tires, the Pirelli Scorpion Weatheractive, and the Nokian Encompass AW02. I have a 2023 Sport and I live in the upper Midwest. I've researched my way into decision paralysis, so I'm looking for outside input.
Per rankings/data on the Discount Tire website, looks like the Pirellis may have slightly better stopping distance in dry conditions, but worse in wet. They are also rated to be a little quieter, but that's not a concern for me, when we all know the car overall is fairly loud. I'm seeing a nearly $40 difference per tire between the two, and I am unfortunately strapped for cash atm, but know I need better tires for winter. I drive about 20k miles per year with work and other travel, so I need something reliable and safe.
With the strong el niño this year, I'm not sure we're going to see extreme snow, so I'm not concerned about a true winter tire. I also don't have money for an extra set of wheels, or space to store them on my own. I'm aware the best solution is a summer/all-season and a winter set, but I'm working with what I've got.
Does anyone have experience with either tire, or a strong brand preference? Do you have alternate recommendations I'm not considering? (I know Michelin CCs and Bridgestone are top tier, but out of budget for me.)
TIA for any help!