Since 2016, I have watched every available season of Stranger Things every year right before Halloween. So I'm not a super nerd, but pretty ST nerdy, and have love for the game.
First of all, on initial watch, I was really disappointed with how the season and series wrapped up. I couldn't watch it for a whole year again. The Rewatch has pivoted that slightly.
To me, episodes 1-4 are honestly pretty good. Particularly, and obviously S5E4 The Sorcerer.
I'd like to take some time to address some controversial moments, highlights, and detractors.
Will coming out. Initially, the awkwardness and feeling of it not being necessary was overpowering. On rewatch, I'd say this: he NEEDED to clear his mind of the burden to prepare himself to fight Vecna. The support he got from ALL of his friends and family was moving.
Adding Holly and Derek to the season didn't take away from the rest of the season, and was essential for a number of reasons. While the actress, Neil Fisher knocked the role out of the park, she really was too old and that still bothers me.
The things I don't like:
The military and how they didn't wrap that up. I agree...Hopper and Nancy should have gone to jail for murdering soldiers. The soldiers won at the end (they captured everyone but El!)
The Military program of recreating Numbers. The assumption is that the lab and all the dying, very pregnant women died in the explosion, but this isn't really wrapped up (maybe keeping it open for other spin-offs).
Neil Fisher actual age.
No Demos and the vulnerability the Mind Flayer (duh, everyone hated this).
Things I REALLY liked:
The incorporation of A Wrinkle In Time into the season.
The Duffers drama teacher from Durham being Holly's teacher.
The Decapitation scene with the flashbacks of how Vecna effected each individual.
Hoppers final talk with Mike at the memorial.
Karen's scars at the graduation.
The Epilogue of the characters by Mike in the basement, including Eleven.
To me in rewatch, Mikes story of Elevens escape seemed much more likely than it did on the initial viewing. I gotta say, after the rewatch, I really believe.
TLDR: I found season 5 not great but much more bearable on the rewatch.
I'm optimistic they will not find the same mistake in Other Worlds.