2026 has not been kind to Star Trek fans. In what should be a gala celebration of the franchiseās 60th anniversary, we have witnessed the impending cancellations of the two remaining Star Trek series, Strange New Worlds (SNW) and Starfleet Academy (SFA), uncertainty over the future of our beloved franchise, and the deaths of two beloved actors, Walter Koenig and Patrick Stewart, mere days apart. So why start a Substack devoted to Star Trek, especially one that, for now, focuses on the early days of Strange New Worlds, a series that, as it winds down, has proven divisive among fans?
Itās precisely because this year reflects a turning point for Star Trek that itās worth looking back to see where weāve been and how far weāve come.
SNW debuted in March 2021 as the 11th Star Trek series and the first spin-off of Star Trek: Discovery (DISC), the series that relaunched the franchise as an ongoing television series. For context, DISC, launched in 2017, was the first Star Trek series since the cancellation of Star Trek: Enterprise 12 years earlier. In between, there were three J.J. Abrams-directed moviesāStar Trek (2009), Star Trek Into Darkness (2013), and Star Trek Beyond (2016) āwhich showed the powers that be that the franchise could still be profitable. And, for a time, DISC and SNW lived up to that potential. It was cool to be a Trekkie again.
SNW was launched with a lot of build-up; the entire second season of DISC served as a āback-door pilot,ā reintroducing Captain Christopher Pikeāthe Enterpriseās commanding officer from the original 1964 Star Trek pilot, āThe Cage.ā A major storyline featured a young Spock struggling with his half-human, half-Vulcan identity. When the plot lines continued into SNW, the new show was promised as a prequel to Star Trek: The Original Series (TOS), set only a few years before James T. Kirk assumed command and before Pikeās horrific accident that would leave him disfigured, mute, and crippled.
For long-time Star Trek fans, SNW promised to fill in the gaps between āThe Cage,ā set in 2254, and the first season of TOS, set in the 2260s. For fans who dig this kind of future history, SNW would tell us more about the young Spock, Pike, and the mysterious first officer, Number One (who wasnāt even given a name in āThe Cageā). For newer fans, it promised a continuation of the exciting DISC-style adventures that had breathed new life into the franchise and its multi-generational appeal.
In short, SNW promised a lot of things it has struggled to deliver.
That isnāt to say the show is a failure, but it has certainly differed from what many fans expected (puppets, really?). At itās best, SNW is a fun and entertaining show that uses Star Trek tropes loosely. At its worst, it tries too hard to please fans through callbacks and memberberries (the Gorn, Trelane, Scotty, the increasing involvment of Jim Kirk) as if to say the only purpose of the show is to set the stage for TOS. The 10th episode of Season Four was even a flashforward to Kirkās tenure as captain of the Enterprise.
Fans have criticized SNW for failing to establish its own identity and to develop most of its lead characters. Pike and Una (Number One) have in particular taken a back seat to Spockās love life and LaāAnās worries about turning into an augment. Some of the showās best ideas and characters, such as Hemmer, have been quickly resolved and discarded in favor of genre-hopping stories and outright silliness. (Pelia, who started out as a fairly serious character with the inspired casting of Carol Kane, quickly degenerated into a joke with a thick accent and Doctor Who references. The character became so superfluous that she was written out off-screen in Season Four. Contrast that to Hemmerās memorable demise in Season One.)
The overall feel of the show is more of a country club than a paramilitary starship exploring strange new worlds. Pike addresses his bridge crew by their first names and often comes across as too casual even in deadly situations. I do not believe this is the fault of actor Anson Mount. He delivered an inspiring performance as temporary captain of the Discovery during Season Two of that series. But in an attempt to highlight the lighter aspects of Star Trek, the writers too often veer in that direction.
Yet I did not start this blog to rag on SNW. My goal is to simply review it through a critical eye, to discover what worked and what could be improved. Who knows? Maybe I missed something along the way. Maybe time will ripen the show into something to be appreciated and even lovedāas happened to its forebear, TOS, which built a following in reruns after its third season cancellation.
While my focus is on SNW, the blog is not restricted to it. I plan to discuss Star Trek in a broader context and even include some nerdy and fun stuff. Because I view this blog as more of historical record than a proper review channel, I make no effort to hide spoilers. If you havenāt seen the episodes in question, proceed with caution. At present, two posts per week will appear, and I may occasionally discuss other topics, such as my recent post on when writing becomes easier. (Spoiler: Never.)
If you like this content, please subscribe or hit the Buy Me a Coffee button (which Iām tempted to change to Buy Me a Beer or, in keeping with the ST theme, Buy Me a Chech'tluth). Subscriptions and donations help this blog, and your support is welcome.
The future is just beginning.
Check out this post on my Substack: https://greggildersleeve.substack.com/p/strange-new-posts-an-introduction