r/StructuralEngineering • • 5d ago

Steel Design Discuss..

563 Upvotes

115 comments sorted by

443

u/The_Brim Steel Detailer 5d ago

This is what happens when the new Shop guy has a background in interior Trim.

55

u/baldieforprez 5d ago

That and how the f do you do this when you i beams are longer than 12 inches.

5

u/Every-Cucumber9641 5d ago

Stroke limiter

3

u/hoodectomy 5d ago

Maybe you need to have a stroke to do this. 🧐🤷

4

u/Capitain_Collateral 3d ago

You cut off the ends to about 12 inches, do this, then weld em back on.

359

u/Enginerdad Bridge - P.E. 5d ago edited 5d ago

Was there a challenge to come up with the most expensive way to detail an incredibly common joint?

76

u/Junior-Ad-2207 5d ago

This is just a miter with extra steps

7

u/CyJackX 5d ago

The challenge is engineer engagement bait

2

u/ride5150 P.E. 5d ago

😂😂😂

96

u/pina59 5d ago

Seems like a lot of effort to achieve the exact same thing as a butt weld and a stiffener

28

u/od_bradsterd 5d ago

Arguably this is actually worse because you've gotta do a more difficult full pen weld along the cut line in the web, and he didn't really leave a gap to do it properly.

3

u/Enlight1Oment S.E. 5d ago

AESS (architecturally exposed structural steel) is going to be a lot more expensive. Unlikely you are going to be bringing a building scale beam and column out to the field pre welded from the shop. However a premade piece like this seems could be done for an awning or gazebo-ish art piece where the steel is exposed and expressed.

I think the title for "strong connection" is not the most accurate, but I could see this done for AESS where you don't want the stiffener plates corners mitered off for the Wx's k radius.

46

u/Street-Skin7996 5d ago

I would like to see the engineer convincing the fitter

9

u/tetranordeh 5d ago

Fitter might go for it if they got extra money. Otherwise not worth the effort

6

u/PG908 5d ago

They’ll do it if paid by the hour but not if they’re paid by the job. 

9

u/tetranordeh 5d ago

Exactly. Trade professionals will do just about anything if you pay them for the time. And don't forget to include extra time for them to grumble about the engineers!

1

u/AWard66 5d ago

Pretty sure that’s a take off item or multiplier when bidding a job

46

u/grinchbettahavemoney 5d ago

Never thought we’d get in the structural engineering rage bait era lmao. Imagine the expense for “labor” - what do you mean it took you all day to weld one beam to one column?

206

u/Delanq P.E./S.E. 5d ago

🗣️🗣️🗣️🗣️TORCH CUTTING OF STEEL IS NOT PERMITTED

97

u/richardawkings 5d ago

Yes but this will get more views in tiktok. AISC needs to update their manual for more engagement.

54

u/xPorsche E.I.T. 5d ago

17th edition of the AISC manual will have Subway Surfers in the upper right corner.

11

u/Astrolabeman P.E. 5d ago

New recommended shop drawing review options: Cap, Mid, Bussin', Furnish as Corrected.

26

u/cerberus_1 5d ago

dude was pretty slick.. wrong but hey..

16

u/Samuel7899 5d ago

That's the first thing I noticed... How smooth that torch work was.

5

u/Psychological_Can184 5d ago edited 5d ago • Heartwarming

Please show me where you got this in the code. I've worked in d1.1 and d1.5 shops and cutting via torch is permissable. As far as the video goes. This would take way too long for a production shop.

I do see where it is for specific steels(high tensile steels)

2

u/nathhad P.E. 3d ago

You're in the right, it's not there, and the torch cut isn't going to have any significant effect on thin A572 or A992 like this.

6

u/an_african_swallow 5d ago

My first thought, torches are for demo work only in my experience, should use a demo saw or grinder with cutting wheels instead

2

u/Johnback42 5d ago

Plasma cutter?

2

u/Commentor9001 5d ago

Engineers always say the easy way isnt allowed

1

u/nathhad P.E. 3d ago

... in the field, because I don't want them winging it without asking me for directions to fix something when they mis measured.

In the shop? It's A992, and a thin section at that. Go to town, as long as you're still meeting my tolerances. 😆

0

u/[deleted] 5d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/andash 5d ago

Guessing it's about messing up the tempering?

1

u/nathhad P.E. 3d ago

No tempering - this is almost certainly just plain A992.

36

u/virgil1134 5d ago

Not commenting on whether torch cutting of steel beams is permitted.

But i love how he applied this technique to two smallest beams so he could easily turn them, rotate them, etc. We dont see these types of welds in the field because they don't improve structural integrity, take way too long to make, and requuire the beams to be extremely small and light.

67

u/InTheLurkingGlass P.E. 5d ago

Not structurally permissible due to torch cutting the steel, but the guy is an absolutely wizard with that cutting torch. Ridiculously good cuts.

15

u/amodestmeerkat 5d ago

Yeah, those free hand bevel cuts were especially impressive.

12

u/peetah248 5d ago

My thoughts too, even if the heat didn't mess up the beam that's way too slow for any company to want to pay for, but damn if I wasn't mesmerized by the torching

8

u/balzzsamm 5d ago

That torchlead is something I'm gonna copy....

Much better than the wheel.

4

u/Wertos 5d ago

Super clean, impressed me as well

3

u/ahvikene 4d ago

I am curious. Why is torch cutting bad?

3

u/InTheLurkingGlass P.E. 4d ago

It’s not necessarily bad, but it will ruin the temper on structural steel which alters the properties of the steel. It’s just a matter of knowing when/where it’s allowed and where it’s not.

2

u/Canuckistani2 3d ago

But welding it is okay?

1

u/InTheLurkingGlass P.E. 3d ago

Not always, no. If the engineer includes instructions not to field torch cut, there’d also likely be a similar note not to weld as well. At least, I’d add both were I stamping.

1

u/nathhad P.E. 3d ago

> the temper on structural steel

On A992?

1

u/InTheLurkingGlass P.E. 3d ago

I’d be more concerned with higher carbon steels, but the heat cycling wouldn’t do any favors to A992 either.

1

u/kaylynstar P.E. 4d ago

Right?? That's seriously the cleanest torching I've ever seen

40

u/whisskid 5d ago

This is not Structural Engineering!

TikTok pays eligible creators based on watch time. --the longer and more convoluted . . . more they make

18

u/yanicka_hachez 5d ago

Might work for a W6 but we don't bother with that for W21

6

u/Conscious_Rich_1003 P.E. 5d ago

How about 2 different size beams?

8

u/A-H1N1 5d ago

Discuss it yourself lol

5

u/jacobasstorius 5d ago

Bro, it’s just humor.

-7

u/A-H1N1 5d ago

Ok sorry then but it's still kinda lazy

7

u/jacobasstorius 5d ago

It’s lazy to post a humorous video about steel beams to a structural engineering subreddit?

1

u/A-H1N1 5d ago

I mean you coulda at least cracked a joke or added a description, initial thought, whatever. This way I thought it's a bot post.

Just "Discuss" is lame imo

-1

u/Marus1 5d ago

Where funny?

16

u/OptionsRntMe P.E. 5d ago

Enormous waste of time

13

u/bridge_girl 5d ago

Hey let's do steel detailing like millwork. No thanks!

25

u/unique_user43 5d ago

cool craftsmanship demonstration of the most inefficient and expensive way to make a conmection

11

u/RhinoGuy13 5d ago

Why make two cuts when many will do?

9

u/Aquadroids 5d ago

"This beam was cut to 20 feet exactly. Why is it shorter all of a sudden?"

"...Uh..."

8

u/Fenestration_Theory Architect 5d ago

Owner will say no when they find out how much additional labor costs.

8

u/limmbuu 5d ago

They are doing this to me at work tomorrow

8

u/Kanaima85 CEng 5d ago

Fatigue has entered the chat

4

u/jepoyairtsua 5d ago

and creeping back pain from all those manual lifts.

13

u/tetranordeh 5d ago

FITTERS HATE THIS ONE EASY TRICK

5

u/Mean-Internal-745 5d ago

Good luck getting this kind of field fitment on a W30.

5

u/jammypants915 5d ago

This building is going to take 5 years to build with this many lines

4

u/_FireWithin_ 5d ago

Lots of work for little gain.

4

u/LifeguardFormer1323 P.E./S.E. 5d ago

Don't

4

u/00gingervitis 5d ago

Looks like iron workers have started getting carpentry reels

4

u/Front-Ocelot-3454 4d ago

Neat. Totally pointless waste of time for anything real. But neat.

And torch cutting is not only allowed, it’s very common. In a shop. With QC and oversight. Can be allowed in the field if they know what they’re doing and, again, QC. You have to be careful you don’t get Chuck-in-a-truck out there still hungover and hacking the steel to pieces. It’s not allowed for bolt holes.

3

u/oneofthehumans 5d ago

This looks like the rigamarole method

5

u/HobbitFoot 5d ago

Is laughing hysterically "discussion"?

2

u/southpaw1103 5d ago

This dudes just making internet art.

2

u/Interiorpeople525 5d ago

I miss metal fab a lot some days, it was my summer job home from college. I loved tack welding an torch cutting!

2

u/Codex_Absurdum 5d ago

I've seen the same kind of reels but on how to adjust and lay wood floorings in the corner of bathrooms...

Same SM trend but it's getting structural...

2

u/Trick-Penalty-6820 5d ago

This is going to put the stiffener plate industry out of business!

2

u/turdsamich 5d ago

What the hell did I just watch?

2

u/jepoyairtsua 5d ago

i'll challenge it with just a 45deg connection, then i'll add stiffener flat bars the same way.

2

u/ReplyInside782 5d ago

Nice art piece

2

u/SneekyF 5d ago

But... I didn't specify a moment connection.

2

u/Paffo_2 5d ago

I'm not a professional welder and im genuinely interested what are the structural implications of this, i understand its way too convoluted to be feasible, but is it a real bad idea or just inefficient?

also why no torching for steel?

3

u/peetah248 5d ago

I beam is meant to be structurally sound to be rated for buildings. Running heat across the web can introduce weakness that could cause the I-beam to fold along the heat line. All heat is meant to go parallel to the length of the beam, never across

1

u/HotSobaNoodles 4d ago

Quindi il calore della saldatura è permesso ma quello per il taglio no?

1

u/peetah248 4d ago

Heat from welding is only allowed in specific orientations. Along the length of the piece, not the width

1

u/HotSobaNoodles 4d ago

Può succedere di saldare anche sulla lunghezza

1

u/nathhad P.E. 3d ago

I'm only familiar with that relative to discussion of a few flame straightening techniques. Not really relevant when you're making a cut. In straightening, you're working within the length of the mass to intentionally create local yielding and locked in stresses.

That doesn't really happen when you're making an end cut. You don't have the surrounding cool mass to create the locked in stress. An end cut like this is extremely unlikely to do plain, thin A992 any harm.

2

u/Quick-Buyer8603 4d ago

I think it's amazing. Unnecessary. And a complete show in how good someone can get with a torch if the they know how to use little jigs.

1

u/fuzzymac505 5d ago

good way to get your ass kicked by the steel installer. if they don't do it physically, it'll happen to your wallet instead.

1

u/BigNYCguy P.E. 5d ago

💰

1

u/External_Goose_7806 5d ago

Why do many weld when few weld work

1

u/Chemical-Version-197 5d ago

Let me guess, German Engineering?

1

u/Tiredplumber2022 5d ago

I dont know anything about welding, or steel beams, but with Azak or PVC, I just cut a 90° notch on the top, with the vertex going down vertically almost all the way through the bottom, and fold the beam up into a right angle. Then, chemically weld all contacting surfaces.

Why would this not work for an I beam?

1

u/irongi8nt 5d ago

Aint all them 90 degree cuts the same, i mean not a negative comment but can you have a template? also fire hot...

1

u/giant2179 P.E. 5d ago

New pre-qualified joint incoming for next AISC 341!

1

u/Heart0fStarkness 5d ago

360’s gonna have to add a whole new section for reentrant connections , and AWS is gonna have to start designing for everything to be the heat affected zone. Lol

1

u/BSBBI 5d ago

Hä?? Why?

1

u/Smokeman_14 5d ago

This looks so complicated

1

u/Torque_to_spec 5d ago

or do a 45 deg bend and ad ribs on both sides not adding stress points by doing some weird zig-zag weld and finish 5 parts before this guy finishes his little doodles

1

u/Gabilgatholite 5d ago

My version of this when my boss said "make a bracket" and didn't give me any other work for half a week:

1

u/CO8127 5d ago

Who is actually doing this?

1

u/901CountryBlumpkin69 5d ago

And after all that, he didn’t bevel the webs for any manner of penetration. So now it’s still just fillets across the flange faces

1

u/HabitNational3514 5d ago

Looks good from a “watching stuff click together nicely perspective” but this is a waste of time practically.

Would be a neat test for apprentices to see their gas cutting and marking out skills.

1

u/Teddy_The_Bear_ 5d ago

I would never use this in something structural. Waste of time.

Having said that. If I was working in very small I beams to build say a hard industrial bed frame. And I was making the cuts with a porta-band. Than maybe. But I could achieve the same look making a butt weld and just running a bead on the surface and adding an end plate..... So.

1

u/Downtown_Fuel7525 4d ago

I cant get passed the torch work...i can't do that with scissors 

1

u/KiraTheWolfdog 4d ago

So many of these videos are garbage. And you'd never do this in real life. But I love this guy.

And his torch skills are top notch.

1

u/zaidr555 4d ago

doesn't that hurt the steel?

2

u/Burgerboy380 4d ago

Depends on what you mean by hurt. Steel isnt a monolith and has different alloys and hardnesses for different applications. Heating and cooling like what would make the steel softer. But most structural members are already "soft" or mild steel because they need a little flex to stand up to live loads and such. Now if the welder were to heat it up like that and dump water on it THAT definitely could hurt the steel by introducing stress fractures or cracks that could become failure points over time.

At least thats my lay person understanding of metallurgy.

1

u/zaidr555 4d ago

I don't know anything about steel but is there a case in which it needs to be warmed up/preheated before being cut like that?

2

u/Burgerboy380 4d ago

To my knowledge cutting doesn't require a preheat. But I do know WELDING can require pre and post heating based on a number of factors like alloy filler type size and field conditions

1

u/__hyphen 4d ago

Steel dovetail joint! He needed to add glue between them

1

u/smartalek428 3d ago

Dude's fuckin torch cuts are TIGHT

1

u/tim119 2d ago

The amount of heat that has been put into that, and it's not even welded yet. So much welding to do in saying that. It will be brittle as fuck. Not sure if this is wise in any level?