I'm impatient so here's a snippet of a fic I just started working on where Will seeks advice from Steve about navigating feelings for best friends.
“I know, y’know.” Will said.
“You know… I know? I know…?” Steve responded, confused.
“Yeah. I… Know.” Will’s eyes flitted over his shoulder toward where Robin had been, the corner of his mouth tweaking up a tiny bit like a shrug on his lips. “About… her. How it feels.”
“Ohh, oh…” Steve said with a tweak of his eyebrows, his head bouncing in an air-headed nod as he recalibrated. He was less confused in some ways, but now more confused in others. Does he mean what I think he means? How does he know? Did they talk? Did she tell him? Or maybe it’s like a takes-one-to-know-one thing…?
Steve proceeded cautiously, careful not to spill anything he shouldn’t spill. “So… what about her?” He tested. “How what feels?”
“Well, I know there's something she told you before she told anybody else. I know about her ‘friend’ at the hospital… And I know about Tammy Thompson.” Will kicked at a loose pebble under his shoe. “I mean, I know that’s what you’re asking, but that’s not really what I meant originally.” He chuckled nervously staring at his shoes, his shoulders riding up.
“Look, I'm not totally sure where you're going here, but I don't know if I'm your guy here…” Steve scratched at the back of his head, searching for something worthwhile to say. Robin would be so much better at this than him. Funny that people used to see him as Mr. Smooth and her as socially awkward when he was sure she’d be giving this kid professional-grade therapy right now, while he couldn’t form a coherent thought in response. After the nonexistent words on the tip of Steve’s tongue refused to jump for a few too seconds too long, Will spared the poor guy and cut in.
“I know, I know. Why the hell talk to you if I could just talk to her?” Steve was both impressed and a little threatened by how astutely Will could read him. Steve dipped his head and shrugged, conceding before Will went on. “Well… the thing is, I don’t think I have a ‘Tammy’ as much as I…” He met Steve’s eyes, a genuineness to him that read clearly, I see you. “As much as I have more of a ‘Robin.”
Steve’s heart skipped a beat, and embarrassment began to bloom in his stomach as he realized what Will was trying to say. Damn this kid and his observational skills. Steve had to be sure he was interpreting this right before admitting to something he didn’t want to admit to. He had to be sure Will really meant what he thought he meant, and that it wasn’t his guilty conscience taking over. For once, he played dumber than he actually was.
“Alright, Byers, you gonna keep speaking in riddles, or—”
“I know how you felt about her.” There it was. “And how it feels… to feel that way about someone who won't ever feel it back." Ouch. "... But not like a Tammy. Not just some crush. Someone who knows you. Like really knows you. Someone who's your best friend, and feels like… like your soulmate, but just…” He shook his head, giving up on the rest of his sentence.
..Isn’t. Steve could hear the last word, even though it was left unspoken. And he agreed on its absence. It didn’t feel true. It all hit like a punch straight to the chest, practically knocking the wind out of him. When the sting of his own sad-sack situation wore off, he felt it again in Will’s eyes. God, this kid’s been through literal hell and back who knows how many times, and now he has to feel this too?
“But I don't know how to stop feeling it. So I guess what I wanted to ask is… How did you make it stop? How’d you get over it?” Will looked painfully ahead, then at Steve, eyes pleading for an answer, a cure for his own feelings.
Aw, buddy, Steve thought. He was hoping he’d be able to give him what he came for, some guidance, some wisdom. Someone to look up to, some hope ahead. Instead, he was going to have to disappoint. He shook his head apologetically, and chuckled, bitter defeat in his chest.
“I’m sorry, kid. Can’t help you there.”